
"The Eurosood came up with new restrictions for Russians." "Low -income inhabitants of Russia may not count on Strasbourg." "The Russians were limited in access to European justice." Such statements could be seen today in most Russian media, which reported changes in the regulations of the European Court of Human Rights. However, lawyers who have been working with citizens in Strasbourg for many years call the storm in a glass of water, noting that in fact, nothing has changed in the court procedure. It’s just now decided to abandon the concessions for applicants from Russia. For 14 years in the jurisdiction of Strasbourg it would be time to remember the requirements for complaints.
The lawyer Anna Stavitskaya says:
-Fear of eye is great. The European Court already recognized a lot of complaints unacceptable. Many do not understand, they believe that the European court is the fourth instance over the national court, and write complaints there the same way as they would write at the national level. But the ECHR is the court that considers violations of the European Convention and, accordingly, it is necessary to substantiate violations of the European Convention and follow the requirements of the regulations. But, if the complaint is really serious and affects some serious violations of the rights guaranteed by the Convention, then I do not think that on formal grounds a complaint will be refused.
Over the 14 years of stay under the jurisdiction of Strasbourg, the Russians sent more than forty thousand complaints to the European Court of Human Rights (a fourth of all applications received here), moreover, more than 35 thousand appeals of Russian citizens to the European court were recognized as clearly unacceptable (essentially, and not on formal grounds). And, if earlier, employees of the secretariat could close their eyes to some formal flaws in the execution of the complaint, now they have given a green light to wrap incorrectly prepared appeals. Some of the journalists who wrote about the changes in the approach of the European Court to the issuance of complaints drew attention to the fact that now the Russians would be forced to turn to lawyers for help, and their services are not a pocket.
The founder of the Center for Assistance of International Protection Karinna Moskalenko is convinced that this task can be dealt with independently, the court regulations contain detailed instructions. In addition, there are many human rights organizations providing free legal assistance to those who apply to Strasbourg.
- The elementary requirements that are presented to the applicant are all in great detail in the form of the complaint and in the explanatory note, which always existed, it was just a little modified, made more detailed - everything for the benefits of the same applicants and their representatives. It is necessary to beat the alarm precisely because we supply the European Court, fill up with a large number of unacceptable complaints or complaints that do not meet the elementary requirements for filling out forms. "
The distrust of the formal approach of the Secretariat of the European Court of Human Rights when working with complaints from Russia Karinna Moskalenko explains, including the history of internships from the Ministry of Justice of Russia in September last year. Human rights activists then even wrote to the president of the European court to Nicholas the brother. They said that the selection of interns was closed and opaque, doubted the high level of their professionalism and expressed fears that the interns sent by the Ministry of Justice would work biased, in the interests of the Russian authorities, in particular, deciding on the acceptability of complaints.
“One was layered on the other,” Moskalenko believes, “on the one hand, the parish of a group of lawyers, which caused, perhaps, dissatisfaction from the point of view of their complete independence from the Russian government.” On the other hand, the time has come when large demands are imposed on Russia, because Russians and especially Russian lawyers should already study this procedure well. On the third hand, too many unacceptable complaints.
In any case, in the changes in the approach to the implementation of the Rules of the European Court of Human Rights, Karinna Moskalenko does not see anything extraordinary and infringing on the right of Russian applicants. According to the founder of the Center for Assistance of International Protection, she has much more questions for her history with the replacement of a judge from Russia in Strasbourg. Anatoly Coster, who has worked for nine years here, will replace the new judge this year, and now the choice of candidates for this position, according to Karinna Moskalenko, was not transparent. She even appealed the procedure in one of the Moscow courts, but the final decision on this case has not yet been made.
- We do not question the high professionalism of those three candidates who are proposed by Russia to the European court, but they specialize in commercial law. And the main recommendation of PACE is that the scope of the future candidate for a judge of the European Court is related to human rights, if possible, to a greater extent. It is difficult to explain to who needs it and why this choice was made by the commission, and then the former president. You may never be in the jurisdiction of the Khamovnichesky court of the city of Moscow or the Dzerzhinsky court of Nizhny Novgorod, but you must, if, God forbid, your rights are violated and not restored in Russia, you will find yourself in the jurisdiction of the European Court of Human Rights. This personal composition is important to every Russian.
Russia leads by the number of appeals to the European Court of Human Rights. Most often, applicants complain about torture, an unfair trial and a violation of rights related to the detention. To date, Strasbourg judges made decisions on 1212 Russian complaints and only in 49 cases did not see violations of citizens' rights by the Russian authorities.