Lev Roitman:
On October 15, in the Soviet Russia newspaper, in an article, which has nothing to do with our upcoming conversation, I read this phrase: "The impoverished and deceived Russian from the television box could not go anywhere, one joy remains in life. If there is no bread, you have to be content with at least spectacles." Well, according to a party habit, the Party newspaper says a half-truth, or rather the truth of the scruff of the worship-smile: even in the conditions of a crisis and bad species for the crop, bread in Russia was and is, but with spectacles it became worse precisely because of the crisis, due to the reduction of commercial advertising, in particular, on television. Advertising, as everyone understands, is the money that allows you to finance television programs and popular, collecting advertising, and socially unusable, which you will not receive advertising. So, the outflow of foreign firms from Russia is an outflow and advertising, it is also coagulation of television programs.
Russian television loses advertising - the viewer loses its usual programs. About this is our conversation today. All by telephone participate, Anna Kachkayeva, our television priest, teacher of the Faculty of Journalism of Moscow State University, Arkady Vaxberg - journalist, writer, lawyer, and our correspondent Semen Mirsky from Paris. Anna Grigoryevna, with the first question to you, but at first I will make a reservation: after all, the advertising crisis hit not only on television, but also on newspapers, magazines, radio stations. With regard to newspapers, for example, the Russian Telegraph generally ceased to exist. But now to our topic: television. What has the Russian viewer have already lost and what is under threat?
Anna Kachkayeva:
The fact is that the Russian viewer, perhaps, has not yet fully realized what was happening on the screen. The obvious, visible signs of the crisis are that a lot of straight programs, not recorded and, obviously completely, suffered, for example, such socially significant programs as all programs of children's broadcasting. This is primarily due to the reduction of employees and with the inability to produce these programs, because they are quite expensive in production. Of course, a certain number of entertainment programs were reduced, especially on state television. In fact, throughout Russia, all television companies both central and regional have completely retained only news services, some part of the film, which still has money, and partially entertainment programs, increasing the so-called “direct broadcasting” during the prime-item. That is why the View program and “Time and We”, and “Press Club” appeared on the air, although, of course, their appearance is also associated with the socio-political situation, the need to talk more about problems and crisis, but I have no doubt that this is also connected with the need to simply reduce the air, because the direct broadcast is certainly cheaper. Well, as for, by the way, advertising, the audience, too, probably noticed that the advertisement was practically left: the “gaskets” flew away, Aunt Asya left, because they were forced to freeze almost 40% of their advertising budgets such advertising giants as “Prikor and Gemble”, which in the 97th year provided 85% of 450 million dollars earned by central channels. in the advertising market. And on the air of the central Russian channels, a very insignificant appeared, but a Russian manufacturer appeared. Say, beer factories, confectionery factories "Bolshevik", washing machine "Oka" and insignificant advertising of AvtoVAZ, yes, and also image videos of the Dovgan, which, of course, is not a manufacturer, but this is in the tradition of Russian advertising, such an image advertisement of Dovgan appeared. These are the obvious results of the last one and a half months, which are already noticeable.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Anna Kachkaeva. I want to notice, looking from here from Prague, which, probably, like around the world, the viewer does not particularly aesthetically aesthetically from the fact that this or that advertisement disappears. From this, ultimately, television suffers, and then, as a reflected light and this viewer, since television has nothing to finance itself. But you are talking about “Prikator and Gemble”, yes, indeed, according to Russian advertising statistics, it was the largest advertiser last year, but was a period in the history of Russian television, it was the 94th year, when MMM is Mavrodi, and when the “selenga” - these pyramids collapsed, had a leading place in Russian television, in the advertising part of the budget. Iosifovich Vaxberg, before the start of this program, you told me that recently you visited some representative congress in Biarrice, dedicated to just an advertising problem in the media. Looking through the Biarrice, what can you say to the topic of our conversation - Russian television and commercial advertising?
Arkady Vaxberg:
It was, indeed, very interesting, at least according to the plan, Congress, and this problem is seen, which Anna Grigoryevna Kachkayeva was talking about now, from there, I would even say, almost paradoxically. It was the congress of the heads of state and public, in Western terminology this is called the "public" channels, public television, that is, non -profit or, as one of the participants in the congress, anti -complifier channels said, it was such a polemic point of confidence in him. Unfortunately, Russian television channels, public, public, were missing and could not tell about the state of affairs. And, probably, they would be extremely surprised to hear what Anna Kachkaeva talked about, this would bring a completely new note, a different note than that which sounded mainly at the congress. Oddly enough, the heads of television companies oppressively opposed the dominance of advertising, although it would seem that there is no company that would not be interested in attracting, even if it is rich enough, additional money. They believed that the availability, especially the excessive availability of advertising, especially in cases where the advertising invades the program itself, it puts, firstly, depending on itself from the advertiser, and, secondly, it affects the tastes of the viewer very significantly and negatively, affects what, from their point of view, these programs are shown on state and public channels. They assure that the viewer dictates the tastes of advertisers who invest money in those programs that, firstly, are most to their liking, and, secondly, which they believe, watch the largest number of their potential customers. And some speakers built a rather ominous chain showing like another advertising that crashes into some serious film or a serious journalistic program, is in its aesthetics and stylistics in contradiction with what the screen had just been broadcasting about, which he seemed to have achieved, and this is repeatedly reproduced, I play their thoughts, “accustoms to double-powered, pharisaicism, pharisa. It instills a bad taste " - it was a quote from the speech of the Canadian delegate. The harmful effects of advertising, which is more and more technically improved, inventive, but escalate in the propaganda of the primitive, was said in great detail. And this is what struck me: the leaders of television companies, it seems, already said, interested, everyone understands this, in the growth of their financial well -being, they argued that they needed legislative restrictions on the use of advertising. What programs are possible and which cannot be interrupted by advertising, when to let it go, at what hours, and at what hours it should be limited and so on. And some people objected, in particular, the Japanese delegate, if the memory does not change me, said something like this: “If the advertisement caused spectator rejection, no one would look at it. If they look, then it is interesting to the viewer, and since it is interesting to the viewer, and we will limit it in some way, this is an encroachment on the freedom of his choice. The viewer has the right to watch what he wants.”
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Arkady Iosifovich. This enchanted circle is an eternal problem, as we know, television and advertising, because the popular program is ready to give advertising, and this popular program should more and more focus on a more mass viewer in order to attract this advertisement. The circle, of course, is closed here in something, the topic is eternal.
Semyon Mirsky:
I would like to say that from Paris the problem of advertising looks a little differently than from the angle proposed by our colleague Anna Kachkaeva, which is quite logical and natural. After all, France is a society of abundance, where there are never too few goods, but almost always too much and the choice is always almost too large. It is enough to go to the local supermarket to make sure that there can be 25 varieties alone - go choose, it is very, very difficult. And, probably, by virtue of what was said, the French viewer, and here I mainly judge by myself, perceives television and first of all not as a means of selling this or that product, but, as it were, a “thing in itself”, a phenomenon of aesthetics, if you like. And Teleraklama here is the best illustration of the prophetic phrase of Marshall Makluen, who said, as we know: "Medium, the means of transmitting information, and there is a notification itself." And therefore, advertising on French television, and not just on advertising cabins, on posters, on panels, is a work of art in the first place. And ultimately, we are convinced that those firms, those companies that manage to enlist the help of the most witty, resourceful and aesthetically advanced advertising agencies are best sold. And the second problem that I would like to mention is, of course, the question of how French advertisers protect against the same advertising, from advertising of insolvent companies that offer not goods, but surrogates. And here is the most relevant example: on October 15, in France, an American medication was on sale to help overcome impotence, I am talking about the famous Viagra tablet. The drug is sold only in pharmacies and only upon presentation of a medical prescription, and advertising, and self -promotion was giant, each of us heard the name of this drug at least once. So, the date of the start of the sale, I remind you, on October 15th, but already 3 months ago in the sections of small ads of many French magazines there were advertising announcements of some company, which did not give its address, only the number of the mailbox, and this company offers Viagra tablets in a packaging of 10 pieces of 250 francs, that is, 25 francs per pill, and the price of one pill, and the price The medication in the pharmacy is 75 francs. But the main thing: where does a person who responded to the advertisement in such a magazine, the belief that they will sell him “Viagra”, and not surrogate? And here it is necessary to mention the ethics committee of the association of advertising agencies operating in France. This committee has very broad powers, it has a very powerful financial basis, and it is capable of suppressing the attempts of linerslam, that is, attempts to impose in the consumer of surrogates with its financial power. And I think that these are the two main features of the French advertising reality - on the one hand, its aesthetic sophistication and sophistication, on the other hand, the action of the ethics committee of the association of advertising agencies that I have mentioned, which give the institution of advertising as such capacity.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Semyon Mirsky. Anna Grigoryevna, I mentioned that there were years, the 94th, for example, when the leading advertisers in the Russian market were a pyramid company. These companies were not stopped by anyone in their advertising activities. Is there that restraining mechanism for advertising unfair or for advertising, misleading, similar to the one that Semyon Mirsky spoke in relation to France and, as we know, existing in other Western countries, I will not say with an ancient, but with an old advertising tradition?
Anna Kachkayeva:
Undoubtedly. In Russia, after the madness of advertising of the 93-94ths, the law "On Advertising" was adopted and it has an article on unfair advertising. Probably, this law is similar to the majority of such laws in the world. But now I listened to my colleagues and thought that all that they were talking about was, unfortunately, not yet about Russia, especially in connection with the current situation. Arkady Iosifovich said that the leaders of the largest companies called for banning advertising and thinking how to limit it. In Russia, this cannot be said about the leaders of the largest companies. Moreover, in September, when the crisis broke out, in Nizhny Novgorod, the head of the National Association of Broadcasters Eduard Sagalaev and the head of the largest group of advertising agencies Sergei Lisovsky signed a document, then most of the largest television companies joined him, a letter of document, which appeals to the government with a request to allow alcohol and a tablet to the central television channels. 23 hours due to the fact that television is in such a sad situation, and he needs to survive somehow. So far, no decision has been made in this connection, but the fact itself, in my opinion, says a lot. To the story of Semen: after all, in Russia, in fact, advertising, as in France, as I now understand, was also perceived as a thing in itself. Here it was perceived as a kind of artifact, as aesthetic givenness and it is no coincidence that image of image and “Imperial Bank” existed, and the same advertising “MMM” - it was a whole series, and then there were Gazprom videos, and others, others. So far there was no middle class, there was no functional, technological such advanced advertising, and more in Russia it was perceived as a small, beautiful, pretty movie. And in the last year, as if still the situation moved off the ground, but the current financial crisis again drove this situation to the level of not only the 93rd, but the 89th year, when all the advertisers will have to start from scratch, when very definite goods such as female tights, washing powders, well, may be gums, that is, no more audiovisual equipment and no more than any audiovisual equipment, and no more other things. And advertisers are afraid that in the spring, when the agencies are impoverished and it will not be very unimportant to feel the advertising market, large advertising agencies are foreign, which in the current situation are not going to go anywhere, buy them as a cheap. I don’t know whether we, the audience, should be afraid of this, because, by and large, in Russia, advertising has not become a factor in the economy. This is still either folklore or an annoying factor. Both the television people themselves and advertisers have never seriously thought about what they need to do self -restraint, although such votes were heard and even attempts to create a charter of broadcasters for some of the television channels at the end of summer. NTV, for example, even wrote its code of its code, where there is a provision on advertising. But again, the situation that happened after August 17th, she violated all the plans, and I think that for a long time, because in the spring or at the end of the next year there will be a political campaign, political advertising and all the conversations about responsibility and self-restraint, I think, it will be necessary to postpone for another two years.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Anna Kachkaeva. I want to note in conclusion that on the CHIN-EN channel there is regularly an advertisement for the International Association of Advertising Agencies under the motto: "Advertising is your right to choose." Thus, for these advertising agencies, advertising is, of course, the good that they supposedly transmit on the chain to the viewer of television. For the viewer itself, advertising is most often the evil is inevitable. Well, advertising allows you to diversify television programs and this is in the interests of the viewer. For television producers, advertising is an evil lusty, which, of course, has an impact on the policy of the television channel, but at the same time supports it financially. These are the contradictions.