Lev Roitman:
In the Czech Republic, in Hungary, and since November last year and in Poland, lustration laws have been in force. Does such a law of Russia need such? Prominent economist, magnificent writer Nikolai Shmelev in his memoirs "Curriculum Vitae" writes: "When today I hear the cries that do not subside in any way about the need for the so -called lustration, that is, the public announcement of the law of the entire former party manager and all the informers, I think: guys, you are crazy - to demand lustration in the country where every tenth was a member of the party and everyone The tenth, and even the fifth was forced to cooperate with the organs. Nikolai Shmelev participates in the program, you will hear his arguments from him. But, I can say in advance, another participant in the program is the world famous Russian writer Georgy Vladimov with Nikolai Shmelev does not agree.
Nikolai Petrovich, speaking really and seriously, if you want, the law on lustrations, that is, on the "translucent" of former large party functionaries, secret and hidden KGB agents in order to prevent informers to state posts, such a law in Russia is simply adopted to be. But why is he, from your point of view, is not needed at all, dangerous?
Nikolai Shmelev:
He, perhaps, from the perspective of, so to speak, of all -class justice, he would be corrected by such a law, and there is nothing to be responsible for the committed both the parties and the safety system for the so -called. But in addition to all -tech justice, there is still just a real life. It cannot be anarchical, it can only be successful when someone controls it at different levels. And how, by the way, one of your good journalist Anatoly Shot once said: "Guys, you didn’t have enough strength for the second elite, and you still have a taldychi about some third." Indeed, a decrease in the quality of the human in the managerial layer, if now drive away the entire previous authorities, from some chairman of the collective farm to the upper officials, the next echelon, life showed over the reform years, because it was before the wretched audience, before that the gray in the second echelon came, there are no serious people, they must be grown in an incubator or in natural conditions of more Could take responsibility for life. My arguments are cynical, pragmatic, I completely agree with the idea of responsibility. Yes, then there is still one such argument: listen, and who will carry out lustration? Where are there so many honest people to whom can I trust the assessment of human fate? As a rule, our experience shows that the next wave of villains will come on foreign bones, it doesn’t matter whether the bones are white or black, but they will also build their career. After all, excuse me, the late Andrei Dmitrievich Sakharov in the lustrators of the main I would not have seen or the same Solzhenitsyn or the same academician of Likhachev - this audience would not be sore, but there will be another bastard to do such things. Here is my kind of set of arguments.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Nikolai Petrovich. I mentioned the Polish law on lustrations, which entered into force on November 28 last year, this law could not be put into effect for a long time, because it provided for the initial version of the judicial presence, in which the judge was supposed to be 21, so the 21st judge, in order to verify the correctness of the statements of the current functionaries that they were not informed, were not agents of the security service, the 21st judge of They could not find all Poland - the judges did not want to. In the end, the usual court of appeal will be engaged in such checks, and in total, about 20 thousand such inspections for Poland are expected. This is what you are talking about candidates for chandeliers.
Georgy Vladimov:
Listening to Nikolai Petrovich, I remembered that one of the stories speaks of his close acquaintance with Nikita Sergeyevich Khrushchev. So he was an example of a man who was also involved in the affairs of unsightly and even bloody, but nevertheless, he was a reformer, nevertheless, he was his father “thaw”, freed millions of convicts from the camps, and in general he made some kind of revolution in our country. Here, I think, this is our misfortune, and not the benefit that our good undertakings are performed by not quite clean hands and precisely those people who were involved in the affairs of unsightly and even bloody. As for the fact that we will not have enough judges for this, and there is probably not enough money to draw a little Malski productive lustration, I think that in general our conversation has a purely platonic meaning - there will be no organized vehicles, and this law will probably not be adopted. However, the position should be declared. And it seems to me that it should be said that without this purification, further life in Russia will not be just impossible, but what we have now will be. People of honest people, noble people, smart people are enough for this event, I’m not as pessimist as Nikolai Petrovich, I think that Russia did not impoverish them with these people, but at least here it was no lower than Germany, who managed to hold its 86 thousand vessels over former Nazis and, in general, cleared.
Nikolai Shmelev:
Georgy Nikolaevich probably does not really represent what he brought the argument, it seems to me against his position. I knew Nikita Sergeyevich Khrushchev well in his youth well, but he also knew that only at first he had the mood of everyone who was very guilty of blood and horrors, at least the most guilty, so to speak, to unscrew the head, but many understanding people hung in his arms, something like this: what are you going to do? Duster trouble has begun, you just release millions of people from the camps, are you going to meet new transport with the same number of people, only through a different fault, for another article will go with you? So the camps, so to speak, are provided for us, so to speak, and Russia is provided, only first, and therefore others will be changed. And Khrushchev limited himself only by the fact that several investigators shot the most frills, and drove away several people, and so ... what to do is the material with whom we live, and we have to deal with this. As for the fact that the moral assessment of all this is needed, I absolutely join the opinion of Georgy Nikolayevich that we need national repentance, but this repentance cannot be any one-time liturgy, there can be no one-time operation. In this sense, although it sounds blasphemous, it was good to the Germans - they got into such a disaster, there was so obviously universal wine and such horror that repentance was natural and very fast. And with us, well, yes, from a sweet quiet stagnation, where nothing happened especially, they crawled to the fact that the devastation began. But there were no convulsions, Catharsis, to shake to the stoves and to the heels, not the generations that are destroyed, but those that live now. Therefore, I can’t even imagine such universal repentance as a liturgy. This is an individual case, everyone will repent, suffer. And then, who will repent at all, sorry that those who committed the atrocities? May they spit on all these moral snot. Or will I repent? Why will I repent? I did not offend anyone, I did not crush the fly in my life. So so we will be further in some slow process of torment. And the last, about the fact that there are enough people: yes Georgy Nikolaevich, not enough. This, unfortunately, is unfortunate, it is amazing that you do not feel it. After all, for the past 7 years they proved very much, they came, maybe at first honest guys, but I emphasize - at the first, but the clums came, they did not know anything, everything is falling from their hands. And then it turned out that a significant part of them was just the most vulgar thieves and julier. So throwing himself, even if he was 10 times in the party being and the secretary of the district committee, but at least he knows how to do something at all. Although, of course, he needs an eye and an eye, and more than the eye and critical, the eye and print, so that he, when he puts it in the wrong place, pull his pants - sediment, they say, a little.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Nikolai Petrovich.
Georgy Vladimov:
It seems to me that Nikolai Petrovich makes one cardinal mistake - lustration, this is not a punitive event, and we are not talking about punishment. Here, a fierce dispute is carried out only that these people should not occupy leading posts. No one will plant anyone, and there will be no trains to Siberia about this. Just people do not have to lead anymore, you know. But they are so accustomed to this that if he does not manage for him, it is no longer life for him, the sun does not shine, the grass does not grow, the birds do not sing - life has ended. Somehow, in the summer I flew to Moscow and in an airplane conversated with one person, as I understand it, he is a former Gibist, who came under abbreviation. So he complains where he is now going. In such cases, my advice is always the same - but what, you can’t learn on a milling machine? After all, good money will be. But he was used to the fact that he hunted people, now he is deprived of this opportunity, he cannot imagine another, for him a life tragedy. Somehow I read the book of Pavel Sudoplatov, our legend, a world intelligence man, is okay to himself that he writes, everything that he did was a continuous feat. So he writes about his smart, kind, high intellectual woman. What did she do? She led a network of informants among the creative intelligentsia, mainly among writers. We remember that the list of writers who have gone to the Gulag and did not return from there is 600 names. How many hundreds of names on the conscience of highly intellectual Madame Sudoplatova? I can’t imagine a German book, where the author said that his father or uncle was a good gazumder in Auschwitz, his equipment was always in order and there were no complaints. So the two systems, very similar and surviving, it seems to me, the tragedies of equal dignity, suddenly parted abruptly - Hitler fascism and our so -called dictatorship of the proletariat went completely different ways. And here is what we have now. We have the same relapses of fascism in Germany, but some, I would say, an operable property, and it seems to me, associated with some hormonal disorders in these skinheads. And we have a developing movement that advertises itself, promotes and, I think, is preparing to rule the country. So this is why such lustration is needed. I think that not only governing bodies, not only governing posts should be cut off from people with a bad past, but, say, such a person cannot be a judge, a prosecutor, an investigator. There are many professions quite acceptable to continue your life and not consider it a tragedy.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Georgy Nikolaevich. In the order of fact: those laws on lustrations in Poland, in the Czech Republic, in Hungary, which I mentioned, they really do not provide for any consequences in the form of repression, they provide for prevention to government posts, and for a limited period. The Czech law was adopted in the year 91 for 5 years, but in the 96th year it was extended for another 5 years and will be valid until the end of 2000, but it should be said that not everyone agrees with these laws. In the Czech Republic, after the fact that the law was extended in the 96th year, President of the Republic Vaclav Gavel, who suffered enough from this audience, which falls under lustrations, the law refused to sign as a violation of human rights, nevertheless, the President’s Veto parliament overcame the proper qualified majority. So the problem is controversial.
Nikolai Shmelev:
Two short remarks: one thing, I am just Georgy Nikolaevich I would like to remind the great Stalinist words once said to Fadeev: "Well, I have no other writers for you, no." So think that there are crowds of ready -made and which can replace old shots - what are these new judges? Where it is the judicial corps, from whom it is formed, the prosecutor’s corps, the investigative corps. All these are people from the past, and until they die out, the new Sailor Schwandu should be called with a revolutionary necessity and expediency gradually or again. This is very easy in theory, but in real life even the process itself to come up with lustration, Lord, so many convulsions are shaking for all reasons, still letting the electricity into society, will begin again as under the volt arc to shake everyone. Well, what will we get from this? All completely completely confused - where, what, who is right, who is to blame? Let the life be sorted out slowly, let these people die out naturally, they will leave. And again, build something on hatred, on arson of human malice, I think this is only to free the way for another company of scammers who use it. After all, the writer Vladimov will have nothing from this, but that bastard who behind him will live up to wait for the change of judges of prosecutors or someone - we have already passed repeatedly, I can guarantee that it will be. Not because I feel sorry for these people, this is terrible, this is the tragedy of Russia. And, perhaps, in personal terms, I could not give hands, but God be delivered to Russia from new convulsions, at least even such, supposedly noble.
Georgy Vladimov:
In his stories, Nikolai Petrovich says that every tenth, they say, collaborated with the authorities, and who did not cooperate. It gives his own example, which has nothing to do with cooperation with the authorities, because everyone who went on a business trip later wrote reports, but these are not cooperation. Here this refers to a very simple business, which is popularly called "Consumption", so the one who contributed to landing or even the death of a completely innocent person collaborated. The writer Vladimov was still injured from one of them. So the fate of my book depended on the person who worked in the press committee and which it was known that he planted a whole family of neighbors to take possession of the apartment, so he now decided that he would not publish. Of course, he would never have published books, which speaks of innocently planted or innocently shot, they are to blame for him because he wanted to eat. As I said, our conversation still has a platonic character, maybe all its benefits from the fact that we expressed our position. In general, we come to the conclusion, it seems to me, to the common for us, that it would be nice to spend such a lustration, but there are no people, there is no money, there are no premises for ships, and probably, and let life itself, as they say, be dealt with these people. Well, life straightens out with all of us the same, as you know, we will rely on new generations that will still read our books, learn something for themselves, and this will be valuable historical experience for them.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you. Nikolai Petrovich, the time of our program expires, there is no time for the answer. I asked Ivan Tolstoy to read an excerpt from your memoirs "Curriculum Vitae", in this passage your position.
“It was in the late 70s, by that time our closest friendship with L.Kh. had no less than 25 years. And one day, after some international scientific conference, the acting director of the institute, where I then worked, was the academician Yuri Shiryaev:“ Petrovich, it’s bad. According to my information, a denunciation received a denunciation to you. The filthy, I must say, a denunciation. It is as if you were on the final banquet with a bed or as said to this English professor Norman Scott: "Wait, Norman, here Brezhnev will die, we will arrange such a discharge!" Ah you damn, what kind of bastard has you tapped? Wait, wait, who was sitting next to me on that banquet? L.Kh.? Well, of course L.Kh.! But, Yura, it cannot be, it cannot be! Why the hell did he need it? 25 years of joint behind him, and our best years, and his, and mine! Almost all my conscious life, I had a dream at least with one eye to look into my dossier, and when in Gorbachev times it arose, albeit not for long, such an opportunity, I myself refused. Frightened? Yes, scared. I was frightened that it could be there, or rather the one who could be there. I have little and so from the life of the slap in the face, no, God with him, with this dossier, it fell through, it is better to live in ignorance, all the smaller ones will be alarming for life and people. And the dossier, meanwhile, is probably growing, growing. "