The program is conducted by Elena Kolomiychenko. It is involved in it: from Germany - Dr. Christoph Royen - the Foundation of International Studies "Science and Politics", as well as Radio Liberty correspondents: in Paris - Semyon Mirsky, and in Vienna - Elena Kharitonova.
Elena Kolomiychenko:
In Santa, Maria Le Feira in Portugal ended the meeting of the leaders of the EU countries. The mood of the politicians who had gathered in this wonderful city was overshadowed by the tragic death of 58 people from Southern China, who sought shelters and a better life in Europe. At the EU meeting in Helsinki in December last year, it was decided that in the near future Türkiye would be a member of the EU. In Lisbon, decisions were made regarding the revival of the European economy, including deregulation of energy and telecommunications. Feira will be remembered by making a decision on banking secrets and paying tax on interest. The point is that if someone is trying to hide their money or get rid of high taxes, putting it in the banks of Luxembourg or Liechtenstein, where bank secrets were respected, now the rule will be gradually introduced that banks at the request of third countries will be required to provide information to third parties. It is clear that such a decision was connected with both France and Germany, where a scandal with illegal party donations of Christian democrats erupted six months ago.
Just when discussing this decision, a drama happened. The fact is that the Austrian delegation was traveling to Feira, hoping that sanctions would be lifted, which were subjected to Austria by Austria 5 months ago, when the government was formed with participation, extremely right, as it is customary to call the Freedom Party in the government. The sanctions did not lead to the party’s exit from the government. For 5 months, the new government could not be reproached for any anti -European actions and were right those who said from the very beginning that the sanctions were unproductive, and that their initiators - France, Belgium Germany and Italy were more likely from their own interests than from the pan -European process. To discuss the results of the meeting in Portugal, which is inferior to the presidential chair of the EU of France from July 1, I invited the Radio Liberty correspondent in Paris -Semen Mirsky, from Germany - Dr. Christophe Roin from the Foundation of International Studies Science and Politics, and Radio Liberty in Vienna Elena Kharitonova.
Before contacting Vienna, I will add that there were reforms of the EU institute on the agenda, and the problems of taking new members in the EU, and the situation in the Balkans, and relations with Russia. So Vienna did not achieve the desired results in Feira. Sanctions remain. The drama played at the end of the meeting when voting on the issue of banking secrets. At first, Austria wanted to block this decision - according to the EU rules, a unanimous vote needed, but then she voted “for”, having secured, however, with a promise that this would not spread to Austrian citizens within Austria. “Austria showed teeth,” said the former chairman of the Freedom Party Yorg Hader, but the sanctions remained. Vice-Chancellor Austria Suzanne RiS Passer calls to quickly hold a referendum on the attitude of the Austrians to the EU. By the way, these requirements support 79 percent of citizens of the country.
Elena Kharitonova:
Austria is disappointed. Chancellor Schussel said yesterday that the abolition of sanctions is currently not visible. Newspapers in Vienna are discussing why none of the participants in the meeting supported Shüssel when he spoke in his speech about the abolition of sanctions. However, she was not included in the official meeting program, she was said at dinner - there was no other moment for her at all. The Chairman of the European Council, Gutherresh, urgently advised the Austrian chancellor to not get out with her: "It is not the time yet. The EU country will offer the problem of the sanctions of the EU country after the meeting and, most likely, will be offered some option for their gradual cancellation." But Shyssel performed, and with pressure. He used to propose to establish something like an international council, which himself would make sure that the Austrian government coalition does not represent anything wrong with Europe. Now there was no question of any international observation council. Schussel agreed only to the dialogue, after which the sanctions should be terminated. But the dialogue did not work.
Among the reasons for this, Austrian newspapers call the persistence of the French President Shirak and the German Chancellor Schroeder, who were the main initiators of the sanctions. Journalists emphasize that most European countries consider these sanctions a mistake, but cannot achieve their revision. Nonsense, they say, is always easier to do than to correct. I must say that in general there are disputes about the meaning of these sanctions about whom they helped. The Courier newspaper writes that the Chancellor Schussel is only increasing - now he is a “fighter for the independence of the Motherland”, and when the sanctions will be canceled “a little and patient David, who defeated a large Goliath”. The ultra -right in this situation also most likely win. According to surveys, about 70 percent of the Austrians insulted the sanctions, and the ultra -right shouts on patriotic notes and show themselves with unbending people. They constantly repeat that the sanctions were unfounded and therefore there can be no talk of any conditions from Europe.
Elena Kolomiychenko:
And how do the Social Democrats of Austria behave?
Elena Kharitonova:
Social Democrats are now in a difficult position. The paradox is that it was precisely those whom the sanctions should have supported because they are opponents of the ultra -right, they put in a difficult position. The sanctions wanted to protect the opponents of the ultra -right, and now it turns out that everyone who is against the government, at the same time, seem to be against the patriots. Patriots say to them: “So you help those who announced us sanctions, you are pouring water on the mill” - and so on. The former Soviet man does not need to explain the whole set of such accusations. Therefore, social democrats, of course, also advocate the abolition of these ill-conceived sanctions. Although the situation is not as simple as the conservative newspaper "press" writes. The sanctions aroused wide debate in Austria on such delicate topics as nationalism and anti -Semitism, and were knocked out of the saddle of the spiritual leader of the Right Hyder, who resigned from the post of chairman of his party. Some journalists and politicians generally say that the sanctions withheld Austria from the adoption of anti -democratic laws, especially laws that infringe on the rights of foreigners and the like. After all, now the Austrian government is forced to constantly demonstrate that it is liberal and democratic.
Elena Kolomiychenko:
It is interesting that when discussing relations with Russia, and this relationship seems to be devoted to a special meeting of the foreign ministers of Russia and the EU, the “EU Foreign Minister and Defense” EU Javier Solan said: “We want to build serious bilateral relations with Russia, but at the same time it should not interfere with us about what we do not agree with.” By the way, what the EU disagrees with is heard much less than the desire to build strong bilateral relations. EU leaders in the signed document write that they will support Vladimir Putin's efforts to modernize and reform in the country. I think that some of our listeners would be surprised, because it is obvious that the first steps are rather not reform and modernization, but on the contrary, in Russia there are so far events that many even find it difficult to give assessments.
So, on the one hand, Austrian sanctions, and on the other, these words are addressed to Russia. France was one of the initiators of Austria’s boycott, however, she criticized Russian actions in Chechnya and the latest events around the media-Moscow holding. Semyon, it seems to you, is such a duality on the one hand of European decisions in relation to little Austria, and on the other, the intention to maintain some incomprehensible reforms in Russia, because so far Vladimir Putin has not clearly stated anything about this - what does this mean for the prestige of the EU himself, the confidence of citizens to this institution in all countries, from Lisbon to Vladivostok?
Semyon Mirsky:
For united Europe, this, of course, does not portend anything good. What we are talking about now in our conversation, perhaps, is shown by one immutable fact - the difficulty of coordinating European positions, because each of the EU member countries has its own tradition, its own national style and, ultimately, its own interests. I think that it would not be an exaggeration to say that the summit in Feira stood under the sign, on the one hand - a skew, and on the other hand, a sulfur. The skew is that the Austrian theme, which, as we know, participants in the summit, all, in addition to Austria, of course, wanted to endure the brackets on the forefront.
Well, a surprise is a tragedy with 58 corpses that were discovered in a refrigerated van who arrived from Rotterdam to England, where there were illegal immigrants. This drama with all the acuteness raised the question of the coordinated politics of the EU member countries and the countries that are part of the so-called Schengen space in the field of the struggle against illegal immigration. As for the comments in France about the results of the summit in Feyra, I would like to quote the Figaro newspaper. "Austria put up weapons on the issue of taxation of bank deposits of persons who are citizens of the EU, but having accounts in Austrian banks," so in its current issue the French newspaper "Figaro" summarizes the essence of the compromise reached at the summit in Fair. Thus, indeed, at the last minute a compromise was reached on the issue, the discussion around which was conducted for at least the last three years. At the same time, this is very significant.
Austria agreed to put its signature under this agreement, provided that the banking secret will be abolished only in relation to the bills that foreigners keep in the Austrian banks, as well as provided that this measure did not enter into force immediately. In fact, this means that complete transparency in the issue of bank accounts and taxation in EU member countries will not come earlier than 2010-2011. And here is a very interesting detail: the Prime Minister of Luxembourg said that his country would agree to the abolition of banking secrets only on the condition that Switzerland would go the way. I think that the essence of the statements of the Prime Minister of Luxembourg - the second, after Switzerland, the "European safe", in which there are hundreds, or maybe even thousands of billions of dollars, does not need comments. It inspired the Figaro newspaper for the next summit of the summit in Feira: "Creation of a single European tax system will come after a rain on Thursday"
Elena Kolomiychenko:
Dr. Royen, I would like to return to what I started. Question to Semyon Mirsky: the decision to maintain reforms in Russia - how is it seen in Germany after the visit of Vladimir Putin?
Christoph Royen:
In Germany, it is so far that this detail of negotiations and this meeting is not paid much attention. Firstly, our football team is at the zero level, and this is the main topic, and as for relations with Russia, just in Berlin in recent days we saw how the main EU states relate to Russia. Everyone says: "We want to cooperate with the new President Putin." Therefore, they leave all sorts of problems, all sorts of critical questions and want to concentrate, focus on the course of negotiations, conversations and so on. We will see the same thing at a meeting in Portugal.
Elena Kolomiychenko:
But how does this correlate with those sanctions that remain about Austria?
Christoph Royen:
Of course, this is a contradiction, but this shows that the main question: how to change the voting system, making it a system without a veto right with decisions made by a majority vote. The main issue at this meeting was also the reforms inside the EU, and this will be the main topic of the next meeting - in December, in Nice, under the chairmanship of France. Small countries in Europe now see that now he is arranged by a franco-German tandem with little Austria, and other small EU members are also more critical of the Franco-German plans regarding the EU effectiveness. So what we see regarding Austria can lead to serious consequences precisely for the plans of the French and Germans.
Elena Kolomiychenko:
And for sure this will affect the attitude to the EU and its institutions of those countries that have or not in the near future to become EU members. On the one hand, their acceptance without reforms is unthinkable, and on the other hand, European institutions of this kind also cause doubts here. But I would like to address this issue now. Feira said that the agricultural sector of the Candidate countries still continues to deserve a separate, especially close, attention and without reforms, it is very difficult to talk about the membership of these countries in the EU. The fact is that the sanitation of agriculture in Eastern Europe will still cost a lot of money. Until now, the universal gross social product per citizen in these countries is twice as lower than in the leading EU countries. And, of course, rich EU countries fear this, as they fear the influx of cheaper slavery in the labor market, where there are enough of their unemployed. Of course, cheaper rabil will be more attractive to these countries. Christoph Royen, you often visit Eastern Europe, in Slovakia in Poland, you know Poland very well Poland, what do you think, does the EU still remain the "star" that Poland wants?
Christoph Royen:
So far, and I think in the future, Poland also has no other choice, and it should become a member of the EU. But hopes associated with the fact that this will bring immediate benefits to Poland is now almost anywhere. Now in Poland and other countries, as in the same Baltic countries, they understand that EU members, basically, do not want these new members. Of course, they promised and, of course, they must continue these negotiations, but the difficulties will still grow, and therefore it is very doubtful that we will see the first new EU member in 2003. Maybe there will be Estonia or little Slovenia, but for large countries this date is becoming less and less realistic.
Elena Kolomiychenko:
On the other hand, Poland, like the Baltic countries, borders on Russia. On the one hand of the EU, on the other - Russia. How are the relations of the EU and current Russia to these small countries projected?
Christoph Royen:
This, of course, for Poland, for example, is difficult. And Baltic countries are difficult to see how these European countries are uncritical of Russia. They would be very grateful if they had heard from Brussels or other capitals of Western states a more critical tone against Russia. Of course, the Baltic countries, of course, the Poles want good relations with Russia. But this requires a common position of all Europeans, all Western and central Europeans. And so far, unfortunately, this is not, and this makes it difficult to improve relations between the Baltic countries and the countries of Central Europe with Russia.
Elena Kolomiychenko:
I want to complete our conversation in Paris, since France, as I said, has been presiding in the EU from July 1. Semyon Mirsky, how are French commentators the tasks that are facing France in the near half of the year?
Semyon Mirsky:
The first task was formulated by Jacques Shirak himself, who returned from Feira in a very good mood. The participants of the summit in Feir voted for his proposal to hold a special summit in the fall of this year, in October - November of this year - a summit in the capital of Croatia - Zagreb, dedicated to the situation in the Balkans. As Jacques Shirak said, Europe cannot afford another war on its territory, and the Balkans, as he emphasized, are in Europe. As for the global results of the summit, I would quote the correspondent of the second French television. He held a very original resume. He said: "A meeting in Feyra and her comparative failure will most likely have a very positive result." What does this paradox mean? Here's what: stubborn reality taught the leaders of Europe a lesson in modesty. They abandoned the idea of a quick and rapid increase in the number of EU member states. The European Union will have to abandon the rapid growth of its ranks. If Europe cannot put things in order in the house in which there are 15 rooms today, then how can it cope with the house in which the rooms will not be 15, but 25 or 30?! Therefore, the EU growth rate will be slow and this, in its own way, is good news.