| Mikhail Khodorkovsky announced his questions and answers to the court Yesterday in the Khamovnichesky Court, Mikhail Khodorkovsky, who is accused of stealing about 350 million tons of oil from Yukos subsidiaries in 1998-2003 for a total amount of almost a trillion rubles, interrogated himself. After the prosecutors finished presenting evidence of his guilt, Mr. Khodorkovsky began giving his own testimony, which he himself roughly divided into three parts: objective, questions and answers, and subjective.
In the objective part of his speech, Mikhail Khodorkovsky spoke about the general principles of oil production and oil refining, which, in the interpretation of the Prosecutor General’s Office, looked completely different from what happens in real life. It took the defendant four days to talk about this, and yesterday he began the second part of his testimony - he asked questions, which he answered himself. In the subjective part of his testimony, Mr. Khodorkovsky plans to express his attitude to each sentence and phrase of the indictment in which his name is mentioned. Since the indictment is set out in 200 volumes, it can be assumed that the former head of YUKOS will be speaking for a long time.
In addition, yesterday the second defendant, the former head of the Menatep MFO Platon Lebedev, made a repeated statement about bringing state prosecutors to criminal liability. He called his statement “a continuation of exposing the criminal activities of the Karimov and Co group, including Lakhtin and Shokhin, in malicious falsification of charges, official forgery, abuse of power and other crimes against justice, state power and individual rights.”
The lawyers, in turn, filed a petition asking “to invite Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin, the Chairman of the Government of the Russian Federation, to the Khamovnichesky Court to testify.”
“M.B. Khodorkovsky stated that he considers it necessary to invite V.V. Putin to court primarily because he personally reported to him, as the President of the Russian Federation (hereinafter quoted from the minutes of the court session), “where the oil was supplied, how the Yukos company’s funds were spent.” These circumstances, of course, are among those to be proven within the framework of the charges brought in the case of oil theft and legalization of proceeds from its sale,” the petition said. But the presiding officer rejected it as prematurely stated.
“I would like to dwell on some individual issues, in some cases I will partially repeat myself, but I consider these issues to be the most important for the purposes of this process,” this is how Mikhail Khodorkovsky began his self-examination yesterday. And his first question actually sounded in the courtroom: “What is extracted from the well at the field?” “This issue is important because in some parts of the indictment it was alleged that oil was stolen from wells. It is not oil that is produced from the wells, but a mixture!” - said the defendant. A week ago, when he first began testifying, his lawyers even brought along jars of oil and well fluid to illustrate the differences. Yesterday, Mr. Khodorkovsky once again emphasized that the share of oil in the mixture ranges from 4 to 98%, the rest is water, gas, mineral salts and other impurities. Then, using a drawing enlarged from the projector, he demonstrated the entire production process step by step - from oil production to its refining. “The third stage is “oil production”, then there is “primary water separation”, then transportation of oil to the oil preparation workshop, then oil preparation - only at this, the sixth stage of the technological process, oil itself is obtained,” said Mr. Khodorkovsky , noting that all the terminology (oil, well fluid, hydrocarbon raw materials) was not invented by him or YUKOS, but approved by legislation and GOSTs.
Mikhail Khodorkovsky formulated the second question as follows: “What is called commercial oil and where does it originate?” He explained that the terms "commercial oil" and "crude oil" refer to the same substance. “Oil as a commodity appears after oil is prepared in the preparation workshop. Its quality is determined by GOST. Although the GOST that is used provides for oil of very different compositions (again a picture appeared on the wall with flasks filled with different types of oil). The familiar black oil is not the only one. It comes in red, yellow and green. The composition of commercial oil in terms of sulfur and the content of various types of hydrocarbons can vary greatly. GOST strictly regulates only the content of water, gas, mineral salts and mechanical impurities in it. Therefore, when we talk about oil from Tomskneft, Yuganskneftegaz, Samaraneftegaz, this is a very specific oil. With very specific indicators, which does not necessarily correspond to the Urals variety. The treated oil is supplied to the Transneft metering unit.
The answer to your third question: “Where exactly does commercial oil produced and produced by Samaraneftegaz, Yuganskneftegaz, Tomskneft cease to exist?” - Khodorkovsky also gave through drawings. It showed how oil from these three producing companies enters the Transneft pipeline. “Its characteristics change—density, sulfur content, hydrocarbon composition, color,” explained the defendant. “Therefore, lawyers consider the agreement with Transneft to be a mixed agreement - an agreement of storage, processing and transportation.” This was followed by an explanation of the differences between oil as a physical object and oil as an object of property law. “Those oil purchase and sale agreements that were examined in court are, in fact, futures contracts. For example, they were concluded in February, and deliveries are made in March. Oil will be produced in March and sold now. This is a technological inevitability because oil is produced and shipped every day, and contracts are concluded for a period. The buyer needs to enter into contracts for transportation and distribute the purchased oil. The buyer, as a rule, resells the purchased right, often multiple times, and before the person carrying out the processing receives the oil. And again, usually before actual production. And this is a technological inevitability,” Mr. Khodorkovsky explained. -- Physical oil as a liquid appears in the oil preparation center and ceases to exist when it enters Transneft. Documented oil (or ownership of oil) arises at the wellhead and only if there is a production license; without a license, ownership does not arise. And the ownership of oil at the refinery is terminated due to the physical liquidation of the equivalent.”
The defendant noted that in the materials of his case there are only acts of unloading oil from Transneft to the refinery, but there are no acts of delivery of oil to Transneft: “I am charged with oil, but there are no acts of transfer of oil in the case. I am not charged with ownership, but all the documents are in place.”
Further, Mr. Khodorkovsky spoke about how theft of raw materials can occur in practice: “They are produced through illegal tappings, illegal selection from tanks. They are also kidnapped by hiding the remains in tanks. A report is drawn up that there was an environmental incident or by overestimating evaporation losses, and they say that there is less oil in the reservoir than there actually is.”
The next question concerned precisely whether Mr. Khodorkovsky was the owner of the oil of Yukos subsidiaries and “whether he turned the oil to his advantage, that is, whether he put himself in the place of the owner.” “In legal terms, of course not! - Mr. Khodorkovsky immediately responded. -- The owner of oil at every moment of its existence, from the moment it appeared in the preparation workshop and until the moment it was terminated through consumption at the refinery, were exclusively legal entities acting on behalf of their management bodies. At no point did any individual, including myself, declare to anyone their personal rights to the oil produced by Yukos’s production subsidiaries.” He illustrated his complex explanations in economic terms with a simple example: “If another person has your money, the question of whether it is yours or not depends not on whether this individual belongs to you, but on whether this individual recognizes your right to dispose of it.” money. If he admits it, the money is yours; if he doesn’t, the money is not yours. The same thing, only in more detail, is described for legal entities.”
Further, Mr. Khodorkovsky quoted an excerpt from the accusation about “the failure to reflect in the YUKOS financial statements the promise to pay the company’s managers part of the income of the Menatep Limited group from the sale of YUKOS shares.” “First of all, I urge you to comprehend this statement from the point of view of common sense, not from the point of view of its reliability - God bless it, with reliability! - said the defendant. -- Some YUKOS shareholders promise other shareholders (managers) that when they sell their shares, they will give part of the income received to other shareholders. How does this relate to the reporting of the company itself? No way! What happens between shareholders is their problem! This does not affect the company’s activities in any way.”
Mikhail Khodorkovsky spoke in detail about the company’s activities, its reporting and audits. “I will account for all the profits without any erroneous deductions from an illiterate investigation,” he said, and that’s where he ended his speech for now. It is expected to continue in the Khamovnichesky Court tomorrow. Ekaterina BUTORINA | |