Russia-Belorussia Plus Ukraine?
Leading Lev Roitman
Lev Roitman:
According to the official forecast, on November 26, an union between Belarus and Russia will be signed in Moscow. A representative survey of public opinion is evidenced by: 70% of Russians for the merger of Russia and Belarus in general into a single state. Therefore, in our conversation, we will raise the question like this: what is the good Russian-Belarusian Union? President of Belarus Alexander Lukashenko looks even further. He says: “The economic collapse that will befall Ukraine after the presidential election will force this republic to join the Union of Belarus and Russia.” Elections in Ukraine took place. Accordingly, the question: what would the Union of Russia, Belarus and Ukraine be good? These questions to Marat Dymov in Minsk, Sergey Kolmakov in Moscow, Vladimir Malinkovich in Kyiv.
The preparing union of Belarus and Russia - nothing is bad, and what is good? So I put a question to the participants of today's conversation. Sergei Alexandrovich Kolmakov, I will present you somewhat more: you are the deputy director of the Politics Foundation, the fund very close to Yuri Luzhkov, to political groups that are united around this figure. So, the question: what is the Union of Belarus-Russia good?
Sergey Kolmakov:
I would start with the second part of the question when the case concerned Ukraine. In fact, in Russia there were no illusions that so far we can talk about this very hypothetically, especially after the presidential elections in Ukraine, which, I think, testify to the opposite. And the election of Kuchma, this attempt will find some unusual desire to join the European Union, other European structures and the realization that now in Ukraine there are no opportunities and somehow it is necessary to exist in the situation that a significant part of economic ties, everything else, is nevertheless oriented towards Russia. But the general trend is just in the opposite direction. And here, I think, this is how sharply the question is not worth it. Now, answering the first part of your question about the Russian-Belarusian agreement. Since our fund at one time took, let’s say, some participation in the formulation of the initial text of the contract that was signed back in the 97th year, since then, few steps have been taken in the real integration case. But a lot of all sorts of purely declarative gestures have been done. And I have a great doubt about the fact that the contract that will be signed on November 26 this year in Moscow may be some kind of microscopic step in the real integration case, but can turn into a very big step in the profanity of this idea. Because, in fact, the integration moves very slowly, everything is complicated by the political struggle associated primarily with the electoral cycle in Russia, using this circumstance, perhaps, to some extent by different forces that are not interested in real integration. So far, things have been postponed to the decision of the political fate of Russia itself.
Lev Roitman:
Sergei Alexandrovich, nevertheless, a passing question, as I formulated it: completely independently of the legal aspects of this agreement, regardless of who he is today, this moment is beneficial or not profitable. After all, I brought the figure - 70% of Russians are generally for the merger of the two states. And the question is: what is the merger, than the union is not on paper, not with obstacles, not with paragraph barriers, is good for Russia in particular?
Sergey Kolmakov:
Well, I think that it is good in the first place because now in Russia, if slowly, albeit with large zigzags, but the rise of a certain real sector of the economy has begun. I think that it is, ”it’s okay, what, it is okay that, Rossia receives the energy resources of the isossia, there are quite large investments. N, the technologist for plusatoset is so far that it predicts. And, before, in courses and goods. We trade more than 60%. But export in Russia is enriching economic reforms. E -good -all, we will enter the European Union - Paqu The western border of Ukraine, Raina lives at least 50% of Rus, is in particular, I am afraid of it. I am in good difficulties, it’s not the Russian authorities, however, the Russian authorities, for the same time,, right, if people are in the Chechen war, Rossia receives energy resources and I would like to say that the alliance is, Union. Low, Belarus, they say, they consist of the KRUSSIA Energoresias of the isossia are quite large investments. Trades with the Posvbelarusdmiti from Russia, for example, the firmware is quite large, the technologist is so far that it predicts. The pipe of the STDMITITRIEVICH, since Alexander Lukashenko, the President of Belarus, goes so far that it will also be predicted that Ukraine will come to the union.
I answer your question. And, provided that we will not have to unite under the Yar anti -democrat Lukashenko, who dispersed the parliament, not during the wiring war in Chechnya Putin and, before, our president, let’s say, Kuchma is by no means a consistent piercing supporter of the protection of the human rights campaign. But in principle, this union, it seems to me, is necessary. In principle, provided that all our three countries will be in, in courses and goods. We are selling this union more, it seems to me necessary. In principle, provided that all of our three countries will be at an economy. Ukraine is still in the field of ruble. Although she managed only in chickens today, as we say, we talk in a ruble course and all our problems are essentially solved by the International Monetary Fund, which essentially blocks the difference in courses and goods. We trade, first of all with Russia, almost half the import of all the imports comes from courses and goods. We trade primarily with Russia, half -severity, which is the President, the President, which is already the President, which is already the President. ”In addition, I would like to pay attention to the fact that now many Belarusians are afraid that if they unite, they will have to participate in Russian military conflicts. And now, in particular, I will again come to the data of the October Subrication - 24% of the respondents said that the new The Chechen war has changed their attitude to the worst, the authorities of the authorities, however, swear and be afraid that the Belarusians will never go beyond Belarusia, but people do not really believe them.
Lev Roitman:
Marat Dymov, however, I would like you to go to that difficult plane of my question, I understand, it is difficult for you: why is the Union of Belarus and Russia good?
Marat Dymov:
In general, really, there are some economic, one might say, pluses from this union. Say, they are that Belarus receives energy resources from Russia at lower prices than other CIS countries, countries outside the CIS. This is still a well-known relief. The lack of customs borders allows you to easily trade with Russia than, for example, to other countries. Well, say, it concerns the authorities, the lack of border and different conditions of trade with third countries allow you to earn quite a lot of money at the expense of the Russian budget, manipulating borders. In addition, there are quite large investments from Russia from Russia. For example, a huge Yamal -Western Europe project, a few months ago the first line of this pipeline was completed. Well, perhaps, such advantages of economic cooperation can be called. Although these advantages can be minuses, because the attachment of Belarus to the Russian economy, as it were, presents the technological backwardness of the Belarusian economy.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Marat Dymov. And I did not hear a single emotional argument in favor of the Union on the plus side. I just state the fact. Vladimir Dmitrievich, since Alexander Lukashenko, the president of Belarus, goes so far that it predicts that Ukraine will come to the Union. What can you see the benefits, advantages, plus sides of such a union, Triple this time?
Vladimir Malinkovich:
It’s easier for me to answer your question than others. I believe that the Union of Russia, Ukraine and Belarus is very good, but provided that it will not be a single state. And provided that we will not have to unite with the Yar anti -democrat Lukashenko, who dispersed the parliament, not during the wiring war in Chechnya Putin, and our president, let’s say, Kuchma is by no means the most consistent supporter of the protection of human rights, freedom and so on, which showed the election campaign. But in principle, this union, it seems to me, is necessary. In principle, provided that all our three countries will move towards democracy for many reasons. Well, first of all, let's say, an economic reason. Ukraine is still in the field of ruble. Although she managed to close somewhat from the financial crisis of the Moscow last year, nevertheless, today, as we say, we are dangling in the ruble course and all our problems are essentially solved by the International Monetary Fund, which essentially blocks the difference in courses and goods. We trade primarily with Russia, almost half of all imports come from Russia. And if we talk about all countries of the ruble zone, that is, the CIS countries, then this is more than 60%. But we have much less export in Russia, we have a little more than 20%. Why? Yes, because our goods are now expensive for Russia in the residence and they go only along Barter. That is, we, finding ourselves in the ruble zone, we live according to other rules than Russia. Russia still goes further towards economic reforms. If we had, say, joint customs rules and a number of other rules, then we would continue to be advanced towards economic reforms. I am absolutely convinced of this, because trade with Western countries is a very, very insignificant part of our common trade. This is the economic part. There is, of course, the emotional part. On both sides of the Russian-Ukrainian border, tens of millions of relatives live, of course they would like the regime between the countries would be visa-free. And this will be very difficult to do after, say, Poland, other countries will join the European Union - it will be necessary to close the western border of Ukraine or the northeastern, that is, Russian. Both that and the other are not beneficial to our citizens, but the closure of the North-Eastern Russian-Ukrainian border is especially unprofitable. And finally, the cultural aspect. At least 50% of the Russian -speaking, that is, people of the Russian language group lives in Ukraine. They are interested in the development of Russian culture in Ukraine. And they are now under the blow of Ukrainian nationalists, their culture. And allied relations with Russia would help them self -identify as Russian citizens of Ukraine. That is, we could quickly form a single political nation of Ukraine, a multinational, multi -ethnic political nation of Ukraine, a single political civil society. That is, I am for the Union, but the Union of Independent States, and the Union, headed by a democrat in each of the states.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Vladimir Malinkovich, Kyiv. And now in Moscow, again Sergey Aleksandrovich Kolmakov, you have enough impulses to answer, based on what Marat Dymov, Minsk and Vladimir Malinkovich, Kyiv said, so without a question, I ask you.
Alexander Kolmakov:
I am especially impressed by what Mr. Malinkovich said about the leaders. I will not touch the leaders of Belarus and Ukraine now. But it is quite obvious that these feverish, cosmetic attempts, as the Yeltsin administration makes them, is, on the one hand, of course, an attempt to a certain extent in his own eyes, in the eyes of history to rehabilitate, as it were, I mean Yeltsin himself, who thinks himself as a historical person and perfectly understands everything that he did in the 91st year. The second point, of course, is connected not only with emotions, but with the real problems of his political survival, let's say, Yeltsin’s regime without Yeltsin, the inheritance that he wants to leave to his successor. But, unfortunately, hence all these games, including speculation on such saints, in general, feelings as friendship and the desire for some unification of the Russian and Belarusian peoples. But all this is largely, unfortunately, the ostentatious character is complicated by purely such conjunctural political considerations. And what seems to me really dangerous, and in this regard one can agree with Lukashenko that we are often talking about some kind of confederate organization, but which would have really real foundations, and not purely cosmetic grounds. Here we can agree with him that, apparently, only after leaving the historical arena of our president, one can somehow think about filling this union, a confederate union with some serious grounds.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Sergey Alexandrovich.
Marat Dymov:
Sergei Alexandrovich expressed the idea of a rather popular in Russia that, when uniting, Russian democracy spread to Belarus. But somehow, the practice of the integration process shows that the reverse process occurs - when combining, a non -free combination occurs. And here is the most, so to speak, the last fresh example. The agreement that is supposed to be signed on November 26 provides that the Higher Council, before, two presidents, two people, can issue decrees that have great power than the laws of Belarus and Russia. Such a system is currently operating in Belarus - Lukashenko can cancel laws with decree. In Russia, this is not so, but when uniting it will be so. And in my opinion, these hopes that there will be more democracy when uniting, they, unfortunately, are not founded, it will be less.
Lev Roitman:
Again, I will give the data of the sociological survey, which was conducted in Russia by the VTsIOM. In your opinion, the question for respondents is whether Lukashenko is currently legally elected President of Belarus or not? “Yes, is” - less than half of the respondents answered; “No” - 18% answered and simply “do not know” legally he was elected or not 33%. Thus, the minority of the respondents are considered by Lukashenko, with whom Boris Yeltsin, the legally chosen leader of Belarus, should sign an agreement on the Union. And with these data, Vladimir Malinkovich, Kyiv, I ask you.
Vladimir Malinkovich:
Well, you know, it is very difficult to say that our president defeated the election, that our president won a completely democratic way. I want to say that the opinion of representatives, observers of the OSCE and other European organizations are very critical. They believe that there were very, very many violations, this is especially due to the suppression of the press. Here is an interesting moment: Russia really contributed not to the development of democracy with us, I agree with Marat Dymov here, but again antidemocratic trends. It was from Russia that such agites came in favor of Kuchma, conversations with Kuchma in the pre -election situation, which is clearly a violation of our rules of the election campaign. In Russia, they know this very well. I say that before we unite in the Confederation and even just some political unions, we must still put the order in each of our countries and create democratic systems. And the unification of anti -democrats will not give anything good to anyone. Therefore, in my opinion, our most important internal problems and understanding, say, in Russia that we should not unite with whom, but only with democratic leaders, only with democratic parties and contribute to the development of such parties, such movements.
Lev Roitman:
Thank you, Vladimir Dmitrievich.