| The FFMS suggested that the Central MD change its director The Federal Service for Financial Markets, which completed an inspection of the work of the Central Moscow Depository on July 28-29, found only a violation of professional ethics in the actions of the Central Moscow Depository. However, as Vremya Novostey learned, the Federal Financial Markets Service, having not found direct violations of investors’ rights in the registrar’s actions, nevertheless invited the depositary to consider the issue of replacing the head of the CMD, Natalya Agafonova, by the beginning of October.
Let us recall that the Central Moscow Depository stopped operations with the registers of all issuers for two days after the investigative authorities seized on July 27 the server on which information on maintaining the registers was stored. The Ministry of Internal Affairs was interested in information related to the Arkhangelsk Pulp and Paper Mill. Its representatives explained the resumption of work of the depository on July 30 by the fact that they were able to launch a backup copy of the registers lost as a result of searches.
On the same day, the Federal Financial Markets Service sent CMD an order demanding to explain the reasons for the downtime and requested information about the status of its backup copies. Speaking about the reasons for the downtime, the Central MD repeated the version related to the seizure of registers. Meanwhile, the seized server, according to the press service of the Federal Financial Markets Service, contained data on only five issuers (including the Arkhangelsk Pulp and Paper Mill), as well as registers of enterprises previously serviced by the Center for Financial Markets. Operations on all registers maintained by the depositary, and their number exceeds 1,500, were suspended. Thus, to maintain the registers of most issuers, duplicate data was not needed at all, as was revealed during the FSFM audit.
Based on the results of the audit of the depository, the service plans to introduce regulatory requirements for the technology of maintaining databases and for their backup, protecting against the suspension of the registrar’s work in the event of extraordinary situations. Such requirements have not previously been described in detail. The FFMS intends to establish the frequency of database backups, oblige registrars to keep records of servers indicating the issuers whose registers are stored on each server, and also regulate in more detail the procedure and time for restoration work.
Having found no grounds for sanctions against the depository, the FFMS noted: “the public actions of the Central Bank did not comply with the principle according to which for professional participants in the securities market serving clients, in any situation and under any conditions, the priority should be strict observance of the interests of clients.” Indeed, the public actions of the CMD resembled a planned PR campaign. Thus, the text of the appeal of the Board of Directors of the Central MD Natalya Agafonova to the head of the FFMS Oleg Vyugin was published on July 28, and the service itself received official documents from the depositary only on July 30. Representatives of the Ministry of Internal Affairs spoke about attempts to put pressure on the investigation with references to the fall of the stock market and the suspension of operations with the RAO UES register.
Now, since, thanks to gaps in the legislation, the Central Moscow Depository managed to avoid liability, the regulator has filed claims against Ms. Agafonova, who may part with her chair. The essence of the FSFM's claims is not new. In June last year, in accordance with the instructions of the Federal Securities Commission, she was already removed from the post of chairman of the board of the Central Bank for several days, and then, by decision of the board of directors of the depositary, she was reinstated. The abolished FCSM motivated the need to remove Ms. Agafonova by the fact that in 2002 she was the director of Energoregistrator, a subsidiary of TsMD, which maintained the register of the Kotlas Pulp and Paper Mill. The license of the Energy Registrar was revoked by the commission, which discovered the fact of maintaining double registers of this pulp and paper mill and a number of other enterprises in the same industry. And according to the amendments to the law “On the Securities Market” that came into force in April 2003, persons who held management positions in the company at the time of revocation of its license are henceforth prohibited from heading companies that are professional participants in the stock market.
The board of directors of the Central MD motivated the reinstatement of Natalya Agafonova to her position last year by the fact that these amendments cannot have retroactive effect: the law came into force in April 2003, and the license of the Energy Registrar was canceled in 2002.
Nevertheless, earlier the FCSM, and now the FFMS, have their own view on this problem: neither the former regulator nor the current one included Natalya Agafonova in the unified register of certified persons, that is, they did not confirm her qualifications. And without this, from the point of view of the financial service, she cannot continue to remain the chairman of the board of the depository. Moreover, the story with the Kotlas Pulp and Paper Mill continued this spring already in the Central MD, where the investigative authorities seized documents relating to this issuer. And the suspension of the depositary's activities in July was associated with an investigation into the case of another pulp and paper mill - this time Arkhangelsk. The FFMS, by the way, announced yesterday its intention to sign an agreement on interaction with the Ministry of Internal Affairs. Igor POLISCHUK |
|