If you bought an apartment in a house with a spacious yard, don’t rush to rejoice! There is a chance that the lion's share of your yard will be taken away from you over time. Moreover, they can take it away on completely legal grounds, since “your yard” does not actually belong to you. How to find out the size of the local area when buying a house? What to do if you already missed this moment? TV2 looked into this issue.
Outraged residents of the house on Botanichesky, 4, seeing the construction of a fence in their yard, called the police. Photo: Alexander SakalovResidents of the house at 4 Botanichesky Lane contacted the TV2 editorial office, concerned that they wanted to take away the lion's share of their local area. The reason for this concern was the construction of a fence separating the residential building from bathhouse No. 13 located opposite. More precisely, even this way: the house and the bathhouse had a common courtyard, not externally demarcated in any way. And now they began to enclose the bathhouse with a fence. Let us explain, the size of the alienated territory from the wall of the bathhouse to the sidewalk along the house is approximately 13.5 meters. The fence should cut off 10 meters from the yard area, leaving 3.5 meters for cars to pass along the house. Residents called the police and demanded to stop the seizure of their property - their yard territory.
Scheme of the yard at Botanichesky, 4. The red line indicates the width of the fenced area measuring approximately 10 by 36 meters. The white dotted line indicates the width of the passage along the house. The total area of the alienated territory is approximately 390 square meters. m. Photo: Alexander SakalovHowever, it turned out that the bathhouse employees were not fencing off someone else’s territory, but their own, that is, they were acting according to the law. We asked the director of Tomsk Bani LLC, Vlada Savva, to comment on the situation:
Bathhouse No. 13 is municipally owned. In 2012, our company entered into a long-term lease agreement with the Tomsk administration for 25 years. We rent a complex of buildings, as well as the surrounding area. We have all the documents for the land. According to these documents, we rent the territory and courtyard of a residential building from the building to the lawn. Now we have begun to fence not even our entire territory, but only part of it. We left residents a pedestrian sidewalk and space for cars to pass through. Two years ago, I came to a general meeting of apartment owners in this building and suggested that they legitimize the territory that they considered theirs. But the residents did nothing. All this time, our company incurred the costs of renting and maintaining this territory. Residents of the house need our territory, first of all, as free parking for personal cars.
The owners of apartments in the building confirm the words of the director of Tomsk Baths LLC. In particular, one of the owners, Anna Zaitseva, told TV2 that Vlada Savva came to their general meeting a couple of years ago with a proposal to decide on the adjacent territory, and that she showed the residents documents stating that the disputed land plot belongs to a bathhouse.
Now Vlada Savva has decided to meet the owners of the house and has suspended the installation of the fence:
I'm ready to wait two weeks. If the owners begin to take some real steps to legitimize their local area, then we will be able to come to some kind of compromise with them. If things don’t go beyond the indignation of a dozen residents, then we will install a fence.
Only after digging holes for the fence posts did the management of Tomsk Bani LLC force the owners of the apartments at 4 Botanichesky to think about the fate of their yard. Photo: Alexander SakalovThe house at 4 Botanichesky Lane was built in 2009. According to the owners, apartments in the building have been on sale for four or five years. All the apartment owners we interviewed unanimously stated:
From the moment we moved in, we were sure that the yard in front of the house was entirely ours!
Who misled the residents? The house was built and commissioned by the construction company "Continent". None of the apartment owners claim that when purchasing the apartment, the seller informed them about the size of the local area. In this case, no one accuses Continent of deception; people moved into a new yard and, by default, assumed that the entire area in front of the house was their yard. However, according to the requirements of the law, the yard is not some abstract territory that people see in front of the house, but a territory whose boundaries are marked by cadastral engineers and registered with the relevant government bodies.
Can citizens find out the real, documented boundaries of the local area before buying an apartment in a building?
Vladimir Fursin“They can,” says lawyer Vladimir Fursin. – If the house was put into operation after March 1, 2005, then the developer was obliged to transfer all documents for the land plot allocated for the construction of this house to the home owners represented by the management company, housing partnership or cooperative. Therefore, a potential buyer simply needs to make a request to the management company, housing association or cooperative and become familiar with the real boundaries of their future yard.
What to do if you have already bought an apartment in a building, but the boundaries of your yard are not defined, that is, the management company, housing association or cooperative does not have the appropriate documents? Vladimir Fursin draws attention to the fact that the obligation to transfer these documents lies with the developer, but the statute of limitations on this issue is three years. Therefore, if three years have not yet passed since your house was put into operation, the owners may require the developer to transfer documents to them for the land plot (voluntarily or through the court).
If more than three years have passed since the delivery of the house, and you do not have documents, then you can proceed according to the following algorithm:
1. Make a request to the Cadastral Chamber. If there are documents for the local area, then copies of them should be taken for yourself (transferred to your management company, housing association or cooperative).
2. If there are no documents in the Cadastral Chamber, then any owner has the right to contact the mayor’s office, in the “single window”, with a request to register the yard territory.
3. Most likely, the mayor’s office will refuse you, because, according to the law, since 2015 it is necessary to first form the land under the blocks, and then the land of the adjacent territories, and the mayor’s office does not have the money for this.
4. Then you should contact the prosecutor’s office with a demand to oblige the mayor’s office to comply with Decree of the Government of Russia No. 491 of August 13, 2006, which obligated the municipal authorities to form land plots of adjacent territories by July 1, 2008, register them and transfer them free of charge to home owners...
Let us repeat: the government decree was issued under the mayor of Tomsk Alexander Makarov, and should have been implemented nine (!) years ago under the mayor of Tomsk Nikolai Nikolaychuk...
5. If the Prosecutor's Office does not solve your problem, you should contact the Prosecutor General's Office.
If this path seems too long to you, then Vladimir Fursin offers another legal way to solve the problem:
Today, since the clarification of this issue by the Supreme Court of Russia, there is another way. It is necessary to hold a general meeting of homeowners. On which to submit documents prepared with the help of a cadastral engineer, who will approve the points (boundaries) of the site of the local area. The assembly must approve these boundaries. If there was a quorum at the general meeting of homeowners, and the majority votes in favor, then this document should be submitted to the mayor’s office, the department of housing and communal services and housing supervision, and the cadastral chamber. This is the best course of action.
But all homeowners will have to pay for the cadastral engineer’s work. According to our estimates, the cost of such work depends on the size of the territory and can vary from ten thousand to several tens of thousands of rubles.
"South Gate" Photo: Alexander SakalovWe draw the attention of readers that the problem of the lack of a legally registered local area is especially relevant for areas with infill development, where new houses were built not in an open field (such as the South Gate microdistrict with its parking lots, children's and sports grounds), but among previously constructed buildings and structures. In such cases, it is especially likely that the real border of your yard is not at all where you think. And it is quite possible that one day people will come to your spacious yard and take it away on completely legal grounds.