People in masks - apparently, it is this image that becomes in the eyes of our fellow citizens unmistakable evidence of the adamance and determination of power.
OMONS in masks, kicking the legs of defeated violators. Bailiffs, with butt breaks the front door. People in masks - in commercial banks. In the editorial premises and accounting of the television company that did not pay for commercial debts. And everywhere, with all that, there is a document with seals and signatures, indicating that everything that happens is carried out "according to the law".
What is this? I dare to believe that the “masks” in the diverse meanings of this word are the sign and symbol of a more complex and in some way a unique phenomenon regarding the very essence of our Russian statehood.
Now, among analysts who evaluate the anxious facts of Russian reality, the conviction is that the democratic and legal institutions formally proclaimed in Russia are “mental”, “imitational” nature. Or, as the author of these lines happened, according to all the canons of Russian history and specifics, to the phenomenon of "Byzantium", "Byzantine law".
But if only that. In this time, along with "pretense" and "imitation", the main thing is still different. This is such a construction and practical implementation of formally established democratic and legal institutions, when the decisive factor is power as such (concentrated in law enforcement agencies), to which the power of the law is attached.
How is it - "the power of the law" joins? What is the matter? To a large extent - the fact that the law really has significant social force and has high prestige, authority according to generally accepted ideas.
At the same time, the law, with all its ideal attractiveness, practical significance and authority, is a powerful tool that can express and implement the will of the dominant power in its various meanings. Be even an instrument of state arbitrariness. And although legal means that block legislative self -will have developed in democratic societies, these funds are not always effective and sufficient. In society, just overcoming the tenacious imperatives and hidden mechanisms of the totalitarian regime, the force as such remains and continues to dominate. And here it may happen that it happened with us - the power of the law also joins this force.
And such a dense combination of power as such with the power of the law as an instrument of state power is, it must be assumed, the most characteristic and unique feature of modern Russian statehood. In it - both real advantages of discipline and order, and the mood for adamance in the implementation of the state will, and a strict warning to all the disobers, and the hidden power of power decisions, and their own greatness, and their own invulnerability. That is, all that is exactly what is characteristic of the "masks" in the appearance and actions of law enforcement agencies, clothed in the action "according to the law". And that, we will be frank, one way or another is already triggered in our difficult reality. In an obvious or barely noticeable change in vocabulary and setting problems in the comments of other independent TV presenters and journalists. In the actions and words of the enormous rulers of the regions. In sudden loyal intonations, in statements of captains of large business. And in many ways.
It is not by chance that the formula became almost the official credo of our statehood - the "dictatorship of the law."
This formula confuses many specialists, a democratically configured public. Meanwhile, I can assure, everything is for sure here.
The dictatorship, no matter what additional words here are entered ("proletarian", "democratic", dictatorship, mating with the "law"), invariably includes dictatorship and unconditional supremacy of the state will.
Hence - when it is "required" - the strictest, unconditional, to each beanie and dashes, compliance with legislative requirements, pleasing authorities.
And when there is no law on this issue - also “nothing can be done”, the political feasibility directly performs, the opportunity to act at the discretion of managerial institutions and officials. Or - on the same dictatorial grounds - generally free, often "on choice" application and interpretation of the law. Or, on the contrary, the non -use of the law. And not only the law, but also the law of laws - the constitution. Many provisions of the latter, including the provisions of fundamental importance (about the land, on mandatory judicial procedures in the field of judicial and criminal procedure law, about alternative military service, etc.), have not entered into force within seven years from the date of adoption of the Constitution. Others related to the upper links of power, on the contrary, are practically interpreted not strictly in the constitutional text, but in accordance with the sovereign traditions that have been established in our society, often in their genetics and practice - tsarist, party -Embroidery.
And in the atmosphere of our domestic realities with particular expressiveness, the fact that a kind of subtext was present from the very beginning of these notes - exceptional importance and principles, the irreplaceability of law in society, which declared itself "democratic", makes itself felt.
Attention: the importance and irreplaceability of not the law in itself (this is only a form of existence of legal norms, their introduction to life, which also admits its arbitrary use by the authorities), and especially not the dictatorship of the law. Namely, the rights in his modern humanistic understanding. That is, such a achievement of civilization, according to science, is one of the most significant, which, in organic matter itself, is opposed to state arbitrariness and at the level of modern development is configured to a person, to ensure his rights. Which makes the statement in the society of the rule of law inevitable.
Is this not: the supremacy of law (pronounced, in our constitution), the sufficiency and effectiveness of all the mechanisms that provide it, primarily independent justice, is called upon to become a key point of development of our society, the central link in our concerns and deeds, the approval of the values and ideals of democracy in the real social life, in which the real modernization of society is only possible, its rising economic and its ascending economic and its rising economic and its rose Social development? However, there is simply no other way to break out of the social state, in which “masks” became a symbol of statehood.