The Russian Orthodox Church (ROC) intends to achieve giving the Spaso-Preobrazhensky Valaam Monastery, and at the same time the island as a whole, a special status. This decision was recently made by members of the board of trustees for the restoration of the monastery, which includes representatives of the Russian Orthodox Church, federal authorities and big business. Patriarch Kirill of Moscow and All Rus' claims that the monastery “has many problems associated with the large flow of tourists and pilgrims.” Experts suggest that the actions of the Russian Orthodox Church are related to the church’s desire to control the tourist flow to the island and will negatively affect the relationship between the church and people “who are not pilgrims, but have spiritual interests.”
The trustees, in particular, believe that Valaam should become “a specially protected territory with certain prohibitions on visiting the archipelago, arbitrary construction and unregulated business activities.” This was stated by the President of the Russian College of Appraisers Alexander Galushka. The detailed draft of the new regime for visiting the monastery, according to Patriarch Kirill, will be developed by a specially created working group. At the same time, as the patriarch emphasized, the status given to the Valaam monastery should suit both the church and the state.
The Russian Orthodox Church does not deny the “immense missionary significance” of the monastery for both believers and ordinary tourists. However, according to Patriarch Kirill, unregulated trade, unauthorized tourist routes around the archipelago, and an excessively large number of ships in the bays around the islands pose not only an environmental danger, “but also destroy the spiritual and cultural environment.”
According to the abbot of the Valaam Monastery, Bishop Pankratius of the Trinity, under whose leadership the decisive work on the restoration of the monastery was carried out, more than 140 thousand people visit the monastery and its surroundings every year during the navigation period, from May to October. According to the church, the number of tourists and pilgrims should not exceed 90 thousand. According to Bishop Pankraty of the Trinity, the influx of visitors increases the threat of forest fires and creates problems with waste disposal.
As the press secretary of the abbot of the monastery, Mikhail Shishkov, told Vremya Novostey, the Valaam archipelago is under the jurisdiction of the federal authorities. “The property of the Russian Orthodox Church is only the Transfiguration Monastery,” he emphasized. However, the Russian Orthodox Church hopes for understanding from the secular authorities. According to Mr. Shishkov, discussion of this issue within a special working group should begin within three to four weeks.
Meanwhile, Valaam is not the only place that, according to the Russian Orthodox Church, needs a special regime for visits by ordinary people. “We have enough special places that could be given a special status,” Vsevolod Chaplin, deputy chairman of the department for external church relations of the Moscow Patriarchate, told Vremya Novostei, “for example, Solovki or the Trinity Lavra of St. Sergius.” According to Father Vsevolod, “you can’t sell nesting dolls in such places.”
The church’s initiative has already been supported by the head of the Republic of Karelia, Sergei Katanandov. According to Mr. Katanandov, only the adoption of a special law can “stop the expansion and regulate the influx of tourists.” “We are for tourism, for people to come to Valaam and leave money here, but not to the detriment of its development,” said the head of Karelia.
In addition, remembering the long-term problem of relocating ordinary island residents to the mainland, Sergei Katanandov stated that “people who are directly connected with Valaam and who share the church’s point of view on the development of the monastery should remain on Valaam.”
Let us recall that the relocation of lay people to the mainland, which has been ongoing for several years, is accompanied by litigation and scandals due to the reluctance of some indigenous secular residents to leave the island and move on conditions that are unacceptable to them.
However, observers believe that the church’s next initiative may be related to the Russian Orthodox Church’s own tourism activities. “Now, as far as I know, tourists can contact both church structures and private companies to come to Valaam. The island’s special status could deprive private tourism companies of a profitable route,” Boris Falikov, associate professor at the Center for Comparative Study of Religion at the Russian State Humanitarian University, told Vremya Novostei.
In addition, according to Mr. Falikov, the establishment of special control on the territory of Valaam could negatively affect the attitude of the church and the laity, “who have spiritual interests. “By not letting these people into Valaam, the Russian Orthodox Church may lose potential parishioners,” he believes.
However, according to tour operators, the Russian Orthodox Church still controls the entire flow of visitors. As one of the travel companies told Vremya Novostey, the island is indeed very popular among travelers. “Before the crisis, tickets were sold out two weeks before the ship’s departure,” noted tour operator manager Olga Romanchenko. At the same time, according to Ms. Romanchenko, the tour route is coordinated with the pilgrimage service of the monastery. “They decide who is allowed in and who is not,” the travel agency says.