![]() | |||||||||
| |||||||||
The OG columnist talks with the President of Chuvashia, deputy head of the conciliation commission from the Federation Council Nikolai FEDOROV about why the conflict initiated by the presidential bill has become so acute and what could follow. Nikolai Vasilyevich, what did the senators actually achieve with their act of disobedience to the president and the State Duma? We can say that we have achieved maximum results. All branches of government were forced to take a time out. Now is the time for society and some deputies to better understand the consequences of the president’s initiative to reform state power. Now the process of persuading each other and exchanging arguments is underway again. There is an opportunity to work with public opinion again, to explain to citizens why the implementation of the proposed bills is dangerous. On the eve of the last meeting of the Federation Council, Vladimir Putin insisted that he agreed to a compromise and did not interfere in the discussion between senators and Duma members. Has the Kremlin really withdrawn from this process? Of course, the presidential administration worked with senators and deputies. I don’t know in detail what was agreed upon in high offices. But, for example, the leader of the People’s Deputy faction, Mr. Raikov, told me that at a meeting with the president it was decided to “close the issue” on July 7. That is, the conciliation commission had to “settle” all controversial issues in a couple of hours, so that by the evening the law would be re-adopted by the Duma. It’s difficult to evaluate this scenario as anything other than a mockery of us. Your colleagues on the Federation Council probably understand that the president did not like their behavior. Don't you think that after this it will be more difficult for regional leaders to communicate with the federal authorities? In the same way, it will be more difficult for the federal authorities to find a common language with regional leaders. Neither the political establishment nor Russian society should be under the delusion that regional authorities can be ignored with impunity. The president or prime minister with a huge staff and machine gunners will make a foray into some area once a month and are satisfied: they have come into contact with the people. And every day we visit factories, factories, farms, and schools, where we communicate with workers, pensioners, students, teachers, and doctors. Ultimately, we are pursuing a political line developed in Moscow, and the level of public support for it depends on how we conduct it. Today we serve as a shield covering Moscow, but we can choose a different role for ourselves. Do you think the names of 13 “good” governors who supported the presidential bill are already known “at the top”? I wonder what will happen to them for this? I believe they have already reported to the Kremlin. One can assume that they will certainly be thanked. Now there is an over-centralization of budget revenues, almost all tax and non-tax revenues will go to the center, that is, 70 percent of everything that is earned locally will be divided in the Kremlin. So there will now be more opportunities to reward loyal governors than before. It is still unclear why the president took up arms against the Federation Council. After all, it was an extremely loyal ally of the Kremlin. Was it worth starting a conflict out of the blue? This is truly the “secret of the Madrid court.” I don’t even rule out that the bill’s developers were motivated by a sense of revenge. Sometimes the Federation Council nevertheless opposed the Kremlin initiatives. For example, against the resignation of Prosecutor General Skuratov. Is it permissible for state leaders to give vent to such feelings? I proceed from the fact that the president of Russia, by definition, must be strong and wise. Like any manager, he needs smart assistants and capable authorities. If the president is weak and not wise, then, according to the well-known laws of psychology, he forms organs and recruits assistants who please, and do not object to him. Frankly speaking, few people expected such audacity from the senators. When the president has a rating of 60 percent, fighting with him is dangerous for one’s own reputation. Anyone who opposes a popular leader becomes almost an "enemy of the people" in public opinion. It’s amazing that the regionals decided to take such a desperate act. Is it really like losing a seat in the Federation Council? It seems to me that none of the senators was motivated by the thought of their place in the upper chamber. For the most part, regional leaders are hardened people. They know how to protect their personal interests. But today they feel a very serious threat not to themselves, but to the state. Maybe not all of us understand and accept democracy, but, in principle, regional leaders have already realized its necessity or, at worst, have come to terms with its elements. It is obvious to us that lowering the status of the upper house will inevitably lead to a sharp weakening of the federal principles of Russian statehood. With a non-independent State Duma and a weak Senate, it will be easy to carry out any, the most unexpected, constitutional reforms. Today we already see a tendency towards building an autocratic, self-sufficient “vertical of power”. The contours are indicated: at the top is the All-Russian autocrat, below him are the governors general... There is a strengthening of the administrative and political mechanisms of government and the displacement of constitutional and legal methods of ensuring order and responsibility. You say that an attack on the regional elite is an attack on democracy. Meanwhile, in the Duma, the Democrats were the most aggressive against the governors, and you found support from the Communists. How to understand this? This suggests that we still have very immature, unformed democrats. As for the communists, they may have seen that the centralization of power according to the “Pinochet model” leaves no hope for maintaining political pluralism. And they are already accustomed to a free press, to free elections, without this they cannot survive. They appear to have a better sense of the situation than their Democratic colleagues. You know that the President is looking for a way to limit the absolute power of regional rulers. Let's say he chose the wrong means. But did you, the regionals, offer him any other ways to solve this problem? Regional leaders do not have any absolute power. Shaimiev, Fedorov, Aushev, Nazdratenko have as much power as Moscow gave them. We act within the limits set by Yeltsin, his government, federal prosecutors and officials appointed to oversee the territories. If one of the governors has become insolent, hold him accountable to the fullest extent of the law! After all, there is a point-by-point procedure for bringing our brother to criminal responsibility. But give at least one example when they tried to bring an overbearing governor or president of the republic under this procedure. There was no such thing. If, say, the Federation Council once, twice, three times did not agree to bring our colleague to justice, then one could say that we are sheltering our people. But, I repeat, this was not the case. I am convinced that all major violations in the regions occur only to the extent that they are resolved “at the top.” Essentially, this is the result of illegal political deals between the Kremlin and regional leaders. In Chuvashia, the head of the FSB department is a general, the Minister of Internal Affairs is a general, and the prosecutor is of the same rank. Under the command of each general there are hundreds, or even thousands, of “bayonets”. What, they are unable to ensure law and order? Still as much as possible! But as soon as one of them takes a swing at the insolent governor, he immediately calls the Kremlin and reminds: “You and I have agreed on everything. What does your federal representative allow himself to do?” And immediately - hang up on all lines. The investigation is “frozen” and the case goes cold. Nikolai Vasilyevich, don’t you think that the president is treating you the same way as you treat local government? You are crushing local democracy, the president is crushing you. I do not agree with this formulation of the question. In my opinion, local self-government is the most effective tool for developing responsible, effective government and creating a civil society. There are a minority of regional leaders fighting local self-government; there are simply different models of relationships, different levels of self-government. Vladimir Putin promises to create a kind of State Council for regional leaders. According to the President of North Ossetia, Alexander Dzasokhov, it was decided to give the State Council almost the same powers that the Federation Council has. Maybe this is the solution to the conflict in your favor? This promise of the head of state brings nothing but a smile to me. Firstly, all this is written with a pitchfork on the water, and secondly, the Constitution does not provide for a place for the State Council in the system of separation of powers. Where should I include it, and from whom should I take away what powers? Either this is stupidity that occurred to one of the “great” Kremlin consultants, or an attempt to mislead senators and the public. How, then, can this conflict end? In the modern history of Russia there have been conspiracies, threats, and coups, but we have never encountered such a sharp turn from legal principles in politics to administrative-repressive ones. But I'm an optimist. In the end, Russia always develops from totalitarianism to rampant democracy, and then again to totalitarianism. I think that the tension, having reached its peak, will subside. The main thing is to survive until this time. | |||||||||
Copyright © 2000 "GENERAL NEWSPAPER" Use of materials without the written consent of the editors is prohibited. | |||||||||