Lev Roitman:
A few years ago, a prominent Russian economist Vladimir Nayshul read a report on the topic "Communism - Death or Transformation?" I will give an excerpt: “The answer to this question will sound different for different countries. In Russia, which was the main communist state of the planet, in which communism, as a terrible illness, covered the whole society, gave rise to the unprecedented extreme forms of despotism, destroyed millions of people, communism is dead and will be dead at least until people who lived under communism, in Western countries, where communism, where is communism where communism is communism. It was transferred as malaise with slightly elevated temperature, communism will exist for a long time, changing its appearance. " The end of the exposure, but by no means the end of the problem. Most recently, it was acutely discussed during the Bordeaux film festival, about the same thing and our conversation.
They participate, all by telephone, the Moscow publicist, writer Arkady Vaxberg. Arkady Iosifovich, it was you who participated in France, in Bordeaux, as part of the film festival, a kind of historical and philosophical retrospective, in the discussion on the topic "Communism - legends and myths of our century", you will tell us all this as soon as I present other participants in the program: this is Vladimir Malinkovich - this is the International Institute of Humanitarian -Political Studies, Ukrainian branch, Ukrainian branch, Ukrainian branch, Ukrainian branch Kyiv, director of this branch and Miklosh Kun - historian, professor of Budapest University.
Arkady Vaxberg:
It was a very interesting festival. He passed under the general name "Results of the century." The results of the century turned out to be a lot, this is quite natural, but mainly not scientific, not environmental or others were discussed, but the political results of the century. Moreover, they were discussed in open discussions with a huge gathering of the public. That's what to explain that the legend of the century, namely, such a definition, as you said, came up with the organism of the festival, became communism? This was the main topic of discussions there. Why is it not to abuse, at least in the minds, after so many decades of bloody experiments, after in many countries in various modifications, he proved his full failure, the absolute inability to solve a single problem that faces society, and to realize his promises enshrined in the programs of various committees? Why? It is curious that I was immediately discovered, I will not tell the abyss, but some kind of moat between those who participated in the discussion as invited and was on stage, and these were historians, philosophers, sociopsychologists, filmmakers and those who were in the hall, that is, the so-called wide public. The scene (and there were such a prominent French historian of communism as Stefan Courtois, such famous filmmakers as Claude Shabrol, Konstantin Costa-Garavas, Claude Lansman, Spanish-French writer and film-cinema chorche Semprun and others), the scene claimed that communism was destroyed by the end of the twentieth century, during their social experiments in a total of their social experiments in a total Eighty million people around the world, completely discredited and must share the historical fate of fascism. Meanwhile, the hall, which actively participated in free discussions, was in most other opinions: many of the public, having received a microphone, argued that it was not an idea, but its implementation, the implementation of bad or insufficiently competent people who also interfered with the world bourgeoisie. And this stable stereotype, which has come into the minds of millions of people around the world, is apparently the most difficult to break. The need for the myth is exclusively tenacious, and the tendency of many people is quite obvious to discuss the declarative starting position of communism, and not his real practice. Communism as an idea could exist only until the 17th year, and then it is already subject to analysis as political reality, not ideas. And it seems to me that there is no universal awareness of this simple thought, to the general awareness, so I would say, still very far.
Vladimir Malinkovich:
It seems to me that everything is not at all as simple as it has just been said. It seems to me that, indeed, the idea of communism is utopian and, in my opinion, cannot be realized, and has never been realized anywhere, except in Israeli kibbutz, and even in Tolstoy communes. This idea, I repeat, is utopian, but implies public self -government, public property, internationalism and universal equality - I do not believe in it, but, nevertheless, this is not at all what we had implemented for decades in the territory of the Soviet space, which has grown from Moscow and spread around the world. There was no self -government, there was a dictatorship, there was no public property, but there was a state monopoly, there was no question of any internationalism. It was, in my opinion, imperialism is classic Moscow, and then all -Soviet, all -off -communist. That is, these are completely different things: a communist reality, what was called communism in this seventieth anniversary, and utopia Domarx and Marxov. I would like to say that now in our countries, post -Soviet countries, in Russia and Ukraine, just those people who still retain the memories of Soviet life, in general, support the Communists, and the influence of the Communists here grows for the simple reason that they do not remember mass repressions and do not need freedom - they are not ready for this, they lived in the conditions of despotism, and not only decades. And, on the other hand, they lived better than today, so the number of people who support the Communists and Socialists is constantly growing both in Russia and in Ukraine. But I, I repeat, it seems that this has nothing to do with the communist myth that people in the West support and which is very different from the Soviet reality.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Vladimir Dmitrievich. Thus, as I understand it, one of the conditions for the further existence of communism as an idea in the minds of people in the post -Soviet space is, at least partially, in order to detach historical memory.
Miklosh Kun:
I would like to largely agree with Arkady Iosifovich. Yes, prominent intellectuals say that communism is the past, these 80 million. There is an association with the book "Black Book of Communism", which has published in Paris and played a huge role recently in our countries, by the way, it will soon be released in Hungary. But, on the other hand, there are, for example, old people in Hungary, who in the summer come with flowers to the grave of Yanosh Kadar and say that then we lived better, then there was a common idea, a common theory, and in addition, there was work for all of us, there were some ideals, and now they are gone. This duality is, of course, in Hungary. At the same time, in Hungary, for example, it is very interesting that there is a Kadarovsky communist party that calls itself a worker, and there is a post -communist party - a party of socialists, a member of the socialist international, which says that it and the Social Democratic Party. Both that and other parties went through a verbal revolution, neither one nor the other wants to call themselves the Communists - in many ways, even the Kadarovsky communist party. They try to say that they have a new countdown of history: then, they say, the past, let's forget about the past, let's talk about the future and the present.
Arkady Vaxberg:
Everything that Vladimir Dmitrievich said, in about the same expressions, I just heard from the hall in the discussion in the Bordeaux, which I spoke about. The transformation of communism, the need to cleanse it from the mud in which he dumped himself for three quarters of the outgoing century, apparently, this is really the cherished dream of those who want his resuscitation and who claims that realized communism is not the communism that was originally conceived. This is a traditional thesis that contributes to the survivability of the communist idea. And it is really curious that modern communists do not want to remember the past, they run from discussing this past, otherwise it will suppress all the conversations about his humanism and justice with their nightmare reality. Here is the leader of the French transformed Communist Party Robert Yu, he always says that everything has already been said about the past of the communist regimes and it does not make sense to return to this. More recently, in the theoretical journal of the Kaye Du Communism party, he praised Zyuganov’s Communist Party for this: about it, instead of Doldoing about the past, hitting herself in the chest, in fact turned into such a modern unification of ideological like-minded people and intends to build a humane democratic society on the basic principles of internationalism, tolerance, respect for civil rights and so on. This Christmas fairy tale did not have time to appear in the press, as one of these "humanists" Comrade Makashov spoke with his all already famous declarations, and Comrade Zyuganov and all the communists of his factions from these declarations did not dissolve, quite the opposite. And now, comrade uses is very difficult, he cannot support any manifestations of xenophobia, it would be suicide for him. And again, the old map is pulled into the light: Makashovshchina, she is Zyuganovshchina - this is a perversion of communism, this is not his essence. No perversions can stain his imperishable purity. Apparently, the organizers of the festival were right, calling communism the legend of the century. With legends, that is, with myths, it is difficult to part. So the bacillus of communism will most likely crawl into the 21st century.
Vladimir Malinkovich:
I am afraid that they did not hear me: I do not consider it necessary to reanimate communism at all. I said only one thing: that the myth of communism and Soviet reality are completely different things. And in order to say that Soviet reality answered to some extent a myth of communism, this must be proved on facts. As for the resuscitation of communism, I am categorically against, I am afraid of this, and I am afraid of it to a large extent because we have not only communists and not so much communists today are dangerous for democracy, but our powerful, who govern the country in Bolshevik, otherwise they do not know how. It is they who suppress civil society in the country, they limit freedom of speech, it is they who today impede the creation of a normal social and legal European state. It is they who know how to work only by destroying everything to the ground, and then ... which direct evidence is the collapse of the Soviet Union, bypassing the intermediate stages; What proof is the execution of parliament and parliamentarism with the approval of the Democrats; What evidence is bombs in Grozny, falling on behalf of the Democratic Government of Russia, which is evidence of a lot, much more. That is, this is precisely the danger of preserving the Bacilli of Bolshism in the heads of our so -called democrats, it seems to me that is the main obstacle to the development of our countries - Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus and others towards the European social and legal society, which, indeed, would be ideal for this moment in this Eurasian territory.
Miklosh Kun:
It seems to me that Makashov’s syndrome should not be bypassed. The fact is that I recently bought a newspaper of the Hungarian Communist Party, it is also the Kadarovsky working party, which comes out only once a week, this is a small newspaper, and they pretended that this was not. But, on the other hand, they say that in Russia a very great danger of fascism and the only way to avoid this fascism is to support Comrade Zyuganov. That is, they specially bypass real facts. In general, on the one hand, information about what is happening in Russia is not given, and on the other hand, the lack of information that many Western communist parties have turned into socialist ones. In fact, they here, as it were, go into the spiritual underground - this says, after all, about a lot.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Miklosh Kun. Arkady Iosifovich, and how do you explain the fact that the mood of the hall was much more pleasant for the communist idea than the mood of the scene in which these prominent Western intellectuals gathered? By the way, many of them are the so -called "left", although today you do not know the right -left one where the side is in politics.
Arkady Vaxberg:
It seems to me that people are inclined to believe beautiful words and good intentions and instinctively discard everything that prevents the dreams of a better share. And again and again, the immortal aphorism is confirmed: "The only lesson in history is that no lessons are removed from it." And I think that everyone is a noticeable pinkishment of Europe (I remind you: 13 of the 15 countries of the European Union, except for Spain and Ireland, have passed under the banners of social democracy, not communism, but social democracy) is an instinctive traction, as it were, to an improved version of communism, without its totalitarian essence, but with the idea of social justice. The idea of social justice cannot be destroyed, the need for it is incredibly great, and therefore this declarative, facade side of the myth of communism is so tenacious. And I do not see the real prospect that the world parted very quickly with it.
Vladimir Malinkovich:
I just see hope, at least for Europe, namely in social democratic and social liberal movements. It is that they dominate Europe today, it seems to me, a symptom of hope. I think that classical capitalism, he, of course, is already as in the past as in the past and the myth of communism. Today, indeed, a person needs, as always he needed it, but today, especially, the idea of social justice and freedom. It is possible to unite the idea of freedom and the idea of social justice only at the level of social democratic and social liberal decisions, which are now in Europe and are trying to implement and implement. It seems to me, in this direction, if we go, it will be wonderful - here we have a way out of the crisis. If we renounce the idea of social justice and only defend the idea of personal individual freedom, then we will flourish this corrupt, clan, I don’t know what capitalism, socialism, anything, the oligarchic system that will destroy our countries.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Vladimir Dmitrievich. No one mentioned, speaking of the problems of posttotalitarian, post -communist societies, the role and functions of a strong, democratic, but having levers of state self -defense. And I think, Vladimir Dmitrievich, that it would be very practical to add this element to what you say. And then suddenly it turns out that the political colors of the ruling parties can change, and the state, as, ultimately, the guarantor of constitutional rights and freedoms, will remain in its place and will regulate all these inevitable shifts, ebbs and flows of political plumages. And in conclusion, the word Arkady Vaxberg.
Arkady Vaxberg:
Despite the fact that the opinions, it would seem different, we all, I think, turned out to be one mainly: with the practice of communism, in no matter what countries it was carried out, whether it was a former Soviet Union, Eastern European countries, China, Vietnam, Cuba, Angola, an infinite number of different variations and modifications, with which the idea of that long ago will now be associated with the idea now The idea, about that long -standing myth, has completely discredited this communism, and this nightmare social experiment should not be repeated. But with the idea of which, in the combination of two principles, social justice and freedom, Vladimir Dmitrievich spoke, I think this is promising - it is completely pointless to fight this. It is only about one thing: so that the past would not be forgotten, so that they would not pretend that this is not the past, and that no one would create the illusions that the myth of communism and its implementation are completely different things. These are not different things, humanity should not turn away from its past.