Without public oversight, the fight against corruption is ineffective
Russian human rights activists celebrated 40 days since the start of the “hunt for werewolves.” They call it “useful window dressing,” but believe that a real fight against corruption is impossible without creating a system of public control over the work of law enforcement agencies. “When the Ministry of Internal Affairs began this action, we would like the loud accusations to be followed by daily work to combat corruption,” Lev Ponomarev, executive director of the Human Rights Movement, said at a press conference yesterday. - However, we have not yet noticed any changes, in particular in cases under our control. Our organizations have dozens of specific examples of the inaction of the prosecutor’s office, arbitrariness of the police, falsification of cases, but we cannot achieve an answer on the merits.”
Chairman of the Committee of the Civil Rights Movement Andrei Babushkin is also confident that it is incredibly difficult to initiate criminal cases or verify facts of torture. “Our organization mainly receives replies from both the Moscow Prosecutor’s Office and the General Prosecutor’s Office,” he said. “Do we need such a cumbersome, expensive, but extremely ineffective system for protecting our rights?”
Human rights activists have long wanted to create a system of public control, including, in particular, an assessment of the work of the investigator or police officer by the person under investigation and the victim, a mandatory response to information about torture, and immediate action on calls to a hotline. And also that when appointing a new Moscow prosecutor, the opinion of the public must be taken into account.
However, so far only the Ministry of Justice has announced interaction with public organizations. Also yesterday, the first meeting of the public council under the Minister of Justice of the Russian Federation on problems of the activities of the penal system was held. The council included all those who had been striving for its creation for many years - Andrei Babushkin, Lyudmila Alekseeva, Valery Abramkin, and Archpriest Dmitry Smirnov. Famous human rights activist Valery Borshchev was elected chairman. In total, according to the head of the Main Directorate for the Execution of Punishments of the Russian Ministry of Justice, Vladimir Yalunin, 350 public and human rights organizations that monitor the observance of the rights of convicted and arrested persons cooperate with the GUIN.
Unfortunately, other law enforcement agencies have not yet followed the example of the Ministry of Justice. “We asked the Ministry of Internal Affairs about the number of cases related to corruption, but even this information, as we were told, is an “official secret,” said German Ivantsov, head of the Society for Improving Legal Culture “Shield.”