
Radio Liberty continues a series of publications on how life in Crimea has changed 11 months after the annexation of the Peninsula of Russia. This time is an interview with the Crimean political scientist
Our next hero, the Crimean political scientist, associate professor of Simferopol State University Dmitry Omelchuk , who does not expect any economic reforms in Crimea and is not surprised at how the criminal redistribution of ownership on the peninsula is happening.
-Why did the new government bold and rudely with the help of “masks-shows” took up the redistribution of property? According to sound logic, it is more profitable to start work with good deeds and gain political glasses, and then “nationalization” is in full swing.

- The point is not only in the new government, but in the prevailing tradition. For almost a quarter of a century of the existence of independent Ukraine, the redistribution of property took on wave -like forms. One group comes to power, takes the property from the predecessors, successfully works, then comes the next one, takes away from the last chair, and also steers the economy, as if nothing had happened, is the continuation of the “general line” of the party. It would be nice to stop and move on to civilized forms of doing business, but such a time did not come.
For almost a quarter of a century of the existence of independent Ukraine, the redistribution of property took on wave -like forms
- Is this criminal tradition established and supported by a specific person or a whole clan?
- This is a strong system. If a person who came to power did not do this, they would look at him with surprise, they say, sick at his head. Do like everyone else!
- Why is this done so brazenly with the help of people in uniforms with machine guns? Where are the lawyers, raider captures, the battle of lawyers?
-In the same way, Mogilev (the former Prime Minister of Crimea) took away the property from the current head of Crimea Sergei Aksenov at one time. They squeezed everything that he had, the Astoria restaurant was left. The story is repeated, the same mechanisms and techniques.
- But none of Aksenov’s predecessors had their own armed brigades in the Crimea, they are called the units of the "people's militia". A militarized group does not obey the Minister of Defense Shoigu, or the Minister of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Kolokoltsev, nor the FSB, nor the Ministry of Emergencies, or the FSO. Why Aksenov is a personal detachment of militants?
- The “People’s Militia” appeared in the spring of 2014, when the Maidan raged in Kyiv, the detachment is conventionally militarized, and does not represent real armed force. This is a kind of security structure not normal. Russian laws do not allow the governors such a power structure, which means that Aksenov has some agreements with Moscow on this subject.
- But armed people in masks with machine guns enter the offices, throw people out of there? It is unlikely that today in Putin’s Russia this is possible if only in the Caucasus, and even then not everywhere.
- So far, this is perceived as an action that has the right to exist. We will consider as features of the transition period.
- For example, when we are talking about such a large company as Crimeavtotrans, where power has changed, the lawyers of the enterprise are trying to appeal to the law, demand to comply with procedures, refer to court decisions. Aksenov openly says: "I have no 3-5 years to walk around the courts, look for some quotes and commas to sue." The end of the quote. No sooner said than done. "CrimeAvtotrans" has new owners. Aksenov does not hide: the law is not written like him.
- Maybe I'm not quite right, I don’t know all the details of the Chechen management system or model, but, apparently, how it is organized in Crimea, it looks like the Kadyrovsky version. We gave the Crimea to the mercy, you will put things in order there, and we do not interfere in your affairs. Weak - we will punish, and we will write off everything else.
I don’t know all the details of the Chechen management system or model, but apparently, how it is organized in Crimea, it looks like the Kadyrovsky version
- Why is there no hard resistance, attempts to prevent this redistribution of property?
- When there is a state apparatus behind the “collision and a break”, there are not so many chances to defend property. A few years ago, “guys from Makeevka and Donetsk” were in the power structures, the officials brought officials to Crimea Yanukovych, they did everything exactly the same, no one could resist. And then, in the Crimea, we are talking about the nationalization of the property of the oligarchs of the oligarchs Igor Kolomoisky and Renat Akhmetov, such actions of the authorities are perceived as if with understanding, and in other things, such as the “nationalization” of the “Crimeavtotrans”, “Crimehleb” and other objects, of course, questions arise. And this is not a complete list, not everything is still published.
- The people look at this chaos and silently?
- If the people are indignant, then, most likely, against local authorities, against specific methods, anger will not be directed to Moscow, but to Crimean officials. The Kremlin will stand aside.
- Why did the “nationalization” according to the head of the Crimea Sergei Aksenov caused rejection from the side of the seemingly political ally, “brother in referendum”, chairman of the Legislative Assembly of Sevastopol Alexei Chalian, who is also called the “People’s Governor”?
- You see, different approaches. Sevastopol uses somewhat different methods of city management, after all, power in the hands of the military, the current governor Sergey Chanyilo-vice-admiral of the reserve, another mentality. Therefore, Chaly openly condemned the nationalization in Axenovsky.
- Is it possible to say that in Crimea and in Sevastopol temporary power?
- This is a common opinion among Crimeans. Those people who came to the administration two or three years and four years ago remained mainly in power. There were no radical personnel changes. Although the level of support of the "Party of Regions" by Yanukovych on the peninsula was very high, the gap between the authorities and the people remained unchanged, as, indeed, in Ukraine in general. The success of the two -year prescription of the Yanukovych party is explained by the lack of an alternative. Neither Tymoshenko, nor Yushchenko, nor the leaders of the Maidan are perceived in Crimea. To a large extent, this product is very reasonable and effective propaganda, which has been conducted here for more than ten years of the Party of Regions. The principle of Richelieu - who is not with us, he was successfully transformed against us: who is not with us, that is the Bandera.
The principle of Richelieu - who is not with us, he was successfully transformed against us: who is not with us, that is the Bandera
- How could people support Yanukovych, whom today only the lazy does not call a thief, corrupt official and a coward who escaped from the presidential palace at the most difficult and critical moment for the country? Even Putin did not say a good word about him, although he provided asylum.
- Do not compare the situation of today, when the people were partially transmitted. The “Party of Regions” that ruling here, which incorporated the entire Crimean elite, personified a certain alternative to the Bandera. Yanukovych was walking under pro -Russian slogans, which in the Crimea, of course, are perceived positively. When they say that Aksenov came from a political organization that had never gained in the elections again, this is a pure truth. The Russian idea was monopolized not by the "Russian bloc", but by the "Party of Regions." No one forgot how Yulia Tymoshenko threatened to entangle the keys with wire and put a hard order there. Nobody forgot Yushchenko, who here and everything was third in Ukrainian. In 2007, a joke went here in 2007. After when all road signs and signs were translated into Ukrainian in the Crimea, the accident rate decreased sharply. Yushchenko believed in it. People frankly chuckled at this. But when the officials forced any lousy paper to translate into Ukrainian, by the way, now the same idiocy begins in the opposite direction, unfortunately, people like Yushchenko and Tymoshenko could not have authority, plus the company was a nationalist Tyagnibok, which more often other politicians appeared on the screen. This work on discrediting the entire trinity was professionally carried out by Yanukovych's supporters. Therefore, Viktor Fedorovich was not an alternative.
The Russian idea was not monopolized by the "Russian bloc" of Aksenov, but the "Party of Regions"
- Is it possible to say that the Crimeans are responsible for their choice, for Yanukovych, who, to put it mildly, disappointed after these revealing golden loaves and toilets, after reporting from the Mezhigorye?
- No, what are you! We have a very short memory. This applies to Crimeans and Ukraine. We laughed, spat, mocked, forgot and switched to today's topics. And Yanukovych today, if someone had conducted sociological surveys today, I think it would not have received more than ten percent.
- Aksenov, Chaly, Changilo - are they temporary leaders? Or did these people come for a long time?
- No, politicians are unlikely to come in the current situation for a long time. They will perform their functions-someone is better, someone is worse-and will be horizontally moved somewhere to other places. But it will not be tomorrow. Tomorrow this can happen only as a result of some major failure, that is, when it will be necessary to punish. And the winners are not judged. They earned their right. The task that stood before them, probably, other people would not have fulfilled as easily as they did.
- Do the Crimeans want good or evil to Ukraine?
- A very different situation. Many are frenzied with everything Ukrainian. Some crave the decay, collapse and collapse of the state, with foam at the mouth and with fists, but I would not say that this is the majority. There are quite a lot of people who are deeply regret to relate to what happened, understanding the great trouble that has suffered Ukraine today, and would like everything to be calm there.
- I felt the unkind attitude of Crimeans to refugees from Donbass. Why?
- This year, the Ministry of Education of Russia from the budget allocated special quotas for refugees. But it turned out that people who came from the military zone are not such. As soon as all this Bodyag began, in the Crimea, throwing their homes and other things, the families who had property here, which had where to leave. And once our dean at the height of the election campaign says: you go to the yard and look at what cars are with Donetsk, Dnepropetrovsk and Lugansk numbers. It was people who brought their children to act by quota. With my representative of the representative class, I look quite modest against this background.
- These were not those who need help?
- That's right, and this is striking, although there are students from poor families. But the fact remains: many people have arrived in the Crimea, who are not refugees in their position and lifestyle. They left the crisis, from the war, did not go to protect either one or the other side. This is a indicative moment.
But the fact remains: a lot of people have arrived in the Crimea who, in their position and lifestyle, are not refugees
- They are considered separatists or people who are in trouble?
- Rather, they are of the opinion that there is a great trouble in the Donbass, but I repeat, they are not approved, some rich and wealthy people behave defiantly. The stereotype, which came here along with Vasily Jarta from Donetsk, the former Prime Minister of Crimea, planted here by Yanukovych, is still imposed on them to a certain extent. Jarta brought here the first and largest wave of immigrants to bureaucratic positions from their native Makeevka, some of these bureaucrats returned to the Donbass. There are signaling that people from the jart team are returning. And what should they do in Donetsk: the business is destroyed, they can give and shoot on the head, what good. So they run here, back, although in theory they also have nothing to do here.
- I talked with different people and, to surprise, found that most of the population of the Crimea is watching Ukrainian channels.
- looks and compares. Frankly, Moscow wins in this information war. It will not be said to the offense of Russia, but in order to watch the Kremlin news, you must have strong nerves. Everything is so monopolized and controlled there!
-Some experts call this Goebbels Tw.
- Without a doubt that Ukraine, with all its tendentious programs, is professional and, I would say, the volumetric level is simply not comparable.
- Why does Russian television look more convincing in the minds of people?
-Firstly, distrust of Ukraine, and secondly, the level of the population is such that they are easily served manipulations with “crucified babies”, with hundreds of raped women. Unfortunately, this is the level of perception and the general culture of the population. On the other hand, there is a clear bust with misinformation, even pro -Russian people who occupy high positions complain - it is impossible to watch. Moods are changing.
The level of the population is such that they are easily served manipulations with "crucified babies", with hundreds of raped women
- Why does the Kremlin actively carry out rotation in individual cities, at key posts they put the Varangians from Russia: in power structures, in universities, in the judicial corps?
- If we are talking about power structures, this is explainable, as well as about the judicial corps - such a corrupt judicial corps, which was in Ukraine, still needs to be searched. But universities and similar institutions are a clear bust, it can only harm and create a certain tension in society.
- How do representatives of the local elite react to this?
- In Sevastopol, the elite is very strictly objected to such methods of rotation. It has not yet reached Simferopol and other cities, but I dare to assure you, in this part, resistance, I mean in universities, in administrative posts, of course, will be. It will be not open, but hidden, but it will certainly be.
- What will happen to those who changed the Ukrainian oath and accepted the Russian one? Do these people get to some unreliable caste?
- I would not hang such labels. Russia is large and rotation, which in any case accompanies any person working in power structures, will become a normal thing, and you need to serve everywhere, both in the Far East, and in Siberia, and not just in the sunny Crimea. But in some ways I agree with you that there are certain notes of distrust.
- Why distrust? After all, nevertheless, in a referendum, they voted together "for Russia."
- Leave aside the expression - "all together." Who wanted, came and voted.
- This is done purposefully in order to take control of all the levers of power, including to give the desired vector ideological thesis?
- There is a rule in the mechanics: when the nut is twisted to the stop, then they are deployed two turns back. If it is further tightened, a breakdown may occur. People are very unhappy. And the Sevastopol residents, those who advocated the most for Russia, by the way, in terms of level and coefficient of discontent, are today above any other Crimean city.
- Euphoria after the referendum passed or does it still exist?
- The percentage of people in a state of euphoria became much less. The reasons, first of all, are economic. On the one hand, part of the population of such a post-Soviet-paternalistic mood very easily believed in the promises that everything will be fine here, Russia will do everything, Russia will give everything. Disappointment begins, first of all, in the economic sphere. 9-10 months have passed, nothing has changed by and large. Pensioners won, yes. In general, euphoria passes. This is today, perhaps, the determining mood in the Crimea.
Euphoria passes, the expectation process really takes place, and everyone, including active supporters and those who calmly perceived the accession of Crimea to Russia
- But the prices that I now see for food are pulled to Moscow.
- And salaries are not pulled up, this is the biggest problem. Salaries are cut under the guise that there is no money. I know people in power structures who are very unhappy that they began to pay much less than they promised. The husband of one of my friends, he moved from the Ukrainian army to Russian, receives half as much as his colleague who came from Russia in a similar position. Maybe this is not a frequent phenomenon, but the question is that the population is still entrusted to local officials, believing that in Moscow they simply do not know about this. There is a rigid filtering of complaints and critical letters. This does not reach the Kremlin. But euphoria goes into a new quality. Maybe we are not satisfied with everyone, but we are ready to endure, because we have no war, and there is a misfortune there. Such moods even among those people who retain pro -Ukrainian orientations.
- Will the reforms be carried out in the Crimea?
- I think they will not be. I see how many enterprises are closed. People whom I know are leaving small business, turn off. Many others, including larger entrepreneurs, sneed and hid. People from the banking sector have lost significantly. This is not pro -Ukrainian discontent, they are dissatisfied with the current situation. Of course, they will wait for changes, including personnel.
- Do you admit that there will be a sharp change in mood? What can this depend on?
- I do not exclude. For example, whether we want or not, the further increase in utility prices is inevitable. Already today, a girl, our gas controller, called me, and said: gas tariffs rose from January 1. Чалый, кстати, где-то с неделю назад говорил о том, чтобы избежать техногенного коллапса, Севастополю нужно поднимать цены на электроэнергию примерно в 3 раза. Мы уже начинаем пожинать плоды несложившегося курортного сезона. Сейчас пока еще люди на каких-то ресурсах сидят, но с каждым месяцем эти запасы будут таять. Не секрет, что курортный сезон в этом году полностью провален. Были разговоры о 600 тысячах отдыхающих с Украины – этим словом обозвали беженцев. Дело в том, что понятие "отдыхающий" носит не физический, а финансовый характер. Есть люди, которые приезжают с деньгами, а есть люди, которые приезжают без денег. Если говорить о туристах из России, их в прошлом году было ровно столько же, как и в 2013-м, может, даже чуть больше, а могло бы быть еще больше, если бы не проблемы с транспортом.
Не секрет, что курортный сезон в этом году полностью провален. Разговоры о 600 тысячах отдыхающих с Украины – этим словом обозвали беженцев
– Татарская тема способна дестабилизировать ситуацию в Крыму, учитывая, что Меджлис, Мустафа Джемилев и его сторонники до сих пор не признают легитимность российских властей в Крыму?
– Начнем с того, что Меджлис сегодня уже не тот, который был 10-15 лет назад, он не представляет всех крымских татар. Думаю, этот фактор не будет серьезно дестабилизировать обстановку. Какой-то элемент может быть, но то, что Меджлис возглавит здесь какое-то сопротивление, уверен, такого не произойдет.
– Можно ли сказать, что татарский вопрос решен?
- Definitely not. Но он не станет источником тяжелого напряжения. С одной стороны, Москва проявит дипломатию и сделает несколько шагов навстречу татарам, с другой стороны, здравомыслящие представители крымских татар найдут компромисс в этой ситуации, с тем чтобы избежать обострений.
– Есть ли в Крыму легальная оппозиция, которая открыто критикует власть? Могут ли люди, которые думают иначе, собираться вместе и не бояться того, что отряд самообороны придет и закроет их?
– На сегодняшний день в Крыму оппозиции нет. Некие критические замечания позволяется высказывать и довольно круто группе, так скажем, приближенных политологов и известных деятелей. Но это критика в пределах, как сделать лучше, а не в принципе.
– Грубо говоря, это косметические процедуры?
– Реально – да. Один из самых известных политологов и экспертов, выживаемый при любом режиме, Александр Форманчук позволил себе недавно очень жесткую критику. Что же это, говорит, за преобразования, если нет новых лиц?! Это публично было заявлено. Ничего, живой, ходит пока еще.
– Есть ли в Крыму альтернативные СМИ, подобные "Дождю" и "Новой газете" в России?
- No. Все зачищено под ноль. Более того, однажды позвонили мне с "Дождя" по скайпу, пригласили принять участие в конференции. Пришло время настраивать скайп – и тут весь интернет в районе умер.