In ancient times, the main technique of military strategy was a decisive battle. As a rule, one of the parties, which managed to intercept the initiative, chose a place that seemed to her the most profitable and forced the enemy to give a battle. And although the battlefield itself was a pure convention and could be a forgotten wasteland, the side of the battlefield, according to the rules, was considered a loser. Often everything ended, especially when the participants in the conflict were small cities -states that did not have resources for long -term hostilities - the defeated accepted the winner’s conditions, and the story continued. But the conditions could be so gestured that there was no way to accept them, and then a new army was equipped in the hope that this time was lucky.
As a result, schoolchildren of the upcoming generations were forced to clutter up the fragile memory with the names of dozens and hundreds of such battles and the results of peace treaties that had bombarded them. In the Greco -Persian war, the first to be documented in sufficient detail, there were four such battles - Marathon, Fermopilsk, Salaminskoye and Platskoye, and the third, among other things, became the first major marine battle.
Despite all the tactical and technological progress, this principle of warfare has survived to the present day and has been questioned for the first time over the past decade. Many, analyzing the lessons of the operation "Storm in the desert", called it the last war in the classic style, bearing in mind that modern weapons are becoming more and more electronic, it requires a specialist at a computer keyboard than a warrior in the field, and therefore armed clashes of human masses gradually retreat into the past. The first major war of the current century, with the use of the most modern technology, leads to thoughts about the prematureness of such conclusions.
It is pointless to turn to the TV who would like to get acquainted with the immediate time, in real time, in real time, despite the fact that most Western television companies have acquired on -duty retired generals for this purpose. Television takes the main emphasis on the pictures, and such a telephoneral, even if he has something to say, the released thirty seconds is unlikely to be enough for one meaningful proposal.
However, there is a completely new journalism genre that arose three years ago on the Internet and spread there at the speed of a forest fire. This is the so -called "blog" - a reduction from Weblog, that is, a "network diary". This, of course, is not about the sad attempts of adolescents of all ages to draw attention to their uniform existence, but about real journalists, or who came to a new genre from traditional newspapers and magazines, or acquired a reputation in the Blogosphere, as they began to call this new area today.
The whole “blogosphere”, being part of the Internet, is permeated with cross -references, and therefore, having entered one of its representatives, you immediately get access to dozens. For our current purposes, I chose the “blog” of American journalist Miki Kouse, one of the most popular, known as Kausfiles. His story is largely typical of representatives of this new genre. Over the years, he was an employee of the magazines of the levocentric direction, but his own views during this time moved to the right, and when, one fine day, he was out of work, the idea of the “blog” was rushed in the air, and the Caus became one of the pioneers. Today, when this genre has already been recognized, it was sheltered by the Slate network magazine, published by Microsoft, it became not only prestigious, but also almost mandatory for many, even quite traditional media.
As a rule, Miki Caus is engaged in internal issues, but today the war has become the center of general attention. The Blog genre is not the most favorable for reporting, although some of the reports from the Middle East, but the Caus and colleagues with whom he conducts polemics are mainly busy with analysis and commentary. The main topic was asked by the famous journalist Simur Hersh: according to his article, published in the New Yorker magazine, US Secretary of Defense Donald Ramsfeld rejected military plans of the military command at least six times, including the commander of the operation “Freedom Iraq” Tommy Franks and the head of the United Committee of the Richard Staff chiefs Mayers, who provided for warfare for the forces of large ground contingents. As a result, the hersh reports from the words of the officers, the allied troops, of which in Iraq were half less provided for, received stretched communications, an unprepared rear and the lack of personnel necessary to maintain order in settlement centers.
Miki Kaus and his colleagues discuss the possible motives of this behavior of the Minister of Defense on the Internet. Of course, there can be no question of the minister wanted to reduce the chances of winning the victory of the Americans in Iraq. In this case, according to Kaus, the logic suggests an almost automatic conclusion.
"If the change of regime in Iraq was the only goal, there would be no reason not to launch the extensive contingent of the troops, ensuring a sufficient security supply. But changing the regime in Iraq is not the only goal. Most likely, neoconservatives in the Bush administration are considering the Iraqi campaign as a debut move in a series of potential power games, including at least a convincing threat Syria, North Korea, Iran and, perhaps, even Saudi Arabia.
If we are able to take Iraq only with the help of large, heavy forces, or if the Powell doctrine is still valid about the need for strongly superior forces, even if we do not need them, we cannot say with sufficient credibility that we are able to attack or even defeat all these countries at the same time or even in a quick sequence: but if we can crush the diligently defendable government of Iraq with the help of light and fast: The contingent, resorting only to a small part of our forces, in this case, the capture of many targets to the fly suddenly becomes a real opportunity and a real threat to Tehran, Damascus and Pyongyang. "
To understand what is at stake, we must recall the so -called "Powell doctrine", formulated by the current state secretary of the United States at the time of the first war with Iraq, when he headed the United Committee of the Chiefs of Staff. In accordance with this doctrine, the United States should be involved in the armed conflict only in an extreme measure, when all other means are exhausted, and only with the use of overwhelming military force, so that the victory is guaranteed.
The current Minister of Defense, whose plans include the indigenous reform of the US Armed Forces, is a supporter of a new type of technological war, which breaks with the tradition of large terrestrial battles. His plans, in particular, include a strong reduction in the army budget and parallel strengthening of the air forces and navy - I recall that the latter also includes the air fleet of aircraft carriers and the corps of marine infantrymen. According to Ramsfeld, the armed forces rebuilt in this way will be able to conduct quick, sudden and high -tech military operations with minor losses both in their own strengths and among the enemy’s civilian population - which is especially important in strategic conflicts when it comes to overthrowing the hostile regime.
It is understandable that these plans do not cause enthusiasm both in an army that does not want to lose their influence, as well as among senior officers, who are responsible for the course of hostilities and for whom it is always better to play it aside than to inadvertently. If the victory in the current war is won only by half the provided contingent, and the forces of the fourth army division will only come to the end of the operation, the risk that Ramsfeld went to can justify itself, and the assumptions expressed by the Caus will seem much less fantastic. As for the Powell doctrine, she will be forever buried.
Analysis of real -time war is extremely ungrateful, since tomorrow's events threaten to smash all today's assumptions. But since there is no other choice now, you have to adopt and try to look into the future that the spectacular television pictures mask.
The photo and title on the cover of the New Republic magazine, apparently, are directly polemicize with the ideas of Donald Ramsfeld: corpses in dust, soldiers in complete equipment, moving through sand storm, and the inscription that says: "War is still hell." In its editorial article, the magazine disputes the decision of most American television companies not to show its spectators photographs of prisoners and victims from among the Americans who are overwhelmed by the reports of the Al-Jazis Arab Canal. The magazine protests against such a disinfected indication of the conflict and notes that the voluntary ban does not apply to Iraqi victims and, therefore, allows addiction in journalism. According to the editorial office, US citizens have the right to know what the real war is, and not to be mistaken, that its justice somehow makes it easy and safe.
On the other hand, the Weekly Standard magazine, one of the most consistent supporters of the Bush administration, prefers to emphasize positive aspects. He gives a speech with which, according to an ancient military tradition, the battalion commander of the British Royal Irish Regiment, Lieutenant Colonel Tim Collins, spoke to his soldiers. Here is an excerpt from this and indeed an unusual speech.
"We are going to free, not to conquer. We will not raise our flags in their country. We go to Iraq to give its people freedom, and the only flag that will develop over this ancient land is its own. Show respect for these people.
Some of those who are now alive will soon leave the number of living. Those who do not want to go on this path, we will not send him. As for the rest, I hope you will ask them the heat. Wash them from the face of the earth, if this is their will.
But if you are furious in the battle, do not forget to be generous in victory. To deprive a person of life is a difficult step. It should not be done without thinking. I know people who killed in other conflicts without need. They live with a kaina seal. "
To understand the unusual appeal to the soldiers before the battle, try to imagine him in the lips of the Russian commander before arriving in Chechnya or the Pakistani detachment before surgery in the Indian Kashmir. The war is really changing, and this has already proved the gentle tactics of the British units when taking Basra. It must be assumed that many of these changes Donald Ramsfeld will consider itself the right to write down on its own positive balance, because it is technological progress that allows you to minimize unwanted losses. Those who follow the war on the staff of the Iraqi or Qatari television, as well as the copies of these personnel on Russian channels, are unlikely to be convinced, but so far the number of victims has been relatively small: the first hundreds in the ranks of the allies, including cases of their own, and as for civilians, these losses are always higher than they would like, but they, in leading to a single scale, are still a hundreds of times, still hundreds of times less, still a hundreds of times less, still a hundreds of times. than on Chechen and any other war. Unfortunately, the balance can still change, and only for the worse.
The Doctrine of Ramsfeld, if I can afford such an expression, I do not extend to strictly military framework, because all political decisions are outside his competence. But if we talk about the hypothetical threat to Syria, Iran and North Korea, which Miki Caus mentions, then it is not the fruit of his imagination. It was about such a massive pressure on the states, designated by George Bush as an “axis of evil”, repeatedly wrote in magazines that are close in views to the administration, including in Weekly Standard. However, there are even more frank statements. Former CIA Director James Woolsey, speaking to the students of the University of California in Los Angeles, called this plan of the Fourth World War - the Cold War was the third nomenclature. By the way, Woolsi is among the administration candidates for one of the leading posts of the temporary occupation regime in the post -war Iraq.
I must say that the rulers of these countries relate to such assumptions with complete seriousness - in particular, Syrian President Bashar Assad spoke about this in an interview with a Syrian journalist, and the North Korean authorities transferred the arms race to the maximum speed and require bilateral negotiations with the United States.
Of course, all of the above is only a guess of guesses built on the minimum number of facts, and since one of the features of the blog genre is that the author does not have an editor, and the materials are published daily and even several times, guesses can be made as far away. In addition, the very doctrine of Ramsfeld is still too early to consider justified. And, nevertheless, peering into these virtual letters, it is difficult to dodge the thought that today's publicists are a landing of tomorrow's historians, and that some of them will seize the world overturning our imagination.
Marx wrote about history at one time, claiming that it is repeated as a farce. Marx, one of the largest intellects of his century, did not understand, nevertheless, simply by the totality of the then knowledge that history is never repeated. Here I recall the parable of Jorge Luis Borges about a man who re -wrote “Don Quixote” - and although Roman Word in Word coincided with the text of Cervantes, it was already a completely different book.
One of the most insightful critics of Marx, the philosopher Karl Popper, believed that history has no laws at all, that, according to a kind of leisure wise man, it is simply one event after another. And if so, any revolution can only be a disaster, and the only way we can influence history is a sequence of small changes in order to look back and make sure that everyone is able to look around and see the correctness of the amendments.
Neither Marx nor Popper were familiar with the modern theory of Chaos. I am not able to state even its foundations now, but one of its principles is extremely clear: if somewhere in America a butterfly waved its wings, after a while it can cause a hurricane in Japan. In case of more strictly, we are never able to unravel the chain of causes and consequences in the open system, and often this chain acquires a cumulative character, like an avalanche caused by a sliding of a tiny pebble.
Apparently, history still has laws, and these are the laws of complex chaos. What is happening in the world today is not just one event after another, but an avalanche or, as specialists in systemic analysis, change of paradigm, change the rules of the game during the game under pressure from external circumstances are expressed.
Looking at the hurricane, which is silent for a while, bringing us illusions about the "new world order" and "end of the story", then flies with renewed vigor, you involuntarily think about which butterfly waved its wings at its origins. And since the rear mind is always stronger, it is easy to guess that it all started in one of the main pain points of the century, in the Bosnian Sarajev, where the seven bullets of the Gavrila student, released along the Austro-Hungarian heir, smashed the crystal palace, erected by the ideological descendants of the European era of education. Today, states, the heirs of this ideology, react differently to its collapse, and not always adequately.
France, one of the central strongholds of the Enlightenment, lost most of its property at the very beginning of the process, having lost the status of a great power and legislator of Western culture. For a long time, she simply did not notice this, but recently she has not noticed from the principle, out of stubbornness. Her historical mission is completed.
Russia in the era of communism, which now seems only one of the stages of the transition to a new paradigm, was a great power that at first caused admiration in many corners of the world, and later, mostly fear. Her reaction to the collapse of political utopia suggests that today she was simply lost. She is not able, like France, to live an illusion, because the contrast between yesterday and today is too harsh, but she stubbornly seeks the keys to the present in her historical past, while they are in the future. Из дипломатических зигзагов президента Путина легко понять, что он движется и ведет за собой страну на ощупь: вначале с неожиданным энтузиазмом поддержал Францию, затем выступил с резкими обличениями США, и завершил признанием, что поражение последних - не в интересах России. Пришлось давать ввергнутому в замешательство народу спешные разъяснения.
Что же касается самих Соединенных Штатов, то они были просто созданы на принципах Просвещения и долгое время были их главным оплотом в мире - можно вспомнить Гаагские мирные конференции, недолговечную Лигу Наций и, в конце концов, нынешнюю Организацию Объединенных Наций, которая была создана по плану и по инициативе США. Но сегодня, на взгляд Вашингтона, эта последнее наследие Просвещения тоже себя изжило. Если прибегнуть к схематическому языку Маркса, США рассматривают нынешнюю ситуацию в мире как революционную: сторона, чувствующая себе обделенной, выступает против своих обидчиков - и даже не важно, реальных или воображемых, потому что любая революция, согласно Попперу, чревата катастрофой, крушением миропорядка без какого бы то ни было плана замены. Альтернативой остается теория постепенных мер - подавление режимов, пытающихся использовать волну возмущения в своих интересах. Это и есть реальная война с терроризмом, а не кругосветная погоня за неуловимым и уже никому не нужным Бин Ладеном. США видят в Ираке и других государствах "оси зла" прямую угрозу своим государственным интересам, и они не согласны уступить право решения третьей стороне.
Было бы общим местом сообщить в конце, что такую позицию США разделяют далеко не все, как далеко не все разделяли позицию Львова или Керенского в месяцы, предшествующие октябрьскому перевороту. Но можно, оставаясь идеологическим минималистом, с уверенностью перефразировать российского президента: поражение США в этой борьбе - далеко не в интересах мирового сообщества.