
December 10 for many is an important calendar day, proclaimed the UN Day of Human Rights. This happened in 1950, two years after the adoption by the World Organization of the famous declaration. The American Eleanor Roosevelt, who chaired the Committee, who developed the document, Canadian lawyer John Humphrey and his French colleague Rene Kassen worked extremely shockfully, formulating the document, which today is pleasure.
“Each person has the right to life, to freedom and personal integrity,” the third article reminds us. "No one should be tortured or cruel, inhuman or humiliating his dignity and punishment," the fifth article claims. "All people have the right to equal protection from any discrimination that violates the real declaration, and from any incitement to such discrimination," the seventh says. "Each person has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or beliefs," the eighteenth guarantees. “No one can be subjected to arbitrary interference in his personal and family life, arbitrary encroachments on the inviolability of his home, the secret of his correspondence or his honor and reputation. Everyone has the right to protect the law from such intervention or such encroachments,” the Dwyeenth encourages.
Since this wonderful declaration was adopted-perhaps the best document in the history of mankind that has ever acquired legal status-more than sixty years have passed. It’s not enough to say that this declaration, contrary to its name, did not become “universal”; Speaking out, it is not fully implemented in any country in the world. Different states, including those considered the standards of liberal democracy, create obstacles and barriers designed to prevent emigrants from other countries, and if these people are allowed, then for the most part only low-paid employees in the labor market who do not have equal civilian status with the "local" population.
Article 13, of course, declared that "everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own," but no country is ready to accept all immigrants who want to connect their fate with it, and the right to leave is obviously pointless without the right to enter. Articles about freedom, personal integrity and prohibition of torture are, of course, remarkable, but the fact is that they are violated not only in the Islamic state, in Chechnya and in the cellars of the so -called Donetsk People’s Republic: the CIA secret prisons in different countries may have been closed in 2009, according to the Decree of the President of Barack Obama , but the prison in Guantanamo still acts. According to the list represented by the US Department of Defense in 2006, 558 prisoners from 41 countries passed through Guantanamo. According to data published several years ago in The New York Times , the American authorities transferred almost eight hundred people in Guantanamo.
Of course, no declaration of human rights did not correspond to all this and does not correspond to any side, as it does not correspond to the guarantees of the “secrets of correspondence” PriSM, carried out by the US National Security Agency in order to massive unspoken electric communication networks. There are no doubts that intelligence of other countries carry out similar programs, the issue concerns only technological capabilities. The fact that in the Western world there were people such as the Americans Bradley Manning and Edward Snowden and the Australian Julian Assange, in my opinion, suggests that in these countries, despite all the efforts of the propaganda of militaristic patriotism, there are those who are ready to really fight for the values of the declaration of human rights and for civilian control over power structures and state bodies power.
It is painful to think that in Russia or China there were no Snowenes in Russia or the Snowden, despite the fact that there is no reason to believe that the power structures and authorities of these countries do not create at least things compared to those that create the NSA, the CIA, the Pentagon and the State Department. But throughout Russia and throughout China there was not a single responsible employee of power structures or authorities that would be ready to put universal ideals of human rights above departmental reasons of honor of the uniform. Manning was in prison, Assange defended the authorities of Ecuador, and Snowden - the Russian Federation. The Americans would probably be happy to provide asylum to the Russian or Chinese colleague and like -minded Snowden, but there were no such - and this is perhaps one of the most striking indicators of how much the Declaration of Human Rights is not taken seriously in these societies.
The universal declaration adopted in 1948 was followed by other documents, in particular, the European Convention on the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, on the basis of which the European Court of Human Rights arose. By the way, in the second half of the 1960s, the ECHR headed just the aforementioned Rene Kassen. Then the jurisdiction of this court did not apply to the Russian Federation, but since 1998, the ECHR has been considering the claims filed by citizens of Russia. Until the end of 2013, judges of the ECHR made decisions on 1475 such cases, in 1381 cases (that is, almost 94%) recognizing the fact of violation by the authorities of the Russian Federation of certain provisions of the European human rights convention. For comparison: over the entire existence of the ECHR, since 1959, only 913 cases were examined against France, in which violations were found in only 674, that is, in less than 74% of cases considered.
Speaking directly, a couple of years of work of a "enraged printer" defeated fifteen years
In recent years, lawsuits against Russia have occupied first place in the total volume of complaints received by the ECHR. Employees and activists of Russian political and legal organizations confidently use threats to the ECHR for any reason, being sure that the truth is on their side, and an independent and impartial European court recognizes this. In more than 90% of cases (!), Funds submitted on certain procedural issues are not accepted for consideration at all, but among the few that are still made, decisions almost always, indeed, find themselves in favor of the applicants. The problem, however, is not even that the highest percentage of refusals to consider cases on the merits is the result of almost exclusively formally procedural considerations (and by no means a guarantee of the lack of violations), and decisions are made years after the contested events, although this, of course, is trouble: justice may not always triumph five to seven years later, before that, it is still necessary to survive. The problem, however, is more serious, and it concerns the effectiveness of all this mechanism as a whole.
No matter how bitter it is to recognize this, it seems to me obvious that no verdicts of the ECHR had a significant impact on the provision in the field of ensuring human rights and freedoms in Russia. Some citizens and organizations received monetary compensation - and, in general, did not have any other effect of the ECHR, state structures and law enforcement agencies did not change the principles of their work under the influence of these decisions. In recent years, judges of the ECHR could only powerlessly look at the large -scale offensive of the Russian authorities to political rights and freedoms of citizens. Speaking directly, a couple of years of work of a “enraged printer” defeated fifteen years of the ECHR to a knockout.
The other day, Putin said something streamlined about the possibility of revision of the Russian Constitution, so that it corresponds to changing realities, and in the human rights community there are experiences on the fact that "we are losing the last line." In principle, a change in laws due to the fact that the world that these laws are trying to regulate is changing is a natural thing. This happens, for example, in Switzerland, which is a model of direct democracy: the Constitution of 1874 ruled more than a hundred times, increasing the number of its articles more than half, until in 1999 they replaced the whole basic law. It is clear that Russia is not Switzerland, but I would still like to ask: did at least some provisions of the Constitution Putin and his close associates prevent the course that they wanted to realize?
It is appropriate to recall in this regard the provisions of the "Stalin" Constitution of 1936, which, as such, has no reason to scold. So, Article 125 stated that "citizens of the USSR is guaranteed by law: a) freedom of speech, b) freedom of print, c) freedom of assembly and rallies, d) freedom of street processions and demonstrations." Moreover, the same article stated that "these rights of citizens are ensured by the provision of printers and their organizations of printing houses, paper reserves, public buildings, streets, communications and other material conditions necessary for their implementation." There is nothing to comment on here, everything that came immediately after the adoption of the Constitution 1937 is clear and so, but the fact that when from 1937 to 1944 echelons to Siberia and Northern Kazakhstan deported entire peoples is worthy of mentioning, Article 127 also acted in the Constitution, which “citizens of the USSR is ensured by the inviolability of the individual”, and Article 123: “Equality of citizens of the USSR, independent Their nationality and race, in all areas of economic, state, cultural and socio-political life, is an immutable law. "
Who and when did the Constitution defend in Russia? Yes, rewrite Putin at least all personally, what will it change? For sixty -six years, which have passed since the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the illusory of hopes for solving political and humanitarian problems has become obvious. A huge amount has been adopted by resolutions, but the world as a whole does not move to the celebration of liberal-law-defendant ethics.
Was it possible to foresee it? Quite. When the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was accepted at the UN, the head of one of the delegations rightly indicated: “Despite some of its advantages, this project has a number of large shortcomings, the main of which is its formal-legal nature and the absence of any events in this project that would be able to promote the main freedoms of human rights and rights.” So it is, as a result of which lawlessness in our world is much more common than justice.
One prevents him from admiring the prophetic gift of this diplomat - his own biography. The quoted words were said by Andrei Vyshinsky, the Prosecutor General of the USSR during the years of large terror, in the postwar years, who first deputy minister, and then the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the USSR. At a time when the head of the Soviet delegation, Vyshinsky by crocodile tears, mourned the absence in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of the obligation of its implementation, the number of completely disenfranchised prisoners in the Gulag exceeded two and a half million people - a record number in the history of the country. Vyshinsky was an academician of the USSR Academy of Sciences that he knew how not to see the logs in his eye, even noting the Sorinka in the eyes of all those to whom he addressed.
Fans of legalism do not need to amuse themselves with illusions: legal norms, no matter how wonderful they are, in themselves are not able to guarantee anything at all, while the guarantors of observing the rights and freedoms of man and citizen can be Stalin with Vyshinsky. It is impossible to hope that the values of freedom in any country can be rooted in international declarations, verdicts of the European Court or articles of the Constitution. No lawyers can impose the values to society and the authorities to which this society and this power do not want to follow. Realizing this, it is quite difficult to live, for it is not clear what to hope for, but the illusions are all the more and never saved from anything.
Alec Epstein - historian and sociologist
Opinions expressed under the heading "Law" may not reflect the point of view of the editorial office