
Recently, I, as a representative of National Best , was invited to the shooting of a TV show “Press Club XXI” (the issue was dedicated to literary prizes). I was forced to reject this proposal because of the range of the road-but it is not a sin to speak out about the premiums of the post-fact.
The program itself, by the way, is not necessary to watch entirely, just get acquainted with the plot about the prizes that the channel prepared. However, the plot is useless - I will retell it now. First, the authors report that in Russia there are already three hundred literary awards. Then - buyers in a bookstore against the backdrop of shelves with Dontsova, all in chorus say that they do not care about the prizes. Finally, the journalist tells in detail about the prisoner - the laureate of the award named after Akhmatova for camp poetry. Message, that is, this: writers are clowns; Literature is a boring between the manner; Watch better TV.
Watch the TV, here you will be shown a beautiful zoo. ZEK is a laureate. The Chairman of the Council of Experts of the Big Book Award is talking with the intonation of a high school student who pressed the baby in the corner: "Have you received a long time ago?" The laureate of the Russian Boker for Afedron-Roman, who speaks of awards with a breath: this is a way to work with the intellectual elite of the country. The fashionable restaurateur is the only one says something reasonable, but his voice is drowning in this choir.
You are terribly far from the people - the host accuses the writers. There is a joke about how the proletarians accept the speech of educated people for a bird's chirus. Again a call to be closer to the people.
On this topic, by the way, there is another joke: what is the conversation of two intellectuals? Have you read it? Read. Did you read it? Read. Did you read it? No, I didn't read it. Be sure to read it!
And again, after the hero of the Figi-Mighiga, I repeat: we are terribly far from the people and we want to be even further!
Because in fact, the tragedy is that it is not far enough. Both in the “expert community” and among “ordinary readers” are the same thing: a good prize is the one that awarded my beloved Pupkin, and the one that awarded someone else is bad.
On duty and as much as possible, I will monitor everything that happens around National Best, including around the reader voting in the LJ-community of the prize. The most common commentary (both in the community and in personal blogs) in general terms the Pasternak formula reinstates: "I actually do not read, but I will say."
Almost a thousand people voted for the book of Olga Lucas, “Crouping of Borders”. What is bad a book? Not at all. She is dear. The book in every sense is a woman’s and pleasant in every way.
This is the voice of the people. But experts vote in the same way, according to the same principle. What, taking a “big book” Biography of Tolstoy - is this is not a book that is pleasant in every way? And the " Flower Cross " by Kolyadina - isn't it a purely boob book?
The people, complain in LiveJournal, simply votes for their frands, without even reading their novels. But in the expert community - the same thing.
Andrei Gelasimov once in Moscow talked about a member of the Buker jury, who admitted that, they say, until I reward all friends, I would not leave the jury (Viktor Toporov sitting in the hall accurately guessed the name of the hero, try you). Mikhail Butov, presiding in the “Big Book”, admits on the air that he really likes the writer Ilicevsky, whose novel, who won the “Big Book”, edited.
So it turns out that the meaning of the existence of a bonus is to reward my beloved Pupkin, and not to broadcast any beliefs. Just like in LiveJournal.
"Be sure to read!" - Both experts and readers say to each other. Why? Yes, because I have not read everything else and I do not advise you!
In the absence of a passionate desire to present something meaningful to the world, in the presence of invincible laziness in general, read something-the books are pleasant in all respects.
But are the experts not because of the experts that they should be half a corps ahead of “ordinary readers”? Should experts be shopkeepers praising their goods? And not fighters on barricades? Shouldn't experts pay tribute to the worthy enemy and be proud of them?
Instead of all this, the “literary process” and “quality of the text”. The monstrous boredom that experts, the public, and even television people who call experts feel, but just in case give a fried plot about the prisoner - the winner of the prize named after A. A. Akhmatova. Here, by extremely, the audience will be gone.