
Here you can read the first and second parts of the conversation.
- It seems to me that the deliberate fusion of state and public interests and organizations that exist in Russian sports is, in principle, incorrect. In many developed countries, for example, in the USA, it is done as follows: a large sport is part of a huge commercial show. And the state would not occur to the state that the NHL, NBA, NFL or, for example, the Association of Professional tennis players, will come to mind. What to become with? The show in itself - the richest, maybe someone you want to nourish with your money. And it is only about the fact that this is a big business. A private commercial structure does not need state feeding. And if she needs, then she will never tell the state about it. If the Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi suddenly said: let's save my "Milan" from financial problems. He is the owner of the Milan club - but this will not occur to him, he instantly and shame his premiere instantly and shame.
- In Russia, huge funds are pumped into the sport of higher achievements. Why this happens is understandable. We have already said that sport, from the point of view of the state, is a huge PR project. And that is why the state finances it. But it seems to me that it should be different. The state should finance what is called physical education, mass sports, create conditions for millions of people so that they grow to some level. Someone will grow up to the champion, someone-no. And then, if someone grows up, it is already good, there it will be picked up by commercial sport. And the sports growth and development of a person will follow in completely different principles.
- But when in Russia the money that could be invested in physical education and mass sport, go to the medal support of PR, the sport of higher achievements, the prizes and prize money of Olympic champions and prize -winners - it turns out that physical education is not developed, that there is no basis, despite the fact that there is too much money in large sport. And now nothing can be done with this distortion now.
In the United States, even student leagues are now gathering a frantic number of spectators, sponsors are happy to participate, and everyone has a good income. And there, no one feeds student sport there from the state budget
“I can’t imagine how to fight it.” Not a single action or a public, a sports figure is visible in Russia, in order to somehow change it. And this is the legacy, by the way, of the Soviet Union. In my opinion, a bad legacy. Although in the Union it was still more and more proportional-mass physical education, children, youth and student sports. They were more developed. And in the United States, even student leagues are now gathering a frantic number of spectators, sponsors are happy to participate, and everyone has a good income. And there, no one feeds student sports from the state budget.
- Do you think this is the main sports problem of Russia?
- Let's do in parts. Of course, it is difficult to do something with the mentality. The mentality will crush. Say, a purely “mentality” idea that the victory at the Olympic Games brings political glory indicates the prestige of the country. Tell me, please, England did not perform well at these Winter Olympic Games, and did not sought to speak well there. What, the prestige of England fell from this?
- Absolutely did not fall. And Italy, too, although winter sport in Italy is much more developed. Italy has not a single gold medal in Vanuvere. England has one - and that random.
- So, we will drop the first option, the first parcel that you can do without this state PR. And you can boast of something else. The second point that is connected with attempts to appeal to the fact that in the Soviet Union there was a state and public organizations, trade union. Let's forbid these conversations, at least with each other. Because everything that was in the Soviet Union appreciated. But those structures and the organization that was in the USSR are no longer possible in Russia. Indeed, in order to reproduce the organization of sports of the Soviet Union, one must have not only a sports committee, but also the ruling party, which permeated the entire system from the primary party organization to the very top. In addition, to put and maintain order, there was a KGB line, which very carefully monitored the moral appearance, etc.
-But we are not campaigning for a return to the Soviet system! And then, now in China in its own way there is also such a system.
- In China in 2008 it was like. But to imagine that "United Russia" will create a system in which it will be responsible for sports from the primary production organization to the top ... Well, of course, such a project is curious. Maybe now many Russian politicians will play this map of defeat in Vancouver with great pleasure. They will take the obligations to get up at the head, etc. Well, there is a policy of politics. This is also a game and also sports.
As for the division of sports into large and mass-yes, of course, you need to build an organization differently. It is necessary to deal with structures again. You see, after all, if we are talking about the fact that we left Soviet sports, we must remember that American sport has left Protestant sports. The Union of Christian Sports Youth was the most powerful organization. You see - different models of sports organization are simply different sources. Therefore, you can look at how and what is being done in America or Europe, but it is necessary to design something in Russia based on the understanding of what kind of material there is, what kind of possibilities, what ideas. And blind copying is simply impossible.
-In this case, it is also impossible also because most Russian organizations conducting one or another tournament, such as, for example, the Continental Hockey League or the Russian Football Premier League, will simply burn without state participation. It’s just that this show is not enough power and quality to exist as an absolutely independent business structure. So they are forced to eat at the expense of state money.
If a person comes to the sport with a good grip, a large -scale sense of business, with understanding the essence of the matter, with understanding management technology, then he will be good in sports
- Let's be realistic. We will distinguish the situation that is now and which needs to be reproduced. Let us believe that in Russia a brilliant economic future with brilliant public development, etc. And, probably, for those structures, the system will be needed at that time. It’s just that with money, people, public organizations, and sponsors in the current Russian situation, and even crisis are not so fun to discuss the problem of the development of commercial sports-and sports in general.
“But still, the model can at least be clear!” One of the most striking is a model for the development of Russian biathlon. In fact, the most richest person of Russia, Mikhail Prokhorov, was appointed to the presidency of the Federation. He clearly poured some money into the Russian biathlon. He is a state man, but it is difficult to understand how much, although formally he is an oligarch and a private businessman. And he leads his sports industry. In Vancouver, his athletes in relation to other federations won the most medals in the Russian team. Probably, there is some share of the state’s participation in this, but no one will say that "the state with an iron hand clung to the Union of Biathlonists of Russia." What if Prokhorov will now choose the president of the Russian Olympic Committee? There is such a version, and then what is it - in public order, is the private capital is ordered to let him into the Olympic movement?
- The idea with Prokhorov is really brilliant. But the situation demonstrates one thing: if a person comes to the sport with a good grip, a large -scale sense of business, with understanding the essence of the matter, with understanding management technology, then he will be good in sports. Indeed, ultimately, a high-class manager, the top manager does not care what the industry to come to. He will bring technology, approaches, bring his people and educate new ones. But where we will find ...
- So many oligarchs? ..
- Probably, you can find them. But it is necessary that the oligarch not only bring money, not only hang out in the Olympic Committee. He must bring another system of vision of activity, the whole organization. And then it will be possible to move to the western model of the development of large sports.
- Perhaps Russia will face Sochi with another serious problem. Starting, approximately, since 1995-1996, in the sports editorial office of Radio Liberty with your participation, we said many times that the Soviet generation of athletes and coaches is gradually coming to naught. Gradually, they grow up, get old, gradually many travel around the world.
-Yes, of course, we repeatedly called to the leadership of Russian sports: the moment will soon come when Russian sport burns in the absence of a systemic factor in the training of athletes, when victories will come at the expense of some bright take-off, crazy talent, as, say, Elena Isinbaeva , but not at the expense of systemic training. A lot was destroyed in due time. And to this day, this training system has not been resumed - neither coaches, nor athletes, no arbitrators, no organizers, no sports managers.
Sochi will have to be considered as a review and preparation of young sports. And those Russian athletes who will win 4-5 years after Sochi will perform there
- And there are 4 years left before Sochi. Now they are already talking about this problem. In your opinion, will the Russian sports system have time to reorganize? Or in Sochi, the issue of victories will not be raised by sports, but otherwise - we will carefully call it "organizational". About this means this: as the Sochi Olympics got, so the medals can go.
- The situation is very difficult. Indeed, the problem of changing generations, the reproduction of sports training was and remains very difficult. The period of all perestroika led to a fall in the number of children's sports schools, a lack of financing. And the young shoots were very, very little. Incredibly little! And finding people under modern training technologies is very, very difficult. In fact, now we meet in the Olympic team athletes 1973, born in 1972. These are those people who began their career in the spirit of those times.
Do you understand what the USSR team has always been strong? It always had 4-5 world champions and the Olympic Games, but also a couple of young, promising athletes. And the young went, studied, and then won under the leadership and support of the "old people". And after two Olympics, they themselves became "old people." And followed by new youth. This continuity is now destroyed. It’s just that it cannot be restored. It is necessary to first reproduce this whole process, restore in the new conditions, with new technologies, with new approaches. And then this idea will act.
In this regard, I would not go into the prophets in relation to the Olympics in Sochi. Not for me to make a decision. But there are two options. The first is mercilessly exploit what is still. It is possible to find the best coaches to make sure that figure skating coaches are preparing not American rivals, but work more with Russian.
“But you won’t force Marina Zuev and Igor Spilbanda, say, work with Russian dancers.” You can, of course, highlight them a crazy grant on behalf of the Russian government. But will they want to leave America, where they work and where they raised the gold and silver pairs of Vancouver, to Russia?
- And I'm talking about the same. Destruction has already happened. Not only athletes, but also coaches "pulled out" from the system. To which "carrots" they will return is unknown. Maybe they will wait for the time when it will be safe for them to come here to do their own business, arrange a life when they will be here in the best conditions than in America?
But there is a very serious thing - this is the problem of how Russia to make a sufficiently large number of trainers for the athlete base of the highest achievements. The coaching staff is in poor condition. Many leading coaches, who were in his prime in the 60s-70s, the Kingdom of Heaven, died. To entrust this business to the institutions of physical education, universities, academies ... A sports teacher can be prepared at the university. This is not a teacher of physical education and physical education. This is another. But the coach is formed in the joint work of the coaches, in joint seminars, joint fees, in the movement from the teacher to the student, etc. Here is another problem: how to raise this disqualified mass of coaches and pull it to a modern level? You will have to face it more than once.
So, we summarize about Sochi. One option is a frying room. The second option is cruel: Sochi will have to be considered as a review and preparation of young sports. And those Russian athletes who will win 4-5 years after Sochi will perform there ...
- I'm afraid that no Russian leadership will never go to this. This means that the PR project was defeated already 4 years before the Olympics.
-Let's put this PR project on the shelf, and we will pull out another PR project from the box.
-There will be no other PR project, except for the current, in Russia! After all, the trouble is that it is Sochi that is planned as a world-Russian event. A string of victories should be ensured for this case.
- Nothing! There will be the Olympiad "Young Russia". There are talents in all sports, all beautiful, young, beginners, tearing. Can I freeze about such a project - the Olympics of young Russia?
- Rather, this will be the Universiade of 2013, which will occur in Kazan, in Tatarstan. This is where the Olympics, the Universiade, the Spartakiad (name as you want) young Russia will be.
- Kazan, I am sure, will simply hold an exemplary universiade. There is just a very strong organizational link. But if you think that by this time all student sports will rise in Russia, 5 thousand basketball teams or 20 thousand athletes would fight for the right to participate in the Olympics ...
- Yes, at least one hockey team appeared, which does not lose hopelessly, as in Vashkuver ...
- So, the Universiade is talking about the future. But I want to remember: in those days when the Soviet Union was very interested in victories in the international arena, and the Universiades were considered as training before the Olympic Games. And there were students who showed the achievements of the world level at the Olympic Games. It remains to wish for today's sports Russia there are more such students!