
Three lawyers who represented the interests of Alexei Navalny: Igor Sergunin, Alexey Liptser and Vadim Kobzev. Photo: Alexander Nemenov / AFP / Scanpix / LETA
These lawyers are often the only link connecting those who are deprived of the right to vote, choice, and the right to call and write to the outside world. And in an era when the state non-stop charges Russians who sympathize with Ukraine with criminal charges, there are fewer and fewer lawyers ready to fight off charges against fellow citizens. First of all, it's dangerous. Secondly, it is not profitable (don’t expect fees like those from colleagues defending business; most work pro bono). Thirdly, too nervous. And only a few risk defending “political” people in Russia today. But the reality is that some of this minority of lawyers are already in prison, some have been squeezed out of the country, some are hiding (they defend, but often do not advertise it and comply with all conceivable and inconceivable security rules). “Novaya Gazeta Europe” talks about the modern repressed legal profession in Russia.

The problems for lawyer and member of the Memorial Human Rights Center Bakhrom Khamroev began at the same time that the authorities successfully liquidated the human rights organization. This coincided with the start of a full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
Security forces raided Khamroev’s Moscow apartment (he has lived in the capital since the early 1990s) in the early morning of February 24, 2022: he was thrown face down on the floor, and his wife Zukhra and a disabled relative were taken out of the apartment and put into a police car. Computers and phones were confiscated from the apartment. After a search, the human rights lawyer was detained and sent to a pre-trial detention center.
As part of the same case, searches were carried out in Moscow at the offices of Memorial and Civic Assistance, an organization helping migrants, as well as in Tatarstan at Khamroev’s relatives.
Bakhrom Khamroev participated in the activities of the Uzbek right-wing democratic party Birlik, in Russia he worked on protecting the rights of migrants from Central Asia, and also monitored human rights violations in Uzbekistan.
In the 2010s, Khamroev began working at the Memorial Human Rights Center. At the same time, for a number of years he was not a paid employee of the Human Rights Center, since the program for monitoring the persecution of Muslims, in which he worked, ended.
In addition, at the time of his arrest, Bakhrom Khamroev headed the Erdam Fund for Legal and Social Support of Migrants, which was engaged in protecting the labor and social rights of migrants from Central Asia, as well as assisting political emigrants from the region.
Investigators charged the lawyer and human rights activist under Part 2 of Art. 205.2 of the Criminal Code “justification of terrorism” for six posts on Facebook. Later, “organizing the activities of a terrorist organization” was added to the charge (Part 1 of Article 205.5 of the Criminal Code).
The FSB made the conclusion that Bakhrom Khamroev’s actions were carried out in the interests of Hizb ut-Tahrir (a religious organization recognized by the Russian authorities as terrorist) on the basis of the “expertise” of bachelor of psychology Danila Mikheev. Even Ministry of Justice officials noted the latter’s incompetence.
Khamroev's lawyer Timofey Shirokov noted that his client's case was based on the testimony of classified witnesses: when they spoke in court from another room, it was heard that there were people with them who were telling them the answers.
The testimony of the human rights activist’s ex-wife Asma Ismailova also played a role. Khamroev had a civil conflict with her about the right to an apartment. From the testimony of his ex-wife, it follows that Bakhrom allegedly encouraged some people to join Hizb ut-Tahrir. Those whom Khamroev helped argued in court that he had nothing to do with this organization and did not call for joining anywhere.
In May 2023, Bakhrom Khamroev was sentenced to 14 years in prison (the prosecutor's office requested 21 years), reclassifying the charge from “organization” to “participation in the activities of a terrorist organization.”
Bakhrom Khamroev came to almost every court hearing with posters against the war with Ukraine written on sheets of paper.
“I used to really dream that my beloved Uzbekistan would overthrow the dictator Karimov and gain freedom, at least the kind that was still in the late 90s and early 2000s. But Russia today, unfortunately, has surpassed the dictatorship of Karimov and is reminiscent of 1937 with its repressions. I am sure that this monstrous lawlessness reigning in Russia will not last long, and all innocent political prisoners will be released and rehabilitated,” Khamroev said at one of the meetings in the 2nd Western District Military Court. On appeal, the court reduced the sentence by three months - to 13 years 9 months.
Serving time in a colony in Vladimir.
600020, Vladimir, st. Bolshaya Nizhegorodskaya, 67, FKU T-2 Federal Penitentiary Service of Russia for the Vladimir Region, Khamroev Bakhrom Mardonovich, born in 1963. Emails can be sent through the Zonatelecom service.

At the end of November 2024, the Zavyalovsky District Court of Udmurtia sentenced lawyer Dmitry Talantov to seven years in prison in the case of distributing “fakes about the army” and “inciting hatred and enmity” for six posts on Facebook. Before Talantov’s arrest, he was the head of the Udmurtia Chamber of Lawyers for many years, and practiced a lot (which is usually not typical for the heads of bar chambers), defended the rights of ordinary lawyers, criticized the Federal Chamber of Lawyers, and also openly supported Alexei Navalny. At the beginning of his career he managed to work as a judge, but five years later he returned “to the field” again. At the time of his arrest, Talantov had already been representing the interests of journalist Ivan Safronov in a treason case for several months. And after February 24, 2022, on his Facebook page he condemned the war in Ukraine. Talantov became the first Russian lawyer to be charged in the case of distributing “fakes” about the Russian army based on political hatred (clause “e”, part 2 of article 207.3 of the Criminal Code).
The reason for the case was Talantov’s post dated April 3, 2022, in which he published a photograph of a man who came to Red Square with a poster “Peace for Ukraine. Russia - sanity, horror, shame, repentance. Putin is in hell." Talantov commented on the photo: “How could it be different after photos and videos from Kharkov, Mariupol, Irpen, Bucha??? This is no longer fascism - these are extreme Nazi practices!” Pro-government blogger Roman Skomorokhov in the publication “Military Review” called the lawyer “a fan of Ukronazism” and complained about him to the Investigative Committee and the Prosecutor General’s Office.
The case against the lawyer was based on a response from the General Staff, in which the department denied information about the killings of civilians in Bucha and Irpen by the Russian military and called it untrue.
The resolution to initiate the case stated that Talantov published the post, “anticipating the inevitability of socially dangerous consequences in the form of undermining the authority and discrediting the current government and the armed forces of the Russian Federation, as well as the fact that by his actions he would mislead an unlimited number of people regarding the legality of the actions armed forces of the Russian Federation during a special military operation."
And although, according to investigators, he published his posts at his dacha near Izhevsk, the case was opened by the Department of the Investigative Committee for the South-Western Administrative District of Moscow.
Talantov was detained on the morning of June 28, 2022 at his dacha. He only managed to write on Facebook that he was being taken to the local IC.
After searches at the dacha, in the apartment and in the Chamber of Lawyers of Udmurtia, Talantov was flown to Moscow. The next day, the Cheryomushkinsky District Court of Moscow sent the then 61-year-old lawyer to a pre-trial detention center. The judge motivated the detention by the fact that Dmitry Talantov had been successfully engaged in legal practice for a long time and this could interfere with the investigation. The Council of the Udmurtia Bar Association accused the judge of using “discriminatory language that affects the very essence of advocacy, its place in the justice system of the Russian Federation.” The judge, however, didn't care.
In the fall of 2022, Talantov’s charges were increased . He was charged with four more anti-war posts and an article about inciting hatred was added (clause “b”, part 2 of article 282 of the Criminal Code). In addition, investigators accused the lawyer of committing crimes using his official position. Now he faced up to 15 years in prison.
In one of the posts in which investigators established a motive of political hatred, Talantov shared a publication by human rights activist Pavel Chikov that in the future, support for the war will become an obstacle to working in government positions. Talentov himself promised that “not a single scum of this kind will remain in the legal profession.”
Of the two and a half years spent in custody, Talantov spent two years in solitary confinement. His trial on the merits took place in Izhevsk and took a year and ten months. As a result, the prosecutor requested 12 years in prison for the lawyer. The judge of the Zavyalovsky District Court gave him five years less - seven. Their lawyer will serve in a general regime colony (although an appeal is still pending). Dmitry Talantov was also banned from administering websites for four years.
In his last word, Talantov himself stated , among other things, that every evening in the pre-trial detention center he is forced to listen to news from state channels: “And this news is broadcast on the Soloviev Live program.” I would never have believed that I would listen carefully to the Internet company “Soloviev Live” every evening for five minutes. And I do it. The fact is that I am waiting for words about the coming world. These words don't exist. There are none. But just recently I heard that the essence of what is happening is the establishment of a “new, fairer world order” in which the “interests of the world majority” will be taken into account and guaranteed. Well, yes, the world is falling apart at the seams, but I just don’t know what it is - “a new, more just world order.” I don’t know what “the interests of the world majority” are. It’s enough for me to know what Dostoevsky’s hero Ivan Karamazov meant when he said that he refuses to accept the brightest and most perfect world harmony if it is bought by “the tear of one single tortured child.” And that he respectfully returns the “ticket” to such harmony. It’s enough for me that for two and a half years a photograph of a girl with her legs torn off from my criminal case has been standing before my eyes. I don’t believe in any harmony, or in any world order that is built on such suffering <…>.”
There was no reaction to the verdict against Dmitry Talantov, except for a few posts by lawyers, in the professional legal community in Russia.
426034, Udmurt Republic, Izhevsk, st. Basisnaya, 13, FKU SIZO-1 Federal Penitentiary Service of Russia for the Udmurt Republic, Dmitry Nikolaevich Talantov, born in 1960. An email can be sent through the ZT service.

On October 13, 2023, three lawyers of opposition politician Alexei Navalny, whose activities were previously declared extremist, were detained in different regions of the country. Vadim Kobzev was detained in Kovrov, Vladimir region, when he was just heading to correctional colony No. 2 to visit his client. At the same time, searches were carried out in Moscow at the office of the Dalet bar association and at the home of two of its members, Alexei Liptser and Igor Sergunin , as a result of which both were detained. All three - Kobzev, Sergunin and Liptser - were sent into custody by the Moscow Basmanny Court as part of the case for participation in an extremist community, although they were never members of Navalny’s structures and were not his public supporters. Moreover, Igor Sergunin and Alexey Liptser have not been Navalny’s representatives for more than a year.
The informal reason for the persecution of the lawyers was that they handed over the politician’s letters to his associates. Thus, the elimination of lawyers was an obvious way to stop contacts with the will and another act of intimidation of Alexei Navalny, who four months later would die in a colony in the village of Kharp under unclear circumstances.
By that time, his lawyers were already languishing in a pre-trial detention center and studying the materials of the criminal case against themselves. According to the prosecution, Kobzev, Sergunin and Liptser, “using their status in providing legal assistance to gain access to the correctional facility, ensured regular transfer of information between leaders, participants of the extremist community and Navalny A.A., who thereby continued to exercise the functions of leader and manager extremist community in planning, preparing, creating conditions and committing extremist crimes.”
That is, the accusation of extremism against Navalny’s lawyers is connected exclusively with their professional activities, and not with fictitious extremism.
The fact that all lawyers have minor children, and Igor Sergunin is the only breadwinner in the family, did not influence the court’s decision when choosing a preventive measure. Alexey Liptser was also not released under house arrest due to his chronic illnesses and his dependent newborn child. Liptser, by the way, before becoming Navalny’s lawyer, actively worked on high-profile criminal cases. Thus, together with his colleagues, he achieved a review of the case of civil activist Ildar Dadin.

Russian security forces also accused two more of the politician’s lawyers, Olga Mikhailova and Alexander Fedulov, of participating in the “extremist community.” They managed to leave the country and were arrested today in absentia.
At the time of writing, it became known that Navalny’s meetings with lawyers in the Vladimir colony were recorded on a hidden camera.
The recordings, to which the politician’s team gained access, depict meetings between Alexei Navalny and lawyers Olga Mikhailova, Vadim Kobzev and Alexei Liptser.
The politician's widow, Yulia Navalnaya, told reporters that the camera footage was obtained after her late husband's team announced a reward for any information about his death. According to the politician’s widow, a hidden camera was mounted in the ceiling right above the table - it recorded everything that Alexei Navalny wrote on paper.
The trial was closed to journalists and the public. The Russian legal community, as usual, did not stand up for their colleagues.
The prosecution demands for Vadim Kobzev 5 years and 11 months in prison, for Alexei Liptser - a sentence of 5 years and 10 months in prison. For Igor Sergunin, who admitted guilt, the prosecutor's office requested 5 years and 6 months in prison. The last words will be spoken in court on January 10. Perhaps the verdict will be announced on the same day.
In 2024, Olga Mikhailova, Vadim Kobzev and Alexey Liptser were awarded the Rule of Law Award from the International Bar Association for “a strong and consistent commitment to protecting human rights and the rule of law, despite extremely difficult circumstances.”
600021, Vladimir, st. January 9, 5a, FKU SIZO-1 Federal Penitentiary Service of Russia for the Vladimir Region, Vadim Dmitrievich Kobzev, born in 1983. A letter can also be written through the F-letter and Zonatelecom services.
600021, Vladimir, st. January 9, 5a, FKU SIZO-1 Federal Penitentiary Service of Russia for the Vladimir Region, Alexey Evgenievich Liptser, born in 1986.
600021, Vladimir, st. January 9, 5a, FKU SIZO-1 Federal Penitentiary Service of Russia for the Vladimir Region, Igor Sergeevich Sergunin, born in 1978.

A resident of Yekaterinburg, a lawyer specializing in protecting the rights of prisoners, Alexey Sokolov was a member of the regional Public Commission for monitoring the observance of human rights in places of deprivation of liberty. Actively helped prisoners in upholding and protecting their rights. In particular, Alexey Sokolov for many years ran the website “Human Rights Defenders of the Urals” and his own YouTube channel, where he posted materials on the topic of violations of the rights of convicts in colonies of the Sverdlovsk region. His opponents from the GUFSIN often filed lawsuits against Sokolov and his colleagues to protect their business reputation. The reason was articles and videos posted on the website about torture, beatings, physical and moral humiliation of convicts in correctional institutions in the region.
In October 2023, Sokolov was first arrested for five days under the administrative article on displaying prohibited symbols (Article 20.3 of the Administrative Code) because of the Facebook logo posted on the website “Human Rights Defenders of the Urals”; In July 2024, a similar post was a reason for initiating a criminal case. When detained in Sokolov’s apartment, they put his face on the floor, although he did not resist, beat him, pulled his t -shirt on his head with the words: “Is everything silent for you? You are for us ... " According to his lawyer, during a search, the human rights activist seized all equipment: not only computers and mobiles, but also a router, a musical column and working documents of the spouse.
Since then, Alexei Sokolov has been in custody. In July 2024, Sokolov was registered as an extremist in a pre -trial detention center.
The lawyer himself claims that the case against him is fabricated by the order of the GUFSIN and that the investigation was deliberately transferred into the hands of those against whom he fought for many years.
620019, Sverdlovsk region, Yekaterinburg, st. Repina, 4, FCU SIZO-1 GUFSIN of Russia in the Sverdlovsk Region, Sokolov Alexei Veniaminovich born in 1973.
According to the ATS-INFO portal , a special category of cases against lawyers is associated with the defended Crimean Tatars and in general human rights work in the territory of Crimea occupied by Russia: lawyers-lawyers are attracted to various administrative cases, then sentences with imprisonment.
In 2022, lawyer Eden Semedlyaev faced similar problems, for example. At first, two protocols on the disobedience of the police were drawn up for him while he visited Saliev’s Crimean Tatar Saliev in the police department: the protocols were compiled for the fact that the lawyer turned on the recorder and refused to remove outerwear. Next, Semedlyaev was accused of “discrediting the army”, and after the consideration of the case, the court on the same day appointed him a fine of 75 thousand rubles.

At the exit from the court, the lawyer of Semedlyaev himself, Nazim Sheikhmambetov was already detained. He was drawn up for a protocol on the organization of a rally in support of Semedlyaev. The court in the case of Sheikhmambetov took place the next day - he was appointed eight days of arrest. Before the meeting of Sheikhmambetov, two lawyers were already detained - Aider Azamatov and Emina Avamilev , again on charges of organizing a rally. According to the law, it resembles the ATS-Info, the appointment of several administrative punishments in a row significantly increases the risks in the future to undergo criminal prosecution and be detained.

Sometimes lawyers and lawyers are forced to psychiatric treatment. This happened with the candidate of legal sciences, a resident of Moscow Elena Rodin, who expressed in social networks against the war in Ukraine. She herself is a native of Sevastopol. In 2022, she was called to the prosecutor’s office, where administrative cases were opened under the article on the initiation of hatred (Article 20.3.1 of the Code of Administrative Offenses). The homeland removed anti-war posts in its telegram channel and in VKontakte. On July 17, 2023, a criminal case on the public justification of terrorism was already opened against her. At first, the “printer” was kept in the female pre -trial detention center, but then the case was stopped, and the second Western District Military Court decided to send it to a psychiatric hospital at the Butyrka pre -trial detention center. From there, a woman sent a letter to human rights activists, claiming that she was subjected to “punitive psychiatry”. Currently, the lawyer continues to be kept for compulsory treatment.
In addition to the search for the defenders of Navalny Olga Mikhailova and Alexander Fedulov, the leading Russian lawyers for political cases Vadim Prokhorov and Ivan Pavlov were forced to emigrate.

Prokhorov, who previously defended the politics of Boris Nemtsov, and then Ilya Yashin and Vladimir Kara-Murza Jr., left the country in the spring of 2023. This happened just at the height of the trial of his principal-Vladimir Kara-Murza, who was eventually sentenced to 25 years in the colony in the case of Fakes and Gosizmen. The reason for the hasty departure was the real threat of criminal proceedings against himself. As Prokhorov himself told the media, right during the process of Kara-Murza in the Moscow City Court, prosecutor Boris Loktionov and the judge from the Magnitsky List, Sergei Podrigorov, stated that it was necessary not only to expel Prokhorov’s lawyer from the Law Chamber, but also to consider the issue of initiating a criminal case. In addition, at the same time, the lawyer, according to him, received through one of the politicians a warning about the possible interest in him from one of the deputies of the Prosecutor General, who was just overseeing the Kara-Murza case.
Today, abroad, Prokhorov is still trying to work for customers in Russia and leaves no attempts to achieve the customers of the murder of Boris Nemtsov, whose interests of the eldest daughter are Jeanne-he represents.
In 2024, the Ministry of Justice of Russia brought Prokhorov to the register of foreign agents.

Ivan Pavlov also works in exile today, who at one time in Russia the project “Team 29” - a community of lawyers, human rights activists and journalists, which specialized in cases regarding freedom of information (Article 29 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation) or state security (Chapter 29 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation ). Ivan Pavlov left Russia a few months before the war with Ukraine - in the fall of 2021. This happened after a criminal case was brought against him about the disclosure of the preliminary investigation data in the case of journalist Ivan Safronov accused of the Stateismman. In addition, Pavlov was introduced into the register of foreign agents, thereby depriving him as a lawyer of access to Gostine. In addition, the authorities achieved the suspension of his lawyer status in Russia. The “team 29” founded by Pavlov was forced to close. True, soon it was revived in the form of the organization “First Department”.
Today Pavlov lives and works in exile. Continues to advise and support lawyers and lawyers who work within Russia, works on a number of projects and plans to return to Russia over time. This summer, Pavlov was arrested in absentia in the case of non -compliance with foreign legislation.
PS dozens of political lawyers still continue to work in Russia. In conditions of a threat, to change the status and from lawyers to turn into accused, many of them today reduce communication with journalists and leading social networks to a minimum. Recently it became known that several defenders of the defendants in the affairs of the “Gosizman” of the FSB closed the departure from the country.
-We, actually, were not going anywhere. But they took and closed the exit, without motivating anything at all, ”said one Russian lawyer to Novaya Gazeta Europe on the basis of anonymity. “So where do we go.” We would still have left. We must continue to work. Otherwise, who then will protect people within the country? Nobody. Scary? Very.