| Vremya Novostei correspondents Natalya ROZHKOVA and Mikhail MOSHKIN asked Russian politicians, political scientists and human rights activists to comment on the parole of former Yukos lawyer Svetlana Bakhmina.
"This is a very important precedent"
Ella PAMFILOVA, Chairman of the Russian Presidential Council for Promoting the Development of Civil Society Institutions and Human Rights:
- It's good that this happened. The release of Bakhmina is what the public sought, and what was also the subject of discussion at the meeting of the president with our council. Bakhmina’s release is a very important precedent that should help humanize the attitude of the penitentiary system towards other women with children who are serving their sentences without being convicted of serious crimes.”
“There is certainly a signal here, but it’s different.”
Dmitry ORLOV, General Director of the Agency for Political and Economic Communications:
- From my point of view, we are not talking about a political “thaw”. There is certainly a signal here, but it’s different. The first is that a woman with young children cannot be in prison if she does not pose a danger to society. Secondly, this is a signal for the general humanization of our law enforcement, judicial, and penitentiary systems. Bakhmina repented, behaved normally in the colony, taking into account these grounds, as well as the fact that she has small children, her request for parole was granted - I do not see any political implications here. There would have been politics here if she had not repented, but she would have been released. Or if some conclusions of the court or investigation were called into question. Finally, if this were somehow connected with the Khodorkovsky case. But there is none of this.
"The President began to define his own political style"
Dmitry ORESHKIN, independent political scientist:
— Of course, there is a signal, just a very weak, neat signal, which, it seems to me, is timed to coincide with the anniversary of Medvedev’s tenure as president. He lived in this post for a year, got used to it and decided that he needed to somehow define his own political style. So he designates it - sequentially, in small steps. Interview with Novaya Gazeta, meeting with members of the Presidential Council for Human Rights, pardon of twelve people, now Bakhmina. Each of these events is quite trivial. The same Bakhmina served half her sentence without notice - she was entitled to parole, for this she would not even have to make any special efforts. Usually in such a situation people are released on parole, but in her case they delayed it and didn’t give it. And what they have now given is absolutely no reason to rejoice wildly. You can interpret this however you like. For example, that the scenario of “two investigators” is being played out: Putin is the “evil investigator”, Medvedev is the “good one”. There is certainly mutual agreement here; it is unlikely that Dmitry Medvedev acts without the consent of such an influential group as Putin’s group. But one can also understand that the president is simply a rationally thinking person and understands that in times of crisis he needs to seek support from citizens, and not just from the bureaucratic apparatus. And also create a good image for the country, otherwise there will be no investment. He could implement such a decision together with Putin, who cannot help but understand that it is easy to scare off investors, but difficult to bring them back together.
“Society must support liberalization”
Leonid GOZMAN, co-chairman of the Right Cause party:
- Nobody knows for sure, but this could be a signal, especially if we consider this in the context of other actions that the president has taken in recent days, I mean an interview with Novaya Gazeta, a visit to InSor, meetings with human rights activists. With the release of Svetlana Bakhmina, this line was continued. Whether this is evidence that the president intends to continue to move in this direction or whether this is connected with some momentary decisions and will not be continued is difficult to say. But without moving along this path, the country simply has no future. Another aspect: whether the line of liberalization will be continued depends not only on the president’s intentions, although they are also very important. But the reaction of society is also important. If society treats this kind of steps with the contemptuous skepticism characteristic of our intelligentsia, if it does not demand continuation of the movement in this direction or calmly accepts the refusal of such a movement, then nothing will happen. No ruler carries out reforms unless absolutely necessary, and one of the indicators of this need is the demands of society. The release of Svetlana Bakhmina itself was also the result of a broad campaign of public support. You can say as much as you want that the authorities supposedly don’t give a damn about the opinion of the people, but here they couldn’t give a damn, the situation was so outrageous.
"This is a normal humanitarian action"
Oleg KULIKOV, Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation:
- The situation is ambiguous, and many political scientists considered it in advance as a kind of signal to liberalize the policy regarding dissent. In this context, I would like the concept of “dissent” to extend to the entire political spectrum. Because now this is a kind of signal to only one part of this spectrum - the liberal one, which is actually quite weakened in Russia. And not so much by political pressure, but by the lack of support of the masses, who associate the current crisis with the liberal policies pursued for a long time. And Svetlana Bakhmina is a special case, a normal humanitarian action that should have been carried out long ago. Returning to the question of whether this will be the beginning of a kind of “thaw,” I will answer: I would like to.
"We must wait for subsequent events"
Lev PONOMAREV, director of the movement “For Human Rights”:
— It is clearly premature to draw conclusions that the release of Svetlana Bakhmina fits into a certain trend. Because Bakhmina will be free, we have no right to be so happy as to think that the regime is liberalizing. Absolutely extraordinary events took place around the so-called “Bakhmina case.” First, she wrote a petition for pardon, then the director of the Federal Penitentiary Service, Yuri Kalinin, publicly stated that the prisoner had withdrawn her petition. If a woman in the seventh month of pregnancy withdraws her request for pardon, this is possible only under pressure. Even after 100 thousand signatures were collected in support of Bakhmina’s release, she was still not released, and she gave birth in custody.
I would not say that there is any progress in relation to the state and citizens, including because on the day when Bakhmina was released, the Tagansky court sentenced anti-fascist Alexei Olesinov to a year in prison. In order to draw conclusions about any changes, we must wait for subsequent events. |