
At the end of January, at a round table in the State Duma dedicated to supporting Russian cinema, director Alexei German Jr. spoke out against excessive regulation of the industry. In other words, for streamlining censorship rules so that filmmakers better understand what is acceptable and what is not. In recent years, more and more Russian films have received well-deserved awards and high marks from film critics, but in the end they are not released and remain inaccessible to a wide audience. The reason for refusing to issue a film a distribution certificate can be anything from the dissatisfaction of “social activists” to the influence of security forces. At the same time, there is no boom in “patriotic cinema” that the authorities are expecting, and cinema attendance is falling.
Curators against "Wind"
Alice doesn't live here anymore
How the “shelves” were dismantled during Perestroika
How the “shelf” is being assembled now
Yakutia under suspicion
Make it clear
The best Russian film of 2025, according to film critics, was “The Wind” by Sergei Chliyants. The White Elephant National Award, which brings together more than 70 experts, assessed the film in several categories, including “Best Screenplay,” written by Pyotr Lutsik and Alexey Samoryadov almost 30 years ago—the authors themselves are no longer alive. For those who have seen their previous films - primarily “Outskirts” and “Wild Field” - the fantastic style of narration, the gloomy, mysterious and disturbing visual environment, and infernal heroes, as if emerging from the works of Andrei Platonov, did not come as a surprise.
What is rather surprising is that over the course of several decades, script material, usually perishable, not only has not become outdated, but has even acquired unexpected relevance. Consider the final scene of the film, when the hero named Ivan, desperate to bring his ruined young wife back to life, decides to go to war. And not concrete, but abstract. “No one can escape the war. Neither a people nor a person. And Moscow will not pay off,” the captain with the face of a fanatic addresses the recruits. “The time has come to stand up for our homeland.” Our great-grandfathers did not spare their stomachs. Why should we look for another share? Why listen to strangers? Do they love us? They haven’t loved you for a thousand years, but now they love you?”
Directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili, 2008.
Directed by Petr Lutsik, 1998.
Director - Boris Khlebnikov, script - Boris Khlebnikov and Natalia Meshchaninova, 2023.

If Ivan Okhlobystin had played this captain, everything would have instantly shifted towards possessed buffoonery with self-parodying overtones. And here a serious dramatic artist is working, and there is no time for black humor. And Ivan, in the end, humbly goes to war, because the alternative to it in the wild field of the Russian outskirts can only be poverty, theft or murder, but among his own.
The premiere of “Wind” was supposed to take place in October 2024 in Gelendzhik as part of the “Mayak” festival, which plays perhaps a key role in the modern Russian film process (replacing “Kinotavr”, which ended in 2022).
But it so happened that the curator from the law enforcement agency, who looked after the investor of the painting, apparently was not initially familiar with the content, which, from the point of view of the man in uniform, poorly reflected the current agenda of the SVO. As a result, the film was not allowed to appear at Mayak, and the director, who is not a media person at all, was sent for preventive purposes with creative meetings in the front-line Donbass. “Wind” was first shown in March 2025 at the international film festival “Spirit of Fire” in Khanty-Mansiysk, where it received the Grand Prix.
One of the favorites of “The White Elephant” of past years is the film “Bullfinch” , based on the novel “Three Minutes of Silence” by Georgy Vladimov, published back in 1969 (the action of the film has been transferred to modern times). Previously, such films were classified under the section “Education of the moral character of Soviet people,” or “Cinema of moral concern.” Two friends, very young, find themselves practicing on a fishing trawler. Weakness and then betrayal of one leads to the death of the other. The film, completely devoid of common Hollywood clichés (and on the contrary, seems to draw the viewer to the experience of psychological cinema in the spirit of Sergei Solovyov or Ilya Averbakh), simply could not help but please the critics. And, oddly enough, more than others, as if forgetting about their imperial-Hollywood habits, “The Bullfinch” was appreciated by the jury of Nikita Mikhalkov’s Golden Eagle Award, awarding the film in four categories, including “Best Film.”
Directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili, 2008.
Directed by Petr Lutsik, 1998.
Director - Boris Khlebnikov, script - Boris Khlebnikov and Natalia Meshchaninova, 2023.

But even here there are some interesting details. “Bullfinch” bypassed the ambitious project “Challenge,” which was filmed in space for the first time in the history of cinema (among the film’s producers are Dmitry Rogozin and Konstantin Ernst), and this decision, according to rumors, caused dissatisfaction in the presidential administration. The usually loyal judges of the “Golden Eagle” did not give “Challenge” a single statuette (except for the prize of the organizing committee for actress Yulia Peresild, who flew into space with director Klim Shipenko), even the nomination “Best Visual Effects” mockingly went to “Bullfinch”. But another version of events is also possible. Since 2023, when “The Bullfinch” appeared, Khlebnikov and Meshchaninova, as directors and screenwriters, have not released a single film.
They, along with Alexander Sokurov, the most recognized domestic filmmakers who did not leave Russia, are de facto excluded from the profession. It is difficult to say whether this is due to the fact that in February 2022 Boris Klebnikov signed a collective letter “No to War”, or to his cooperation with the general producer of the Kion online cinema, Igor Mishin, who was forced out of the industry after a search of his country house in 2025.
Directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili, 2008.
Directed by Petr Lutsik, 1998.
Director - Boris Khlebnikov, script - Boris Khlebnikov and Natalia Meshchaninova, 2023.
Many recognized domestic filmmakers who did not leave Russia are de facto excluded from the profession
In 2021, Khlebnikov and Mishin filmed the comedy series “Comrade Major” about an eccentric FSB officer “in a hurry to do good.” After the pilot episodes were shown, the project never appeared on any online platform, but in August 2022, for some reason, it received a distribution certificate, which makes it possible to show the series in theaters, although no one took advantage of this.
Natalia Meshchaninova has no relation to Comrade Major and did not sign any protest letters. She is primarily the author of stories on everyday, moral, ethical, and family topics. Another thing is the sharp, modern interpretation of these themes, which the champions of “traditional values” do not like. Her directorial work One Little Night Secret, shown in February 2023 at the Rotterdam International Film Festival (this despite the sanctions!), tells the story of a 14-year-old girl who is sexually coerced by her stepfather, against the backdrop of the external well-being of the family. The series “Alice Can’t Wait” is about another teenage girl who, having learned that she is hopelessly losing her sight, decides to sell her virginity in order to find money for an operation, and if that doesn’t help, just have fun for herself.
At the New Season 2022 online cinema festival, this project won in the Most Anticipated Series category. But after the premiere on the START video service, “social activists” from among professional informers turned to Roskomnadzor, and the series was banned because it “contains information that should not be disseminated in an audiovisual service.” At first glance, “One Little Night Secret” has a more prosperous fate. The film is allowed, but only for showing on platforms. They don’t buy it, perhaps out of fear of new denunciations.
Directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili, 2008.
Directed by Petr Lutsik, 1998.
Director - Boris Khlebnikov, script - Boris Khlebnikov and Natalia Meshchaninova, 2023.
One Little Secret from the Night is only allowed to be shown on platforms. But they don’t buy it - perhaps for fear of denunciations
This happens not only with signatories of various kinds of letters or desecrators of traditional family values. The director of “The Challenge” Klim Shipenko, who, by the way, received the State Prize of the Russian Federation for his work, has his own skeleton in the closet - a film about the suicide of Sergei Yesenin “December”, which has not been released since October of the same 2022. There is no official wording of the ban, but the unofficial wording is “too bloody security officers.”
May marks the 40th anniversary of the legendary Fifth Congress of Cinematographers in the Kremlin, which, in fact, opened the era of Gorbachev's glasnost in the USSR. Among other things, the congress decided to create a conflict commission under the Union of Cinematographers, which would analyze “shelf”—that is, prohibited by censorship—cinema. It was headed by film critic Andrei Plakhov.
According to him, the commission initially believed that we could be talking about two or three dozen films. Many of them - for example, "Road Check" by Alexey German, "Bad Joke" by Alexander Alov and Vladimir Naumov, "Repentance" by Tengiz Abuladze, "The Lonely Voice of a Man" by Alexander Sokurov - were heard, and the commission recommended releasing them on priority terms.
Then came the turn of lesser-known films, among which the “Commissar” by Alexander Askoldov turned out to be an absolute masterpiece, but there were also simply unsuccessful works. Then they started talking about films edited at the request of censorship - and in the author’s version, “Ilyich’s Outpost” (in the Soviet box office - “I am 20 years old”) by Marlena Khutsieva and “The Story of Asya Klyachina, who loved, but did not marry” (“Asia’s Happiness”) by Andrei Konchalovsky were released. After some time, the commission came to the conclusion that manipulation of circulation is also a form of censorship. Who could see the film “Pastoral” by Otar Ioseliani, if it was printed in almost 15 copies throughout the country? The situation was no better with Andrei Tarkovsky’s “Mirror” or the films of Kira Muratova. Documentary filmmakers and animators, as well as in the television production sector, found their own “shelves” (despite the fact that in the Soviet years, unlike today, this segment was not at all large).
Directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili, 2008.
Directed by Petr Lutsik, 1998.
Director - Boris Khlebnikov, script - Boris Khlebnikov and Natalia Meshchaninova, 2023.
The Commission of the Union of Cinematographers came to the conclusion that manipulation of circulation is also a form of censorship
The conflict commission worked for two years and reviewed more than 250 films. However, this takes into account the authorities’ monopoly on cinema, when applications for filming went through officials, and production was carried out at a state film studio. It was not difficult to get lost in such a situation (in the 1980s, 150 feature-length feature films and the same number of other formats were shot annually in the USSR), but it was impossible to disappear without a trace.
The film process in the Soviet years was regulated by permits issued by Goskino. Without such a document, the film could not be released. Similar certificates exist today - however, they are called rental ones. However, now the film can be released on any personal Youtube channel even without any approval from above.
This is what happened with Alexander Sokurov’s work “The Fairy Tale”: in 2023, after the Ministry of Culture refused to issue a distribution certificate for the film, Ksenia Sobchak published it, accompanying the screening with a public discussion with the participation of the director.
Nevertheless, the new “shelf” is filling up before our eyes. This signals not only the increase in total censorship in modern Russia (which is obvious), but also the degradation of the entire film process in the country. After all, what is removed from the sphere of public attention does not seem to exist. It is very significant that the Golden Eagle and Nika film awards, which in theory reflect opposing factions of the cinematic community, in reality, receiving state support, undertake not to include films without distribution certificates in their nomination lists.
And if in the case of the Golden Eagle this is understandable and explainable, then in the case of the oldest and most democratic, as it was believed, film award Nika, it is not. Nevertheless, Sokurov’s “Fairy Tale” was not nominated, although several years earlier the director was awarded an award in the “Honor and Dignity” category.
The experience of the White Elephant Award is important,” which not only supported “The Tale”, calling it the best film of the year, but also continues to evaluate the film process without censorship restrictions. Among the winners of the “White Elephant” are the project “Dau” by Ilya Khrzhanovsky (four episodes out of ten were refused distribution certificates), the film “Patient No. 1” by Rezo Gigineishvili (does not have a PU, there was not even an appeal on this matter), the already mentioned “One Little Night Secret”.
In addition, the award supports independent documentary films. In 2025, critics named the film with the symbolic title “The Doors Are Closing” as the best non-fiction film about a choir of Moscow metro workers who goes to perform at a military-patriotic holiday in Crimea. Director Yana Isaenko subtly demonstrates how, against the backdrop of war, human connections and the contours of a world that traditionally positions itself “outside politics” are destroyed.
Directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili, 2008.
Directed by Petr Lutsik, 1998.
Director - Boris Khlebnikov, script - Boris Khlebnikov and Natalia Meshchaninova, 2023.
In general, the presence or absence of a rental certificate, if you do not take into account the festival aspect, ceases to be a significant factor in modern life. The Ministry of Culture’s ban on “Fairy Tales” only fueled interest in it. Some lists of banned films include “Captain Volkonogov Fled” by Natasha Merkulova and Alexey Chupov. But this picture has a PU. It is dated August 2021 and has not been cancelled. Not releasing the film is the decision of the producers. They can be understood: a collision with an “indignant public” is fraught with both moral and material damage. After all, releasing a film into distribution is also a cost.
The historical and ethnographic film “Nuuccia” by Vladimir Munkuev, a laureate of international film festivals in Karlovy Vary and Tallinn, also has a distribution. The certificate for the film was issued in the same August 2021, the audience premiere was scheduled for April 2022. But in February the film was accused of Russophobia, and since then the situation has remained in limbo. There is no formal ban on the film, but there is also confidence that it can be released without a scandal. Censorship and self-censorship go hand in hand.
The film “Nuuccia” was filmed in Yakutia. In recent years, Yakut cinema has been on the rise, and its development occurred “from below”, due to the desire of the local audience to watch films in their native language and the great desire of filmmakers (often almost amateurs) to make films - even for small, two orders of magnitude lower than in Moscow, money. But in Russia, anything that the center did not initiate automatically comes under suspicion. At least three Yakut films are now officially or tacitly banned. In addition to “Nuucci”, this is the comedy “The Candidate” by Dmitry Shadrin (the refusal to receive a permit dates back to October 2023) and the psychological thriller “Aita” by Stepan Burnashev.
Directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili, 2008.
Directed by Petr Lutsik, 1998.
Director - Boris Khlebnikov, script - Boris Khlebnikov and Natalia Meshchaninova, 2023.
At least three Yakut films are officially or tacitly banned today
The main character of Aita, a Yakut with the Russian name Nikolai, is investigating a criminal incident: after a teenage party, 16-year-old Aita tries to commit suicide and eventually dies. The girl leaves a note with the name of the possible offender - Afonya. In the monoethnic village where the film takes place, there is only one Afonya. And he is Russian, and also a policeman.
The investigation is just beginning, and the village is already seething, demanding lynching. The suspect is left at the police station for safety reasons, but the crowd is ready to storm him. At the same time, Nikolai has no sympathy for Athos. In another situation, he himself would have joined the crowd. But he is the head of the police department - in fact, the only authority in the village. And the hero protects the Russian to the last, risking his life, until in the neighboring village they find another Afonya, a Yakut by nationality, the girl’s peer and lover.
The film was made with a refined understanding of the genre and “thick” everyday authenticity. At the box office, it made back the spent budget 10 times (which sounds fantastic for today's Russian cinema).
However, in September 2023, Rospotrebnadzor intervened in the history of Aita. The film's distribution certificate was revoked with the verdict "The film demonstrates the inequality of persons based on nationality." Director Stepan Burnashev was publicly supported by the head of Yakutia, Aisen Nikolaev. The Yakutsk Evening newspaper published an issue with the headline “Roskompozor”. 70 critics and film experts signed an open letter in defense of the film. Rospotrebnadzor was accused of lacking professional expertise in resolving issues such as the assessment of works of art.
However, this did not help the film. As a result, “Aytu” was bought by the international streaming platform Amazon Prime Video, and now viewers around the world can see the film. In Russia, the film is available only on pirated services.
On January 29, a round table was held in the State Duma on the topic “State support and ways to develop domestic cinematography.” Almost all the key figures in the industry took part in it - from the Minister of Culture Olga Lyubimova to the film director, actor and producer Fyodor Bondarchuk. As it turned out, the deputies had a lot of complaints about Russian film production: some did not like “Cheburashka”, while others did not like “Pinocchio”. But the main thing is that the State Duma sincerely does not understand why great patriotic cinema has not yet appeared, which would sell out cinemas. Moreover, after the departure of Western distributors from Russia, there are practically no such distributors.
Directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili, 2008.
Directed by Petr Lutsik, 1998.
Director - Boris Khlebnikov, script - Boris Khlebnikov and Natalia Meshchaninova, 2023.

The event would have gone unnoticed if not for the speech of director Alexei German Jr., who spoke out in a cautious manner against the supervision of government agencies (“If we continue to create more regulatory bodies, we will simply suffocate”) and censorship (“Excessive regulation now can hinder the development of domestic cinema”). All this was said not so much in defense of creative freedom, but out of pure pragmatism: the industry needs rules to adhere to. “It’s very important for us to understand,” Herman said, “what we can talk about and what we can’t talk about.”
Last summer, a column on a similar topic was published in Rossiyskaya Gazeta by Vladimir Putin’s special representative for international cultural cooperation, Mikhail Shvydkoy, who is also a theater producer and critic. In his opinion, due to the many “requirements that are difficult to formalize from a legal point of view” and the lack of uniform rules, it is primarily the quality of works that suffers. “You cannot create while keeping on the table the decrees of the President of the Russian Federation and sets of laws, including, in addition to the Civil Code, the Criminal Code,” noted Shvydkoy.
From all that has been said above, we can conclude that the most pragmatic part of the cultural establishment is trying to agree with the state on the limits of its censorship participation in the lives of artists (and the latter will eventually come up with ways to bypass these limits, as was already the case in Soviet times). But the same Shvydkoy seems to understand the complexity of such a task:
“It would be much more honest to return to censorship, which would be carried out by professionals, and not by bureaucrats of various departments, who themselves do not fully understand what they need to be afraid of in order not to lose their position. Yes, the revival of the institution of censorship is an expensive pleasure, requiring not hundreds, but thousands of enlightened servants of the state, but, perhaps, only it can maintain a healthy environment in the creative environment.”
We are, in fact, talking about the restoration of the Soviet era of stagnation, when the newspaper “Pravda” hung on every pole, and Georgy Danelia filmed the “Autumn Marathon”, and every artist knew perfectly well what was allowed by the rules and what was not. Only such rules are a consequence of building long-term and compromise relations between the artist and the authorities. Does the current state need such relations, if under its command are detachments of “social activists” who, at a whistle from above, are capable of destroying the exhibition of Vadim Sidur, and throwing paint on an objectionable artist in a public place, and “cancelling” any film or performance - despite the fact that the other part of society has either left the country or is subject to a heap of repressive laws?
It is much easier for the authorities, while solving momentary tactical problems, to keep both the intelligentsia and the people, as the classic said, “in a state of constant amazement,” declaring through their speakers and thinkers that “Cheburashka,” for example, is “a harmful film product that is corrupting our children” (the words of deputy Dmitry Pevtsov), or even cooler, “the appearance of Cheburashka coincides with the transition to petty-bourgeois values and infantilism. That’s how the USSR collapsed - Cheburashka destroyed it!”, as the philosopher Alexander Dugin said.
Directed by Mikheil Kalatozishvili, 2008.
Directed by Petr Lutsik, 1998.
Director - Boris Khlebnikov, script - Boris Khlebnikov and Natalia Meshchaninova, 2023.
Sign up for regular donations