| Edinburgh Festival is finally over Here we live and think that it is only our evil state that does not provide money for culture, only our uncouth bosses create obstacles to bold undertakings, and only our public grumbles and grimaces at any reason. Nothing happened. Even in such a prosperous country as Great Britain, enthusiasts and devotees face inhuman difficulties and heroically overcome them. Among these dedicated people is undoubtedly Edinburgh Festival Director Brian McMaster. On the one hand, everyone pays tribute to him, praising his organizational skills and calling him a long-lived director (he recently again agreed to extend his contract with the city authorities for four years and by the end of this period he will have headed the festival for 13 years - an incident unprecedented in the history of the Edinburgh Forum) . On the other hand, talk is becoming more and more active that the festival has lost its once unattainable status and that it will soon be swallowed up by the Fringe, which is growing by leaps and bounds (a festival of street and marginal theaters accompanying the main forum). Both are true.
McMaster's merits are obvious. It was he who was able to attract to the capital of Scotland not only performances by famous opera directors, but also productions by first-class choreographers (ballet in the British Isles has always been less popular than opera). It was he who first began to provide festival venues for the cool avant-garde and long theatrical epics. But what pleases some causes confusion for others. McMaster is considered not only the longest-serving director, but also the most adventurous. Thus, the final article in the Sunday Times begins with the statement that there were no hits at the current Edinburgh Festival, but there were many failures. And in general, mediocrity of all shades and stripes (from traditionalists to avant-garde) triumphed. This sounds quite strange, considering that the ballet part of the festival included such world celebrities as Mats Eck and Jiri Kylian. The young choreographer from Germany Sasha Waltz can also be reproached for anything, but not for being mediocre.
McMaster reacts to all these attacks with Olympic calm. He formulates his festival philosophy as follows: “A real director must be able to take risks.” Some of McMaster's initiatives are truly impressive. This year, for example, he, on the one hand, spared no expense to bring the performance of the fashionable Italian choreographer Emio Greco Extra Dry and perform it only once, and even then late in the evening (“since we can’t invite for a long time, let at least someone he’ll see something”), on the other hand, he took the risk of inviting the epic play “Rough Comedies” based on Ramon del Valle Inclan to Edinburgh for two and a half weeks. The performance lasts four hours, there are many seats in the hall, the troupe (Dublin's Abbey Theater) is little known outside of Ireland, and tickets are expensive. “But this is one of the most significant Spanish writers of the twentieth century, these are wonderful actors and the most interesting director Calixto Bieto. Moreover, such a performance cannot be seen either in the West End or at the National Theater. Our task is not to adapt to the tastes of the crowd, but to make a serious popular art. What else is a festival for?
Among the blockbusters of the Edinburgh Festival that caused the most surprise among the press and the public was Wagner's "Ring of the Nibelungs", staged at the Scottish Opera. This work of the gloomy German genius is one of the most complex and expensive projects; even the most famous theaters rarely dare to attempt The Ring. This undertaking completely led the Scottish Opera into organizational and financial confusion. But McMaster, who initiated it, was relentless. “Yes, Scottish Opera is not the strongest in the world. But there are works that need to be staged at least once. For example, in Wales, the National Opera achieved recognition in its homeland only when it staged Wagner and brought him to Covent Garden,” - - he explained.
Another McMaster venture is an attempt to combine the Czech Philharmonic Orchestra, Australian conductor Charles Mackeras and the Dutch Dance Theater in one performance to present a ballet by Jiri Kylian to the music of the famous Czech composer Leoš Janáček. “If the idea succeeds, it will be a sensation,” declared McMaster, “Czech musicians and Kilian (of Czech origin) have Janacek’s music in their blood, and Makkeras is one of his best conductors.”
It is difficult to say whether the idea was a success. The famous Australian said that he would never “go down into this damn pit to conduct a ballet” again. Kilian himself was in constant hysterics due to the fact that rehearsal time was limited. And the press sarcastically wrote that the audience at the performance enjoyed the sound of the orchestra more than the ballet itself, “this strange cross between classical and modern dance, which Janacek’s music kept tripping over.” “But this is a real festival project,” McMaster lamented, “you won’t see this anywhere except Edinburgh.”
British critics reacted somewhat more favorably to Sacha Waltz's play Korper ("Bodies") (this is her first production at the famous Berlin Schaubühne Theater, which she recently headed together with Thomas Ostermeier). “There’s something Teutonic-sinister about Waltz’s carnal comedy,” writes a columnist for The Times. “People are lifted and moved by grasping folds of skin. Two women report the value of their internal organs. The stage becomes a refuge for the insane. Half-naked bodies are rolling along the stage, like corpses in a concentration camp, into a common grave. All this is clearly too much, but as an example of social apocalypse it makes sense.” However, the main definition that Waltz's performance received was an artistic adventure. “Those who stayed until the end gave a standing ovation, but most of the audience left the performance in the middle of the action,” the critics stated.
According to the director himself, this year the program was not as radical as in the past, when the controversy about the festival was in full swing. “Moreover, tickets for the most “problematic” performances (for example, for the play “The Sleepwalkers” by Polish director Krystian Lupa, based on the novel by Hermann Broch, running three nights in a row) were sold out,” McMaster noted with satisfaction.
The festival halls are indeed not empty, but the idealistic director continually faces financial difficulties. In 1994, the festival budget was 2,000,000 pounds, this year it is 1,900,000. Taking into account inflation, this means a twenty percent sequestration. We never dreamed of such sums, but for McMaster this is a significant blow. Another painful issue is the notorious Fringe. Especially his unilateral decision to start his program a week earlier than the main one. All this completely confuses guests of the capital. The main festival is just beginning, and many people think that it has already passed the halfway point. It's difficult for McMaster to adjust to the Fringe. After all, the directorate of the “curbside” does not have to negotiate deadlines with first-class orchestras and look for venues for fastidious choreographers. Everybody comes to the Fringe and plays whatever they want. This is, so to speak, the true kingdom of democracy and egalitarianism. McMaster, on the other hand, has a hard time with his elitist approach. So, to all the complaints of our directors and artistic directors, the Ministry of Culture can, referring to the Scottish ascetic, answer: “Who has it easy now?” Marina DAVYDOVA |
|