Lev Roitman:
Fascism will not pass in the Izmailovo Sports Palace. That is, by decision of the Moscow government, the second congress of the Russian National Unity movement will not be there next Saturday, the reserve corporal Alexander Barkashov is headed by this movement. The purpose of the movement is in his anthem: "There should be one order in the world, and it should rightfully be Russians." The decision of the Moscow government is sensational. It was in Moscow that Barkashov’s movement was officially registered 5 years ago, it was in the Reutovo sanatorium that Barkashovtsy threw up their hands at their first congress last year. And suddenly it was decided that their congress is a threat to the security of Muscovites, although the Barkashovites patrol the trains near Moscow along with the police. What happened? The program participates: Chairman of the Moscow Anti -Fascist Center Evgeny Voskhchkin; from Cologne Professor-historian Gerhard Simon; From Kyiv, political analyst Vladimir Malinkovich.
Evgeny Viktorovich Voskhchkin, the Moscow Anti-Fascist Center, no further than November 24, the capital's authorities allowed the manifestation of the Black Hundred before the main entrance to the State Duma. Well, they showed there, and all this was seen on television, such posters as: “General Makashov - crush the reptile, otherwise we will lose”, “Jewish fascists will fall from Russian terror” and so on. And now they are prohibited by the "Chernarubaschniki" Barkashov to sing in Izmailovo. What's happened?
Evgeny Evshoschkin:
It happened that the Barkashovites decided to hold a congress on Saturday on December 19th for their trouble. In the evil irony of fate, this completely coincides with the congress of the "Fatherland" of Luzhkovsky, and the start of the election campaign for Luzhkov could be very unsuccessful. Imagine what beautiful video sections would be shown on all television channels: a blessed Luzhkovsky sitting and raised in the fascist, Nazi greeting of the "black brown -haired" with swastikas. Paradoxically, this trifle played, it seems to me, a significant role.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Evgeny Viktorovich. Professor Gerhard Simon, Cologne, recently Yuri Luzhkov was in Germany, and now, being in Germany, he proposed Moscow as a place of the anti -fascist European congress, so, perhaps, a similar congress is most relevant for Moscow today. How does it see you from Germany?
Gerhard Simon:
It may really be more relevant to conduct such a congress today in Moscow than in Berlin or other cities of Western Europe. Although, I must tell you that this proposal to take part in this congress in Germany so far is a big response. At least, the general public of Germany did not respond to this proposal of Luzhkov. And I want to add the following: anti -fascism in Germany is not entirely clear, because, on the one hand, in Germany all anti -fascists, we already have a part of our political indemnity. On the other hand, anti -fascism is this term and this idea was used by German communists in the former GDR. In the former GDR for a very long time, indeed, the German state was based on anti -fascism. I want to pay attention to this that, unlike Russia, the term “anti-fascism” in Germany has some kind of ambiguous meaning: on the one hand, we can say that we are all anti-fascists, and on the other hand, this term-idea was at one time very widely used by German communists during the GDR.
Lev Roitman:
Since we are not talking about terminology, but we are talking about the activities of such, say, law -by -acting, neo -Nazi organizations and groups that are undoubtedly in Germany - this is a fact. How freely, do they feel free in the German legal field?
Gerhard Simon:
Indeed, we have enough of our right -wing radicals, and among these right -wing radicals there are real fascist groups. Although, I want to pay attention to the fact that these are real fascists, nevertheless, thank God, marginal. The extreme right exist as a party or as a plural party, they are especially active in the new lands, that is, in the territory of the former GDR. Against them should be fought by political means and legal funds. But, first of all, I think, there should be a political struggle against extremism on the right side and on the left side. At the same time, some statements that we hear from Russia today in Germany are at least publicly not possible, or if someone speaks in Germany with such statements as some now from the high rostrum of the Russian parliament, they cause a prosecutor from Germany for such statements. Because of this, our right-wing radicals try to at least go too far and say a terminology that is more or less acceptable, and at least a rhetoric that does not cause a prosecutor.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Professor Simon. Vladimir Dmitrievich Malinkovich, I will present you somewhat more: you are the director of the Ukrainian branch of the International Institute of Humanitarian and Political Studies. After all, Ukraine is also not free from political extremism, do you have any parallels with what we see in Russia?
Vladimir Malinkovich:
I must say that, in my opinion, Germany is not free from political extremism. And I remember very well when I lived in Germany, the tricks of opponents, xenophobes, aggressive nationalists, I remember how the town in the former GDR was almost captured by these nationalists, and the journalist spoke to them as among enemies. This is everywhere, but, of course, legal regulation in Germany at a much higher level than in our post -Soviet countries. And therefore, fighting fascism, Nazism there is much easier. As for Ukraine, here, of course, a pronounced manifestation of Nazism, fascism is, and there are these tricks from the “left”, but there are much more of them from the “right”. Because our nationalism, in general, is represented in the form of a fairly serious political force: they have newspapers, frankly anti-Semitic, for example, “for Vilna Ukraine”, where such articles were published, which, in my opinion, can only compete with Hitler Mine Campf or with Goebbels's department. Frankly fascist, Nazi, not only anti -Semitic, but also anti -Russian, anti -Polish and so on. There are also frank actions of xenophobia, for example, in Kharkov somewhere in the late August in early September, they burned the synagogue, set fire to the Russian cultural center in Lviv, mocked the Poles many times, and there were abundance over the Polish graves in Lviv and Western Ukraine. In general, we have these phenomena in superior, and moreover, now, as in Russia, in general, folk xenophobia is strengthened, it is very sad, but this is so. Why is this happening? In my opinion, because we always had strong traditions of this xenophobia, we never had civil society, including in Ukraine. You remember the pogroms of the times of Bogdan Khmelnitsky, and the pogroms at the king-priest, and Kyiv in Ukraine, and in Moldova Chisinau pogroms, and the White Guard, Makhnovsky, and the Grigoryevsky pogroms. And so, oddly enough, Makhno, and “Angels”, and “Green”, that is, are these pogromers, in the heroes of national heroes today. Unfortunately, no rebuke. More recently, we recorded a television program where the dispute was in place: I argued with the famous Rukh’s figure about the problems of Ukraine-Russia, but the crowd that supported the rush frankly shouted that it was all the machinations of the Muscovites, Jews, Jews, and violently greeted when they shouted not to give them words. Such an atmosphere was publicly when recording a program on the body. In general, we have this atmosphere, and, of course, we all should fight this. This atmosphere of intolerance has intensified recently in connection with many circumstances. First of all, with social madness, which today, in general, is, this is the expression of Evgen Golovakhi, in our society. Our level of demoralization of society, according to the McClosky method, determined by Evgen Golovacha, perhaps our best sociologist, 75% at the rate of 50. We have an incredible xenophobia, only 15% are ready to let a Jew, Pole or Germans into our family as a member of this family. Russians are only 38-40%. All this is scary, so it requires immediate measures, resistance is necessary.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Vladimir Malinkovich. Evgeny Viktorovich Veshchkin, so we heard about the situation in Ukraine. This situation is very reminiscent of what is officially happening now in the region, where the governor is Kondratenko, who is called "Old Man" there. Does your anti -fascist center cover only Moscow problems or does it act with an emphasis on the all -Russian situation?
Evgeny Evshoschkin:
It is impossible to engage in the fight against fascism and cover only the Moscow problem. Here is an example: Kondratenko, Krasnodar "Old Man", was just invited to the RNE Congress as an honorary guest. Of course, we are engaged in problems throughout Russia. And the fact that in the elections to the Legislative Assembly of the Krasnodar Territory such "red-brown", Xenophobic in many ways, this is the result, in our opinion, aggressive, not stopped by the propaganda of the "Old Man". I was a year ago, as a deputy of the Moscow City Duma, on a business trip in Krasnodar, met with many deputies of the Legislative Assembly, beautiful lovely people, but no, no in their conversations, as a granted one, already skipped: Zionists would shit us, twist their heads and so on. Anti -Semitism, or antisionicism, has become, practically, the Stavropol Territory, practically, is not behind the state ideology in the Krasnodar Territory. So this is a very, very disturbing phenomenon. But I would also like to notice: in general, it has a very indirect attitude towards Jews as a people. Well, how much are those Jews left there in the Krasnodar Territory? And this threat to any person. I don’t like Kondratenko, the mayor of the city of Krasnodar and his media, for example, all - he immediately declares them with Zionist or sold Zionism. That is, this anti -Semitic hysteria in general in Russia and in particular in the Krasnodar Territory threatens civil rights and freedoms of not only national minorities (although they, of course, threatens), but the rights and freedoms of any citizen of Russia.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Evgeny Viktorovich. You mentioned the mayor of Krasnodar Valery Samoilenko, and so, according to Russian newspaper messages, Valery Samoilenko recently sent Joseph Kobzon, a deputy of the State Duma, a communist, his friend, that leaflet that was distributed last week in Krasnodar. The leaflet is called to get rid of the "damned, damaged Jews-Gids." And now Valery Samoilenko writes to Kobzon: "Joseph, how good that you live in Moscow." Well, we are talking about Moscow, so in Moscow (and Professor Simon mentioned this casually about this) from the high Duma stands is heard what is very nice to hear, for sure, and the Krasnodar governor Nikolai Kondratenko. More recently, Viktor Ilyukhin, the chairman of the Duma Security Commission, accused President Yeltsin of carrying out the genocide of the Russian people, according to Ilyukhin, so successfully, because his encirclement was mainly predominated by Jews. Well, against this, I believe, Evgeny Viktorovich Your Anti -Fascist committee is powerless.
Gerhard Simon:
From Germany, such statements are seen very strange and incomprehensible. I want to pay attention to the fact that until very recently in Germany, many people simply did not want to believe that in Russia there is a danger of fascism. Russian fascism seems to be such a very incredible phenomenon that the public, the media still have not paid attention to this. But, it seems, this changes precisely in connection with these anti -Semitic statements even deputies of parliament. This, of course, is no longer a joke, and this was very much noteworthy in Germany, and the outrage in Germany was very clearly expressed. I also want to say that, on the one hand, this, of course, is very sad, disgusting anti -Semitic statements in Russia. On the other hand, it must be emphasized that other statements are very strong against this in Russia. That is, such anti -Semitic statements do not go unnoticed in Russia, on the contrary, television, media, many people from the intelligentsia, journalists are outraged and opposed. I do not want to say this in this way that these anti -Semitic statements do not need to be perceived too seriously, they must be very seriously perceived. But we must add that in Russia such things are not unnoticed, that today, thank God, you can still speak freely against such outrageous attacks.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Professor Simon. Vladimir Malinkovich, well, do you react to such excesses of verbal?
Vladimir Malinkovich:
Much weaker than in Moscow. Unfortunately, we do not have a public discussion of all these problems and in electronic media, we almost do not react to all these tricks state power. And all this causes fear that, indeed, we can have fascism. As, however, I am afraid, he is not excluded in Russia. The situation today is largely reminiscent of the one that was in Germany on the eve of the 33rd year. Here, it seems to me, the most important question is how to resist this. It seems to me (I always say this, for almost all reasons), the decisive form of resistance to all our outrages is the formation of civil society and the creation of such a structure of civil society, necessarily a multi -ethnic, polycultural, with orientation, mainly to human rights and the national -cultural autonomy of various national groups. This is what civil society needs to be created so that it can affect the nature of the election campaign and so on, and to engage in open diplomasics of all these manifestations of aggressive nationalism, national intolerance, racism and anti -Semitism. Now in Ukraine such a movement is being created, it is just the organizing committee, the institute has been created, our institute is directly involved in these problems. And we hope to create a wide movement that will directly resist all the manifestations of aggressive nationalism. Because otherwise it may be too late, it is necessary to stop this fascism at the beginning, at the first stages, not to allow in Ukraine, like now in Moscow, frankly from the rostrum of the State Duma, these pogrom statements are rushing. Here, it seems to me, you just need to use the authorities.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Vladimir Dmitrievich. Evgeny Viktorovich, “we need to use power” - in Moscow, it seems, the power was used: the second (the first one was allowed) the congress of the Russian National Unity movement. How do you feel about such a power?
Evgeny Evshoschkin:
A small amendment: Reutovo is not Moscow, it is another subject of the Federation - the Moscow region. But, nevertheless, in fact you are right. The fact that now the desire of the authorities to show itself strong and respectable, on the eve of various election campaigns, that it coincided with my anti -fascist aspirations: both the public and the “RNU” are covered, at least at this stage, it pleases me very much. On the other hand, I am afraid that this is not a single case, so that it is not just a campaign. Because, the same prefect of Ulyanov, the man of the Moscow government at least 3 years on his territory by Terletsky Forest Park, took care of this politicized gang. More recently, I was talking to him on the phone, I say: "Everything continues there," he says: "How so? I gave the command to seal." But, of course, nothing is sealed. I say: “And the flag hangs with the swastika,” to which he replied: “I don’t know. I don’t see. I don’t remember.” Although the flag is large. That is, this is good - better late than never. But I'm afraid that there will be no constant continuation of this anti -fascist struggle by the authorities.