The author of the program Alexander Genis
Probably, many listeners learned a musical epigraph for our today's conversation. "Carnival of animals" of Saint-Sansa. With this play, a musical education began in a Soviet school. It was believed that onomatopoeia makes music accessible to schoolchildren. Meanwhile, the "carnival of animals" is not as simple as it seems. In fact, Sensans wrote a rather poisonous cartoon on modern composers, witty parodies of the music of Rossini, Offenbach and his teacher Berlioz. Thus, Saint -Sans used animals according to their usual, in traditional art, appointment as allegorical deputies of people. This means that his animals are fable.
Today's art refers to animals, I would say, with great trust. According to my observations, in the last decade, the post -Soviet society has become characteristic of a kind of biophilism. This, in particular, is evidenced by a huge demand for thoroughbred dogs and cats. As for art, here you can recall the painting of Mitkov, the bright animal parable of the prose writer Anatoly Kim "The village of Centaurs", the story of Vladimir Makanin "Laz", but, above all, the books of the current youth of Viktor Polevin. He constantly turns to animals, trying to live the interspecific border. So, the heroes of the story “Six -fingered recluse” are two chicken, engaged in metaphysical experiments at the Lunacharsky Broilel Plant. In his story, “The Problem of the Werroville in the Middle Strip” - the transformation of a person into an animal, fills the soul of a werewolf with the highest meaning. But the most animal theme is developed in the absurd-realistic novel by Pelevin's absurdity "Life of insects." What, I note in brackets, and understandable. In relation to people, insects play a double role - they are least like a person, but most often they live with him. In addition, they are close to us by their numerous. One way or another, the phenomenon of the beast in a new culture gives it a fantastic and mystical character. The beast is convenient for the artist with its original inability. This gift foreignity allows you to conduct metaphysical search in the opposite ordinary direction. Not up, but down the evolutionary staircase. After all, this animal is also different, the owner of someone else's consciousness, dividing with us not only the living space, but also the secret of our stay in it. Today we will continue these biohythetic surveys with the help of the guest of our studio, New York artist Vitaly Komar, representing the creative duet of Komar and Melamida, known in America and Russia. In recent years, they have been working, however, not together, but the three of them. The third artist in their coordinated team was the 16-year-old Indian elephant named Rene. How did this happen?
Vitaly Komar: Firstly, this is not an elephant, but an elephant. Rene is only 16 years old and she is very pretty and talented. And one more amendment. We work not only with Rene, but also with other elephants. But, basically, these are elephants, these are women. In the history of arts, as we know, male names are more common. And among the elephants, it is the females that are much more talented and are more likely to work in co -authorship with us.
Alexander Genis: Vitaly, why did you need elephants?
Vitaliy Komar: You know, I think this story, this need for co -authorship began for a very long time. Maybe therefore, we have been working on co-authorship since 1965, when we did our first joint work as artists. Then, at times, we did not work together, separately, and then again connected. And now, apparently, the search for co -authorship and work in co -authorship is inseparable. Because, in general, people who work together for a long time, on the one hand, are used to it, this is like a company that unites them, and on the other hand, I want something new. And so, in search of a new one I want to find new co -authors. So I remind you that in the early 90s we tried to work with the masses. Thousands of people were interviewed, expressed their desires, their dreams, what they want to see in art and we, in collaboration with these masses, drew a number of paintings, the most desirable to peoples of different countries. And now we have found other co -authors, Reneh Reneu was let into our cramped team. And she really revived our life and our relationship creative.
Alexander Genis: How does this technically happen?
Vitaly Melamide: The fact is that there are mainly two types of elephants. Asian and African. Or there were still dwarf African ones, who were very close to the Asian, but they, in fact, have disappeared now. So, African elephants differ not only in that they have very large ears, and that they are larger, but also because their trunk end ends with three such fingers. These are very tender and, at the same time, strong fingers, because the trunk consists of more than 50,000 muscles. Much more than the hand of any artist. And these three fingers, the elephant can quite easily hold the brush. Accordingly, we prepare different mixtures of colors, the elephant chooses ready -made mixtures or, sometimes, it mixes them on canvas, which is very popular among the American school of painting. The Russian school basically rested on the fact that the artists first mixed on the paint palette, and then applied the already found color on the canvas. In America, a very strong school and many expressionist artists mix the color directly on the canvas. There is no exact border between the palette and the canvas. In this sense, elephants are followers of abstract expressionism.
Alexander Genis: Vitaly, what is more important to you, process or result? Drawing an elephant or work written by him?
Vitaly Komar: This is a very good question. The fact is that we fix the process of working with an elephant on a photographic film in the form of color photographs and videos. And when you watch the video of our joint work with animals and see separately the result of the written work, you understand that they make an impression best when they are together. This is a diptych. We see one part of the diptych, a photograph or screen of a TV or a video projector, and on the other hand we see painting, as such.
Alexander Genis: I also want to ask one question related to the use of animals in art. Last year, the Russian artist Kulik came to America, in the image of a dog, and delivered a lot of entertainment to critics and spectators. In what relation are these experiments for your work?
Vitaly Komar: The work of Kulik and artists close to him, too, are very close. I think that in Russian art there were several lines originating back in the 70s. Or maybe earlier, at the beginning of the century. If you remember, there was a futuristic, more shocking line, and another, more isoteric line, a more decadent, symbolist line. And I think that Kulik, like us, with Alik Melamid, belong to this line, which is closer to the futuristic one. At that time, as another, the Moscow school, which is closer to Kabakov, it develops this decadent line.
Alexander Genis: I must say that the use of animals in the artistic process, as you rightly noticed, is not such news. I want to remind a few facts. On December 1, 1962, Nikita Sergeyevich Khrushchev, pointing to one of the paintings exhibited in the Moscow arena, said, literally, the following: "Outdoor's tail smears better." In the same year, an article by a certain Reshetnikov “The Secrets of Abstractism” was published in the “Ogonka”. Among other things, it stated that "it recently found that 759 abstract watercolors exhibited in Los Angeles wrote a one-eyed Miss Powers parrot." Do you think you should trust this information?
Vitaly Komar: Of course, it should. Only one amendment. For some reason, it is believed that such artists or critics and art historians corrupted by decadent art are corrupting innocent animals. I think it happened the other way around. The fact is that there are messages very ancient, about 2000 years ago, messages of Greek and Roman historians that elephants draw mysterious letters on the sand or on soft soil using pebbles or sticks. This is really a proven fact, because in the 19th century there is a mention of such a strange hobby found among elephants. A lot of explanations for this. Perhaps elephants, since they have a long organ, trunk, are lines in the same way as other animals belong to the print of their legs or limbs on the ground. That is, we are dealing with a developed attitude to prints. Maybe this is the original embryo of fine art. Moreover, there are possible assumptions that Kandinsky saw the drawings of the elephant in the Berlin Zoo before he became a universally recognized inventor of abstract art. So, I think that Russia, in a sense, is the homeland of elephants. Regardless of whether Kandinsky invented this, or the elephants invented. Anyway, the honor of this discovery belongs to Russia because in Russia a very long time ago mammoths were found, who were ancestors of elephants and, I think, will soon prove that mammoths also painted for a very long time.
Alexander Genis: It seems to me that we have to remember another participant in our program - Saint -Sanse and his "Carnival of Animals". Among them was, of course, an elephant, whose heavy tread is perfectly illustrated by music. Vitaly, your thesis - Russia's homeland of elephants - needs another confirmation. I found him. This is a fable written right on your occasion. Sergey Mikhalkov, "Elephant-Copies". Let's listen to her.
Speaker:
The elephant-writer wrote a landscape,
But before sending him to the vernissage,
He invited friends to look at the canvas,
What if it suddenly failed?
The attention of the guests is flattered by our artist,
What criticism will he hear now?
Will the animal court be cruel?
Will they overthrow or ascend?
Connoisseurs came, the picture opened the picture,
Who got up further, who came closer,
“But then,” the crocodile began, “
The landscape is good, but I don’t see the Nile. "
"That there is no NILA, that is not a big trouble, -
Said the seal, - but where is the snow, where is the ice "?
“Let me,” the mole was surprised, “
There is something more important than ice.
The artist forgot the garden. "
“Evil -chrya,” the pig remarked, “
The picture was a success,
But from the point of view of us, pigs
There must be acorns on it. "
All wishes accepted the elephant
He took up the colors again,
And all friends as far as possible
I got an elephant brush
By depicting snow and ice,
And the Nile, and the oak and the garden, and even honey,
In case the bear is suddenly
The picture will come to see.
The picture at the elephant is ready
Friends called the artist again
The guests looked at the landscape
And whispered: "Yeralash."
My friend, don't be such an elephant
Follow the advice, but wisely,
You can't please all friends
You will only harm yourself.
Alexander Genis: I see in this fable a description of your two types, with a melamide of actions. Firstly, the exploitation of animals, in this case, the elephant, and secondly, the creation of paintings on public surveys.
Vitaly Komar: Absolutely. The fact is that I and Alik, and we are children of the last years of the war, studied at school. We were forced to recite it by heart. And, apparently, somewhere these school knowledge deeply departed with us. And the last two projects of the 90s - polls of public opinion and work in co -authorship with animals - echoing somewhere with the Mikhalkov fable. I agree absolutely.
Alexander Genis: Vitaly, the famous Biennale in Venice soon opens. As far as I know, you were invited there, right? In the quality of whom are you invited, which country will you represent?
Vitaly Komar: We are invited by the Ministry of Culture of Russia and, in this sense, we represent Russia. And we imagine at the same time, I would say, the kingdom of animals. Because on the ground floor of the pavilion there are two rooms. In one, we intend to show elephants, and in the other there will be a monkey-photographer. By the way, the monkey who was born and lives in Moscow and is very famous for the Moscow children. She performs in the Moscow circus. So this is Russia and, at the same time, the kingdom of animals.
Alexander Genis: What will you represent in Venice?
Vitaly Komar: We intend to bring a living elephant from Thailand. The fact is that we started working with an American elephant, or rather with an African-American elephant, but continued this work with Thai elephants. If the elephants living in American zoos are quite provided, do not starve and have a great time, then in Thailand this is not so. There, elephants have been belonging to people for about 300 years, they are a kind of domestic animals and they are busy with a timber. The fact is that the valuable breeds of a tick tree grow on such strange hills where not a single tractor will pass, and only the elephant can pass calmly, dragging these valuable trunks along. But now the forest trees are prohibited. This is a tree under the protection of international laws. And the elephants in three villages lost their jobs. It sounds strange, but, indeed, both elephants and their owners starve. Because it is difficult for them to do rice cleaning, which was traditionally occupied by their neighbors. It is very difficult to change the profession. And we made a proposal to organize art schools for elephants in these villages. Three Academy of Arts in Thailand. Now we have opened them, elephants draw and sell work to tourists. The first collection of donations in favor of elephants and the first auction of their work took place in Bangkok about 4 months ago and brought 50,000 dollars. The fact is that the princess came to the opening of the exhibition, she is considered the patroness of local artists, including elephants, in our case. These 50,000 are enough for these three villages of the year for two calm normal life and also to buy colors, papers to continue this work.
Alexander Genis: What will happen in Venice?
Vitaliy Komar: We are going to bring Thai elephants, one or two to Venice, for rooms on the ground floor. In the second part there will be Miki - Moscow chimpanzees. But, as it turns out, I am not sure yet and I do not know. In Italy, there are very complex bureaucratic obstacles against animal visits from other countries. They are not so easy to deliver.
Alexander Genis: What are your plans with Alik? Are you going to continue to go down the evolutionary ladder? Dostoevsky mentioned the production in which the singing minerals participated. This idea does not seduce you?
Vitaly Komar: Of course, this is a very interesting idea. I think to get to minerals, you need to go a long way. So far, we plan architectural structures in co -authorship with beavers, of course. Then we plan a joint architecture with termites, they are also wonderful builders. And the project, which, perhaps, will show on the Lyon Biennale, it will be in 2001 - these are vegetables that will photograph, and the tree that will draw. The fact is that we came up with such a special device, an automatic descent on the camera for the camera, which will be pressed by the vegetable during its growth. And, at some point, unpredictable, there will be a click of a camera that is above the ground and we will get a photograph of a garden or field taken by vegetables.
Alexander Genis: What are the vegetables?
Vitaly Komar: Potatoes and carrots. They are the most elastic and resemble a fist or finger.
Alexander Genis: It resembles Chipollino. And the second project?
Vitaly Komar: This is drawing with trees and winds. This is a more romantic project. We intend to attach brushes to the branches of a tree and wait for a strong wind. Before the tree, in front of the branch, the easel with canvas will stand and thus branches will draw abstract, self -exposing smears.
Alexander Genis: As always, your projects are extremely radical and go beyond not only art but, I would say, humanity. In this regard, I want to ask you a question inevitable in this time, at the end of the 20th century. What do you think about the art of the next century? What do you think the exhibition in 50 or 100 years will look like?
Vitaly Komar: I think it will look like a journey into the world of ancient myths. Artists in the 20th century worked in different techniques, in different directions. But technically, the imagination of artists was limited. All these monsters that were depicted in surrealistic paintings are not three -dimensional, they do not exist in reality. But the development of experiments with a genetic code will enable artists of the future to work with real creatures of fantasy. Monsters or, conversely, perfectly beautiful objects, like Greek myths. It will not be a problem to create an excellent Elena or a centaur. Moreover, it must be taken into account that art relieves moral tension. Blood on stage, as you know, is cranberry juice, this is not a real murder. Therefore, I think that the artists use these discoveries will be interested and the so -called power structures. Because no one will then raise a voice against these experiments, because it will be an attempt to freedom of creativity in this case. And I see, in the future, artists working with large scientific laboratories, creating such strange creatures of their bizarre fantasy. For example, in the case of centaurs, both animals and people are connected.
Alexander Genis: What lively reminds your experiments with elephants.