Novaya's columnist Boris Vishnevsky talks about why the dictatorship doesn't know how to deal with crises
medical workers have died in St. Petersburg and the Leningrad region since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic (*according to the “Memory List”)
Judge Vitaly Barkovsky became famous after considering the so-called Madonna case, when several Orthodox activists demanded compensation from the pop diva for allegedly suffering moral suffering. .
When Vitaly Barkovsky refused to satisfy the claim, even skeptics who followed the process were forced to admit that adequate judges still exist 
Plaintiff Dedova

Defendant Madonna
Novaya talked with the deputy chairman of the Moscow District Court, Vitaly Barkovsky, whose phrase about “other plaintiffs who can see a phallic symbol in a sausage” became a catchphrase. About the court, about freedom, about clericalization and about Madonna.
— Let's start with the pop one. Do you like the work of Madonna and Lady Gaga?
“Before the lawsuit was accepted, I could not distinguish Lady Gaga from Madonna either from photographs or from Madonna’s voice. Afterwards, I began to recognize Madonna’s work, especially since none of my acquaintances missed an opportunity to joke about “our special relationship.” I like the performance and creative approach; I will leave her political and social statements without comment.
— How do you feel about gays?
— I’ll answer classically: I’m not one of them. I have never had anything to do with the gay community. Due to my convictions in a completely traditional orientation, let everyone who will include me in this community prepare for a lawsuit for the protection of honor and dignity, since this will be the dissemination of information that does not correspond to reality. It is very unpleasant for the son of an officer with orthodox family traditions and a boxing background to hear such things.
— The plaintiffs in the Madonna case say they are scared by gay pride parades. Do they scare you?
- No, if they don’t attack (just kidding). Like any public event, it must be agreed with the administration. I'm not against social groups expressing themselves. It’s different when such self-expression turns into showing off. To me, openly protesting against gays is tantamount to showing off being gay. Both are self-exaggeration and a manifestation of intolerance. I believe that a person is a value in himself, and what hobbies and physiological needs he has are his own business.
— At the trial you talked about Oscar Wilde...
“I cited him as an example when discussing the issue of attitude towards great people who did not hide their gay orientation. I learned about Wilde’s personality traits only when I read opinions on the law regarding the promotion of homosexuality. And so, when reading literature, I never wonder whether the author is gay, football fans or gardeners.
— Name your favorite writers.
- Nabokov, Bulgakov and Dovlatov. From foreign ones - Hesse, Kundera. I'm currently reading Salman Rushdie's Shame.
— And as far as I understand, you are not very interested in the work of Marat Gelman.
“To my shame, I first heard about it from the plaintiffs, for which I thank them. My whole life is spent at work, which absorbs absolutely all my time. 12 hour work day. The judge is lucky if he manages to meet this time, which is usually longer. Judges even take vacations to retire from cases. What people see in our work, the actual court hearings, is the tip of the iceberg; 90% of the work goes unnoticed in the deliberation room. This includes motivating decisions, checking protocols, analyzing newly received applications, etc., etc. You can only read for yourself on the subway or train.
—Are you a liberal or a conservative?
- Liberal. For me, liberal values are freedom of speech and freedom of creativity.
-Are you an idealist?
— The last time a teacher called me an idealist was in the 6th grade during a biology lesson, when I was not prepared for an answer about the origin of species. Probably everything remains the same.
— Did you go to rallies?
- No, I haven’t and I won’t go as long as I have the status of a judge. Participation in rallies is expressly prohibited.
— Do you know who hipsters are?
- No, this is the first time I’ve heard from you.
- A liberal judge... In today's Russia this sounds somehow sinful, as they say on the Internet.
— My personal opinion: the judge is a liberal. Man is free from birth. To recognize this means to be a liberal, to be free and to recognize the freedom of others. I was born with this. Regarding the Internet: thank you to all users for your feedback about this matter and about me, especially the positive ones. I didn't expect such a massive reaction. I consider reviews like “I was convinced that there is justice” to be the highest assessment of my work.
— In the early 90s, were you among those who demanded democracy?
— In the early 90s, I was still growing up; at the end of the 90s I worked as an investigator at the prosecutor’s office, and I personally felt those hard years. I have always been guided by the principle of personal freedom. The question is: who understands this freedom? Freedom ends where another person's freedom begins. Nobody said it better than Kant. If one exercises freedom in such a way that this constitutes the elements of a specific offense, then he must answer for such freedom. My work gives me the opportunity to observe an amazing metamorphosis: the bastard, who yesterday stole mobile phones, in the detention center becomes scrupulous in strictly observing the laws regarding himself.
— Aren’t you afraid that Russia will turn into Europe? Denmark, for example, where some say boys are forced to wear dresses.
— I want to live in a country integrated into the world community (without the shadow of negativity that some plaintiffs put into this concept). Russia is a European country, and its identity will never go away. The question is that the struggle for identity does not become absurd. Throwing dumplings at McDonald's won't work, and there's no point in doing so. The social groups and ideas that the plaintiffs called “imported” do not pose any serious danger to identity, much less sovereignty. And those who think otherwise, I believe, underestimate the strength and importance of the Russian spirit and Russian community.
— How do you work given the current colossal mistrust of the judicial system?
— Negativity from society is felt and cultivated. I think that when we start talking to people in a language they understand, they will not be subject to the stereotype that the court is a repressive machine. The court is really the power that resolves real disputes, every day and with specific people. You may never get an appointment with an official from the executive branch, only the doors of the court are always open, you just need to enter these doors in the procedural form established by law, without this form they may seem closed. There should be no negativity towards the judicial system. The attitude towards the court must be based on total and unconditional trust, then the court itself will prove that it can be trusted. It's impossible otherwise. No control measures can instill faith in justice.
- At the same time, he exists. Former Pussy Riot lawyer Mark Feigin says left and right that almost all lawyers come to judges with bribes. And only he, supposedly, in the company of his colleagues Volkova and Polozov, all dressed in white.
— The myth of corruption in court was invented and cultivated by dishonest lawyers and corrupt officials from the executive branch. The logic of a legal degenerate: if a lawyer wins in court, that means he is a genius; if he loses, that means the other side “gave” more. If your lawyer included “money for the judge” in his fee, contact the Investigative Committee. I assume 99% that such a lawyer will be convicted of fraud, and if that same one percent is acquitted, he will sit with the judge for bribery.
— Let's return to the openness of the judiciary. Can you be found on the Internet?
— The position of the higher court, announced to the judges: avoid presence on social networks. The reason for this was the dissemination of personal data taken from judges’ pages on social networks. But this applies to the personal pages of judges. Officially, each court has websites that ensure openness and accessibility of information.
— Distrust in the judicial system has increased significantly over the past year. Many watched the trials following the December elections.
— The electoral law is very complex in structure and presentation. Its effective use is due to a good command of legal techniques. The position of the election commissions was based on legal norms, and in some cases the applicants agreed with them. I’m not saying that the law is perfect, I would present it simpler and clearer, which would eliminate double interpretation, which, in fact, is what the law should have since the time of Justinian.
Personally, this year I reviewed four cases of complaints against the actions of election commissions, one application was satisfied. The actions of one head of the PEC were declared illegal. I have never faced pressure on myself, I can’t imagine what it should look like: a call from a higher court or an installation at a general meeting of judges? If this happens, I will let you know.
And with the so-called There was no hint, no pressure, or even interest from higher courts or the executive branch in Madonna’s case. It's a shame. Kidding.
— It is possible that the example of the “Trade Union of Citizens of Russia” will be followed by Cossacks, priests and others. And all with crazy lawsuits in pursuit of PR. The court actually becomes a platform for such PR operations.
“The court is a hostage to this situation; we have no right to refuse to accept the application.” For example: one of the first statements that I encountered while working in the prosecutor’s office literally contained the following: “I ask you to poison my son-in-law with potassium cyanide because he performs indecent sexual acts with my daughter, which I personally witnessed through the keyhole.” In accordance with the Criminal Procedure Code, such a statement must be checked and a procedural decision must be made; this is the responsibility of the investigator in this case. To anyone else, it will seem ridiculous and worthy only of the trash can.
The court is even more constrained by procedural requirements. Failure to accept statements, including obviously absurd ones, is immediately regarded as a restriction of access to justice. Having accepted the application, the court is obliged to provide a public form for its consideration. History confirms that the court was used as a platform for public statements by Vera Zasulich, Hitler, and Breivik. So if you want a quick PR, welcome to court.
— We have already found out that you are not gay, but do you want to be friends with the Cossacks who recently offended Nabokov?
— Representatives of the Cossacks, as far as I know, denied their participation in the actions that led to the cancellation of this performance. In any case, the actions of those who caused the performance to be canceled are utter absurdity and obscurantism. I will subscribe to these words of Leonid Mozgovoy. Obscurantism is darkness and demons. In darkness there is no reason, and where it is absent, monsters are born. Remember Goya’s engraving “The Sleep of Reason Gives Birth to Monsters”?
—Are you Orthodox?
— I’ll state the answer this way: First, God is in the heart. Secondly, persecution for religious beliefs is unacceptable. Thirdly, religion should be engaged in the search for truth, and not in the propagation of dogmas. The last expression, unfortunately, is not mine, but Steve Jobs’, but I will subscribe to it.
— Did you participate in the procession led by the Vice-Governor of St. Petersburg Vasily Kichedzhi?
— No, I think that religion is a very personal matter. In addition, when officials participate in such events, it takes on the character of a political action, in which judges are expressly prohibited from participating.
— Let’s imagine a situation: recertification of judges has been announced. Only Orthodox Christians can pass it. What are your actions?
“I consider this a violation of personal freedom, even if it does not concern me personally.” If such a requirement is a necessary condition for acquiring or continuing the status of a judge, then I will prefer to refuse this status.
Interviewed by Alexandra GARMAZHAPOV