An unusual trial is taking place these days in the Vasileostrovsky Federal Court of St. Petersburg. What is happening in the Temple of Themis is very reminiscent of a meeting of the Inquisition, especially since the case is being considered to protect the honor and dignity of Christians around the world.
Themis got confused in the nuances of television art and the intricacies of faith
Let us remind you: back in the summer of this year, St. Petersburg resident Artak Aleksanyan filed a lawsuit against the Rambler NBN television company, demanding compensation for moral damage in the amount of 1 million rubles. The essence of Aleksanyan’s claims is extremely simple. For several years, on a variety of TV channels, including Rambler NBN, he saw a commercial about a holiday in Turkey. The advertisement, in his opinion, turned out to be quite strange - Muslim sectarian dervishes were inviting people to go to the shores of the Black Sea, dancing as if on the face of Jesus Christ from the famous St. Sophia Cathedral in Istanbul.
According to Artak Aleksanyan, such television advertising offended him to the core. From specialists at the Museum of the History of Religion, he received a certificate stating that the dancers in the frame are indeed dervishes, and in addition, he secured an expert opinion from the North-West Regional Forensic Center that the advertising video humiliates the honor and dignity of Christians. Aleksanyan applied to the Vasileostrovsky Federal Court with these documents. He demands from Themis to ban the broadcast of the mentioned video, and in addition, to recover a million rubles from the television company. Artak Aleksanyan plans to spend the entire amount for charitable purposes.
The Vasileostrovsky Court of St. Petersburg accepted Aleksanyan’s claim for consideration, but still cannot make a decision. More and more new persons are being brought to participate in the case as defendants. It turned out that the ill-fated video was released several years ago by the Turkish Ministry of Tourism and is broadcast throughout the world. It has not yet been possible to find out who exactly is responsible for its display on Russian territory.
The position of the TV channel is also quite interesting. Initially, his representatives could not understand why it was Aleksanyan who filed the lawsuit. After Artak’s stories about how humiliating he, a Christian, was to be shown such pictures, they changed their point of view. According to a representative of Rambler NBN, any sane person understands that icons cannot be placed on the floor, this is simply a projection of an image, one might say, an optical illusion. The dervish dance itself is not prohibited; it symbolizes the rotation of the spheres of the universe and is an element of Turkish culture. Its combination with the face of Christ, according to the television crew, is not an insult, but, on the contrary, a friendly gesture towards Christians around the world, which demonstrates the Turks’ tolerance for representatives of other religions.
However, some scientists and representatives of Orthodoxy involved in the case as experts categorically disagree with such statements.
“The display of such videos contradicts the understanding of the relationship between Islam and Christianity in the modern world and leads us back to religious wars,” says Nikolai Semakov, a teacher of the foundations of Orthodox culture. – If the video had been anti-Islamic in nature, it would most likely have caused an outburst of indignation with the most negative consequences.
Disputes about faith in the Vasileostrovsky Federal Court have not yet ended in anything. The next hearing on Aleksanyan’s lawsuit is scheduled for December 4. Artak hopes that his claim will be satisfied this year, and plans to spend the money recovered from the claim on Christmas gifts for children from disadvantaged families.
Andrey IVANOV
Photo by the author