
A month before the New Year, when most people are already starting to prepare for the holiday, residents of the house at Shchetinkina, 35 are thinking about how not to end up on the street. Recently they received an unusual “gift” - a notice that the mayor’s office had filed a lawsuit to declare their house an illegal building. If the court agrees with the arguments of the city administration, the house will be demolished within a month.
The apartment building on Shchetinkina Street was built in 2011, i.e. four years ago. 33 economy class apartments were bought quickly. 600 – 800 thousand rubles, on average, for 18 “square meters” satisfied buyers. They moved in, settled down... Initially, shared ownership was registered in the house, but later the residents reissued the documents, left the shares and became full owners of the apartments.
— When we registered ownership, the developer had all the permits. And the document on ownership was assured to us at TORTS,” says Marina Sokolova, a resident of the house. “We pay for electricity, water, and heat, so the house is registered with them; if it were an unauthorized construction, they wouldn’t pay,” she adds. Marina Sokolova says that the owners of the neighboring houses did not make any claims against them; according to SanPiN, the construction conditions were met. Therefore, residents of the new building do not understand why the mayor’s office has come up with complaints and why now, four years later.
In turn, the mayor's office filed a lawsuit against the homeowners. As the press service of the mayor’s office explained to us, this house has “a number of signs of unauthorized construction,” including non-compliance with SanPiN rules and violation of the boundaries of neighboring plots.
In addition, the prosecutor's office asked to pay attention to this house at the beginning of last year, but lawyers filed documents with the court only now. True, by November 15, for some reason, only the owners of five apartments received lawsuits. Court notices have not yet been sent to the mailboxes of the remaining owners.

The court hearing will take place on December 4; if the residents lose, the house will be demolished within a month, and the apartment owners will remain on the street.
“A retired grandmother lives with us. She is 91 years old and has had several heart attacks! Where should she go? Renting a home? So she doesn’t have money for this,” says Marina. According to Maxpark lawyer Mikhail Matveev, even if the residents lose the trial, no one will demolish the house, because you can’t just throw 31 families out onto the street.
“The main question here will be whether this construction is unauthorized. In my opinion, the plaintiff (the mayor's office - author's note) will not be able to prove that the construction was carried out without permission. The plot for individual housing construction belongs to the defendants on the basis of shared ownership. The site was provided by the authorities, the purpose of the site was determined by the authorities, and now the authorities declare that there cannot be land plots for individual construction in this territorial zone. But these are the problems of the authorities who provided the site, not the owners of the site. They have what they have and the rights to registered property. An individual house has been built, the rights to it have been registered and an entry about it has been made in the Unified State Register in the prescribed manner. What kind of self-construction can we even talk about? Permission to build and put an individual house into operation is not required until March 1, 2018, due to the law on dacha amnesty,” he notes.
At the same time, Mikhail Matveev says that the apartment status of this building is the residents’ most important argument in their favor.
“Since all actions to divide the house into separate premises were carried out strictly within the framework of the law and were accompanied by state registration of rights to separate premises in the house, the court will have no grounds to satisfy this claim. But we live in Russia, where it is not laws that apply, but the right of the authorities to any arbitrariness. Therefore, everything will depend on the owners of the premises in this apartment building. If they resist, they will stay in this house. If they obey, they will lose everything,” he says.
At the same time, Mikhail Matveev emphasizes that there is a controversial point in this situation: the house was built on land intended for the construction of an individual house, and not an apartment building.
“They originally built an individual house. It may be objected that an individual house for 33 owners is not provided for by law. However, in the legislation there are no restrictions on the number of owners of an individual house, but there are restrictions on the number of floors and the area of the land plot (in a wide range). Their home complies with the restrictions. And any individual house can be divided. At least from two apartments. And make it multi-apartment,” notes Mikhail Matveev.
This is not the first time in Tomsk that an apartment building was eventually built on land intended for individual construction. Developers found this loophole in the law several years ago, and in 2013, Deputy Mayor Alexander Tsymbalyuk said that the authorities could not do anything about it.
Story "Rush Hour" from 06/14/2013
The mayor's office also stepped on this rake. In 2012, she bought apartments for orphans in a building that was essentially an unauthorized construction.