
Presenter Mikhail Sokolov
Mikhail Sokolov:
The weekly program of the Moscow edition of Radio Liberty "Elections-99" is on air. The program is hosted by Mikhail Sokolov.
Russian Prime Minister Yevgeny Primakov said that he considers it necessary to abandon the election of governors by the population. Let the head of the region be elected, on the proposal of the president, by the local legislative assembly. This idea has long been put forward by communist leader Gennady Zyuganov. The rejection of the principles of democracy is presented as an opportunity to restore the vertical of state power. A simple option is being ignored - to provide the central government with the opportunity in the Supreme Court to seek the removal from their posts of those leaders who violate the law and the constitution.
But in fact, the prime minister does not set the task of fighting separatism. His practical activities condone the autocracy of leaders such as Yevgeny Nazdratenko or Ruslan Aushev. In fact, Primakov's proposal looks like a sounding board - is it possible, instead of electing the head of state in 2000, to take the path of elite collusion. Among the new and old nomenklatura, the idea of electing a new president, say Primakov, together with a vice-president, say Luzhkov, is becoming increasingly popular, and thus “freeze” Russian life for many years, keeping a coalition of national communists and state bureaucrats in power. National elections are scary. The economic crisis, plus new information technologies, can crush any reputation.
Before the parliamentary and presidential elections, the political struggle in Russia with the use of new technologies is intensifying. Another dose of compromising evidence was skillfully introduced into hyperspace. Moscow Mayor Yuri Luzhkov became a victim of an information attack on the new Internet site “Claw-2”. The leader of the Fatherland movement is accused of very dubious contacts with the Krasnoyarsk authoritative businessman Anatoly Bykov. Bykov is a former boxer, now the chairman of the board of directors of one of the largest in Siberia, the Krasnoyarsk aluminum plant. Owner of approximately 10 percent of the shares of this enterprise. Izvestia has written about him more than once as the leader of the local organized “sportsmanship”, nicknamed Bull, whose path to power and wealth is not paved with roses.
In Krasnoyarsk itself they like to remind guests of the Walk of Fame at the local honorary cemetery, where the most desperate “brothers” are laid to rest. A gigantic dossier of similar publications telling where the tycoon’s competitors went to eternal rest is also on the Kogot-2 website. But the “Claw” collection tells a lot of new things about the business relationship between a businessman, whose personal shadow income is $40-50 million a year, and the generals of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and State Security, many of whom are allegedly in the pay of the millionaire. The website contains, as it were, copies of payment documents, and Bykov’s account number abroad is named. There is also an address for his American office in New Jersey.
The rich man's villa with a helipad is described very impressively. It is interesting that the vice-president of the Siberian Aluminum group, which is Bykov’s competitors, German Tkachenko, in an interview with the Kommersant newspaper, remarked: “90 percent of what was published is true.” By the way, an investigative commission headed by First Deputy Minister of Internal Affairs of Russia Vladimir Kolesnikov is currently working in the region. Maybe she will figure out where the truth is and where the lie is.
As I was convinced, having recently visited KrAZ, Anatoly Bykov, deputy of the legislative assembly of the Krasnoyarsk Territory, is an extraordinary person. Now he was trying to create a giant monopoly that would unite Siberian coal miners, energy workers and metal producers. Bykov had previously supported Governor Lebed, but having become convinced that the general was poorly governed, he began to conflict with him. Now the Swan is rushing about. His choice is not easy - to use the help of Anatoly Chubais and some members of the federal government, for example, Vladimir Bulgak, who, through RAO EU of Russia, is paying off the debts of coal miners to Bykov's structures, demanding that controlling stakes in the debtors' enterprises be pledged to KrAZenergoservis. Or accept the fact that Anatoly Bykov will receive ownership of the largest coal mines in Siberia through the court for a penny debt. This battle is in full swing, so the general's supporters could have an interest in compromising their political opponent. From the lips of Mr. Bykov, I myself heard that Alexander Lebed and his team are interested in Krasnoyarsk only as a source of resources for the presidential campaign of 2000, but he, Bykov, is precisely concerned about the fate of his native land.
However, the industrialist’s enemies claim that Bykov is going to impeach the brave general fighting corruption, and he himself plans to be elected in his place, to the post of governor of the Krasnoyarsk Territory. By the way, in the elections to the regional legislative assembly in his native village of Nazarovo, Bykov received almost 90 percent of the votes... “The Krasnoyarsk Territory is becoming a testing ground where organized crime is practicing a model of ousting legitimate authorities from real levers of control.” This is a quote.
Now on the Internet on the foreign website www.krasnobykov.com, everyone can read that, I quote, “the regional administration and Governor Lebed personally have become objects of powerful pressure from local criminals seeking complete control over the region. At the same time, blackmail and bribery of officials, artificial creation of economic difficulties and outright terror are used.” An example is given - in December 1998, unknown persons kidnapped the deputy chairman of the regional property fund, Andrei Cherkashin, who was involved in the privatization of coal industry enterprises. Quote: “According to agents from Bykov’s entourage, the crime was committed by militants from Tatarenkov’s group in order to stop the leakage of information about the true state of affairs in the region’s coal industry, as well as to exert psychological pressure on Governor Lebed’s entourage and the region’s administration.
After describing Krasnoyarsk criminal horrors, true and imaginary, anonymous authors use a technique known as “amalgam”. The idea is being pursued: Bykov is an ally of Yuri Luzhkov. It is alleged that the head of the trade department in the Moscow government, Vladimir Malyshkov, allegedly had a number of confidential meetings with Bykov and his entourage during the boxing championship in Krasnoyarsk. Another quote: “criminal political forces opposing the federal center and destabilizing the situation in the regions have united around the financial economic support of the mayor of Moscow, the joint-stock financial corporation Sistema, headed by V.P. Evtushenkov.” It is reported that, I quote: “in 1998, Bykov managed to establish direct contact with the mayor of Moscow, Yu.M. Luzhkov. The formal reason was Luzhkov’s initiative for the development and extraction of marble in the region, and the construction of housing in the village of Shushenskoye.” As if facts of financial abuse on the part of the mayor of Moscow, Yuri Luzhkov, were revealed.
The previous theses were already refuted by the Deputy Prime Minister of the Moscow Government, Mr. Resin, in an interview with Komsomolskaya Pravda. The authors of this active event on the Internet conclude: using the confrontation between Luzhkov and Lebed, Bykov in November 1998, with the help of the Moscow mayor’s communications, managed to neutralize the most powerful check of the region’s special services by the federal center. And another story - Luzhkov allegedly liked the hunting lodge created by Bykov in the taiga reserve, where, I quote: “in 1998, both Luzhkov himself and his close “connections” began to come with rare consistency.” The names of Shoigu, Ilyushenko, and Yastrzhembsky are mentioned.
Deputy Prime Minister of the Moscow government Sergei Yastrzhembsky, having familiarized himself with “Kogtem-2”, gave an interview to Radio Liberty and said: “Be careful, provocation. As for me, this is complete nonsense, since I was in the Krasnoyarsk Territory only once with President Yeltsin. Despite all my love for hunting, I have not been to any hunting camp, I am not familiar with Bykov. I think that what was told about Yuri Mikhailovich Luzhkov is also “misconception”, said Sergei Yastrzhembsky and noted that it is worth conducting an investigation - who releases such “claws” on the Internet?
A pseudo-dossier on the famous analyst Sergei Kurginyan was published not so long ago in the first, also scandalous, full of intercepted telephone conversations of Russian politicians, issue of “Kogtya”. In the current “Claw-2”, Kurginyan is no longer named as Berezovsky’s person, but as a specialist whose political science center, which has access to the Ministry of Internal Affairs, allegedly provides support in the preparation of information and promotion in the media for Anatoly Bykov. Political scientist Sergei Kurginyan gave an interview to Radio Liberty.
How did you perceive the appearance of this site “Claw-2” and the information that affects you specifically?
Sergey Kurginyan:
I draw your attention to the fact that I am already the “gray eminence” of Berezovsky and at the same time the “gray eminence” of Luzhkov, as well as Zyuganov, and Yeltsin’s adviser on geopolitics. Since this is already beginning to resemble the old joke of the Brezhnev era - Leonid Ilyich’s nightmare: Czechs are sitting on Red Square and eating matzo with chopsticks - I approach this with a healthy, constructive sense of humor and the understanding that someone wants to create unrestrained advertising for me. These are elements of some kind of ill health, which may contain part of reality. I meet a lot of people.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Do you know Bykov?
Sergey Kurginyan:
Of course I do.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Tell me, how do you evaluate the quality of execution of this large-scale compromising evidence on the Internet?
Sergey Kurginyan:
I rate this quality as self-string.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Sergei Romanovich, but the point of this site “Claw-2” is to discredit Yuri Luzhkov, that the presidential candidate and Moscow mayor maintains business ties with Anatoly Bykov, a man whose past and present for the public after many publications in the press is not impeccable.
Sergey Kurginyan:
What does it mean to “maintain relationships”? What kind of relationship? Why does he support them? For example, I don’t know about this. Secondly, I myself do not maintain any strong relations with Luzhkov. I formally sympathize with him on many of his positions, but I do not maintain any relations with him. Therefore, since Kurginyan once met with Bykov, this means that Luzhkov is building a relationship with Kurginyan. And who says that Luzhkov has a relationship with Kurginyan? What gossip does all this come from? This is all some kind of cheap work, of very low quality.
Mikhail Sokolov:
And who benefits from all this?
Sergey Kurginyan:
Especially there was this first “Claw”, according to which it suddenly turned out that I, together with Berezovsky, “reduced Galina Vasilievna Starovoitova to a nail”. So, first of all, I say that this is a challenge, I seriously intend to wonder about who did this. The main demonic aspect of my deputy appears there all the time. They, since the people are very stupid, those who do this, are not very knowledgeable and are in a terrible hurry to achieve results faster... they all get exposed. There it turns out that our malicious plans are mine with Berezovsky, whom I saw six months ago, so what are they?.. To “destroy” Seleznev.
If you remember "Claw", there is the main idea that all our terrible machinations are with the goal of creating some kind of social democratic party and with this party destroying the great Seleznev. Firstly, I don’t understand how Seleznev can be “destroyed”, because in order to destroy him, he must first be created. But he is not there. But even if I want to destroy him, then the people who are spreading all this crap, they are simply exposing their orientation with the help of such a technique. These are people, apparently from the speaker’s circle, who are very bothered by the existence of my organization and everything else that is connected with it. The speaker's environment is generally very multidimensional.
And if my information sources do not betray me, and it seems to me that they do not betray me, then one of Mr. and comrade Seleznev’s advisers is Mr. Dugin. Well, there is a long-standing and quite merciless and irreconcilable dispute with Mr. Dugin. As for the initial material, as far as I was told (and our information work is not the worst), these materials were once in the custody of one large structure associated with television and then were allegedly stolen from there, perhaps really stolen. And for a year we hung around Moscow. And they offered them to me, it seems, for 3 thousand dollars. I said this junk isn't worth three thousand dollars. And even in this form, in the form of top-secret materials.
And then someone who loves the Internet and is very passionate about working with the Internet now, and you know the new right is crazy about the Internet now, they decided to make this such an Internet sensation. This seemed to overlap with the thinking about our evil essence, emanating from certain circles around Mr. Seleznev, and coincided with the interests of a number of commercial structures that have always been engaged in similar types of discrediting activities. They put this whole huge package there, threw a hysteria, and now they want to replicate this hysteria, “Claw-2, 3, 4” and so on.
Mikhail Sokolov:
This was the version of the head of the Experimental Creative Center corporation Sergei Kurginyan.
There are other assumptions. The Internet agency "Dormer Window" claims that the sites "Claw 1 and 2" were created by different structures. Right-wingers who are “fascinated by the Internet,” Bykov’s competitor Oleg Deripasko and the famous image maker Gleb Pavlovsky are suspected of carrying out a “claw-two” blow to the reputation of presidential candidate Yuri Luzhkov. Naturally, all such speculations mentioned above are refuted. In general, it is obvious that the closer the elections are, the fiercer the political struggle in Russia, including with the use of new methods of disseminating compromising evidence with impunity through the Russian virtual space.
Mikhail Sokolov:
In Ingushetia, parliamentary elections of the republic will be held on February 28. Radio Liberty special correspondent Andrei Babitsky has returned from Nazran.
Andrey Babitsky:
Ingushetia has seen almost no snow this year. Those pitiful snowflakes that rarely fell on the earth melted immediately or the next day. My friend, Mohammed from Nazran, to whom I told about the unusually snowy winter in Moscow, rolled his eyes and clicked his tongue, thus expressing a high degree of satisfaction.
It is difficult to suspect the Ingush of any specific commitment to cold weather, despite the fact that large Ingush communities have long been formed in the north of Russia. It’s just that the warm winter that happened this year for the residents of this small southern republic becomes a period of painful off-season, endless thaw. Mud here, just like everywhere else in the Russian provinces, in the fall becomes the undivided mistress of the roads, filling all imaginable spaces. Acrobatic skill is required in order to walk down the street of an Ingush city or village (which is the same thing) and not get covered in mud up to your ears. I have always admired how unusually neat the graceful Ingush girls are - wearing pumps, they overcame the muddy breakers without any visible effort, emerging from giant drifts without a single dull spot on their shoes. Winter shackles all this heavy element of the Russian thaw, and the snow, which the Ingush now miss, covers it, bringing beauty to the meager autumn landscape. The harsh nature of Ingushetia in many ways matches the history of the Vainakhs, full of hardships and hardships. Our North Caucasian correspondent Oleg Kusov reports.
Oleg Kusov:
The Ingush, like many North Caucasian highlanders, got their name in the 18th century, during the conquest of the Caucasus by the Russians. The village of Angush became the first lowland village founded by the ancestors of the present-day Ingush. Hence the custom in the Russian language - “Angushty”, or “Ingush”, that is, people from a given village. Until this time, travelers and ethnographers, rare in the Caucasus, had heard about several mountain societies in the central Caucasus in the floodplains of the Terek, Sunzha and Asa rivers. The inhabitants of these mountain communities spoke a language that each other understood and called themselves fellow tribesmen. They were divided, respectively, into Dzheiraks, Khetins, Galgaevs, Tsarins, Mirijins and Agins. Historians agree that the Ingush, like the Chechens, are descendants of the most ancient indigenous inhabitants of the mountainous part of the Caucasian Isthmus. But their first attempts to move to the plain were made only simultaneously with the arrival of the Russians in the Caucasus.
The life of the mountaineers in the gorges of the Central Caucasus in those days was described by the Russian traveler of the mid-19th century Grobovsky. He visited the Dzheirak and Kistin gorge in 1868, where he was amazed by the pristine mountain nature and unusual architecture. “All mountain settlements,” writes Grobovsky, “are distinguished by the beauty of their locations, the grandiose structure and the poetic dispersion of dwellings. But with all this, the village of Arzy is especially striking in Kist society, considered, quite rightly, the most picturesque in the whole area. It has perfectly preserved several pyramidal towers, slenderly rising one above the other. Looking out from the ruins and surviving stone buildings, these towers represent a very attractive group, captivating the viewer into a world of fantasy. But, unfortunately, one cannot return to that world for a long time. One glance at the pale faces of the inhabitants of these enchanting towers is enough to convince oneself that life here is far from being furnished with good material conditions,” end of quote.
The material conditions of the Ingush improved noticeably after moving to rich lowland lands. However, not all Ingush had the opportunity to move here at the same time as other mountain peoples, that is, at the beginning of the 19th century. Then the cruel, long-term Russian-Caucasian war began. Many mountaineers fought with the tsarist troops and could not engage in peaceful labor. This significantly hampered their economic development. Only at the end of the last century did most of the Ingush get the opportunity to develop flat lands. The mass migration of the Ingush to the plane can be dated back to the beginning of the 20th century. On the right bank of the Terek and in the basin of its tributary, the Kambeleevka River, Ingush villages came to life, the largest of which was Bazorkino. Then a prototype of the future Ingushetia appeared on the map, the Nazran district, which was part of the Terek region, and then part of the mountainous Soviet autonomy.
In 24, the Ingush Autonomous Region was established, which in 34 was united with the administrative entity of the Chechens into the Chechen-Ingush Autonomy. Checheno-Ingushetia, as is known, was abolished by Stalin’s decision 10 years after its formation. Two peoples - Chechens and Ingush - were subjected to brutal repression and were deported to Kazakhstan and Central Asia. Only in 1957 did they get the opportunity to return to their homeland. Already in our time, in 91, Checheno-Ingushetia was divided into two administrative entities. The Republic of Ingushetia at the beginning of 93 elected its first president, Ruslan Aushev.
It must be said that, according to local observers, Lieutenant General Aushev shares first place with the national writer Igris Bazorkin in the unofficial ranking of the popularity of Ingush of all generations. This speaks of his great authority among his compatriots. And in the North Caucasus, Ruslan Aushev is considered an authoritative politician. He is able to influence political processes in the region.
Andrey Babitsky:
Despite the despondency, the nature of Ingushetia at any time of the year is characterized by a purely oriental flavor, consisting of the constant bustle in hundreds of small bright markets scattered on all the roads of the republic, from the picturesque idleness of young Ingush who spend hours squatting in a row or in a circle, husking seeds and discussing their problems, from fatty lamb shish kebab, generously sprinkled with vinegar and sprinkled with coarsely chopped onions. Unbridled luxury, splendor of the interior and exterior are an indispensable condition of eastern life, and this is well understood here. The end of an Ingush house facing the street must be made of red Italian, as it is called here, brick with rounded edges, although the back wall and internal masonry are usually waste stone, either the cheapest, factory-made, or purchased from traders from Grozny, dismantling houses damaged by the bombing. Iron gates are usually decorated with traditional, not too intricate script. The Ingush still prefer that the overall quality factor dominates over the detail. Inside the house, from the very threshold, there are carpets on the floor, on the walls. The ceiling has the same stucco molding and a large Turkish chandelier, the rotating blades of which disperse the stagnant air in the hot summer.
Mikhail Sokolov:
Parliamentary elections will be held in Ingushetia on February 28, but the referendum with which President Ruslan Aushev threatened Moscow will not take place. What happened in Nazran? This was found out by Radio Liberty special correspondent Andrei Babitsky. He continues his reporting from Ingushetia.
Andrey Babitsky:
On the threshold of a Vainakh home, it is customary to take off your shoes - a rule that came to the Caucasus from the Arab world. You cannot step on the carpet with dirty feet, since its sacred purpose is to serve as a covering for performing namaz. However, in Chechnya I also heard a very strange statement - that this Vainakh tradition, which today is no longer decipherable, points to ancient mountain ethics, according to which the guest, by taking off his shoes, demonstrated that he was not afraid of sudden persecution, thus he expressed his trust in the owner. Pure pragmatists believe that the custom of taking off shoes is a common hygienic procedure since ancient times.
The Vainakhs generally retained in daily use the essential elements of adat - traditional law that in the past regulated the tribal life of the Ingush and Chechens. Some customs have turned over time into dead rituals, the meaning of which is understandable only to ethnographers. Others are still alive today. So, for example, the ritual of kidnapping a bride from a real theft, as it was in the past, today has turned into a way, by mutual consent of the bride and groom, to bypass relatives who object to the marriage on one side or the other.
But the institution of blood feud among the Vainakhs, who did not have any statehood until the 19th century, played the role of one of the main regulators of tribal relations. And although only rudiments have survived to this day, the events of recent years in Chechnya and Ingushetia, when trust in state power and its legal system was lost, have once again made the idea of direct retribution popular. However, more on all this below. On February 19 of this year, an agreement on the division of powers between the federal center and the Republic of Ingushetia was signed in Moscow. This agreement was the result of many years of confrontation between the federal center and the leadership of Ingushetia. Back in 1995, Ruslan Aushev raised the issue of reforming the system of law enforcement and judicial authorities. The Ingush president demanded that the right to appoint the heads of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the chairman of the court and the prosecutor be transferred from the center to the republic. According to the Constitution, such appointments are made by the President of Russia.
At the same time, the idea of holding a republican referendum on these issues first appeared. A little later, Aushev came up with another initiative - the President of Ingushetia, he argued, should be able to grant pardons for crimes committed based on blood feud or related to folk customs and traditions. I am using the wording of the question that should have been submitted to the last referendum that did not take place.
Aushev’s initiatives did not find understanding in Moscow, and for several years the situation hung in the air. But in 1998, before the presidential elections, Ruslan Aushev passed through the republican parliament a decision to hold a referendum on judicial and legal reform. This was a direct challenge to the Kremlin. Detractors argued that Aushev needed the conflict with the central government solely to win the presidential election. An ordinary voter in Ingushetia accuses the center of provoking the 1992 conflict between Ossetians and Ingush, as a result of which the Ingush were expelled (again, with the support of federal troops) from their villages located in the Prigorodny region of North Ossetia. The appointment of a referendum in this context was perceived by the population as one of the forms of struggle against the unjust central government.
This significantly strengthened the pre-election positions of the presidential candidate of Ingushetia, Ruslan Aushev. However, just before the elections, Aushev unexpectedly easily, at the insistence of Moscow, agrees to cancel the referendum. At that time, the conflict was settled. At the beginning of this year, the President of Ingushetia again raised the issue of judicial and legal reform. This time the company was held on a much larger scale. In January and February, the topic of confrontation between Ingushetia and the federal center became one of the central ones in the media. Everyone understood that the situation that had once arisen in the relationship between Moscow and Tatarstan was being repeated again. Kazan, seeking maximum powers at the republican level, seriously threatened the federal center with secession from the federation. It was then that the question of the real prospect of the collapse of Russia was first raised.
The context of the current confrontation turned out to be very similar. In numerous television interviews, Aushev spoke about the need to reform the entire system of relations between the center and the subjects of the federation. He argued that the Kremlin was imposing a unitary model of statehood on the regions, while true federalism required a careful and sympathetic attitude to the characteristics of national entities. Using the example of his own republic and its traditions, the Ingush leader argued for the need to significantly expand the powers of the leaders of individual entities.
Aushev's arguments are well known - appointees from Moscow are not able to understand and appreciate all the uniqueness of national customs. Thus, bride kidnapping is qualified, in accordance with criminal law, as a serious crime. And this is a widespread custom among the Ingush. Just like blood feud, which, due to the imperfection of legal institutions, the Ingush are not able to refuse. Accordingly, the President of Ingushetia should have the right to grant pardon in individual cases. On February 28, the Ingush president scheduled a new popular vote on old issues. This action was calculated precisely. The specter of Russia's collapse again loomed before the eyes of the capital's politicians, and no one at that moment thought about the obvious artificiality and frivolity of the arguments of the President of Ingushetia. Deputy Prosecutor General of Russia, presidential candidate of Ingushetia in the last elections, Isa Kostoev, speaking.
Isa Kostoev:
So I should have the right to pardon. Our legislation provides for very strict liability, as an aggravating circumstance... the law has an article “murder motivated by blood feud.” It arises due to the fact that before the blood feud was declared, a murder had already occurred. This means that the person who commits the initial murder must naturally be prosecuted and sentenced to some term. Naturally, the convict and his relatives had bloodlines. Their man was killed. He is serving his sentence, but the blood feud remains. This blood feud was fought throughout the years of the existence of the Soviet Union and even Tsarist Russia. Aushev works out that if a person is convicted of committing a murder prior to blood feud, and the blood relatives of the murdered man went and killed the brother of the convicted man, Aushev should have the right to pardon this murderer, who killed an essentially innocent person.
Another question is to prepare at the local level, taking into account national customs and traditions, a bill on how to reconcile the conflicting parties, taking into account the fact that the culprit has been punished. There is a special republican commission for reconciliation, which is successfully working, trying to eliminate this phenomenon, which in itself is savagery. To provoke mass murders of people and not bear any punishment for it is, to say the least, absurd. The second statement in support of their claims is the so-called bride kidnapping. And there are cases when the bride’s relatives or the groom’s relatives do not want their child to marry. Naturally, there are very many cases when young people come to work in a similar situation. At the appointed time, at the appointed place, they get into the car and leave. Naturally, relatives become aware. Hurray, our so-and-so was kidnapped and taken away. Naturally, the elders and authorities are the first to act if there is a message that they have been taken away.
So it was, so it is at all times. They ask the kidnapped woman, how did you get married?.. at the police station, at the prosecutor. "I left by my own consent." - “Why didn’t they officially match?” - “But because my mother or my brother, or my father, or my relatives do not agree with this.” - “Are you ready to throw in your lot with this young man?” - “Yes, I married him for love.” Kommersant
Stay healthy. There is not a single case where someone was convicted for this. They made up. The authorities say: that’s it, your application has been considered, an explanation has been received, confrontations have been made, the relatives of the abducted woman met alone with the bride, she agrees. And live. But the fact that you don’t like your relatives is, in fact, a family matter; somehow you’ll get used to it later.
Very rarely there are cases when a girl clearly does not agree to get married, but an annoying, pushy groom, hoping that somehow the old people will settle this matter, kidnaps this girl for himself. After the kidnapping, he tries to persuade her, declares that he will never give her back in his life, and that no one will marry her later, because since I kidnapped you, you are my bride. If a girl says: “I will never marry, I don’t want to live with you. If you rape me here, then you will serve both rape and kidnapping”...
This phenomenon, just like blood feud, must be fought on the spot, with the use of religious authorities, elders, respected people, to create special commissions on this issue, but if he wants, based on the fact that the kidnapping took place and he will force her to live with this person against the will of this girl, this is, to say the least, insanity, it does not even fit into the reasoning of a civilized person. Since according to customs it is supposed to kidnap, since you have been kidnapped, live. I am the president, I allow you to live with her.
Andrey Babitsky:
It is doubtful that Ruslan Aushev himself did not understand the unfoundedness of his own position. Evidence of this can be seen in the extraordinary ease with which he once again canceled the republican referendum in exchange for an agreement on the division of powers signed in Moscow. Under this agreement, did the leader of Ingushetia receive the powers that he sought? Says the plenipotentiary representative of the Russian President in Ingushetia and North Ossetia, Vladimir Kalamanov, who took part in the work on the agreement, and who, together with Ruslan Aushev, returned from Moscow on the day of signing. We talked with Vladimir Kalamanov a day later.
Vladimir Kalamanov:
There are some aspects with which we can agree, and the federal center agreed, without taking the selection of people to the point of absurdity. At the same time, there is the axis on which the unified state was and will be based, that is, the preservation of the vertical. The vertical of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the vertical of the prosecutor's office. If you don’t go deep, so to speak, into the weeds, you can briefly answer this way: common points of contact were found and, what’s most interesting, whether this document was signed or not, it was precisely this formula that they had been working on for a year or two before, and this was stated very briefly by the Minister of Internal Affairs Sergei Vladimirovich Stepashin.
Basically, nothing happened. We simply approved what was already in the works.
Andrey Babitsky:
The complacency of Vladimir Kalamanov, who certifies the President of Ingushetia as a champion of the Russian constitution, is easily explained. It must be assumed that no one at the center expected that Ruslan Aushev would be satisfied with a purely formal procedure. Kalamanov explained that the power vertical remains unchanged, which means that the Ingush president never received the right to appoint heads of law enforcement and judicial bodies of Ingushetia, nor the right to grant pardons. Deputy Prosecutor General Isa Kostoev also speaks about this.
Isa Kostoev:
This agreement made absolutely no changes to current legislation. It did not introduce any additional powers other than those that previously existed and are in effect.
Andrey Babitsky:
What's the matter here? Why did such an energetic and noisy campaign burst like a soap bubble? Why did Ruslan Aushev, who at the beginning of February extremely aggravated the conflict with his refusal to implement Boris Yeltsin’s decree to cancel the referendum in Ingushetia, at the last moment settle for a pathetic agreement that was absolutely useless for him? Did he even need a referendum? Sergei Stepashin argues that the agreement on the division of powers fixed the status quo. What was the actual practice like? Magomet Kostoev speaks.
Isa Kostoev:
In Ingushetia, whose president of the republic has been fighting so hard for the subordination of law enforcement agencies to himself since 1992, in 6 years - the fifth prosecutor of the republic. They are each appointed for five years, and they were agreed upon, they were released. Why were they released? Because the president of the republic demanded: get him away from me. He gave his consent - take him away from me. I don't need him. Now, if I don’t need him, the federal government should clearly figure it out and say whether he commits violations, whether he fulfills his assigned duties or not. If we take the situation in the Ministry of Internal Affairs in this same republic over these same six years, if I’m not mistaken, it’s also about the fifth or sixth. There are about four heads of the FSB in this republic. The question is, what's the matter? Someone has to ask - listen, what's going on? You appoint them, you introduce them, we appoint them, you say after a month - no, remove him, he is not good. Nobody finds out.
Andrey Babitsky:
So, in reality, Ruslan Aushev, during the years of his presidency, calmly changed prosecutors and ministers of internal affairs and even heads of FSB agencies, that is, for one reason or another, the Kremlin was forced to follow the lead of the Ingush leader. Thus, Aushev’s true ability to influence the federal center was almost equal to the powers that he seemed to intend to achieve through the referendum. From the outside it may seem that there is no visible logic in Aushev’s actions. Having made so much effort to get what he already had, at the very last moment he mediocrely abandoned the brilliant work he had begun. At the same time, logic in such actions can be detected. Isa Kostoev believes that Ruslan Aushev, having started a grandiose quarrel with Moscow, pursued completely different goals.
Isa Kostoev:
It seemed to me that it wasn’t really a matter of what was being voiced. Probably there were some other interests. If they had told him: well, keep your bodies there, pay them salaries, five thousand employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, hundreds of employees of the prosecutor's office, judicial officers, provide for them. You can imagine a republic that is in dire straits today and is unable to do this. This is not the point, the point is probably something else. What was he trying to achieve with this? Well, these are the statements that are voiced and written, I mean, blood feud, kidnapping, you know that this does not stand up to criticism. It is NOT based on anything. Even if we proceed from the so-called Sharia law and our customary law. I believe that the interests here were different. Aushev himself should know which ones exactly.
Andrey Babitsky:
Let's pause for a while our story about the relationship between Nazran and Moscow and turn our gaze towards the new capital of Ingushetia, which is under construction. Alexander Yevtushenko attended its presentation in 1998. Here is his story.
Alexander Yevtushenko:
The first reports about the construction of Magas on the site of the legendary city, the true location of which has never been established, appeared in Ingushetia five years ago. The authorship of the idea is attributed to the President of the Republic Ruslan Aushev. On April 15, 1994, Boris Yeltsin issued a decree on the construction of the capital of the Republic of Ingushetia. Then Chernomyrdin signed a corresponding decree of the Russian government. On December 28, 1995, the President of Russia signs the federal law. Its first article states: the construction of the capital of the Ingush Republic is an object of federal significance.
Let me remind you that by this time thousands of Russian tanks, planes and soldiers were attacking neighboring, brotherly Ingush Chechnya. Therefore, the green light for the construction of Magas at all levels of federal government is most likely a tribute to political strategy. From the certificate of the Magas Construction Directorate, as of October last year, the cost of work on the capital’s facilities amounted to over $53 million, not counting communications. More than three million are just the engineering structures of government quarter number one. The certificate says nothing about the presidential residence.
However, by the end of last year, when President Aushev gathered guests for the presentation of his capital, it was the presidential palace that struck them. Cascade stairs, columns, fountains, all in marble, bronze, crystal. There is even a crystal dome over the palace. Not long before this, I visited the country residence of Ruslan Aushev and naively decided that I would definitely never see greater splendor in Ingushetia. When asked how much such a “dacha” cost, the president answered evasively - about a million dollars or one and a half. The cost of the presidential palace in Magas is even more vague, they say, somewhat more expensive than a country house. The real amount is a great state secret. At the same time, Aushev emphasized that the money did not come from the republic’s budget, not from the taxpayer’s pocket, but was financed by the construction mainly by the economically favored zone of Ingushetia. Evil tongues say that the Ingush criminal authorities, who control gold, oil and gas production in the north, also invested their share in Magas.
But, if desired, this money would not pass by the more pressing needs of the republic. And there are a dime a dozen of them in Ingushetia. Here we have the highest unemployment rate in Russia, while all new expensive facilities in the republic are being built by Turks and Slovaks. And the lack of roads, communication structures, and other vital details of statehood. A good thing, of course, is a new city, but why is money primarily spent not on housing, but on the splendor of residences for high-ranking officials, and maybe it’s not trolleybus routes that should be launched to the surrounding villages, as Aushev plans, but rather the houses should be provided with gas and water?
Andrey Babitsky:
After the adventure of 1992, when a confrontation was artificially organized in the Prigorodny region of North Ossetia, the center began to send huge funds to both Ingushetia and North Ossetia to overcome the consequences of the conflict. Ruslan Aushev, having become the president of Ingushetia in 1993, quickly mastered the extremely advantageous geopolitical position of the republic he headed. Refugees from the Prigorodny region (according to various sources - from 30 to 70 thousand) settled in Ingushetia. In addition to the funds allocated to solve all these problems, Ruslan Aushev received permission in 1994 to open an offshore zone on the territory of Ingushetia. It existed until '97.
The federal center feared that the offended Ingush would follow the path of the Chechens, who declared independence in 1991. These fears intensified many times over with the outbreak of the war. Therefore, no money was spared on Ingushetia, despite all its obvious disloyalty on issues related to the fighting in Chechnya. That is why budget funds have always been carefully transferred to Ingushetia. None of the republics of the North Caucasus could dream of this.
In 1997, as Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian government, Anatoly Chubais said that the offshore zone, like a black hole, had absorbed hundreds of millions of dollars lost from the budget. During the election campaign in 1998, the opposition directly accused Ruslan Aushev of embezzlement of budget money and misuse of funds. Then they cited data on the construction of the supposedly four-star Assa hotel in Nazran, a cottage town and other objects. Now a “sun city” has been added to the construction sites in Nazran. The Russian prosecutor's office told me that with the money that, starting in '92, was sent to Ossetia and Ingushetia to overcome the consequences of the conflict, it was possible for every Ossetian and Ingush to build a house and also buy a car.
Unlike the President of Kalmykia, Kirsan Ilyumzhinov, whose threats are most often a response to the center’s moves, Ruslan Aushev prefers to keep the initiative in his own hands and not bring the matter to direct accusations against himself. The policy of preemptive strikes constantly keeps Moscow on edge. The Ingush leader presents her with one political puzzle after another. “Secondary” politicians remain confident every time that they have solved the problem brilliantly. In fact, they were solving a completely different equation. And on February 28, elections to the People's Assembly, the president's “pocket” parliament, will be held in Ingushetia. After the cancellation of the referendum, these events can no longer interest anyone.
Mikhail Sokolov:
This was a report by Radio Liberty special correspondent Andrei Babitsky, who visited Nazran before the elections of the People's Assembly of Ingushetia - the parliament of the republic. In the next episode of the program “Elections-99” on March 4: the results of the elections in Ingushetia, Dagestan before the parliamentary elections and referendum, how the formation of the right-wing coalition is progressing.