For the second week in a row, writing about the European University in St. Petersburg, by modern standards, should be even more boring than reading about it. After all, what do you need now? By historical standards, the EU instantly defended itself from the ban on educational activities by Rosobrnadzor, having received a corresponding ruling from the Moscow Arbitration Court.
Students have been studying since last Friday, the enemies of education are hissing in their lairs, in the offices of officials who have been given the appropriate instructions, a set of measures is being cheerfully, cynically and slowly developed that will allow everyone, in full compliance with the law and without much fuss, to return the situation back without any damage to status. all potential and actual actors. But that's not what I'm talking about. The EU is a European university, to be useful to society by its reaction to the situation - and it was last week that an excellent opportunity was discovered to show how the EU differs from other similar structures.
On December 23, the university launches a series of public lectures in support of itself. The first lecture will be given by the head of the EU Board of Trustees, Mikhail Piotrovsky, who will talk about his vision of the museum institution as a historiographer of conflict and dialogue of cultures. The next lectures will most likely include Boris Grebenshchikov and Valery Gergiev. The very combination of just these three names in one cycle is enough to understand that something non-trivial is happening. But that's not what I'm talking about. The EU, through its collective decision, acts in a way that no institution of Soviet origin would have acted under any circumstances, and in a way that, in general, no one expected from it.
Until the last moment, the general concern about what the EU threatens in the future was, on the one hand, moderate in intensity of emotions, and on the other hand, pessimistic. Details aside, in mid-December the university acted out a classic scene from Mikhail Bulgakov’s “Heart of a Dog.” After Professor Preobrazhensky’s conversation with the delegation of the house committee reaches a dead end, he asks to wait, goes to the phone and, in a short conversation with the unknown powers that be, in which he promises to leave for Crimea and stop practicing medicine, demands that they stop trying to social terror. In the process of discussing with his transcendental interlocutor, Preobrazhensky asks from him “the final piece of paper, factual, real - armor!”, a safe-conduct that protects against attacks by idiots accompanied by Red Army soldiers. They mumble something on the clouds, after which the idiots are called to the telephone and receive a telephone scolding for their zeal.
I have every reason to believe that in the case of the EU, the scene continues along the classical outline, and Comrade Pestrukhina tried to have her say, and Comrade Shvonder will certainly not abandon his cleanup activities and will visit the EU more than once in 2017, although and more than once he will be taken out. Society, in turn, has every reason to believe that when Bulgakov’s plot ends, the continuation will also be historical. Preobrazhensky still has five years left to call beyond the clouds: the newly blessed thirty-proof vodka “Rykovka” appeared on mass sale around Orthodox Christmas in 1925; The “Academics’ Case” is just five years away, you can still die in peace; after that the professor would go into exile as a member of a “church group”, like, for example, the historian Alexander Brilliantov - he died in 1933 in exile in Tambov. What can EU expect in the medium term? For a few more years, Piotrovsky, Kudrin, Gergiev, and many others will be communicating with the highest echelon of the scientific and cultural institution, which will not make any futile noise in the future. Then everything will get worse, it will be more difficult to call. I don’t want to think about the future - we will live in the present, as long as we are given. Moreover, it seems that EU is one of the few private universities that in the public field makes a much smaller impression than it would be worth talking about: the lack of image self-promotion, participation in pretentious cultural events, refusal of fashionable intellectual provocations, some isolation and even introversion.
And it’s even clear why they are introverts. The poorly captured moment of Preobrazhensky’s conversation on the phone with the idea of power is what the authorities quite honestly explain to him behind the text: “a final piece of paper” cannot exist by definition in the social system that is being formed. There is no such stamped paper, such a large seal, such ink and such a name that they are left behind forever and the spirit of them is not here. This, professor, is not provided for by the basis of the constitutional system. It's strange that you don't understand such things. Until recently, the EU seemed to understand everything. And then they bucked. And they did the right thing.
EU professors (let’s use an outdated norm, I think it wouldn’t be out of place), when launching a series of lectures, of course, proceed from a deeper understanding of the work of society. Lectures in support of the EU certainly promise to be a public irritant. But their goal, as I understand this project, is not at all that. It means that the “final piece of paper” of a completely different form is provided to the EU by another authority. Namely, a society in front of which, in fact, any government is essentially powerless.
To do this, society should be considered normal and enter into a full dialogue with it, explaining, guided by knowledge about the natural mechanism for the dissemination of opinions and beliefs about any subjects, what your value is and why you need to be supported. The "natural mechanism" is critical. Over the past two or three decades, we have become accustomed exclusively to a naive-democratic approach to any public campaign, and all the technologies of such campaigning are shamelessly ripped off from professional P&G marketers who sell us washing powder and cars. If you don’t bashfully steal their methods, but ask these people a question about how and when it works, they will answer like professionals: it works when selling washing powder and similar products, with ideologies it’s more and more complicated, there the number of “contacts with customers” is not the main thing and not a measure of future success. In the world of ideas and moral and ethical views, support for various groups in the most complex and invisible hierarchy of authorities for various groups is built in a blatantly undemocratic manner. Nothing here is decided by a vote of the masses. Here, sincerity, unfalsified goals and a reliable change in the beliefs of important interlocutors, achieved through dialogue, are valued.
These interlocutors, also on occasion expressing their own opinion about what is happening, ultimately create a situation in which institutions that are truly important to society and significant for it are protected by “armor” more reliable than any power structure can imagine. The majority of Russian residents do not know what the Pushkin House is and what they do in it, which can easily be shown by any opinion poll. Referendum “Is it possible to close the Pushkin House?” doomed to fail. He has the “ultimate piece of paper”, he is the sacred cow of society. Society “does not know” about this scientific institution in the sense in which each of its members may or may not know about it, but it “knows” perfectly well in another: “If you dare to ask, you will hear.” This does not mean that a sacred cow cannot be slaughtered - if desired, anything is possible; The question is how much it will cost - and it costs too much, it’s scary to even ask the price.
The pleasure of the EU's pre-Christmas demarche is that it is the European University that has the right to claim the status of such a sacred cow of Russian society. Moreover, if we are self-respecting people, we are obliged to have a certain number of such sacred cows in our public stalls. Not to check with them on issues close to religious - there are enough people in the EU with beliefs that I, for example, consider unacceptable for myself. But a society that aspires to development also needs individual institutions to play exactly this role in it - values that are not involved in exchange and political bargaining, which is certified not by voting, not by a referendum, but by their natural position in the socially recognized traditional way of hierarchy of values. These are our funny trinkets. We cannot respect ourselves without them.
Of course, the process of establishing such values is always painful, full of embarrassment, and even tragedies, it is always accompanied by lively resistance from certain groups of ill-wishers, and the furious hissing of applicants for the same status, and the strange behavior of the sacred cows themselves: these are very quarrelsome, eccentric and quite lively on occasion. Moreover, the fate of these sacred cows is to be the objects of constant, completely natural and usually futile attacks from those who want to change the world, either for their own benefit or for the benefit of others. Sooner or later, the attackers succeed - sacred cows are mortal, like all social institutions.
It is clear why the EU never aspired to be this part of reality and avoided such status in every possible way. And it’s not even that he’s left with no choice—there is: he can lead a quiet, introverted life without attracting the attention of forest orderlies and management. If I understand what is happening correctly, for the EU now being a sacred cow and receiving a safe conduct letter from society is not only a possible right, but also an obligation. After all, the beneficiary of this activity, which is not the most convenient for intelligent people - telling why you are so valuable to society - is society itself.
If we remember how many potential applicants for such a role in the history of modern Russia have previously exercised their inalienable right not to do this, the EU can only be supported. Not a month has passed in recent years when some simpleton on social networks did not loudly ask the question: “Friends, who do you consider the moral authority in the country?” - and did not receive a share of slaps for naivety. But where can moral authorities come from in a country where no one wants to be one and is afraid of it like scabies? And it’s embarrassing, and dangerous, and ridiculous, and distracts from truly important matters. Everything is like in damned 1925.
We can only wish the EU firmness in what I hope has already been a decision. The business you are doing has long needed a generally recognized and fairly high price.