- Conflict of Gazprom and RAO UES of Russia.
- To Ukraine was allowed to import used cars.
- The court found Microsoft guilty.
- A review of the publications of the next issue of the British weekly "Economist".
Sergey Seninsky:
The leadership of the joint -stock company "The Unified Energy System of Russia" accused Gazprom last week of deliberately reducing gas supplies at a power plant. Anatoly Chubais announced the upcoming disconnection of consumers-wings. In turn, Gazprom accused the electric power that she almost did not pay for gas. Our conversation with experts today is about the economic background of the conflict, which is unlikely to resolve urgently signed power orders.
Let's start it with the structure of Russian energy. What is the share of thermal, atomic and hydroelectric power plants? And what is the specific gravity of the gas? Mikhail Seleznev, employee of the analytical department of the Investment Bank "United Financial Group":
Mikhail Seleznev:
63% of electricity is now produced by thermal power plants, 18% hydroelectric power plants and 19% atomic power plants.
If we talk about how gas is important for the heat sector ... It will be easier to resort to the concept of "conditional fuel". If you take all the fuel consumed by thermal power plants, as conditional, then 63% of this conditional fuel is gas.
Sergey Seninsky:
Why did the current conflict between Gazprom and RAO UES of Russia burst out right now, in early April?
Mikhail Seleznev:
The fact is that the beginning of April is the beginning of the second quarter. And the agreement between RAO "UES of Russia" and Gazprom on the supply of gas was concluded only for the first quarter.
Moreover, Gazprom presented rather strict requirements for gas payment. RAO "UES of Russia", of course, was supposed to pay 100% of the current gas consumption as a whole. Of these, the regional companies should have paid 50%, and individual power plants owned by RAO UES of Russia were supposed to pay 20%.
This agreement was violated. That is, the payments of the RAO "UES of Russia" were significantly lower than determined by the agreement. And therefore, Gazprom since the beginning of the second quarter, to which the full gas supplies have been expected only in case of full payment in the first, reduced supplies.
The total debt of RAO "UES of Russia" Gazprom for 1999 increased from 51 billion rubles to 55 billion rubles. Of course, this is a rather significant amount - about $ 2 billion.
Sergey Seninsky:
Andrey Gaidamaka, Senior Analyst for the Oil and Gas Sector of the Eastern European Countries of the Investment Bank Morgan Stanley Dean Witter:
Andrey Gaidamaka:
Why today? For two reasons. Firstly, in the first quarter of RAO "UES of Russia", the conditions for payment have significantly worsened, that is, it practically stopped paying for the delivered gas. But then Gazprom could not turn off, because it was a heating season, and simply everyone understands that people cannot be frozen.
Secondly, there was a fairly specific political reason. It was a pre -election time, and it was all the more impossible to “freeze” people.
Sergey Seninsky:
Electricity tariffs and gas prices - within Russia and during export? And is it possible to say that in Russia itself some are relatively underestimated or overstated?
Andrey Gaidamaka:
It is impossible to say that in Russia, tariffs for electricity or gas tariffs are high. Because both gas tariffs and electricity tariffs in Russia are extremely low. E
Compared with international tariffs, then the internal tariffs for gas in Russia by the consumer are about 10 times lower than the tariffs for the already delivered gas to the consumer, for example, in Germany. Electricity tariffs, according to my data, are lower than six times below. That is, even in comparison with low electricity tariffs, gas tariffs are almost doubled.
Mikhail Seleznev, United Financial Group Bank:
Both gas tariffs and electricity tariffs in Russia are very low. The price at which Gazprom sells gas in the domestic market is about 10 times lower than the one by which he sells gas in Europe. Prices for electricity within Russia are 5-6 times lower than in Eastern Europe.
True, there are very minor export contracts, according to which RAO "UES of Russia" sells electricity, for example, to Finland. And in fact, this is not the export of electricity, but the export of cheap Russian gas, as if "convertible" into electricity.
But at the same time, we see a very simple situation: one company owed a lot of money to another company, although both of these companies are natural monopolies. And Gazprom is trying to use this situation in its interests.
Sergey Seninsky:
If Russia exports little electricity, then for Gazprom - what is the share of domestic deliveries and the share of arrival from them? Andrey Gaidamaka, Morgan Stanley Dean Witter:
Andrey Gaidamaka:
Gazprom supplies about 300 billion cubic meters of gas to the domestic market and about 200 billion cubic meters of gas for export. A small balance is the loss and domestic consumption of the company.
That is, more than 60% of the physical volumes of the extracted gas are delivered to the domestic market of Russia. These 300 billion cubic meters are comparable with the total consumption of the European Union. At the same time, the share of Gazprom revenue from supplies to the domestic market is about 20%...
What is even more interesting, if we talk about the share of the funds received to the Gazprom accounts, then “internal” sales give no more than 10%. That is, 90% of all cash funds come from abroad, and only 10% from domestic consumers. Despite the fact that 60% of the physical volumes of gas production goes to the domestic market.
If we talk about profit, then Gazprom has no profit on “internal” supplies at all - they are unprofitable and covered only due to export revenue.
Sergey Seninsky:
Let us recall what is the share of state participation in Gazprom and its regional companies?
Andrey Gaidamaka:
The state of the state in Gazprom is still about 40%. The state is the largest shareholder of the company, but it does not have the vast majority.
At the same time, regional companies are 100 percent "daughters" of the holding, that is, Gazprom. And thus, the state has about 40% of the shares of the entire structure.
Sergey Seninsky:
In the authorized capital of RAO "UES of Russia", the state belongs to approximately 52%. And in its regional structures?
Mikhail Seleznev:
Its employees themselves even admit that RAO "UES of Russia" is actually not a commercially oriented company, but one of the ministries of the Russian Federation. There are 74 regional energy companies, and RAO UES of Russia, in most cases, owns 50% of the shares in them.
In addition, the main organizations regulating the tariff policy in all Russian regions are the so -called regional energy comeds that are accountable to governors. Which, too, of course, emphasizes the great influence of the state.
Sergey Seninsky:
Gas prices, as well as are also established by the Federal Energy Commission.
Andrey Gaidamaka:
When determining tariffs, the Federal Energy Commission proceeds from the net production cost of gas. And in fact, the current cost of gas is very low. In order to obtain gas, with our giant unique deposits, the costs are about $ 2-2.5 per thousand cubic meters of gas. And this is really one of the lowest costs in the world.
But the fact is that the content of a huge pipeline system imposes a lot on this - according to my estimates, about $ 6 for the same thousand cubic meters.
In addition, when determining these tariffs, the cost of substitution of gas is not “laid”. That is, the cost of reconnaissance and the development of new deposits to maintain current production. These components are not laid at all in the current tariff. According to our approximate estimates, which were compiled on the basis of financial statements prepared by Pricewaterhousecoopers, the full cost of one thousand cubic meters of gas during the supply of the domestic market, taking into account this investment component, should be at least $ 20 for 1000 cubic meters of gas.
Another detail: with the tariff of $ 10 for 1000 cubic meters of gas, which now operates on the domestic market, about 35-40% are taxes. There is no investment component there at all. And if it were turned on, we would talk about intra -Russian tariffs more than $ 20 per thousand cubic meters of gas.
Sergey Seninsky:
The Minister of Russia in Antimonopoly Policy Ilya Yuzhanov said last week that after 4-5 years Russia, if not taken measures, from the country of energy-watering can turn into a energy-dependent country. What did you mean? Mikhail Seleznev, Investment Bank "United Financial Group":
Mikhail Seleznev:
Of course, in many ways, these are attempts caused by desire by the management of the RAO UES of Russia, and Anatoly Chubais personally, to somehow change the tariff policy pursued at the state level. And, perhaps, there is some element of exaggeration of assessments of the release of generating capacities, not collapse, but serious problems that expect the sector by about 2005.
On the other hand, here we return to the question of tariffs. The tariffs that are allowed by regional energy companies and RAO UES of Russia as a whole, of course, are insufficient to maintain generating capacities at the proper level. Perhaps not by 2005, but by 2007, due to the growth of the excreting capacities due to their insufficient repair, we will really say that Russia can turn from an excessive production of electricity into a country with a shortage of electricity.
Sergey Seninsky:
It turns out that the dynamics of the offer and demand for electricity in Russia are increasingly acquiring the opposite orientation?
Mikhail Seleznev:
In principle, this is so. In 1999, an increase in electricity consumption was recorded in Russia by about 3%. Of course, we should take into account the fact that all previous years, electricity consumption was constantly falling. And this increase was the first in ten years. We see that this increase in consumption begins with a very “low start”. But this trend is undoubtedly there.
And what is especially important - in the first months of 2000, this trend is still noticeable. That is, energy consumption for the same 3-4 %, depending on the region, of course, more than in the corresponding months in 1999.
Sergey Seninsky:
As for gas, its explored reserves should be enough for Russia for a long time. But is there enough real volumes? Andrey Gaidamaka, Investment Bank Morgan Stanley Dean Witter.
Andrey Gaidamaka:
I would propose to refer to the estimates of the International company Degolyer & McNaughton, which conducted a geological audit of Gazprom reserves. Yes, indeed, explored reserves that can be launched in industrial development, in our country is enough for more than 60 years. And if we talk about common reserves, then we can talk about the whole century.
But at the same time, the gas deficit, which begins to be felt now, is real. And then the situation with gas in Russia will only worsen. If there are no cardinal measures now to normalize payment and increase tariffs.
The fact is that for the past 10 years, Russia has lived at the expense of only two deposits - Urengoy and Yamburg, which still give about 70% of all gas consumed in the country. New deposits were introduced extremely rarely and in those volumes that cannot replace these two giant and truly unique deposits.
So, these two deposits are now included in the stage of accelerating the fall of prey. And, according to Degolyer & McNaughton estimates, this phase of an accelerating loss of production will be achieved here in about 2003-2004. Therefore, if you do not start introducing new large deposits now and invest real money in their development, then in a rather close future we will encounter a real gas shortage in the domestic market.
Sergey Seninsky:
Thanks to both experts. Let me remind you that our questions were answered: the senior analyst in the oil and gas sector of the Eastern European European Bank "Morgan Stanley Dean Witter" Andrei Gaidamak and an employee of the analytical department of the United financial group "Mikhail Seleznev.
In Ukraine, two years ago, under pressure from the South Korean Corporation of Daewoo Motor, which intended to invest a billion dollars in a joint venture with a car factory in Zaporozhye, the import of used cars over 5 years was prohibited. Now in South Korea Daewoo Motor is preparing for sale. And in Ukraine, a new decree entered into force last Tuesday: you cannot import cars over 8 years old. Our correspondent in Kyiv Sergey Kiselev says:
Sergey Kiselev:
The Decree of the Government of Ukraine partially canceles those benefits, the introduction of which in the spring of 1998 was achieved by the Daewoo Autosaz- "Autosasis-" Daewoo ": the import of foreign vehicles over 5 years old was prohibited, and the minimum customs value for imported cars was installed at the amount of $ 5 thousand. Including for Russian low-profiles. Now this norm has been canceled.
As the Government of Ukraine now recognizes, then, two years ago, the decision brought the budget only losses. At a press conference on the current automobile innovations, the chairman of the Customs Service of Ukraine Yuri Solovkov said:
Yuri Solovkov:
Most importantly, we did it to the detriment. The data that revenues to the state budget has been reduced are true. Completely correspond.
If we compare the volumes to the innovation and after, then we really lost a lot of money. Let's say in 1996: customs payments for the cars imported from abroad amounted to 334 million hryvnias. Now let's look at the results of 1999 - 149 million.
Sergey Kiselev:
Yuri Solovkov, Chairman of the Customs Service of Ukraine.
Another comparison: out of $ 250 million, which the Ukrainian treasury annually received in the form of customs fees, $ 210 million was received precisely from fees for the import of used cars into the country.
However, citizens of Ukraine quickly learned to bypass customs barriers installed in 1998: the import of foreign cars was issued as temporary.
Yuri Solovkov:
As soon as these restrictions were introduced - you can import cars no older than 5 years, this niche on the market was filled with cars designed in temporary import mode. And it was very difficult to deal with it. Because there is a Constitution of Ukraine, there is a Civil Code according to which a person can use his personal property as he himself considers necessary. And no one can deprive him of this opportunity.
Sergey Kiselev:
Chairman of the Customs Service of Ukraine Yuri Solovkov. In his speech, such a forecast sounded. Over the past two years, 80 thousand cars have been imported to Ukraine - according to the temporary import scheme. If even every second of them the owners now legally re -form at customs (which will cost each of them about $ 550), then this alone can bring the state treasury about $ 22 million.
2 years ago, the European Union called the “discriminatory” measures adopted by Kiev for the investment of Daewoo Corporation and threatened with retaliatory sanctions. And now, in the resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the abolition of these measures, it is directly indicated to the European Union.
As for the joint venture "Avtozaz -Daewoo", this is the most expensive investment project that has ever been started in Ukraine - it was estimated at 1 billion $ 280 million - after the bankruptcy of Daewoo Corporation in South Korea was threatened by a breakdown. And, as one of the Kyiv newspapers wrote, invented by journalists a couple of years ago, the slogan "Everything for Daewoo, all for her victory!" It can be replaced by the well -known name of the famous march: "Farewell to South Koreki."
Sergey Seninsky:
Sergey Kiselev, our correspondent in Kyiv.
A review of some publications of the next issue of the British weekly "Economist". He went out on Friday, April 7th. Maria Salycheva will introduce you to the review:
Maria Salycheva:
The court decision on Microsoft Corporation - "Guilty!" - Few for who became unexpected, writes "Economist". Too often in the past, the company Bila Gates managed to create only the appearance of the fact that it supposedly should be warned by antimonopoly departments. And therefore, now the plaintiffs can insist on a more severe punishment. However, the task of the judge does not become easier from this. On the one hand, the future verdict should solve the main problem: to destroy the monopoly of the Windows operating system, which suppresses competitors' products. But on the other hand, the punishment should not harm the innovative possibilities of Microsoft itself. And no matter how paradoxical such a proposal would look, the division of the corporation, at least three companies - two would be engaged in Windows, and the third - application programs - would become the best way out of the situation not only for the Ministry of Justice, but also for Microsoft itself, the economist concludes.
More recently, even the most pessimistic analysts believed that the merger of the German Deutsche Bank and Dresdner Bank would still take place. And yet, the deal failed. First of all, due to the reluctance to unite employees of investment divisions of both banks, although their top management did not mind. The failed merger is a powerful step back for the entire financial industry of Germany, writes "Economist". It should have become a sign that German banks are changing for the better. Now both banks will again gain their unprofitable branches of branches. Expensive costs for their maintenance have long deprived these banks of the opportunity to compete normally in financial markets, the "economist" concludes.
For 15 years, it doubled annually. Теперь здесь работают 29 тысяч человек, прибыль в прошлом году составила 3 миллиарда долларов, а по рыночной стоимости акций она почти стала крупнейшей в мире. Такова корпорация Cisco Systems, пишет "Экономист". Нынешний исполнительный директор, Джон Чэмберс, стремится сделать ее первой в мире компанией, которая будет стоить триллион долларов. 84% всех продаж компании приходится на электронную коммерцию. При этом сама Cisco Systems владеет лишь тремя небольшими заводами, где производится наиболее сложное оборудование. Остальное производство разбросано по десяткам заводов в разных странах мира, которые работают по ее заказам. В связи с делом Microsoft, есть риск, что компания может стать очередным объектом внимания антимонопольных органов. Впрочем, вряд ли: рынки сетевого оборудования, на выпуске которого специализируется Cisco Systems, основаны на открытых стандартах, и их весьма трудно монополизировать, заключает "Экономист".
Sergey Seninsky:
Мария Салычева познакомила вас с обзором некоторых публикаций очередного номера британского еженедельника "Экономист", который вышел в пятницу, 7 апреля.
"Корпорация Microsoft виновна в нарушении антимонопольного законодательства". Это заявление окружного судьи в Вашингтоне Томаса Джексона в прошлый уик-энд привело в итоге к крутому падению курсов акций технологических компаний на фондовых биржах, прежде всего в США. Но мы говорим сегодня о судьбе самой Microsoft. Корпорация признана виновной в нарушении законодательства: что предстоит теперь? Наш корреспондент в Нью-Йорке Владимир Морозов обратился к американским юристам:
Vladimir Morozov:
Судья Томас Джексон вынес постановление, в котором поддержал три из четырех пунктов обвинения, выдвинутых против Microsoft корпорации правительством США и прокурорами 19 штатов еще весной 1998 года. В решении судьи, в частности, говорится, что корпорация использовала незаконные методы для того, чтобы сохранить свое монопольное положение на рынке операционных систем для персональных компьютеров, а также монополизировала рынок интернет-браузеров. В ноябре прошлого года тот же судья вынес предварительное постановление. Чем от него отличается нынешнее? Говорит профессор юридического факультета Колумбийского университета в Нью-Йорке Эбен Моглен:
Эбен Моглен:
В ноябре суд заявил об обнаруженных фактах - это первый этап дела. Нынешнее заявление - второй этап: оценка фактов с точки зрения закона. Теперь предстоит третий этап: наметить пути исправления положения, определить, что надо сделать, чтобы устранить нарушения закона, допущенные корпорацией Microsoft.
Vladimir Morozov:
По мнению моего собеседника, несмотря на то, что корпорация признана виновной, стороны все еще могут договориться без суда. Хотя судья и вынес свое решение ровно через 48 часов после того, как полным провалом завершились продолжавшиеся 4 месяца переговоры о возможности именно такого внесудебного решения. За это же время на Microsoft уже подали в суд около ста групп обиженных клиентов.
Эбен Моглен:
Факты, собранные по ходу следствия, признаны нарушением закона. Теперь сотни, если не тысячи, частных компаний, которые посчитают, что они пострадали из-за противозаконной тактики Microsoft, не должны будут доказывать в суде факт нарушения закона. А значит, эти процессы обойдутся истцам гораздо дешевле. Может возникнуть лавина частных исков. Их не остановит даже апелляция, потому что пока апелляция обсуждается, решение судьи Джексона остается в силе.
Vladimir Morozov:
Среди таких истцов могут оказаться и крупные корпорации - America OnLine, Sun Microsystems, Apple Computer и IBM. Во всяком случае, в решении судьи они названы в числе пострадавших от незаконной практики компании Microsoft.
Но вернемся к третьему этапу дела. Microsoft уже объявила, что подаст апелляцию. Делом будет заниматься Апелляционный суд, а затем, вероятно, Верховный суд Соединенных Штатов. По мнению юристов, на все это может уйти два с половиной - три года.
Каким может стать окончательное решение судебных инстанций? Если вспомнить наиболее крупные в США антитрестовские процессы ХХ века - например, компании Standard Oil Джона Рокфеллера или телефонной компании AT&T, которые завершились принудительным разделением этих корпораций, - то можно предположить, что и процесс против Microsoft может завершиться подобным образом? Профессор Моглен, Колумбийский университет:
Эбен Моглен:
Нет, я не думаю, что это неизбежно. Дело в том, что разделение компании - не есть наказание. Это лишь один из многих способов восстановить конкуренцию на рынке. И главный вопрос, стоящий перед судьей Джексоном, - не как просто наказать Microsoft, а какое решение может наилучшим образом восстановить справедливую конкуренцию: юридический контроль за коммерческой тактикой Microsoft или же организационная перестройка компании, в том или ином виде?
Если же и будет, в итоге, принято решение разделить Microsoft на отдельные компании (в чем я лично сомневаюсь), то на выполнение такого решения уйдут годы. Например, дело, завершившееся разделением компании AT&T, длилось 18 лет. This is a very long process.
Но перемены к лучшему могут происходить уже сейчас. Само судебное разбирательство и необходимость защищаться против бесчисленных частных исков, на мой взгляд, изменят тактику корпорации Microsoft, каким бы ни оказалось решение суда.
Vladimir Morozov:
Другой юрист, сотрудница частного исследовательского института Кэйто в Вашингтоне - Солвейг Синглтон также сомневается, что суд может принять решение о разделение Microsoft:
Сольвейг Синглтон:
В прошлом было немало антитрестовских процессов, в результате которых компании были разделены - скажем, Standard Oil или AT&T. Но эти компании уже состояли из обособленных подразделений, почти независимых друг от друга. А Microsoft всегда была единой компанией, с единым руководством. Поэтому вопрос о разделении такого монолита очень сложен. Судам еще не приходились решать таких трудных проблем.
Vladimir Morozov:
Тем не менее, многие американские юристы не исключают, что суд может вынести решение о необходимости разделения корпорации.
Судья Томас Джексон уже назначил слушания о мерах наказания в отношении Microsoft на 24 мая этого года. Министерство юстиции передаст судье свои предложения в конце апреля. А до 10 мая Microsoft должна подготовить свой ответ.