

Interview with Konstantin Titov, elections in Saratov
Mikhail Sokolov:
The presidential campaign in Russia and the rivalry between Vladimir Putin and Gennady Zyuganov are not encouraging with bright events. But the upcoming elections for governor of St. Petersburg in May, the duel between Valentina Matvienko and Vladimir Yakovlev with an unpredictable ending, are intriguing.
In St. Petersburg, the elite is split. In Russia, the leaders recognize Vladimir Putin's indisputable right to Yeltsin's legacy. And the government’s sparring partner, the Communist Party of Russia, half-heartedly finishes the match with a known result.
Having refused the services of professional specialists in conducting election campaigns, Gennady Zyuganov is trying to attract voters with monotonous promises of tripling pensions and salaries, and endlessly challenges Vladimir Putin to debates.
Putin, having abandoned discussions and not paying attention to his rivals, still continues his election campaign with state affairs, demonstrating concern either for the production of the opera “War and Peace”, or for oil production, or for productivity growth in light industry, or for the normalization of relations with NATO.
By the will of the Supreme Court, Vladimir Zhirinovsky returned to the electoral stage again. The decision in the case regarding the property of the LDPR leader closes the topic of Putin’s country house and Tuleyev’s service apartment, hidden from the eyes of the Central Election Commission.
The struggle for the role of a single candidate of the democratic forces between Yabloko leader Grigory Yavlinsky and Samara governor Konstantin Titov has also intensified.
Russian presidential candidate, Samara Region Governor Konstantin Titov, suggested that another candidate, Yabloko leader Grigory Yavlinsky, withdraw from the race for the presidency. The headquarters of the Yabloko candidate dismissed this demarche. Yavlinsky has already stated that under no circumstances will he withdraw his candidacy. But Konstantin Titov does not calm down. “Three times he (that is, Yavlinsky) made attempts to get elected, and always - an empty number,” says Konstantin Titov, accusing Grigory Yavlinsky of splitting the democratic electorate.
What sense does the quite successful regional politician, Samara governor and head of the budget committee of the Federation Council see in his participation in the elections? Is Konstantin Titov simply satisfying his ambitions, or is he destined for a different role in this campaign?
Today, Russian presidential candidate Konstantin Titov is a guest of the “Elections 2000” program.
- Konstantin Alekseevich, after all, why was it necessary to turn to Yavlinsky, if his - a priori - position is known: he will not withdraw his candidacy under any circumstances, considering himself, in fact, the sole candidate of the democratic forces?
Konstantin Titov:
Everyone is free to consider themselves who they consider themselves to be. This is his right, and we must respect this human right, this is a democratic right.
I have nothing against Grigory Alekseevich Yavlinsky. A normal person of democratic convictions, always in opposition to the authorities. This, by the way, is also not very easy. But to get out three times, and, as it were, “miss the money,” right? We must already understand that perhaps we should nominate another person from the democratic coalition, and Grigory Alekseevich should concentrate on his work in the State Duma: consolidating the democratic forces, pushing through the laws that we need, which he talks about, and which the Duma does not accept.
But today there is an opportunity to consolidate. Both the Union of Right Forces and part of the OVR are not against the development of the ideas of federalism, they are not against the development of the ideas of a certain change in the balance of forces between the government, parliament, the presidential administration and the president himself.
There is a lot of work for which Grigory Alekseevich Yavlinsky is needed as the leader of the democratic forces in parliament. He went to the polls with this. At least once in your life you need to start something and finish it. That is, there is a period of four years. You promised people: there will be such, such, such, such laws. Let's do them. There is no need to come out here today - “we’ll just leave it there and then we’ll whine.”
I understand that there will be a replacement for the leader of the faction, and that’s all. But we understand that today this seems to take people away from work. Not a single law has been promised yet, two months... The Duma has been working for the third month.... There are no these laws, no amendments to other laws. I understand that this is not being done quickly, but there are things that can already be passed by committees, submitted to a plenary session of the Duma - there is nothing of this yet.
Therefore, let’s say openly: I respect Grigory Alekseevich, but I come up with a proposal that today one is consolidating forces in the executive branch, the other is consolidating forces to work in parliament.
I also understand that the favorite is very strong in the race, the favorite is far ahead, but having received the rating here and the rating of Grigory Alekseevich, if we combine him later in subsequent work, he can give very good results.
Mikhail Sokolov:
However, he refused you. And many will be sure that this is just a squabble, and you are taking away votes from Yavlinsky, whose rating is still higher, just as Tuleyev is taking away votes from Zyuganov. So, in fact, everyone will decide that this is your role.
Konstantin Titov:
Mikhail, you are absolutely right. There's no need to even decide. Grigory Alekseevich and I are on the same field. Only he is a theorist, and I am a practitioner. I have been governor for nine years. And I know how to constructively and pragmatically solve everything that Grigory Alekseevich promises. I am doing this in the Samara region, and I am ready to do this for Russia, because then it will be good. There will be pensions, there will be salaries, without delays, day after day.
Therefore, today we must understand: here is the position of practice and experience, a theoretical democrat is a practical democrat. Today, executive power is practical work, it is pragmatic work, it is constructive work. Let's engage in lawmaking based on the experience that has been accumulated in the constituent entities of the federation, in particular in the Samara region, and together we will move this to the executive branch. And then there will be no gap in the electorate.
And so... Grigory Alekseevich and I hug, shake hands - the rupture of the electorate is still happening.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Well, as a result, the third will be Zhirinovsky, who has now received such good publicity while the democratic candidates sort things out among themselves. No?
Konstantin Titov:
And the grandmother said this in two.
Mikhail Sokolov:
But, in fact, doesn’t it turn out that the essence of this campaign is precisely that the struggle is not for places even, who is first, who is second, who is third, since it is known who is first and who is second, but for the image of the new president, for the image of Putin? That is, there is Putin, who is going to “kill” someone, there is Putin, who says, why not Russia join NATO? These are completely different approaches.
And your role then turns out to be that you are trying to influence the favorite, no?
Konstantin Titov:
Everyone tries to influence the favorite, not just me. But today I want to say that I am ready to support Putin. But just as a statement was made regarding NATO, the same statements should be made regarding the subjects of the federation, the same statements should be made regarding economic liberalization, the same should be made regarding a liberal society. All this should. Then I am ready to support Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin.
Therefore, today I believe that talking about Zyuganov and Putin in the second round is also problematic. People are already tired of the promises of the communists. Just as the democrats are tired of pure criticism of Grigory Alekseevich Yavlinsky, let’s return to the topic, right? The people are also tired of the empty promises of the communists.
Who is Zyuganov today? He is not a communist. You read their program. There is nothing left of Marx or Lenin there. There's nothing there. There is private property, there is this.... Then call yourself “We are Social Democrats.” If he calls himself a “social democrat”, then some people will immediately move away from him. To Tuleyev.
I just can’t understand why we a priori decided today that Zyuganov will be in the second round. Yes, some grandmothers carry it in their arms. But they also carry Putin in their arms for increasing his pensions, and are more grateful, because his opponent has only promises, Zyuganov, and Putin did it. They also carry Titov in their arms, because he did it too. But Zyuganov and the communists only make promises.
In general, tell me, have their promises been realized anywhere? So, he starts scolding Chubais, saying “fire Chubais.” Well, please. We have been in power for eight years. You are in the State Duma, you are the leader of the largest faction, the Chairman of the Duma is your man. You mixed with the authorities, you blurred communist interests, you betrayed communist ideals, right? Drive Chubais, call him to the commission.... No, he doesn’t, right? I guess Zyuganov likes being an oppositionist today. He likes to drive around in nice cars. He likes to promise high pensions, salaries, and so on, but he hasn’t lifted a finger.
Mikhail Sokolov:
For you, Governor Titov, Governor Tuleyev, apparently, is still closer, since he is doing something, unlike Zyuganov.
Konstantin Titov:
Governor Tuleyev is closer to me, but the truth is dearer. If you received one and a half billion rubles for the restructuring of industries, for transfers and so on, then, indeed, well done, and everything is clear. But if you are struggling, while in other regions of the federation they do not receive any transfers or anything on time, then this is a different question.
But a colleague is a colleague. I don't want to discuss, right? Colleague. But I want to say that I just can’t understand why Tuleyev is in favor of the appointment. He understands perfectly well that he would never have been appointed. The people elected him.
Mikhail Sokolov:
How? Yeltsin appointed him, there was a rumor.
Konstantin Titov:
The people elected him.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Before his election, he was appointed by Boris Nikolaevich Yeltsin.
Konstantin Titov:
Here he was the chairman of the council, then he went to the government, and he was elected from the government.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Was appointed first.
Konstantin Titov:
OK then. Appointed, right? Well, that means he has earned trust. Then the face of the communists will be even clearer. And they scold Yeltsin. Yeltsin appointed them. But now it’s no longer Yeltsin.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Putin will appoint - they are counting on it.
Konstantin Titov:
Then what happens - Tuleyev doubts his electorate? Does he doubt that he will be elected governor? If you doubt that you will be elected governor, there is no need to run for president.
I am running for president, with no doubt that I will be elected governor in the Samara region. And if you doubt it, if you stand up for appointment, then either you are afraid, or you do not know how to manage complex systems. Because the municipality is independent, the subject of the federation is independent. This is a complex system, but it is very stable.
And if you want to build an uncomplicated, simple system... the vertical, this notorious, unitary system, then the Soviet Union collapsed.... Nursultan Nazarbayev did not have time to fly to Moscow - the Union was gone. In an instant. This is how simple systems fall apart. Is this what he wants for Russia, Tuleyev?
Mikhail Sokolov:
Konstantin Alekseevich, you are quite harshly opposed to the appointment of governors. Now you have met...
Konstantin Titov:
...professionally tough, I would say. Professionally tough, because I know what will follow for people. It will be bad for people.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Well, you met with the mayor of Moscow Yuri Luzhkov. It turns out that in contrast to the group that advocates the appointment, for the consolidation of regions, for changing the role of the Federation Council... are you creating another group in the Federation Council? Are you, Luzhkov, someone else?
Konstantin Titov:
I don’t want to say that the Federation Council works according to interests, like some kind of club, you know. No. I actually met with Yuri Mikhailovich. And I discussed precisely these problems with him. Because Yuri Mikhailovich... well, we can judge something differently, but he has always been a supporter of elections. And rightly so. Because if there had been an appointment, then he would not have been appointed on December 19th. Who would you appoint? - he wrote about this very well in the newspaper Moskovsky Komsomolets. Therefore, I am on the same path with him in this direction of movement.
The next stage, besides appointment, is federalism. After all, for some reason everyone thinks that Luzhkov is robbing Russia. Luzhkov is not fleecing Russia. It’s just that Moscow has historically developed as a government and financial center.
But many people think that large oil companies are registered in Moscow, they pay taxes.... They are not registered in Moscow. They are not even in the Moscow region, many are registered. And this must also be understood.
Therefore, his positions on federalism and mine are also close. We can talk about a market economy in different ways. We can talk about the role of the state in different ways. But there are positions that bring us closer, and I consulted with him today. I think we urgently need to assemble the Federation Council. We need to discuss, in general, why this demagoguery - the dissolution of the Federation Council, the dissolution of political parties, the appointment of governors - is beginning to disturb society. And, mind you, on the eve of the presidential elections.
Mikhail Sokolov:
So, the president is being offered such a cooperation program? That is, he is elected for seven years, and governors are appointed, but the same ones who offer this program, right?
Konstantin Titov:
We haven't elected a president yet, so let's talk like that. They offer acting president, right? But let’s choose - maybe we’ll offer him another one, and maybe he’ll like it better?
I say this again to the fact that I am ready to support Putin, but he must understand what federalism is and, together with us, build a federal state, not a unitary one. There is no need for these forces, the executive vertical, which is a lever for centrifugal forces, for the collapse of Russia. This must be understood. This is a very difficult position, and if Putin is ready to support this, then I am ready to support him.
Therefore, excuse me, elections will be held on the 26th. If Putin is elected, we will also present our views on these things to him. And let's see where else the majority in the Federation Council is - those who are in favor of the appointment, who have served their last term.... And you also look at how subtly it is done... right, well, I would say, not even very well, right? So, another word comes to mind: I won’t speak on air. What kind of "lining" is it? Governors are to be appointed, mayors are to be appointed, and presidents of the republics are to be elected. Yes? Do you feel what a step is already taken towards the collapse of Russia? Split! There is a split right away along ethnic lines.
Is this from a great mind? I think that this is either a task, or the federal structure and the Constitution of the Russian Federation are misunderstood.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Konstantin Alekseevich, but, on the other hand, a fairly reasonable thing is being proposed - to form the Federation Council through election. That is, it’s not like there were governors and heads of legislative assemblies there. After all, you see, the executive and legislative powers are mixed here, and the principle of separation of powers is violated. That is, in this regard there is a reasonable thing.
Konstantin Titov:
Misha, it’s a pleasure to work with you. You probably really communicate with ordinary people who really want democracy. Well, I, as a liberal, as a democrat, also want this. If you conducted surveys, talked to people, these are your thoughts, then you and I are supporters.
Yes, this must be done. Right now, right? On the eve of the presidential elections?
Mikhail Sokolov:
Discuss.
Konstantin Titov:
Discuss. Here, let's discuss this. I agree. Let's build this. And maybe I agree that by the end of 2003 or 2004 we will come to a scheme where the Federation Council will be elected. But now many people say... the example of America, and there, other higher chambers. There, indeed, representatives from the regions are elected. But America didn’t come to this right away either.
Our Constitution has been in existence since 1993. Seven years. Less than seven years. Not seven years passed before they came to the electors and then, that means, two representatives from the state. Not seven years. Let's live and work.
That's what is needed, I think, is the post of vice president. This is what I consider necessary.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Why do we need a vice president? There was already a vice president. I quarreled with the president - there were disgraces.
Konstantin Titov:
It was very easy to quarrel there. The character of one is Nordic, and the second is also no less Nordic. Moreover, the post of vice president without powers was determined. That is, he has nothing. He doesn't do anything. Do you understand? If specific powers had been given - this is your area of work - yes, I am more than sure: this situation would not have happened. And then the oligarchs deliberately pulled him away from Boris Nikolaevich, Rutskoy. The oligarchs deliberately pushed him away. They didn't need him. He was in the way.
Mikhail Sokolov:
And in your system, what will he do?
Konstantin Titov:
If we take such a situation as election, yes? He is elected together with the president, I would think that he should still be involved and be in touch with parliament.
Mikhail Sokolov:
As the head of the chamber?
Konstantin Titov:
Maybe as the head of the upper house. And this, by the way, can be done now. That is, he becomes the chairman of the chamber, and we all - including Yegor Semenovich Stroev, and the entire presidium - sit in the hall, equal among equals. And not first among equals. Do you understand? This is also normal. This would already be the first step towards the construction that the people dream of. That's what I understood from your question.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Konstantin Alekseevich, what about a seven-year term for the new president? How do you feel about this idea?
Konstantin Titov:
Badly.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Why?
Konstantin Titov:
If we like the president, we will elect him again for four years. Yes? And from a management point of view, eight years, seven years is the optimal regime. For a position.
Mikhail Sokolov:
But you are already nine.
Konstantin Titov:
Governor?
Konstantin Titov:
Well, of course.
Konstantin Titov:
I have only been governor for four years. And there I was the head of administration. These things are somewhat different. I worked with an eye on the Kremlin. I worked with an eye on the government. And now I work as a governor on my own. These are completely different jobs. These are completely different responsibilities. These are completely different work tasks.
If we go further, then, well, we liked him. Okay, right? Can you imagine - after a year or two I didn’t like it. And what? Seven years... five years to endure then?
Mikhail Sokolov:
And we will arrange impeachment.
Konstantin Titov:
We won't arrange anything. What impeachment? With this opposition in the person of Zyuganov? What impeachment? All! They will say: “And here, on this issue, the vote is free. The communists will decide for themselves.” Remember his sacramental phrase, right? And we won’t get five or six votes.
Mikhail Sokolov:
The Union of Right Forces may have the majority, not the Communists.
Konstantin Titov:
And the Union of Right Forces, you know, which is in the Duma today, seems to be friends with the authorities. And, I think - for your health. Let him be friends.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Well, are you going to...
Konstantin Titov:
I don't criticize them for this.
Mikhail Sokolov:
So you are going to create a new party together with Yabloko if it surrenders to you?
Konstantin Titov:
In general, the idea is interesting. It's worth thinking about. I'm not ready for that answer right now. I like the ideology of the Union of Right Forces, I like that I worked for nine years according to this ideology, and something worked out for me. I am not ready to leave the Union of Right Forces.
Mikhail Sokolov:
But you don't like the fact that he didn't support you.
Konstantin Titov:
But not only did he not support me, but he also did not support Putin. Because everyone is silent. The Union of Right Forces did not support Putin and Titov. And, by the way, not the Union of Right Forces, but the Coordination Council. I can name the names of members of the Coordination Council who did not support Putin and did not support Titov.
Mikhail Sokolov:
And they didn’t convene a congress.
Konstantin Titov:
And they didn’t convene a congress. Name it?
Mikhail Sokolov:
Yes, everyone knows.
Konstantin Titov:
Everyone knows, right? OK then. Since everyone knows, I’ll repeat it so that it’s better remembered. This is Mr. Gaidar, Mr. Kiriyenko, Mr. Nemtsov, Mr. Titov, Ms. Khakamada, Mr. Chubais.
Mikhail Sokolov:
You said that you are against the appointment of governors, but the Center should have the right to remove them? Well, at least through the courts, if there are any, again, violations of the law and the Constitution? Now there is no such right.
Konstantin Titov:
The charter of the Samara region states that if the governor has violated the law, the prosecutor has the right to initiate administrative or criminal prosecution. He appeals to the provincial Duma, it makes a decision, and the case is sent to court. Or he doesn’t make a decision, the prosecutor still has the right to take it to court. And after a court decision or a decision of the Duma, if this is a criminal offense, then only the decision of the Duma is sufficient. If this is an administrative violation, then it is a referendum. And he is freed. All. No problem.
And this is true throughout the civilized world. Bill Clinton is a great friend of Boris Nikolayevich Yeltsin, right? "Good guy Bill," right? Now, he was the governor of Arkansas. Do you remember in the 1960s when the black-white coeducational law came out, right? Well, it was this state and the governor of this state that were “against”. I don't remember who was the President of the United States of America back then, right? He brought troops - there are guardsmen - into the territory of the state, and black children, under the protection, under the protection of these troops, went to school. So that there were no dangers, there was nothing.
At this moment, an investigation was underway. Federal and state prosecutors were determining whether the state governor broke the law. And it turned out that the state governor did not break the law. Because a federal law was issued, and in the state of Arkansas, this federal law has not yet taken effect. But the federal law triumphed because it is superior. Why - higher? Not because it is federal. But because the law is aimed at protecting human rights and freedoms against racial discrimination.
Now, when we have such laws, perhaps we will also.... Well, we need to write such laws.
Let's return to Grigory Alekseevich. He knows the US economy very well. He knows the law of the United States of America very well. Well, we need such laws.
Mikhail Sokolov:
And yet, are you in favor of having a universal mechanism like you have in the Samara region?
Konstantin Titov:
I believe that there must be such a mechanism. Position of checks and balances. The first leader should not bury himself. No way. There must be such a mechanism.
But if the president or prime minister, let’s say, doesn’t like the governor for some reason, then they are obliged to file this petition only through the court.
Mikhail Sokolov:
What should be done in Chechnya at the moment, when it is announced that the anti-terrorist operation (as some believe, and others believe that it is a big war) is ending?
Konstantin Titov:
Nothing is over, as you and I can see. Therefore, politicians must sit down at the negotiating table.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Mikhail Sokolov is at the microphone. We talked with Russian presidential candidate Konstantin Titov.
One of the most noticeable events of the past week for those who are trying to predict the course of Vladimir Putin’s economic policy was the trip of the Russian head of state to Surgut. Here, in the oil-bearing Khanty-Mansiysk Okrug, acting. the President communicated with the owners of Russian mineral resources.
Putin, who was generally neutral, eventually made it clear to the oil and gas barons and energy workers that he was on the side of the production workers, not the bureaucrats.
Vladimir Putin's trip to Surgut became an expensive gift for the head of the Khanty-Mansiysk Okrug, Alexander Filipenko, because on March 26, gubernatorial elections will be held in the district.
The economic observer of the Moscow edition of Radio Liberty, Elmar Murtazaev, tells the story.
Elmar Murtazaev:
The election of the head of the regional executive branch is an outwardly ordinary event for the federal center. However, in this case, this rule does not apply. A lot depends on who and how will be elected in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug. The fact is that the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug, or KhMAO, as residents of the region call it for short, is, in fact, the main source of money for the entire Russian treasury. INTERFAX agency columnist Nikolai Sidorov talks about the significance of this region.
Nikolay Sidorov:
In order to imagine the importance of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug, for example, for the Russian oil industry and the economy as a whole, you need to imagine the importance of the oil industry for the Russian economy, on which, in fact, it now rests. Over 50 percent of budget revenues come from the fuel and energy sector. Therefore, naturally, the Khanty-Mansiysk Okrug, in which, in fact, all the major large Russian oil-producing companies are concentrated, plays a fairly important role here. Well, it’s enough to give some numbers.
In February, Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug celebrates the production of its seven billionth ton of oil in just over forty years. This is a huge figure, which, as Filipenko recently said at a press conference, is not even believable.
In general, over 55 percent of Russian oil is produced in Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug. And production in Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug accounts for about 5 percent of all global oil production on Earth.
At the same time, 80 percent of the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug's economy is made up of the oil and gas sector. Almost all major Russian oil companies operate there - LUKoil, YUKOS, Surgutneftegaz, TNK, Sibneft. In general, in Soviet times, about 370 million tons of oil per year were produced in the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug, and now, in general, about three hundred million tons of oil are produced in Russia, and about 170 million tons were produced in the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug, according to the results of 1999.
Elmar Murtazaev:
Control over the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug ensures not only the votes and loyalty of the three million residents of this region. Something else is more important. The governor of Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug today is, in fact, one of the main regulators of the Russian oil market. Almost all of Russia's leading oil companies operate in the district - LUKoil, YUKOS, Surgutneftegaz, TNK, Sibneft and Slavneft.
Nikolai Sidorov talks about the importance of the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug for oil workers.
Nikolay Sidorov:
In general, it must be said that all major Russian oil companies operate in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug. Just look at their names. The largest Russian oil company, in fact, in terms of production, LUKoil, got its name from three Khanty-Mansi cities - Longipas, Urai and Kagalym, where its main fields are located.
The name of YUKOS traces the name of the city of Nefteyugansk, located in the Khanty-Mansiysk Okrug. The Surgutneftegaz company has concentrated one hundred percent of its production capacity in the Surgut region. The main production divisions of the Tyumen Oil Company are located in the Nizhnevartovsk area. "Megionneftegaz" is a Khanty-Mansiysk city. This is the oil company Slavneft with production of approximately eleven million tons per year. This is the entire production of Slavneft.
Also in Khanty-Mansiysk there is the famous Samotlor field, which began to be developed back in 1965, and today its reserves amount to about one billion tons of oil. True - with a water cut of 90 percent. That is, their extraction is quite difficult now. But at one time, in the 1980s, the entire Soviet Union practically lived on Samotlor. As they say, the 80 Olympics were held with this money.
Now LUKoil is trying to differentiate its production and is developing projects in the north of the Caspian Sea and in Komi. This is one of the most aggressive Russian companies, trying to extract as much oil as possible outside Western Siberia, since production there is still quite expensive. And yet, today LUKoil produces about 50 million tons of oil in the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug, and only about 14 million tons in European Russia and in its foreign projects.
Elmar Murtazaev:
Thus, elections in the district are interesting not even from the point of view of control over voters, but rather for influencing the leaders of the Russian fuel and energy complex.
Almost all the heads of oil companies, especially the head of LUKoil Vagit Alekperov, the owner of Sibneft Roman Abramovich and the head of YUKOS Mikhail Khodorkovsky are Russian oligarchs and seriously influence the federal government. That is why both the presidential administration and government officials are following the elections for the governor of Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug with such passion.
Meanwhile, the elections seem to be taking place according to a pre-written script. To date, there are seven candidates for the post of head of the regional executive power. This is a temporarily unemployed resident of Tyumen Valery Abramov, again, a temporarily unemployed Evgeny Ostapenko, living in the city of Lyubertsy, vice-president of the association of reserve officers Alexander Chusvitin, rector of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug Sergey Solovyov and head of the ordinary department of the Yukos division Sergey Kravets.
All of them are little known and do not have serious financial support from local oil workers, and are also practically uninteresting to the federal authorities. The head of the Russian Party of Pensioners, Sergei Otroshenko, who has already managed to hold several noisy press conferences, also ran for election in the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug. The “main pensioner of the country” sharply criticized the policies of the current governor Alexander Filipenko. In his opinion, Filipenko refused additional fees in favor of the regional budget. He himself proposes to introduce a five percent deduction from oil and gas production in favor of the district. The proposal is very exotic and populist, but, by and large, it is practically impossible to implement, since it contradicts the tax code and common sense. Oil workers will still not pay new taxes, successfully escaping the additional tax burden to offshore companies.
Otroshenko’s desire to become governor, meanwhile, looks all the more strange since at one time he headed a bankrupt bank, after the “death” of which many defrauded depositors remained in the district.
As representatives of oil companies testify, Otroshenko’s appearance is the purest impromptu of a poppy Moscow politician, which will not in any way affect the results of the upcoming vote. It will not be reflected because the winner of the election race is already obvious.
This is the current governor Alexander Filipenko. A survey by sociologists at Surgut State University, conducted three weeks before the elections, showed that the absolute majority of voters in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug - 82 percent - are confident in Filipenko's victory.
When asked about the need to change the governor, only 12 percent of voters answered positively, while more than 73 percent voted for maintaining the current government.
Meanwhile, in the last elections for the head of the region in 1996, Filipenko received 71 percent of the votes. According to experts, in the current elections Alexander Filipenko is quite capable of overriding this result. The governor’s position looks so strong that long before the elections, very influential and well-known officials gave up the idea of encroaching on Filipenko’s post.
So, for example, it was rumored that both the Minister of Fuel and Energy, Viktor Kalyuzhny, and the governor of the neighboring, dominant Tyumen region, Leonid Roketsky, aspired to become the governor of the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug. Each of these politicians has good connections with oil companies and actively lobbies their interests. Kalyuzhny is considered one of Abramovich’s people, and Roketsky has long been associated with the Tyumen Oil Company. However, even a superficial monitoring of the situation in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug convinced both politicians of the futility of their claims to the governor’s chair.
What is Filipenko's secret? First of all, in his caution. Working as the head of a region where such global interests intersect, he manages to maintain his neutrality, benefiting from any oil conflict. Filipenko successfully uses the region's resources to put pressure on the oil industry. Firstly, it is the regional authorities that issue licenses for the development of new deposits. Since most companies operate in old fields, the development of new resources is vital for them. In addition, Filipenko successfully uses local taxes, providing benefits for their payment - depending on the political and economic situation.
Thanks to these measures, the governor of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug became a real arbiter in disputes between oil workers. As Deputy Minister of Fuel and Energy Ruslan Garipov once publicly admitted: “We often come to Filipenko, almost tearing each other’s hair out, and he makes peace between us.” If you consider how many conflicts the governor has to resolve, it becomes clear where Filipenko gets so much opportunity and influence.
Nikolai Sidorov talks about the most noisy disputes between oil companies.
Nikolay Sidorov:
The most noisy story, of course, concerns the conflict between the international company BP-Amoco and the Tyumen Oil Company. It concerns the problem of the Tyumen Oil Company's takeover of a number of Sidanco subsidiaries through bankruptcy proceedings. Well, this has already been said a lot and repeatedly that the bankruptcy procedure is quite imperfect in the Russian Federation, the legislative framework is quite imperfect.
Naturally, the administration of Khanty-Mansiysk has always opposed such things, but, nevertheless, the practice is very widespread in the Khanty-Mansiysk Okrug, but not due to the position of the administration, but, let’s say, due to the fact that it is there, as mentioned above, that the interests of all the largest Russian oil companies intersect.
And so, such a conflict arose last year around two subsidiaries of the Sidanco oil company. These are Chernogorneft and Kont-petroleum. Chernogorneft is one of the largest companies in Sidanco. It produces almost eight and a half million tons of oil, and TNK carried out a bankruptcy procedure for the company at the request of not only the regional authorities, but some local organization began bankruptcy. Then the companies went bankrupt and were sold at auction, and they were bought by TNK.
For BP-Amoco, which owns 10 percent of the shares of Sidanco, which, naturally, did not want to lose its money (these are one of the largest oil-producing enterprises), the conflict even reached the level of the US State Department. Until now, TNK cannot receive a loan from the US Eximbank, promised to it for the modernization of the Ryazan oil refinery and the development of Samotlor.
Elmar Murtazaev:
According to its objective indicators, the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug is a very developed region. Its residents traditionally vote for centrist and right-wing parties. This is explained not only by the relatively high standard of living of voters. The fact is that the vast majority of residents work at export-oriented enterprises, be it oil production or logging companies.
They, like their owners, need an open economy that provides their companies, region and families with currency. Hence the very market orientation of the head of the region.
Here, for example, is how the governor speaks out on the subject of tightening the rules for regulating the oil market - an idea that is promoted by many Russian officials and left-wing politicians.
Alexander Filipenko:
I don't think monopoly is a help in solving these issues. Concentration of funds and opportunities - yes, but to a certain extent. Because this is not the main path for the development of the oil industry. And even in the United States, and in any other countries, along with the existence of some supergiants, there is a huge number of so-called independent oil companies, which each do their own thing... and add their own diversity... and it seems to me that they balance everything, that is, they create stability.
This, I think, is very important, and therefore the only way to reduce it to the problem is - the more, the better. The only thing is that I don’t understand control methods using directives. Well, for example, decide that a liter of gasoline will cost one and a half dollars, or some rubles, or something else. Now, I don’t accept such methods.
And I accept economic methods of influencing the economy. But to do this, we really need to weigh what the state needs, on what scale, and at what prices. If suddenly the state, for example, needs petroleum products that are two times cheaper than they are on the market today, then the state must, accordingly, build a mechanism to compensate for the costs incurred by producers in producing these petroleum products.
That is, this is not a mechanism of simple restrictions, of course. Economic mechanism of influence. I emphasize - influences.
Elmar Murtazaev:
The predetermined outcome of the upcoming elections also affects Filipenko’s relations with the federal center. During his recent trip to Surgut, Vladimir Putin abandoned the traditional scenarios of agitation and propaganda. Unlike, for example, a trip to the Krasnodar Territory, where the Prime President carefully sorted through feed grains, or a visit to Ivanovo, where Putin routinely smiled at the noble weavers, in Surgut the head of state concentrated on meetings with district leaders and representatives of local companies and enterprises.
Mutual “probing” took place in the best traditions of the party-Soviet genre. Putin bowed to the oil workers, talking about their special situation in Russia. They, in turn, swore allegiance to the successor of the party in power.
Seeking the loyalty of the oil generals, Putin took an unconventional step. He gave a public flogging to the Minister of Fuel and Energy, Viktor Kalyuzhny, who causes persistent rejection among the heads of oil companies. The minister was accused of connivance in the fight against oil exporters.
It is very characteristic that almost all of Putin’s meetings in Surgut, both in a wide and narrow circle, took place in the presence of Filipenko. According to officials familiar with the rules of bureaucratic etiquette, this is a sign of special trust. Filipenko, in turn, showers Putin with compliments at every opportunity.
Alexander Filipenko:
Vladimir Putin and... or someone else who has become the head of Russia simply cannot ignore the fact that the Khanty-Mansiysk Okrug today is the main fuel and energy base of the Russian Federation. From what I have already heard and am hearing from Vladimir Vladimirovich, I feel that he understands. For example, when he says the following phrase: “Yes, of course, oil workers are rich companies, and we need to take taxes from them somehow, but don’t forget that if we put too much emphasis on this, then there will be no one else to take taxes from.”
Elmar Murtazaev:
In the case of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug, the blessing of the federal center is an important, but not the decisive factor in victory. The opinion of oil workers is no less important. However, the governor will not have any special problems here either. Almost all the heads of oil companies operating in Khanty-Mansiysk have already spoken out in support of Filipenko.
It seems that the Russian oil kings have decided to act on the principle of the least evil. Filipenko, despite his very independent positions, is a fairly predictable and calm governor. This means that the elections on March 26 in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug may simply become a legitimization of the existing situation for Filipenko.
Here, for example, is what the current governor answered when asked by Radio Liberty about the upcoming elections.
Alexander Filipenko:
I'm not involved in elections. I am the current governor. I’m working, and I don’t intend, in any case, to leave this post. Therefore, if you are interested, ask questions as the governor of the autonomous region. When I have pre-election meetings - maybe there will be - you will ask different questions.
Elmar Murtazaev:
Filipenko is right. In the current conditions, when the outcome of the elections is predetermined, one should not think about the elections. Today, elections for the governor are, albeit complex, but still a procedural issue.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Elmar Murtazaev, an economic observer for the Moscow edition of Radio Liberty, spoke about the election of the governor of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug.
A lot of new things happened in Saratov during the gubernatorial elections. World pop star, violinist Vanessa May took part in the election campaign of the head of the region, Dmitry Ayatskov.
The main rival of the communist governor, Valery Razhkin, has a different music. Disqualified from participating in the elections, he is trying to defend his rights through the courts.
Radio Liberty special correspondent Karen Agamirov reports.
Karen Agamirov:
The removal of Valery Razhkin from participation in the elections by the regional election commission did not become a sensation. In a conversation with me, the editor-in-chief of the Volga News Agency Ilya Malyakin predicted.
Ilya Malyakin:
According to available data, the bet is on keeping him out of the election campaign altogether.
Karen Agamirov:
And so it happened: the leader of the Saratov communists was charged with too many false signature sheets. Razhkin went to court.
Valery Razhkin:
On March 3 we filed a complaint. It was accepted by the court. The law requires that the court investigate and make a decision within ten days. I collected one hundred and twenty thousand signatures, we handed over fifty, the rest are lying there; and all of them are true. All are true. This is a real provocation... of the so-called black, dirty technologies for which the Saratov region is once again famous.
Karen Agamirov:
But on television, Valery Fedorovich, they showed that the date of birth and the date of issue of the passport coincide in your signature sheets in many cases.
Valery Razhkin:
I do not rule out that somewhere... can you imagine what one hundred and twenty thousand signatures are? Somewhere, the person who filled out the fields “date of passport issue” and “date of signature” could simply have made a mistake. That is, the very 15 percent of false information in the law that is allowed.
Karen Agamirov:
But the fact that there were a lot of names crossed out, there were a lot of different corrections?
Valery Razhkin:
A lot has been crossed out, and corrections need to be sorted out. We need an expert assessment of who did this. I do not exclude the possibility that this could have been done by the election commission. Until now, the election commission has not yet provided us with signature sheets, even through the court, so that we can do an analysis.
Karen Agamirov:
But are you sure that you have no more than 15 percent?
Valery Razhkin:
Convinced. I am categorically convinced that our subscription lists are valid, and there are less than 15 percent of false information. In the practice of collecting signatures in our support, since 1993, we have not had more than 4-8 percent. Seven years. And this just happened today, considering I'm running for governor.
Our opinion polls show that the governor does not gain even 25 percent. This shocked them. This scared them. And they found a way out in preparing and conducting the election campaign without the main competitor, without Valery Fedorovich Razhkin.
Karen Agamirov:
That is, you are not losing hope that you will still be registered?
Valery Razhkin:
I am deeply convinced. In the Saratov region, at least, this is problematic. Here our situation is such that all law enforcement agencies, starting with the prosecutor's office, the Internal Affairs Directorate, and the courts, are subordinate to a single figure - the governor. This is a dictatorial established government. It will be difficult to win in the regional court. But the Supreme Court is one hundred percent convinced: we will win.
Karen Agamirov:
Nevertheless, Saratov experts insist - even if State Duma deputy, head of the regional organization of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation Valery Razhkin takes part in the elections....
Ilya Malyakin:
There is that ceiling, the number of those who voted for the communists during the Duma elections is about 30 percent, with a little. This is what he can really count on to the maximum.
Karen Agamirov:
In any case, with or without Razhkin,” summed up the editor-in-chief of the Volga News Agency Ilya Malyakin, “Dmitry Ayatskov wins in the first round. He was and remains the most cheerful Russian governor.
Dmitry Ayatskov:
I love speed. I have the best snowmobile, I have the fastest boat. I have the best car. So, my dream is to have the fastest personal plane. I think that someday I will have such a plane. I love risk.
I have a huge collection of watches, about one and a half thousand. I love looking at them. There are at least two dozen clocks on my desk. I am constantly adding to my collection.
I love to read. I love working with children. I think that in the near future I will study with my grandchildren. Whenever possible, I go out into nature. I love women. I like to drink. I like to joke. A small patient comes to the doctor, puts the device on the table and says: “Doctor, cut off half.” He says: “Look how beautiful it is. Why cut it?” He says: “Well, that’s the problem. He gets up - I fall.”
Karen Agamirov:
And the people in Saratov are no strangers to humor.
Resident: Monitoring our government is a very, very big thing.... Ridiculous.
Karen Agamirov:
The Saratov region elects a governor.
Mikhail Sokolov:
It was a report by Radio Liberty special correspondent Karen Agamirov about the elections for governor of the Saratov region.
In the next issue, March 16 - Vyatka before the gubernatorial elections.