
Provocation is not a topic. The events have already occurred. Long, 20 years ago. Nothing is impossible to beat. No one was convicted, and the winners in general, as you know, are not
Two large groups of the Soviet nomenclature grabbed, which were deeply spitting on the interests of ordinary citizens of the countryJudge. It is much more interesting to write about something else. About the myths (on both sides) that surround the coup d'etat of 1993, and about what did not happen, that is, what could be if not Yeltsin and Gaidar, but Rutskoy and Hasbulatov won. The fact that Russia received as a result of the victory of Yeltsin and Gaidar, what it came to, and so everyone knows. There is a neoliberal myth, according to which, if the Supreme Council had defeated, he would have stopped “building capitalism”, would return the USSR and almost have made a new Stalinist dictatorship. On the other hand, all kinds of “red” (they cannot be called so without quotes) say almost the same thing: if the Supreme Council won in 1993 and sent the defendants of Yeltsin with Gaidar to the bench, we would have Soviet power, there would be no “wild capitalism”, the liquidation of the social state, etc. etc. This myth was also operated by Rutskoy and Khasbulatov, but what else could they do? It was necessary to somehow support the version that they were an alternative.
In fact, of course, in October 1993, not left and right seized. Two large groups of the Soviet nomenclature grabbed, which were deeply spitting on the interests of ordinary citizens of the country. They grabbed because of the authorities-because by that time they already knew (primarily from the experience of the "shock therapy" of Gaidar) that the authorities allows us to assign property. That is, the conflict was due to property, or rather, because of the possibility of privatizing it "correctly." That's right - means to yourself. For this, political power was needed.
Neither Rutskoy nor Khasbulatov nor a second were “red” and “red-brown”. Let's not forget that they were the faithful associates of Yeltsin and, together with him, eliminated the USSR. Their conflict with Yeltsin and Gaidar was a conflict, firstly, personal, and secondly, the conflict of two branches of power, each of which hoped to grumble more in the process of privatization. But the executive branch already began to do this, by a clear order, and was not going to share with anyone. It was then that the legislative power remembered the "interests of ordinary citizens." You need to be very naive to think that it was defeated by Rutskoy and Khasbulatov, they would not build capitalism and carry a privatization. Another thing is that they would do this differently and other pace. Including because they - especially in the presence of such serious opponents - would have to constantly look back at their "support base", take into account its requirements.
This is where the most interesting begins. What, different from the "Gaidarovshchi", could they offer Rutskoy and Khasbulatov? Only neo -Ceincian schemes. The Supreme Council did not have any economic geniuses that could come up with something else, completely original. Moreover, there are two examples of the Eastern European countries, where the “construction of capitalism” was carried out precisely according to neo -Noveinzian schemes (although the publicly leaders of these countries swore always fidelity to neoliberalism): Slovenia and the Czech Republic. Both countries entered capitalism "softly", not shocking, both for the long time preserved large industry from privatization and both last in all eastern Europe experienced serious economic problems.
This is about the economy. As for politics, of course, Rutskaya and Khasbulatov could not have imposed on the country the current authoritarian, in fact the dictatorial constitution - they were officially the defenders of the previous one! That is, we can say that under Rutskoy with Khasbulatov there was no.
There would be no economic collapse of the 1990s (there would be an economic decline, long and gentle, more sparing, which would later be replaced by an rise-due to the same energy prices). There would be no destruction of high -tech sectors of the economy (except for the narrow segment of the military -industrial complex), although in conditions of international competition, probably many enterprises would not have survived. It would not be
Of course, Rutskaya and Khasbulatov could not have imposed on the country the current authoritarian, essentially dictatorial constitution"Semibankershirsh". There would be no 1998 default. There would be no such radical dismantling of the social state (but events would still develop in this direction, no illusions). There would be no explosions of houses designed to legitimize the “successor” and the Second Chechen war (of course, Rutsky and Khasbulatov would have to solve the Chechen problem; they would probably solve it clumsily and, one must think, not without the use of strength, but definitely not massaged bombing - Khasbulatov had the possibilities of playing a teip policy). There would be no Kadyrov regime with all the ensuing. By the way, there would be no “national leader” Putin, who is generally brought to power by the “family” as a guarantor of the protection of Yeltsin and his family from criminal prosecution. There would be no "Reform of the Russian Academy of Sciences" (do not forget the academic status of Khasbulatov). There would be no “main opposition force - the Communist Party: Rutskoy and Khasbulatov would definitely remember her demonstrative cowardice and betrayal in October 1993.
And everything else would probably be, just a little “older”, “lower”, “more civilized”: peripheral capitalism, social stratification, criminalization, and “brain leak”, and degradation of education and healthcare systems. Therefore, our "left" (calling them so without quotes is funny) is completely in vain now mourn the Supreme Council. The left are opponents of capitalism, right? Well, if so, then they should have been 20 years ago instead of protecting some supporters of capitalism from others (possibly more radical), to fight with those and others! And if there was no strength and means for it - sit and be silent in a rag. But they so much wanted to join at least some power ... Now they were intensely imposing myths. This is such a psychological compensation, an payback for the stupidity of twenty years ago - and at the same time a certificate of reluctance to grow wiser.
Winners write history. The defeated-if they were not destroyed at all-try to create their own, “prohibited”, “alternative” story, which can become one of the ideologically propaganda instruments of future victory. But for this it is necessary that the “alternative” story be certainly closer to the truth, to real events than the official history. Myths of such a victory only interfere.
Since both sides of the 1993 conflict were very unsightly and, in a good way, did not deserve anything except Shakespeare's “plague for both of your homes”, no one was going to abandon the myths: it was a very inglorious story. Also bloody.
Alexander Tarasov - Director of the Center for New Sociology and the Study of Practical Policy "Phoenix"