Last Friday, the Smolninsky Federal Court sentenced “minister” Vtulkin: for inciting hatred on the grounds of nationality, race, religion and membership in various social groups using the media and accompanied by the threat of violence. The court sentenced the “fighter against the enslavers of the Russian people” Vtulkin to one and a half years in a colony-settlement, half as much as the state prosecution requested. But, given that he has already served six months (he was detained on August 17 last year), he only has a year left in his sentence.
“Minister of National Security” of the self-proclaimed “Russian Republic” Alexander Vtulkin, who posted a “death sentence” on the Internet to the governor of St. Petersburg Valentina Matvienko, will spend the next year behind bars in a penal colony. 
Alexander Vtulkin paid the price
It was only by miracle that the sentencing process remained within the legal framework. Journalists gathered near the courthouse were stopped by bailiffs. They refused to let the press into the courthouse, citing an oral order from Judge Natalya Soboleva, who presided over the trial in the Vtulkin case. It is surprising that the process was closed only by the time the verdict was pronounced. All previous meetings were held in the open, although in personal conversations Ms. Soboleva expressed dissatisfaction with the close attention of the press to this criminal case. The reason for closing the process was the need to “ensure the safety of the participants in the process.” And as proof of the “maliciousness” of the defendant’s anonymous supporters, fresh inscriptions were presented on the walls of the district temple of Themis: “CJSC Court”, “Brotherhood of Justice”, “Here the rich have justice.” The court workers promptly washed away the writings on the walls, but only intervention helped journalists achieve publicity of the proceedings
about the Chairman of the Council of Judges of St. Petersburg Yuri Kozlov...
Immediately after the verdict was pronounced, the mother of the convict called the trial “ordered,” and the brother of the self-proclaimed “minister” called it “fascist.” However, whoever calls their political opponents fascists today...
Let us recall how events developed. On July 30, 2004, on the forums of two St. Petersburg Internet sites, information appeared about the creation by the Freedom Party of a certain tribunal, which considers the Governor of St. Petersburg Valentina Matvienko “an enemy of the Russian national movement,” and for “anti-Russian policies” sentences her to death, which will be “carried out in the near future.” The message was signed with the name of the chairman of the Freedom Party, the famous nationalist Yuri Belyaev. Of course, these messages were removed from the forums by moderators, and copies of them were transferred to law enforcement agencies.
The investigation then moved in two directions. The first is technical, in order to find out from which computer this information was sent. The second is personal, which began with the interrogation of Yuri Belyaev, whose signature appeared under the virtual verdict.
The technical part established: the notorious recording was sent from one of the computers in the Zebra Internet club at the Moscow railway station. Moreover, at the time the message was sent, there was only one visitor there, and he also came into view of the Internet club’s security cameras.
A video recording of a thin, middle-aged man in a black leather vest was shown to Yuri Belyaev, who categorically denied authorship of the verdict against Valentina Matvienko. And in the unknown visitor to Zebra he immediately recognized his former party comrade Alexander Vtulkin. (Who, having left Belyaev’s party, took up the “Russian Republic”, whose loud name hid a little over three dozen nationalists from a dozen Russian cities who united in December 2003).
Vtulkin was put on the international wanted list, but they were able to detain him... only a year after the notorious messages appeared on the Internet, on the platform of the Vitebsk station with a ticket to Ukraine in his pocket.
Initially, the City Prosecutor's Office formulated the charge against Alexander Vtulkin as a threat to kill, but then reclassified it as inciting hatred on the grounds of nationality, race, religion and membership in various social groups using the media and accompanied by the threat of violence. At the same time, the real discovery of both the prosecution and the court was the recognition of a cohort of major government officials, including Governor Matvienko, as a separate “social group”...
The trial of the self-proclaimed “Minister of National Security of the Russian Republic” did not last long: the first hearing took place on December 23 last year, and the verdict was pronounced on February 10 of this year.
Alexander Vtulkin did not deny that he was the author of the notorious message about the verdict against the St. Petersburg governor. But he said that he didn’t come up with anything, and that he learned about the verdict of the Freedom Party tribunal from party member Andrei Grebnev (Grebnev was killed a few months after this story). And he decided, by publishing the message, to inform law enforcement agencies about the danger to Valentina Matvienko from Yuri Belyaev.
In addition, the defense built its line on a number of legal lacunae - challenging the status of Internet site forums as not corresponding to the concept of mass media.
But the court was not convinced by the position of the defense, which asked to acquit Alexander Vtulkin. Moreover, the victim herself (who never appeared in court) stated during the investigation that she took the virtual verdict addressed to her, which city administration employees told her about, quite seriously, remembering the sad fate of State Duma deputy Galina Starovoitova and ethnologist Nikolai Girenko. Which, as you know, were killed after numerous threats from nationalists. And Girenko’s murder was also accompanied by the appearance of a “verdict” on the Internet.
Alexander SAMOILOV
Photo INTERPRESS