| Lawyers for Khodorkovsky and Lebedev praised the work of the prosecutor's office Next week, Mikhail Khodorkovsky will testify in the Khamovnichesky District Court of Moscow on charges brought against him and his business partner Platon Lebedev of stealing in 1998-2003 350 million tons of oil from subsidiaries of an oil company worth more than 892.4 billion rubles. Yesterday, lawyers for the country's most famous defendants held a press conference to mark the end of the prosecution's presentation of evidence.
“Mikhail Khodorkovsky and Platon Lebedev were charged with crimes that were never committed by anyone. That is, the accusation is completely falsified,” Vadim Klyuvgant voiced this conclusion on behalf of all the lawyers. Being confident in the innocence of their clients, the lawyers, at the same time, do not have high hopes for the outcome of the trial, because the decision, as lawyer Yuri Shmidt put it, “the court will not make, it will formalize it.” Nevertheless, the lawyers have hope, and it is expressed in the fact that these days are different times than they were when Khodorkovsky and Lebedev were arrested. Since then, the YUKOS case has gone beyond state borders, and the authorities of other countries have refused to hand over their Russian colleagues both the extradition of wanted company managers and the provision of legal assistance. The once prosperous major oil company is long gone, but in court cases it lives on and will likely live on for a long time.
Recently, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) considered the case “YUKOS v. Russia”, in which the foreign management of the company accused the Russian authorities of deliberately ruining it. Similar proceedings at the International Court of Arbitration in The Hague are just around the corner. In addition, the ECHR, presumably, will hear more than one case concerning the criminal prosecution of Yukos employees. "I can't help but admit that the authorities today feel uncomfortable about the Yukos affair," Mr. Schmidt said.
“We understood that we were holding this press conference on April 1. But this does not mean that everything we say here is a joke. It’s just that this once again emphasizes the tragic and farcical nature of what is happening in the building located diagonally from us,” said lawyer Vadim Klyuvgant. The press conference actually took place next to the Khamovnichesky Court.
“A year ago, when the second trial of Khodorkovsky and Lebedev was just beginning, we said that this trial was an insane proof of an insane accusation,” Mr. Klyuvgant continued. - And now a year has passed. Thousands of documents were read and retold to us, and 50 witnesses were heard.” According to him, all this time the lawyers waited patiently for the conversation about the stolen oil, but they never did. At the end of the presentation of evidence by the prosecution, interrogations of representatives of the victims, three oil companies - Rosneft, Tomskneft and Samaraneftegaz - were to take place. But this never happened.
“Fearing even greater shame, an organized group of prosecutors hid the victims. Because they have not suffered anything and therefore are afraid to come to court,” said Mr. Klyuvgant. The defense is bewildered by the very fact that Rosneft is involved in this case as a victim. “At that time (in 1998-2003, during the period of the alleged oil theft. - Ed. ) Rosneft had nothing to do with this. And now you know what it is,” said Mr. Klyuvgant. It was Rosneft that in 2007 became the main owner of YUKOS assets. At the same time, it took over two other current victims - Samaraneftegaz and Tomskneft. Actually, at the trial in the Khamovnichesky Court, as the lawyer explained, the interests of all three were to be defended by a representative of Rosneft.
Lawyer Konstantin Rivkin, in turn, said that there were 50 prosecution witnesses, although initially the prosecutor's office announced 250 people for questioning. Mr. Rivkin did not name their names, fearing that because of this they might later be subject to persecution. He conditionally divided all of them into three categories - “aggressors”, “defense witnesses” and “neutrals”. The last category is, as Mr. Rivkin explained, those who were engaged in technical work at YUKOS and during interrogations only confirmed the facts: yes, I was in this place at this hour, yes, I signed something, sent something .
“Aggressors” are, according to the lawyer, those who are offended by Khodorkovsky and Lebedev for something. “Several people showed their great resentment about something. For example, for the fact that they were once removed from leadership positions at YUKOS-owned enterprises. But when they were asked questions about the merits of the case, they said that they did not know at all what charges were brought against Khodorkovsky and Lebedev,” the lawyer said. The third group of witnesses was called “defense witnesses” not because they were presented by this side (officially they belonged to the prosecution), but in essence of the answers they gave to the court. “Among them were specialists of the highest level in the financial and oil markets. And we listened with deepest satisfaction to what they said and how they said it,” the lawyer noted.
In turn, lawyer Elena Liptser noted that “the defense has no illusions about the outcome of this process.” “Nevertheless, we record all violations during the process, and there were many,” she said. These violations relate primarily to the unfounded, in Ms. Liptser’s opinion, satisfaction of requests from the prosecutor’s office and denials of the same to the defense. And this, according to the lawyer, indicates a certain interest of the court. Recording is needed in order to later talk about them in complaints to the ECHR.
Ms. Liptser recalled that the Supreme Court recently reviewed, due to newly discovered circumstances, the case of Platon Lebedev on his first charge of illegality of arrests and their extension. New circumstances in this case were the ruling of the ECHR, which found a number of violations of Mr. Lebedev’s rights to freedom and personal integrity, as well as to a fair trial. “Subsequently, the Supreme Court was forced to recognize these violations,” Ms. Liptser emphasized.
At the beginning of March, the ECHR held a hearing on the case “YUKOS v. Russia”, and lawyers are going to use some of what was said in Strasbourg for their defense in the Khamovniki Court. “The Russian Federation stated in the European Court that YUKOS owned the oil, that it sold it, received income from these sales and did not pay taxes on them,” said lawyer Klyuvgant. - The Russian Federation claims in the Khamovnichesky Court that YUKOS did not have oil, since all of it was stolen by an organized crime group led by Khodorkovsky. That is, the same state asserts different positions in different courts.”
Lawyer Yuri Shmidt dwelled in more detail on the violations during the trial: “It seems that the trial is proceeding quite calmly - the judge gives the opportunity to speak out, and removes relatively few questions. But this is only the appearance of an equal and competitive process. If you dig deeper, you begin to understand that the game is going against one goal.” Even during the preliminary investigation, as the lawyer said, a huge number of documents were confiscated, from which a case of 200 volumes was later compiled. “When reviewing the case, it was discovered that many important documents were missing - reporting, summary, primary. And now the court refuses to reclaim these originals,” said Mr. Schmidt. According to him, these refusals are explained by the fact that the documents are not in the indictment.
“The indictment is for them like the Bible for believers - what is not there is not in nature,” the lawyer was indignant. He also suggested that it would be difficult for lawyers to get their witnesses questioned. “In all my 50 years of work as a lawyer, I have never seen that in the indictment the column reserved for the list of witnesses, which the investigator is required to fill out, was empty,” Mr. Schmidt said.
Mr. Schmidt also went over the political component of the “second YUKOS case.” “When Khodorkovsky was arrested, everyone was sure that the fight against the oligarchs had begun. They thought that the others would follow him - Abramovich, Vekselberg, Deripaska, Potanin. And the people waited. But nothing happened! As a last resort, tax arrears were collected in arbitration courts. The target of the blow and reprisal was precisely Khodorkovsky, and the unfortunate Platon Leonidovich (Lebedev - Ed. ) and the rest became hostages of his cause.” Ekaterina BUTORINA | |