
Materials of the criminal case on tax evasion instituted against Sergei Magnitsky may soon be transferred to the prosecutor’s office to sign the indictment, the press service of the Hermitage Capital Foundation reports. According to his representatives, the investigation forbade lawyers to further familiarize themselves with these documents. Hermitage Capital emphasizes that the fund's lawyers found “falsification by a consequence of the criminal case materials, which throughout the entire length was carried out with gross violations of the criminal procedure law.” According to the representative of the Jamison Fayerstone Foundation, the investigation also ignored the numerous complaints of Magnitsky’s relatives who objected to his posthumous criminal prosecution.
The case against Magnitsky was closed after his death in the investigative insulator. However, in August of this year, by decision of the General Prosecutor's Office, criminal prosecution was resumed posthumously. This was done due to the fact that the Constitutional Court of Russia forbade to close criminal cases without the consent of relatives. However, the resumption of the criminal case was also carried out without the consent of the family of the deceased. Hermitage Capital called this a repeated violation of the constitutional rights of Magnitsky's relatives.
In June 2008, Sergei Magnitsky, on behalf of the Hermitage Capital investment fund, accused Russian officials of embezzlement from the budget of more than 5 billion rubles. A few months later, he repeated his charges of the media - and already in November the lawyer was arrested. The investigation charged him with tax evasion. According to investigators, Magnitsky was the author of the criminal scheme, thanks to which the fund managed to reduce income tax by 6 times, and the tax on dividends - 3 times. Magnitsky’s colleagues claim that it was precisely those officials against whom Magnitsky testified that they achieved his arrest and initiation of the case of tax failure. In 2009, Magnitsky died in an investigative insulator. Currently, the accusation of involvement in his death was brought by one person - the former deputy chief of Butyr prison Dmitry Kratov. A criminal case was instituted against him under the article “Criminal negligence”.
According to Jamison Fayerstone , officials who were suspected by Magnitsky in embezzlement are also interested in posthumous criminal prosecution:
- The indisputable fact is that millions of dollars were systematically abducted from the Russian budget. Sergei revealed this crime, and the people he accused shortly after that they achieved his arrest. We all know that in the end Sergey died in prison. The resumption of the case against Magnitsky shows that Russian officials who participated in these thefts are striving to protect themselves. They do not want to investigate who stole this huge money - they want to justify Magnitsky’s arrest in 2008. For this, his posthumous criminal prosecution was continued .
Lawyer Dmitry Kharitonov , representing the interests of the widow of Magnitsky Natalia, believes the posthumous persecution of Sergei illegal:
- To resume the proceedings in the case in relation to a person who died and the persecution of which was terminated in connection with death, even after the entry into force of the decision of the Constitutional Court is possible only for rehabilitation. Rehabilitation means the termination of the case due to the lack of corpus delicti, and the Prosecutor General had to terminate this case, since there was no crime in Sergey’s actions. But the investigation went the other way, they began to call Natalia for interrogation and demand from her either to agree with the termination of the case, or with the direction of the case to court. We decided not to take part in this, since it is obvious to us that Natalia’s consent to the termination of the criminal case in connection with Sergey’s death will be immediately regarded as recognition - albeit formal or indirect - Magnitsky’s guilt. The referral of the case to court and his consideration on the merits in a situation where Sergey died, after spending a year under investigation, in any case will end with his accusation - it is obvious to us. Thus, having violated the law, we were put in a situation when, in any situation, Sergey is guilty.
According to the lawyer Dmitry Kharitonov, the investigators and their chiefs who initiated him and their chiefs are now interested in the consideration of the criminal case against Magnitsky, since they need to prove that Sergey was in prison during the year not just like that, but in a real criminal case, which has a judicial perspective.
In mid -October, the mother of Sergei Magnitsky filed a lawsuit in the European Court of Human Rights with a demand to recognize the criminal prosecution of her son illegal. In the complaint, Natalya Magnitskaya indicates that the Russian authorities violated at once six articles of the European Convention on Human Rights, in particular, the article “Refusal of Life”, “Torture”, “Illegal Detention”.