| Negotiations between India and Pakistan ended in failure The three-day Indo-Pakistani summit in Agra, from which both countries were expected almost a breakthrough capable of ending the long-standing Kashmir conflict, ended in a crushing failure. The eight hours that Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf spent in a face-to-face conversation were not enough to reach mutual understanding: the parties failed to sign even the most neutral joint statement. An even bigger scandal was caused by the decision of the Indian authorities not to hold the final press conference of the two leaders, taken “for security reasons.”
Neither side is saying what exactly led to the breakdown of negotiations. According to the Chief of the General Staff of the Pakistani Armed Forces, Lieutenant General Ghulam Ahmed, the Indians were offered three options for a joint statement, but all of them were rejected. Reporting this to journalists, the general especially insisted that his revelations be made public. In response, the Indian side took an extraordinary step, making public (with the help of one of the private television channels) the words of Prime Minister Vajpayee, spoken by him in the first hours of negotiations with the Pakistani leader. The Indian prime minister said that any negotiations related to Kashmir must include the issue of “cross-border terrorism.” Delhi famously accuses its neighbor of supporting Kashmiri Muslim insurgents, while Islamabad denies the accusations, calling the insurgents "armed freedom fighters."
The Pakistanis, however, express cautious optimism: according to Foreign Minister Abdul Sattar, twice during the negotiations the parties were closer than ever to a cherished compromise. And Vajpayee, despite the failure of the first meeting, accepted Musharraf’s invitation to visit Pakistan (the visit could take place as early as September, however, according to Pakistani newspapers, it will most likely be postponed until next year). At the same time, Indian Foreign Minister Jaswant Singh said yesterday that concentrating on only one issue - Kashmir - will not help bring peace. “The fate of the complex negotiations literally hangs in the balance,” the minister said.
Perhaps the Indian minister's statements shed some light on what happened in Agra. Given the sensitivity of the Pakistanis to the Kashmir issue, it is not at all impossible that General Musharraf unequivocally stated that until the Kashmir problem is resolved, further negotiations are pointless. The difficulties that stand in the way of the Indo-Pakistani dialogue are evidenced by the fact that in Agra the parties could not even agree on how to call the Kashmir confrontation - an “issue”, a “problem” or something else. Alexey SLOBODIN, Evgeny ANTONOV |
|