About the "speakers" - the Christian ecomanifesta Tatyana Goricheva
Tatyana Goricheva is known as a Christian philosopher, co -author of Yuri Mamleeva, feminist and activist of animal rights. The theme of her book “Talking“ Yes ”” was the thoughts of an Orthodox person about the protection of the environment - a completely eschatological problem, if you look at it through the eyes of a believer. Eduard Lukoyanov tells about this book, in which theology and actual criticism of Western civilization came together.Tatyana Goricheva. "Talking" yes. " M.: Ecological Chamber of Russia, 2020. Content
Ecology today is inextricable with ethics. Moreover, the words “ethics” and “ethical” are quite cunningly losing their true meaning, rather acquiring the meaning of “correct” or even “corresponding to expectations”. In the entrances there are posters that campaign for separate garbage collection, because it is undoubtedly correct, but even in Moscow there are appropriate containers in every yard. However, this is a tenth business in the world where ethics is reduced to a strictly limited idea of the norm, and in some cases to the state of fashion - the most superficial way of public expression of utilitarian ethics.
Veganism is acceptable as a kind of diet, but not as a moral attitude - in this case, it is perceived as food deviation, turning into a disorder of social behavior. Concerned to the state of the environment is approved while the volunteers clean the cans scattered in the forest belt. It is worth the same volunteers to sabotage the construction of the next nickel plant in the protected zone, as they immediately go from the category of decent caring citizens into the category of enemies of society, who take their jobs from people, and indeed “paid money”. In the United States, environmental radicals acting outside state standards are recorded in terrorists. In Russia, ecologists who are not inscribed in power structures, at best, are portrayed by city crazy ones, at worst - they beat their feet and try to cover up for “unwanted”.
And the very concept of “environmentally friendly” in the world with flickering ethical optics has become primarily “prestigious”. Take care of your health? Buy a kilogram of ecologically pure meat of an ecologically purely clogged calf. And arrange a monthly donation for our organization, which fights environmental pollution by synthetic tissue production factories, lobbying the interests of environmentally friendly fox farms.
In the political field, this substitution of concepts is even more noticeable. Dictators and not quite dictators love animals. But the gold monument to Alabay in the center of Ashgabat is a monument, of course, not to the dog, but to the one who put it. The participation of Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin in environmental actions is not a signal about the need to participate in the environment, but just a reminder that our president cares about all existence.
Tatyana Goricheva in the book “Talking“ Yes ”“ is trying to return their original meaning to the wiped words, converting the conversation about ecology into the channel of ethics, and in its most extreme form - religious. And this gesture is more than fair in its radicality: if the arguments of the mind are powerless, then why not look at the same problems from an emotional point of view? This gaze can be very painful, because the fact that we in everyday life consider only a small deviation from the ethical norm in Goricheva becomes the deepest moral disaster, an unbearable burden of collective sin:
“Everywhere around us massacres are committed, on which we close our eyes in general joint effort ... We do not feel the mud of our actions. <...> The meaningless and cruel scientific experiences continue. According to Oygen Oldern, for the sake of “scientific goals” every year 300 million animals are tortured and killed every year. The inability of Christians to formulate the question of the attitude to animals speaks of our immaturity, about the lag in time even compared to atheistic thought. ”
Despite the purely religious (in this case - Orthodox) optics, Goricheva’s book is universal and can be translated into the language of “secular humanism”, which is based on the same Christian morality. And Tatyana Mikhailovna himself deftly combines biblical studies with attention to worldly problems - in the end, global climatic changes and other Timotimortonon hypertension do not look at the column “religion” and do not bypass anyone. It is the unity of people in front of the disaster that becomes the leading motive of the book, in which Goricheva, which had a very negative experience in emigration and, in its journalism, was largely oriented towards the anti -Western agenda, admits with reference to Felix Guattari:
“The time passed when the world was under the auspices of the Antagonism“ West - East ”, the antagonism of“ Bourgeois - Worker ”. Nowadays, everyone is equally exposed to danger. Establishments for benefits, utilitarianism are outdated everywhere, both in capitalist countries and in socialist countries. The world is rapidly Europeanized. Everywhere we meet the same thing: the installation of rationalism, the dictatorship of the media, the same youth mods, the same rock music, the same language. And the same danger of self -destruction. ”
However, despite the victorious globalism that defeated and has become non -alternative, "a modern Western man feels like an emigrant in any country." The Marxist would explain this through a logical alienation of personality from the primary speakers of being; In fact, about the same (but carefully avoiding Marxist vocabulary) says Gorichev, interpreting alienation as a result of the crisis of Christian civilization:
“Being is manifested. This is his imperfection and sinfulness. As Jean-Paul Sartre said, everything exists due to weakness or only because there is no strength to die. Genesis, deprived of meaning, and such is Sartre, and many today, is always superfluous. Outgoing to nausea. The less being, the less connected with the hierarchy of values, the more impudently it declares itself. ”
A person from the East Christian world feels especially painfully painfully, because contrary to the declared spiritual victory over Protestantism and Catholicism love for the neighbor, which in this case means animals and elements, which manages itself in the northern Protestant countries like Sweden and Norway than in Orthodox Greece, Serbia and Russia. Of course, in this case, Gorichev falls into the trap of imaginary correlations, but the fact remains, and a mournful reproach - a mournful reproach.
Moreover, Goricheva, speaking of Christian ecology, is literally forced to turn to thinkers of other faiths, which is fraught with accusations of ecumenism, which Tatyana Mikhailovna, however, rejects in advance. Of course, she addresses the patristic texts, to Seraphim Rose, to Bishop John (Kovalevsky), from which Goricheva borrowed the image of animals from the Noah ark, speaking to God “Yes,” but speech, based exclusively on Orthodox scriptures, turns out to be insufficient. Therefore, Martin Bubert, Kierkegaard, Henri Le C and many other representatives are largely antagonistic in relation to the Orthodoxy of the world are involved in the discussion.
With the same ease and freedom, Tatyana Goricheva also addresses secular authors, whose ideological attitudes seem to be alien to her. She consistently criticizes Western utilitarianism, but with enthusiasm, she quotes Bentam, on whose ideas this very utilitarianism is based; The postmodern stagnation also causes her a feeling of disgust, but Derrida becomes an important co -author of Gorichev’s texts, and over the pages devoted to criticism of technological progress, the shadow of the philosopher of the speed of the field of Virillo is clearly visible. At such, rather unexpected clashes, all philosophical journalism, presented in the book, is built.
Those who take up the “speaking“ yes ”” should be in advance of the usual attributes of critical analysis and be guided by a purely emotional perception of the text. In this sense, Goricheva’s book, consciously or not, serves as a kind of illustration to pragmatic (and, as a rule, hopelessly false) criticism of the ideologies of religious or quasi -religious phenomena. And here it is important to note that the reader needs to be prepared for another characteristic property of Goricheva’s letter.
Tatyana Mikhailovna Goricheva is customary to represent as a Christian philosopher, which she, of course, is. But its method goes far beyond the borders of both academic philosophy and non -academic philosophy, one way or another inscribed in conventional ideas about philosophical science. From Goricheva-Ecophilosopher, you should not wait for the harmony of thought and sequence of conclusions-they are compensated by the same journalistic affect and the bare perception of being, which is close to the corset of academism. (In this sense, she in her own way organically looks in the provocative anthology of Alexei Nilogov “Who today makes philosophy in Russia”, where Goricheva’s article “They did not leave Paradise” is adjacent to the texts of Marxist Boris Kagarlitsky or, for example, an outstanding theorist and the practice of Extreme transgression of Azsaklah Zaratustra.)
But the main difficulty is not at all connected with the unusual and, frankly, disordered by the manner of Goricheva’s letter, but with the form in which it exists with the efforts of the “Ecological Chamber of Russia”. The book is submitted as a holistic work, divided into three parts (except for the appendix with several articles and interviews): “Holy Animals”, “The Silence of Animals” and “They did not leave paradise”. And the reader, turning to this text, will sooner or later notice that in places the author contradicts himself, or even simply refutes himself. I will give such an example:
“At all times, the voice of a person, the voice of reason, opposed the growl of the lion and the mooing of the bull. The man waged war against Leo and the Bull, and he finally won this war. Today, animals have no advantages. They confront us only with their silence. Our victims heroically refuse to talk to us. ”
But in another place Gorichev, as if forgetting about this wonderful observation in his poetic pathos, writes:
“The animal suffers and suffers doubly.
Firstly, because it suffers innocently.
Secondly, because he cannot tell about his suffering, to explain them. The stated suffering is only half suffering. ”
What was presented as heroic dignity suddenly turns out to be a component of stigma. Because of this contradiction, one suspicion arises, which is confirmed, for example, by the fact that sometimes Goricheva speaks of Heidegger (with which, by the way, was in many years of correspondence) almost as a contemporary, and sometimes as a philosopher of the long time.
The fact is that in “Talking“ Yes ”” articles of different years are collected, the earliest of which was written no later than 1993, and the latter was dated to 2009. It is quite natural, when a person over a quarter of a century changes his views or simply forgets about some little things, but within the limits of one book that does not contain a hint of a conceptual justification, this is somewhat confused, and it turns out that it is proposed not to argue with the author, but with its editors who have hastily filled with disparate articles under one cover. (By the way, judging by the repeated typos, the employees of the “Ecological Chamber of Russia” took on the basis of the Slovenian publishing house Kud Logos, the compilation of Gorichev’s articles “Blessed and the livestock has mercy on”.) If even the partners of the Goricheva case are indifferent to her ideas, then what to expect from the reader of an outsider, non -entertained, and reduced, reduced to them. Listen to?
Of course, the texts of Tatyana Goricheva, dedicated to Christian ecology, deserve to finally be published in an acceptable form, because they are very significant in the light of an obvious dead end of humanism in its current form and for the search for an alternative, non-human project. It is very significant that recently we have regularly been released, including the philosophy of ecology and animal philosophy, literature written by completely different authors: this, say, “what animals teach us in politics?” The representative of the “speculative pragmatism” by Bayan Massy, the “homeland” of Oksana Timofeeva, and now the journalism of Tatyana Goricheva, who has come to the reader, representing a completely different philosophical and political tradition. And the intersection of the interests of such different theorists is, of course, one of the points where human thought goes through the healing process.