"Spades of Aesculapius" - modern medicine and healthcare
Leading Evgeny Muslin
You are listening to the program "Spades of Aesculapius - Modern Medicine and Healthcare." Improving the diagnosis of mitral valve lesions, a new point of view on fat in a diet, as well as the latest medical news - these are the topics of our program today.
More recently, the insufficiency of the mitral valve of the heart was considered a frequent and extremely dangerous disease that affects people of all ages. But lately, the look at this disease has changed significantly. We asked to talk about the reasons for these changes to Professor D. Golubev.
Golubev:
The mitral valve separates the left atrium from the left ventricle of the heart, hermetically “clogging” the atrium after the blood passed from it into the ventricle. In case of certain deformations of the valve, that is, its failure after reducing the left ventricle, the blood partially again enters the atrium, which leads to a wide variety of pathological manifestations. The patient may experience pain in the chest cavity, he can have difficult or weakened breathing, but sometimes he does not experience any unpleasant sensations and is considered healthy until he has a valve failure during a special examination. It should also be noted that these symptoms can occur in other diseases that are in no way related to the pathology of the heart valves, so that the correct diagnosis is absolutely necessary in these cases.
For many decades, it has been believed that the defeat of mitral valves is an extremely widespread state, which leads to the development of heart failure, violation of heart rate rhythm, strokes, infectious processes and other complications. Experts believed that the indicated disease is affected by 14 to 28 million Americans. I repeat: this was the opinion of experts over the past decades, but in the very recent time data have been obtained that allow you to look at all this problem completely differently.
Muslin:
What kind of given are we talking about?
Golubev:
We are talking about a study conducted by a group of employees of the Yale University and Harvard Medical School under the leadership of Dr. Lisa Fried. As you know, the number of diagnoses “Mitral Cream deficiency” began to increase sharply from the late 70s and early 80s, when equipment for ultrasound cardiological diagnosis appeared and introduced into wide practice, which allows to quickly diagnose heart lesions. Most often, the so -called echocardiography is used for these purposes, and it is on its basis that all this information was obtained about many millions of Americans, patients with the insufficiency of the mitral valve. The main conclusion of the Harvard scientists group is that the standard procedure for echocardiography leads to obvious hyperdiagnosis of the disease, giving false positive results. This is how Dr. Emilia Venjamin, the leading clinician cardiologist of the group of Dr. Frid, characterizes the situation. The first task of the Harvard group of cattle improvement of the technique of echocardiographic diagnostics in order to reduce the number of false positive results. Based on the improved technology, the true number of patients with mitral failure was revealed, and the results were sharply different from what until recently seemed indisputable.
Muslin:
What are the results of the application of advanced diagnostic technique?
Golubev:
Scientists under the leadership of Dr. Fried examined three and a half thousand people who had a suspicion of the mitral valve pathology. The true failure of the valve was detected only in 84 people, that is, 2.4 percent of the total number of examined. Moreover, these 84 people have the frequency of formidable complications, which are considered mandatory "fellow travelers" of the defect of the mitral valve, did not exceed the control background, that is, what is observed in any other group of people of this age. The previous ideas that this disease more often affects women than men was also not confirmed. Among the identified patients, men and women were equally represented. If you summarize the data obtained, it turns out that no more than 15 percent of patients from among those who still have “yesterday” was considered indisputable suffer in the true mitral vice.
Muslin:
And what should these, so to speak, “imaginary” patients do? After all, something made them see a doctor?
Golubev:
This question is answered by Dr. Claude Lenfant, director of the Institute of Heart, Light and Blood. In his opinion, such patients should again turn to their cardiologist to continue the examination and make a true diagnosis. For those who have obvious pathological manifestations, which are considered complications of mitral failure, it is necessary to continue treatment with antibiotics, since infectious layers are very frequent with one or another heart lesion. In general, Dr. Lenfant called the data received by Dr. Fried and her colleagues very impressive. He even used the term "irresistible" in relation to them.
Muslin:
Please tell me, what is the reason for such a striking differences in the new results from the seemingly established ideas about the frequency of the spread of mitral failure? After all, we are talking about differences 6-7 times? Is it only a matter of the errors of diagnostic techniques?
Golubev:
No, and not only. Dr. Fried and Dr. Venjamin believe that largely hyperdiagnosis of mitral deficiency was associated with the psychological attitudes of doctors, who, as expressed by “enthusiasm”, reacted to the possibilities of diagnosing this disease using echocardiography. Within the framework of a specialized cardiological program conducted in Massachusetts, the results of which were recently published by doctors Fried, Venjamin and their colleagues in the authoritative "Medical Journal of New England", managed to "put everything in place" and identify the true frequency of this specific cardiac pathology. In all cases where this diagnosis is not confirmed, and a certain pathology is available, it is necessary to continue the diagnostic examination to clarify the diagnosis. Very often in such unclear cases, the diagnosis is completely different. Especially often, in particular, the syndrome of chronic fatigue is revealed, which has nothing to do with mitral insufficiency.
Muslin:
What is the place of fat in our daily menu? The answer to this question is not as simple as it still seemed.
Ivanov:
So avocados, walnuts, oil gravy, oily fish, vegetable soot and many products on Margarine in the near future, apparently, will return to the menu of Americans who are concerned about their health and weight. The latest surveys in the field of food make such an assumption very believable.
For thirty years, the Americans were convinced by the less fat: then they will keep their heart and a slender waist. But, despite the fact that over these thirty years, the number of calories obtained from fat has decreased in the total balance from forty -four percent to thirty, neither slender waists, nor healthy hearts were added. Rather, on the contrary. Once, a cardiologist and nutritionist Dean Ornish in his bestseller, there is more - to weigh less "called for reducing the amount of fat consumption to ten percent and not to lean on sweet and flour, in which America left far behind all developed countries. But those who tried to rest his call, found that he was unreal. A decrease in fat consumption increases the craving for sweet and flour.
Now, specialists in the field of nutrition and combat of obesity put forward a new idea that is directly opposite to the previous one. The first swallow was the book of Professor Richard Klein, “Eat Fat” (“Eat Fat”), which produced some sensation two years ago. But the Swallow did not make spring: the author hit the extremes, and in such cases the reader only shrugs, but the advice should not. "Fat Fat Floor" - this is the new slogan of today's nutritionists. This is already clear, it is worth listening to this.
What made the Americans stand sweet and flour?
It is "the flight from the fat, which, unfortunately, has accepted the form of insanity," say well -known nutritionists Robert Atkins and Barry Sifs. Sensitive to such trends, the food industry flooded the country with products with a reduced combination of fat or without it, unable to satisfy appetite. Small cookies, low -fat cakes, low -fat cottage cheese - all fat -free, but all with a monstrous amount of carbohydrates, that is, the same calories. Caloria then from degrease has become no less, but more. Nobody thought about carbohydrates, as about fat substitutes. Meanwhile, they continue Atkins and SIFS, it is more logical to include potatoes, not lard in the list of killer products. You can’t eat a lot of fat, and it is easy to eat potatoes and half a kilo. And these are pure carbohydrates. Those who want to lose weight should avoid not fat, but carbohydrates.
Margo Denke, professor of endocrinology at the Dallas Medical Center of Texas University, agrees with Atkins and Sirs. “It doesn’t matter,” she says, “where are calories from fat or from carbohydrates. Studying metabolism shows that only their total number shows. Therefore, to consider how much you have eaten“ fat ”calories, not paying attention to carbohydrates - a complete nonsense and dense ignorance. From this, of course, you should now put on fat. With food, not sugar and starch (potatoes - continuous starch!), But less high -calorie fruits and vegetables, which, incidentally, contain everything that the body needs. "
Robert Eckel, chairman of the US Association and Professor of Medicine and Physiology at Colorado University, also speaks of fruits and vegetables, about various legumes. First of all, he notes, this food is useful for the cardiovascular system. It plays a significant role in the prevention of heart attacks, strokes, as well as obesity and cancer. Meanwhile, according to a massive survey conducted in 1997, an institute of the food market, out of fifty-six percent of customers who cut off the consumption of fat, only fifteen percent began to eat more low-calorie fruits and vegetables. The remaining forty -one percent admitted that they increased the consumption of bread, potatoes and confectionery.
Even people with a high level of cholesterol do not have to strive for fat -free food in order to protect their heart. Dr. Robert Knopp and his colleagues from the University of Washington in Seattle examined four hundred and forty men with a high level of the so-called "poor" low density cholesterol and found that the reduction of "fat" calories from only thirty-five percent to thirty and the use of saturated fats within seven percent of their total amounts, reduces the level of cholesterol not cholesterol. Worse than a diet with a reduced fat content. This content cannot be reduced thoughtlessly and too radically. The same studies have shown that if the consumption of “fat” calories falls up to twenty percent, then the level of “good” high density cholesterol that protects the heart and the level of triglycerides are growing with them.
Almost all the diets that are used to slow down, leave people hungry, continues the topic of compensation for the fat shortage of Mary Flynn, a food specialist from the University of Brown. People walk hungry all the time, pounce on any food and overeat. Recently, Flynn, along with Dr. Kevin Vizhylate, released a book under the eloquent name: "Low -fat lies, fatty deceives." “Fat makes many dishes tastier,” says this book, “and gives you a feeling of satiety. If your diet is delicious, then it is viable. A little fat, and you will want to eat all the time. The only question is, which fat to choose.”
In one of the latest issues of the magazine "Pediatrics" a report on the study of twelve suffering from obesity of boys was published. It is clear that food, in which there are few fats, but a lot of carbohydrates, is much more likely to cause hunger, and this feeling is much sharper than with a diet of more fat, but the same calorie content. David Ludwig from the Harvard Medical School and the Children's Hospital in Boston is convinced that the steady increase in the share of fat children owes his origin to high -calorie hamburgers, buns, and especially “syriala” - milk porridge, which got used to breakfasting half the American.
The Association of Cardiologists is now preparing a special guide for nutritionists and consumers of diets, which will say about the desirable percentage of "fat" calories, but at the same time, recommendations are given to limit saturated (satulated) fats. Over the past twenty years, the association has repeatedly issued such recommendations, advising healthy people to limit the consumption of “fat” calories thirty percent, withdrawing no more than ten percent of them with rich fats and less than ten percent of polyunsaturated. The remaining ten percent should be mono -saturated fats, to which olive oil belongs, as well as canols and avocados oil.
The association recommends, in particular, the Mediterranean diet, rich in vegetables, fish and olive oil. “With such a diet, you can afford more than thirty percent of the“ fat ”calories,” says Dr. Eckel, “but do not forget that it is not only about food, but also in the lifestyle. Residents of the Mediterranean lead a more mobile life than we, and this protects their cardiovascular system from heart attacks than olive oil.”
Passing the consumption of fats, you risk depriving the body of vital substances, for example, vitamins A, D, E and K, soluble in fat. For this, we need unsaturated fats from vegetables and any sea living creatures. They also supply us with fatty acids, on which the production of hormones and nerve cells depends. There were also indisputable evidence that unsaturated fatty acids protect the body from dangerous diseases. Studies conducted in Italy, Spain, Greece, Sweden and the USA have shown that olive oil reduces the risk of breast cancer and is very useful for the brain. Unrefined olive oil, writes the journal "Neurology", referring to the study of Italian scientists, has a beneficial effect on the cognitive functions of the brain in the elderly.
Fat - fat. Cardiologists examined eighty thousand women aged thirty -four to fifty -nine years and came to the conclusion that fat consumption is basically not related to coronary risk. Only consumers of saturated fats, which are rich in meat and dairy products, risk: every five percent of calories from them increase the risk of acquiring heart disease by seventeen percent. Margarine, obtained by the transformation of beneficial vegetable fats into a solid shape, is also dangerous in this regard. Every two percent of the "fat" calories in this case, the coronary risk in women sometimes almost doubles.
Polyunsaturated fatty acids of the Omega-3 type contained in fish protect the heart, especially from a sudden stop. The fact is that fish oils prevent blood clots and a violation of heart rhythm, and also increase the level of “good” cholesterol. Some Dutch and American scientists claim that men who eat fish twice a week half reduce the risk of heart attack.
In the oils of canols, soy, walnut, linseed seed and in many vegetables with dark green leaves there is a different type of "omega-3". He also protects his heart from a sudden stop. This was proved by scientists from the Harvard School of Public Health, who examined seventy -six thousand women. Thanks to this acid, the risk of heart attack decreases half. “Fat is perceived as an enemy,” says Dr. Frank Hu, who led this examination. “But this is a delusion. Some fats are harmful, while others are useful and necessary. That's the truth.”
Muslin:
And in the conclusion of our transfer, an interesting message about the features of heart attacks in women.
At the age of fifty years, heart attacks in women happen much less often than in men. But if they still occur, then they entail the danger of death for women twice as often than for men.
Doctors have long known that women tolerate heart attacks worse than men, but it was still not known that at a relatively young age the difference is so great. Over the years, mortality in women from heart attacks falls, and in men it grows, compared by about 75 years of age. What is explained, is still unknown, but the study of diseases of almost four hundred thousand infarctic, treated in one and a half thousand American hospitals, shows that young women require increased care and attention after a heart attack. An extensive study on this issue is published in the authoritative "Medical Journal of New England."
In women, as a rule, after heart attacks, the heart muscle weakens more, blood pressure drops, and cardiograms give a very obscure picture. Кроме того, у женщин обычно больше осложнений при последующем лечении, особенно кровотечений от разжижающих кровь лекарств. К тому же и первопричины инфарктов у женщин не те, что у мужчин. У мужчин это чаще всего закупоривание артерий, а у женщин - кровяные тромбы и артериальные спазмы.
Руководитель исследования, о котором идет речь, эпидемиолог из Йельского университета доктор Виола Виккарино считает, что молодые женщины должны обращать больше внимания на такие факторы кардиологического риска, как высокое кровяное давление, высокий уровень холестерина в крови и диабет. Особенно это касается женщин с плохой кардиологической наследственностью.
Доктор Джудит Гохман, руководящая кардиологическими исследованиями в нью-йоркском Рузвельтовском медицинском центре, находит, что у женщин часто не наблюдаются при инфарктах такие типичные синдромы, как, например, грудные боли. Они чувствуют только одышку и дискомфорт в верхней части брюшной полости.
Что же касается повышенной смертности женщин по сравнению с мужчинами от инфарктов, то доктор Виккарино частично объясняет ее тремя факторами. Во-первых, у женщин-инфарктниц, как правило, чаще имеются такие отягчающие обстоятельства, как диабет и инсульты. Кроме того, женщины обычно с опозданием обращаются за медицинской помощью, да и в больнице меньшая вероятность того, что врачи сразу станут предполагать у них инфаркт и примут соответствующие меры, то есть, начнут им давать бета-блокеры, аспирин и другие лекарства - разжижители крови.
Но как бы там ни было, считает доктор Виккарино, необходимы дополнительные исследования для лучшего понимания большего риска и разработки более эффективных кардиологических терапий для молодых женщин. Ибо симптомы и принятые сейчас методы лечения этих больных основываются на наших знаниях, полученных при лечении либо мужчин, либо женщин старших возрастов.