"It was taken to the West to the West to poison him!" This concept of Navalny's disease is promoted by federal Russian channels. It would seem absurd. But they are promoting. Because the more monstrous the lie, the more willing to believe in it? The Big Seven countries made a joint statement, calling the main Russian opposition policy a victim of a chemical attack. The German ambassador officially tells Sergei Lavrov that, according to the German side, Navalny became a victim of crimes committed in the Russian Federation using the substances of the Novice group developed in Russia. In turn, the Russian Foreign Ministry expressed a “decisive protest” in connection with the nomination by the Government of the Federal Republic of Germany “unfounded accusations and ultimatums against Russia in the context of the disease of Russian citizen Alexei Navalny, as well as the use of the situation as a reason for the discrediting of the Russian Federation in the international arena”. Is it possible in principle to somehow convince Russia that the crime was committed on its territory and with its participation? Vil Mirzayanov, chemical weapons expert (USA), Boris Wright Shuster, journalist (Germany), Konstantin Eggert, journalist (Lithuania), Alexander Melman , journalist (Russia) are discussed. The program "Faces to the event" Elena Rykovtseva is conducting.
Video version of the program
Elena Rykovtseva: German ambassador spent two hours in the Russian Foreign Ministry today. He tried to convince Sergey Lavrov for two full hours of what the whole civilized world was convinced of. But, nevertheless, as soon as he went beyond the threshold, the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation immediately published a statement that all these are unfounded accusations and ultimatums against the Russian Federation, and enough with this, stop it. Alexander Melman is with us. Everyone who does not listen to federal Russian channels believe that Alexei Navalny was poisoned by a "newcomer". Big Seven Foreign Ministers believe, they made a statement that yes, he is poisoned, we trust the conclusions of German specialists. Many who believe, but there are no laurels. How to convince him?
Alexander Melman: Not only he. Indeed, the keyword, what you said, is "believes." While we were so divided into groups, some are a club that they know accurately and peremptorily, that Alexey Navalny is poisoned in Russia and poisoned by the Kremlin, others in Moscow consider it quite the other way around. And those and others believe so far, that both are unprovable. I would like evidence, in fact.
Elena Rykovtseva: The German ambassador says: all the results of laboratory studies were sent by the Federal Republic of Germany to the organization to prohibit chemical weapons. That is, all this is, it is all officially, it is on forms, it is aimed at the organization that will be professionally engaged in this. Do they want to be sent to the address of the Foreign Ministry of the Russian Federation?
Alexander Melman: And they do the right thing, why not?
Elena Rykovtseva: We will now have a specialist in chemical weapons, one of the authors of the very frightening "newcomer" whom we ask why everyone believes and only Sergey Lavrov does not believe. I do not think that these results were sent to each of the foreign ministers of the Big Seven, but, nevertheless, they accept a joint statement without receiving these tests.
Alexander Melman: Sergey Lavrov, as well as Lukashenko, as well as Putin, as well as all the propaganda clans that we see on TV every day.
Elena Rykovtseva: Alexander, you recently recorded another statement on TV, on a box, an Omsk doctor, a toxicologist. What did he express again?
Alexander Melman: He said that Alexei Navalny had a hyperglycemic coma. Before that, at the very beginning, we were told by all doctors of the Omsk hospital, starting from the head physician that it was a metabolic disorder and a hypoglycemic coma. As an old diabetic, I know perfectly well how one differs from one another. In one of the programs, we also talked about it with you. Because hypoglycemic is a low decrease in sugar, so Mrs. Simonyan advised Alexei to accept Raphael, that is, when it is urgent to eat something sweet. And the hyperglycemic coma, about which the chief toxicologist Omsk said is a completely different one, is a sharp increase in sugar. I would like to ask: you guys, stop at any one version. And when you bifurcate this way, that's why you are not believed.
Elena Rykovtseva: If only not a "beginner", a hyper-, the hypocome-if only not a "beginner". Vil, you do not consider the conclusions that German experts made unfounded?
VIL MIRZAYANOV: The fact is that when the poisoning of the Skripals occurred in Salisbury, they made tests there and received spectra of poisoning substance 234 and identified. Now this is beyond doubt. Naturally, the British received these spectra, physicochemical constants, DNA of the substance that was used. This is the mass spectrum. This mass spectrum, of course, the British shared with NATO countries. After that, there is no need to have any sample of “newcomers” in any country, wherever poisoning occurs, taking samples, having processed them accordingly, concentrating, taking the device, receiving these spectra, which are compared electronically with library data, you get a positive answer. Moreover, it gives the name of this substance. Thanks to these formulas, the British managed to synthesize and get spectra. It is impossible to deny, this is equivalent to the denial of human DNA.
Elena Rykovtseva: I want to understand that it is quite obvious to you that Sergey Lavrov should get in his hands, so that it is obvious to him too? He says: these are all conversations, these are all speculations. They had a sample, they conducted comparative tests, there is no other option here when you have something to compare with, and he says: prove to me. How to prove to him?
VIL MIRZAYANOV: Now the samples are sent to the executive body of the organization to comply with chemical disarmament. Russia is a member of this organization, of course, Russia will be familiarized with the results of these samples. Moreover, in the same organization, most likely, they will conduct additional tests. And after that, a representative who understands what a spectrum is distinguished from something else, he has nowhere to go, how to say: yes, this substance, I believe, a242.
Elena Rykovtseva: I understand correctly that when you call this substance, does he have some differences from the substance that was used in England? And it consists in the fact that several people were struck there, but here the blow was stroke pointedly?
VIL MIRZAYANOV: Yes, on this basis I just concluded that another substance was used here, however, it is already in a solid state, much more toxic than A234, therefore, a much smaller amount is required for poisoning. Already 10 milligrams of this substance are enough to kill a person. Apparently, in this case, the goal was not the murder, but the decommissioning, did not give a fatal dose. The fact that in Omsk the doctor guessed what was the matter, atropin gave - this suggests that he suspected the use of a poisonous substance, which class, is difficult to say, but phosphoruscorganic, of course. In this case, they always give this type of antidota.
Elena Rykovtseva: The offender, of course, had a goal to introduce this substance so that it was not found? Because if there is a lot, if such a shock dose that kills is easier to calculate. That is, there was some subtle calculation there to disable, but so that this substance could not fix it, they thought that they would not find this substance in the body?
Vil Mirzayanov: The terrorist did not count anything, he was just a performer. Everything is done in the medical and biological department, there are experiments on animals, rabbits, dogs, mice. This is a very long work, a clinical dose after the introduction of a certain concentration of a certain amount of substances in these animals, then measurement, convulsions and everything else, how much such and such and such a substance is required to get only half a target, as they say. All this is calculated, work is underway in this department. They determined there, but, apparently, a miscalculation was allowed. The experiments showed, for example, in the medical and biological department that the substance after three or four days falls to a concentration, which cannot be determined by modern methods. Thus, then extracted to people. Extrapolation is not always adequate, they could in this way count, a significant fall in concentration did not occur on a person. And then, by the example of the poisoning of the Skripals, they know in Russia that after a person’s poisoning, this substance is not distributed evenly, but is localized in certain places.
Elena Rykovtseva: You can compare this with the Litvinenko case, when at the last moment it was established than, another day or two literally-and there would be no traces of this polonium?
VIL MIRZAYANOV: A similar story. The calculation was that the concentration would fall. But, you see, one thing is on animals, another thing is in public. We have now conducted experience on a person, now we will know.
Elena Rykovtseva: Konstantin Eggert is in touch with us. I would like to ask you now to listen to a number of statements that were made from different diplomats of different countries, ask you for help, explain to us why Sergey Lavrov, the Russian Foreign Ministry, and Russian politicians are so abuting. It’s easier to say: well, let's wait for what the organization on the ban on chemical weapons will say. No, they rest and make new and new statements.
Your browser does not support HTML5
Statements of politicians about the poisoning of Navalny
Elena Rykovtseva: They are sitting for two hours in the Foreign Ministry, communicate. The German ambassador reports that "in connection with the use of" Novice "an organization for a ban on chemical weapons will be involved in the investigation of the Navalny case." It seems that other countries are enough for this, it is a solid organization. Why is it still starting to be called a provocation? They told you that there would be serious people to do this, there will be an investigation, no, he acts with this statement, Sergey Lavrov, that all this is a provocation, was celebrated from the threshold.
Konstantin Eggert: The fact is that in fact the position of Germany, and the Western allies, it is very clear. This is not said openly, because it is necessary to preserve political correctly, to pretend that there may be some very long investigation in Russia, that suddenly Russian prosecutors, Russian government officials, will say: but, how we did not understand, we must investigate how they actually poisoned Navalny. It is clear that this will not happen. In fact, what the West says is extremely unpleasant for the Kremlin, because that poisoning substance that was used cannot be synthesized at home. In fact, these phrases of Germany and other Western countries are worth a very simple position: we understand that someone who related to the Russian state has done it, we will formulate carefully. It is quite difficult to do such things in relation to such a prominent public figure as Alexei Navalny, without what, let's say, they knew very highly. And this is terribly nervous of the Russian elite, which perfectly understands that if this investigation goes the same way as it goes today in the Dutch court, in fact the second investigation, or a discussion of the topic of the death of the Malaysian liner in 2014, this will lead to very disappointing conclusions for the Russian elite. And it annoys, outrages. They demand documents from Germany in order to probably guess how to react better to this. The matter is going to a very serious crisis, because for many, many years the Kremlin believed: the reputation does not play any role in world affairs, good relations do not play any role, the most important thing is interests and strength. But ultimately, a certain baggage of this distrust of Moscow is accumulated. Now, I think, this is already close to the very notorious drop that overflows the bowl, or a straw that breaks the back of the camel. I think that if this investigation goes the way it will go, then the results will be extremely unpleasant for Moscow. And, probably, the last thing I will say, probably in Moscow, they are also worried and that's why. The fact is that for the first time, perhaps over all these years in Berlin, they approached to seriously think about the possibility of stopping construction, completion of the construction of the pipeline, the Northern Stream 2 gas pipeline. If this happens, it will be a very strong slap in the face of the Kremlin, it will be largely the end of the special relations that have been between Moscow and Berlin all this time, despite anything, in spite of Ukraine, regardless of any stories with Syria, despite the murder of the Georgian Chechen Khangoshvili. If this happens, it will be a break in relations with one of the few Western countries that was ready to listen to the Kremlin.
Elena Rykovtseva: Konstantin, Alexander says: well, send them these papers. I want to ask you: what's the point of sending whatever the documents, if the federal channels have already told us - well, let's say this is a "newcomer", but he was poisoned in Germany, they brought and poisoned him in "shattage? How can they be convinced that this crime is committed in the territory of the Russian Federation, that it is a "newcomer"? This is, in principle, a possible task - to convince them of this?
Konstantin Eggert: The answer is not. Because everyone understands how this happened, everyone understands that there is no point in the German government to poison Navalny. What is this madness? There was no fantasy who could come up with such a plot. This, I think, is a little such a position of powerlessness, because it is clear that you can’t do anything with the doctors of the clinic “Shait”, you can not do anything with the German government that will transfer this to the organization of chemical disarmament. You can’t do anything that all these results will be transferred to the NATO allies. You can’t do anything with the American Congress, which will get to this topic after the election and can take some additional sanctions that will be, to put it mildly, extremely unpleasant. We already see that in Germany its "Magnitsky Law" will soon be put into effect. Now in the Congress, a number of senators propose to introduce the "Navalny Law", which will strengthen responsibility, including for the use of poisonous substances abroad. This is all extremely unpleasant for Moscow. The most important thing is what Alexander said, why do not give documents is very simple: there is completely no confidence between Moscow and the Western capitals today. Such things are not done without trust. We are dealing today with the deplorable result of Russian foreign policy of the last 20 years, it has come to a dead end. Today, Russia today, at least, does not have Western partners, she has only one partner who looks down at her, this is China. And to put all this in a large foreign policy context - this, I would say, on the verge of a foreign policy catastrophe.
Elena Rykovtseva: In touch, Berlin, Boris Wright Shuster. Konstantin Eggert said that for the first time, the Angel Merkel was probably made from the side of the assumption that, perhaps, the “northern stream” would also be comprehended by sanctions. Do you think this is a very serious situation with Navalny and can end in a disaster in the relationship "Russia - West"?
Boris Wright Shuster: I, with all due respect to Konstantin, whom I love and appreciate, I do not agree here at all. I see the role of Merkel completely differently. You just need to pay attention to what she said. She did not say that we were thinking about the "northern stream", she did not say that we are raising the question, she said that she did not exclude the fact that this should be reviewed. I also do not exclude, Elena, that you will be the president of Russia tomorrow. Nothing can be excluded at all. This is precisely the Komsomol manner of Merkel, she is a Komsomol figure in the past, so to say. If you look, then with the Litvinenko case there was a much more serious matter, because this crime was committed on the territory of London. Three thousand residents of London were subject to contact with this terribly dangerous substance radioactive. What was it to Putin? In the end, there was nothing wrong with him. Now we are dealing with poisoning in Russia. Alas, I am very skeptical, what we see now, conversations, I think that it will be the same as Litvinenko, big conversations, and then there will be no real steps. I really hope that I am mistaken, maybe the bowl of patience is crowded, God forbid. But my skepticism is very large.
Elena Rykovtseva: And if nevertheless to assume that this organization to ban chemical weapons conducts its investigation, its conclusions coincide with the conclusions of German scientists, it provides its results to the Kremlin. Do you think this will convince the Kremlin that Alexei Navalny was poisoned by this military-chemical substance "Novice" in the Russian Federation?
Boris Wright Shuster: They wanted to sneeze. In the case of Litvinenko, the English judge decided that it was precisely from Moscow, in the case of the Skripals they wanted to sneeze. I just spoke with Marina Litvinenko, this is the widow of Alexander Litvinenko, she was already resorting to black humor, hinting at the fact that the killer Litvinenko Lugova is sitting in the Duma today and even leads the commission in the Duma, which is now involved in the investigation of the attempt on Navalny. Она говорила: нам надо посмотреть, кто сейчас войдет в Думу, кто будет награжден орденами, тогда увидим, кто это был. То есть верить в то, что сейчас какие-то доказательства, Кремль будет впечатлен, – это детский сад, извиняюсь.
Елена Рыковцева: Кстати, только что у нас была передача в пятницу, дело об убийстве Рейсса 37-го года, как его убийцы действительно получили повышения, государственные, прекрасные теплые должности. Ваш прогноз, что это рассосется точно так же, как рассосалось дело Скрипалей, оно по сути рассосалось, никто Россию ни в чем не убедит, она ни в чем не сознается, никаких особых санкций не будет, а если будут такие, которые не принесут ей особого беспокойства?
Борис Райтшустер: Очень хотелось бы желаемое за действительное выдавать, но все-таки надо реально смотреть на вещи. Когда постоянно никаких шагов не предпринимали, очень мало основы предполагать, что в этот раз будет кардинально по-другому.
Елена Рыковцева: Теперь мы переходим к этой части разговора, ради которой сидит Александр Мельман, о том, как на вас действует то, что вы слышите в федеральном эфире, эта кремлевская новая методичка, что, наверное, что-то случилось, но, конечно, не у нас, а где-то еще. Давайте посмотрим наш сюжет.
Your browser does not support HTML5
Federal media deny Russia's involvement in poisoning
Елена Рыковцева: Вот отвлекают, развлекают свою публику тем, что травят неких выходцев из России в данном случае в Солсбери, с Литвиненко мы прекрасно помним сюжет. По-моему, Березовский травил Литвиненко?
Александр Мельман: Березовский всегда был палочкой-выручалочкой в этом смысле, он всегда появлялся и всегда травил, господина Рыбкина он хотел убить и так далее. Кстати, не доказано ни то, ни другое, в обратную сторону тоже, поэтому сомнения все равно остаются. Березовский был очень выгодный товарищ, когда жил на этом свете. Сейчас его нет, уже на кого сваливать? Придумываются, конечно, другие версии. Но опять же это надо все реально доказать.
Елена Рыковцева: Теперь вместо Березовского какой-то глобальный мировой заговор, закулиса, которой выгодно. Естественно, что это выгодно кому угодно, только не Российской Федерации. Поскольку эта схема используется уже из года в год, из драматического случая в случай, считаете ли вы, что она используется, потому что она работает?
Александр Мельман: Да, я смотрел то, что вы показали, как-то даже восхитился, какие же профессионалы работают у нас в пропагандистском цехе, как они прекрасно владеют словом, то есть такие супермастера разговорного жанра, они могут убедить кого угодно, я боюсь, что даже меня. Но я изо всех сил стараюсь не поддаваться. Но то, что действительно нужны какие-то реальные доказательства — это да. Поэтому они играют на том, что есть обвинение, уже никто в этом не сомневается, уже все цитируют Ежи Леца, что глупо сомневаться, когда знаешь точно. Тем не менее, это все очень красивые слова. Мне бы хотелось действительно знать правду, чтобы прижать их носом просто к стене и сказать - это сделали вы, чтобы был какой-то судебный процесс. Нюрнбергский процесс, был процесс над фашизмом, над гитлеризмом — это уже юридически обосновано. Над Сталиным не было процесса, над сталинизмом. Мне бы хотелось, чтобы здесь это было не просто кто-то верит, а кто-то не верит, мало ли что я хочу, но как это сделать реально на самом деле. А пока можно играть в эти пропагандистские игры, можно отбиваться до последнего и делать это довольно убедительно.
Елена Рыковцева: По поводу доказательств тут же дело такое, почему немцы не отправляют результаты своих исследований лично Лаврову в папочке, потому что это действительно секретная вещь. Это методики выявления этих веществ, это не размножается даже по "семерке", это действительно отправляется в организацию серьезную, которая сделает свои выводы и ознакомит с ними российское руководство. Но дело же в том, что российскому руководству, как говорит Борис, начхать на эти выводы. Получат они эти выводы, неужели они согласятся с тем, что "Новичком" был отравлен? Вы верите в то, что Лавров скажет: да, вы нас убедили?
Александр Мельман: Лавров сам ничего не скажет. Я вообще даже удивляюсь, что он присутствует в этой пропагандистской кампании. Чтобы министр иностранных дел таким образом этим занимался, я как-то не очень это понимаю. Естественно, "да" может сказать только один человек.
Елена Рыковцева: Конечно, вам не напишет никакая организация по запрету, никакие следователи, никакие ученые вам не напишут списка имен людей, которые это сделали. Они даже способа, мы говорили со специалистом, он примерно представляет, что это за тип вещества, который действует точечно, но способ, был он втерт в его носки или он был растворен в стаканчике с чаем, он не знает и думает, что никто не знает.
Александр Мельман: Для этого нужно расследование на территории Российской Федерации, международное расследование. Россия не хочет этого делать, и мы это видим. Отравлен Щекочихин был, Анна Политковская, многие другие, и мы все равно говорим, что это скорее всего, то есть мы точно опять же не знаем, хотя целый ряд выстраивается. Тогда надо может быть ждать хотя бы суда нидерландского по МН17. Потому что пока власть очень уверенно выходит из всех этих ситуаций и говорит: это не мы, это не мы. Если этот суд, который длится столько лет, все-таки он придет к определенному решению, я бы хотел посмотреть тогда на Владимира Путина и на его окружение, на господина Пескова, как они будут тогда виртуозно отбрыкиваться, отмахиваться. И плевать ли им будет, если будет уже юридическое решение суда по поводу гибели самолета.
Елена Рыковцева: Давайте мы покажем результаты нашего опроса в Твиттере. Мы задавали вопрос: верите ли вы, что Навальный был отравлен именно "Новичком"? Вы видите, что 79,5% верят, 17,9% не верят, 2,5% об этом вообще не думали, у них нет никакого мнения по этому поводу. Мы можем, конечно, предполагать, что наша аудитория, которая сидит в Твиттере, она телевизор не смотрит. Но мы вышли на улицу проверить, что думает та аудитория, которую мы встречаем просто на улице, тоже их спросили об этом.
Your browser does not support HTML5
Верите ли вы, что Навальный был отравлен "Новичком"?
Continuation of the conversation watch the video