Hearings on the city’s draft budget, its adjustments and the report on execution will now be held without gathering the public in the Great Hall of the Mariinsky Palace.
People's deputies are reviewing the format of public hearings: the public will be left out of brackets
The budget and financial committee of the city parliament supported the draft law introduced by its chairman Vladimir Barkanov, providing for both in-person and absentee public hearings. The deputy believes that the upcoming budget cuts for 2009-11 (the project has already been introduced by the governor and implies a reduction in city expenses this year by 90.5 billion rubles) are “psychologically and morally inconvenient” for citizens. If so, one should not create inconvenience for the townspeople and discuss difficult but necessary measures in their presence, otherwise “there will be much more people speaking negatively than those who are happy.” And, they say, it is inappropriate to listen to criticism of the financial policy of the city government for two and a half hours...
“The practice of holding public hearings has shown that hearings are attended mainly by ordinary residents of our city, often far from issues of financial policy and legal regulation of public finance”... “the problem becomes especially acute during the pre-election period, when hearings are used as an arena for political struggle and propaganda” ... “politically engaged participants violate the rules of procedure and order in the meeting room,” states Barkanov’s explanatory note.
Well, we have already heard this: in 2007, the chairman of the CFK was extremely dissatisfied that the opposition, having carefully analyzed the budget, began asking unpleasant questions - and declared this an attempt to disrupt the hearings. True, in 2008 he spoke differently: that, “supporting the policy of openness, the St. Petersburg parliament is holding public hearings for the third time,” that “it is important for us to get an assessment of the project, to listen to the opinions of residents,” and that “we hope for fruitful cooperation and We will try to answer all the questions that concern the townspeople”...
If the bill is passed, then the decision on what form to hold hearings on the budget - in person or in absentia - will be made by the BFC. As for the report on budget execution, the relevant hearings will be held in person only if the Chamber of Control and Accounts has identified any inconsistencies.
Absentee hearings are entirely at the mercy of the BFC: the committee will determine their date, time and method of holding in order to “ensure that the public’s opinion on the draft budget and the draft annual report on budget execution is identified and taken into account.” Apparently, they will identify and take into account the simple Soviet “write letters” method: the draft budget will be posted on the website and asked to make proposals in writing. Then they promise to summarize them and transfer them to the governor and members of the government from the financial and economic bloc. This is where the consideration of citizens' opinions will most likely end.
The proposal to switch from face-to-face budget discussions to absentee discussions is, without a doubt, captivating in its cynicism. Both the federal law on the organization of state power in the regions and the Charter of St. Petersburg speak specifically about public hearings. If you look into Ushakov’s Encyclopedic Dictionary, it is easy to see that he defines the concept of “public” as “taking place in the presence of society, the public, open, public.” Yes, in fact, even without a dictionary it is clear that the absentee form of collecting budget proposals cannot be considered “public hearings” (if only telephone boxing had been declared a sport). Announcing hearings in “absentia” is nothing more than a mockery of the law and the Russian language. I personally promise: if they decide on an “absentia” hearing on the budget, I will go to court to challenge it...
Of course, many people come to hearings on the budget - as well as hearings on the PZZ - who do not want to discuss the specific parameters of the budget expenditure item, but to meet with government officials (usually inaccessible to them) face to face and talk about painful issues. About low pensions, about uncleaned yards, about leaking pipes, about defrauded shareholders, about cutting down public gardens and gardens, and so on.
However, with each new hearing, the number of participants increases who are able to competently understand the budget, highlight its “weak points”, formulate questions and proposals - and it is extremely difficult for officials to brush them aside in a packed room. So they decided to save themselves the inconvenience by depriving citizens of the right to publicly discuss how their money, the taxpayers, will be spent. The point is clear, with absentee hearings no discomfort is expected for officials...
However, everything is logical in the era of the destruction of public policies hated by the authorities. Instead of elections - appointments, instead of discussions in parliament - behind-the-scenes decisions of a narrow circle of people, instead of public discussions - a collection of letters.
What's next - absentee hearings on urban planning issues? And then - holding rallies, processions, demonstrations and pickets in absentia (“public events” according to the law) by submitting petitions to Smolny? And there is no need to agree on anything, and there is no threat of batons...
Boris VISHNEVSKY