| The number of criminal cases based on a tip from the Accounts Chamber has increased sharply Based on the results of audits by the Accounts Chamber in 2004, about 300 criminal cases were already initiated on economic crimes and corruption. Chairman of the Accounts Chamber Sergei Stepashin told the deputies about this yesterday. Last year, the Accounts Chamber managed to initiate only two hundred cases with its recommendations.
“In less than 2004, based on the results of inspections by the Accounts Chamber, mostly by the Prosecutor General’s Office, 298 criminal cases were opened for economic crimes and corruption,” Sergei Stepashin said during parliamentary hearings in the State Duma. The final results of the effectiveness of the chamber’s work this year cannot yet be summed up. But it is already clear that the chamber is making confident progress in this regard. The number of criminal cases initiated as a result of inspections in 2001 was only 49; last year this number increased to 241. And 72 officials were brought to justice. According to Deputy Prosecutor General of Russia Sabir Kekhlerov, in 2003 more than two thousand officials were convicted of corruption.
Sergei Stepashin established the relationship between the level of corruption and the quality of legal norms in the state: “The fight against corruption cannot be effective without a significant revision of the current legislation.” According to him, the required audit methodology has already been developed and tested in the Land, Forestry and other codes. In addition, Mr. Stepashin said, migration legislation will undergo such an audit in the near future.
By the way, this summer the head of the Accounts Chamber proposed to legislators, for example, to legally justify the approach in which it is officials who pay out of their own pockets for the misuse of budget funds. In particular, according to the head of the chamber, amendments to the Criminal Code on the personal liability of officials would help solve this problem. Mr. Stepashin told deputies on Tuesday that about 5% of the gross domestic product is lost due to corruption.
If last year the Accounts Chamber considered the inspection of the Chukotka Autonomous Okrug to be the most successful “project,” in 2004 the most high-profile action of the chamber will most likely be an analysis of the results of the privatization of state property over ten years. Over the course of six months, the chamber analyzed all three stages of privatization: “political” check privatization, privatization through investment competitions and fiscal (simple sale of state-owned enterprises). In an analytical note, the Accounts Chamber assessed the initial economic data and the main economic and social results of privatization. She also separately examined the activities of government bodies during privatization and the effectiveness of attracting foreign capital. The auditors agreed that the main goals of privatization were not achieved. By “main goals” the Accounts Chamber meant the formation of a significant layer of private owners in Russia, the formation of socially responsible businesses, the social protection of citizens and the creation of a competitive environment. However, the latter was achieved to some extent. Also, according to the auditors, “privatization fulfilled its historical role”: although “formally the economic situation of the country has worsened, in fact, if we remember what happened in the early 90s, it has improved.”
Based on the results of this audit, the Prosecutor General's Office has not yet opened any criminal cases. At the moment, there are no plans to revise the results of privatization. But now the Accounts Chamber can conduct audits of modern privatization, relying on “historical experience.”
Legislators appreciated the growing activity of the Accounts Chamber, leaving themselves the opportunity to closely interact with this body. At the end of the previous session, the Duma proposed transferring to the president the right to actually appoint and remove the chairman of the chamber, as well as his deputy. But the Federation Council rejected this law with the creation of a conciliation commission. According to the deputy chairman of the Senate commission for interaction with the Accounts Chamber, Sergei Ivanov, after finalization, proposals on candidates for the position of head of the Accounts Chamber and his deputy can be submitted to the president not only by deputy associations in the State Duma and its committees, but also by committees and commissions of the Federation Council. Or no less than one fifth of the total number of deputies or senators. “The proposed change in the procedure for forming the Accounts Chamber involves ensuring the most favorable conditions for the effective implementation of constitutional powers to exercise independent control over the expenditure of state budget funds,” said Mr. Ivanov and promised that at a meeting on Wednesday the relevant committee will recommend that senators approve this option formation of the Accounts Chamber. Daria GUSEVA |
|