When they talk and write about dreams, they tell a lot of curious dream plots, unexpected memories, etc. They argue about the role of today, or yesterday, the day before yesterday, or long-ago experiences, all this is very interesting and important to know. It is very interesting that in a dream film all literary tropes are revealed, and this requires special research. I can only briefly outline a few. The dream has a very strong hyperbole: Freud talks about a terrible dream: a man is led to the scaffold, his head is cut off, and all he has is the cushion of the sofa on which he slept has fallen back. Such exaggeration occurs, if not always, then very often, which contradicts the definition of a dream as a guardian of sleep; it excites, awakens, and guards, in principle, not a dream, but our life.
No one seems to have noticed that the visible part of the dream is preceded by a long part of the invisible or semi-visible part of the dream. Then you wake up with the feeling that a lot, a lot has happened, but there is nothing to tell. Sleep is the resolution of neural tensions, and therefore brings rest.
And this resolution occurs through logical channels, because everything in the world is logical and natural. Neural micrologic is different from our usual macrologic, but it organically transforms into it because it easily transitions into the process of half-thought-dream, and this is already at the stage of less deep sleep. And after a visible dream you usually wake up - the dream does not guard our sleep well. The guard function of a dream does not explain its essence, just like a lock on a door, it guards without having a clue about the meaning of its function. Both the invisible and visible parts of a dream are, in principle, a thought process, but why is this thought so surreal and illogical?
And it seems that no one has asked this main question about dreams.
The main question that I would like to ask is: why does a dream never speak about anything directly, only allegorically, and we have to unravel the allegories? But having said this, we cannot help but immediately remember that art also suffers from this mania of allegory. True, art can be very different: there is very documentary prose, very plausible painting, but we will find elements of allegory there, and poetry, in general, is obsessed with allegory, and the metaphorical nature progresses. For example, they pay attention to the fact that Pushkin does not have metaphors, but in modern poetry it reigns, here is a piece from Andrei Bitov:
Everything in everything is so alien and transparent,
And before our eyes the last outline melts,
We’ll take away a random detail as a keepsake;
On the horizon, the janitor dawns.
How good-natured and carefree the swing
His brooms! Toy... What a shame
Matter appears in the darkness:
You can see through us, since I can’t see myself.
It's all a metaphor! A dream is also a complete allegory - a metaphor.
In dream metaphors, Freud looks for real but repressed secret desires, especially incestuous ones. Suppressed from our consciousness due to their prohibition, these desires, like titans in tartarus, rush out at night, taking advantage of the fact that the thunderer Zeus, the omnipotent ruler of consciousness and law, is asleep. This is a central motif of Freudian philosophy and psychology and has practical implications.
But it is interesting that Freud himself seems to act against himself in the sense that thanks to his teaching, people no longer hide anything from themselves, they become aware of themselves.
Sexual prohibitions remain, and there are much more of them than expediency requires, but in thoughts and conversations we have become liberated and at least we do not hide anything from ourselves. Therefore, the Freudian ethical principle of repression is clearly insufficient. What other principle of repression (if it is repression) can be recognized?
There is a universal coordinate system for understanding any system: entropy-negentropy, chaos-space (as a perfectly organized world), harmony-disharmony, holism-reductionism, organization-disorganization. All these pairs are synonymous. In this coordinate system, displacement should also be considered.
In philosophy one can recognize the struggle of ideas: among the Greeks (Stoics) the beginning of the world is chaos, the Bible begins with God - the highest organization. Modern cosmogony votes for the biblical principle.
But if in philosophy this dispute is possible, then in psychology the presumption of the cosmos-logos is undeniable. Chaos is something unknown, unmastered and therefore hostile. We strive to organize everything both outside and inside ourselves. What our brain does is that it puts the signals entering it into some order. This is very difficult, the phenomena are contradictory, their connection is not always clear. Unable to connect phenomena strictly logically, humanity creates myths that order the world in their own way, because it is impossible to live in chaos.
But we can create order in our room, in our house, order is always narrow, small in comparison with the endless unknown around us. But chaos does not cease to be real because we did not let it into the house, it is aggressive and breaks in one way or another - that’s the whole scheme of repression, it differs from Freud’s so far only in that I use more general criteria.
But the essence of repression and the repressed still changes. The repressed desire expresses itself through an allegory - a metaphor, which means that the metaphor itself not only hides, but also reveals and expresses. This expressive function of metaphor has remained misunderstood. We repress the sexually forbidden, but no less important is that we miss everything that does not fit in our logically ordered room.
So the poor Jew kicked out the goat from the house, which he had taken into the house on the advice of the rabbi, and which was greatly bothering him. But he still needs her milk, and cannot get rid of the goat. This is how, while establishing logical order in the house, we are obliged to drive out the goat and much else that is necessary, important, but does not fit into our logical order. This is a completely different principle of repression-expression: not forbidden, but inappropriate, inedible, alien, incomprehensible!
And the exiled goats have their own opinion and a sense of their own worth, and they bleat at night, preventing them from sleeping. This is not exactly what Freud told us.
And thanks to him, we have become more conscious, we understand ourselves perfectly, but have our dreams become less metaphorical, less secretive? So what are they hiding and what are we trying to reveal?
And if our consciousness still had something to hide, delicate instincts, then it is completely unclear what literary and artistic metaphors hide and what they reveal, what should they hide? And if not, why is poetry so sick with metaphor, allegory, why not say directly: I love you, what more! And get a straight answer? But no, Tsvetaeva beckons us: “I like that you are not sick with me, I like that I am sick not with you.” when it is clear to everyone that she is sick with them, and he with her! Everything is roundabout - affirmation through negation... why?
But let’s admit that this denial immediately expands the background: it’s not like they both confessed to each other and locked themselves in the room, don’t peep! Suddenly an invisible picture of poetic bohemia appears before us, where he and she kiss the other, the other, touch only with their sleeves, why don’t they fall into each other’s arms?
The obnoxious Jew Isaac Newton is to blame for this, you won’t believe it - it was he who discovered that the whole world is structured like this: the earth reaches out to the sun, but for some reason does not fall into his arms? Oh, that would be tragic! And she always revolves around... here they are, these people revolve mutually in their get-together, there are happy embraces in love, but everything is so complicated, and through this small “no”: “not by me, not by you, not by festivities, not above our heads...” all this complexity bursts into the relationship of two like anti-gravity, preventing the earth from connecting with the sun, and forcing two people to root for each other at a distance...? This is how the world works, gravity and repulsion never tire of fighting and intercourse with each other.
And in this small example we still catch the nimble lizard - the content of the metaphor! She does not hide - she reveals not only and not so much what is forbidden and therefore repressed, she expresses what cannot be expressed in words, what does not lend itself to logic.
The word names - the metaphor expresses, another principle works here - not designations, but expressions, through imitation, the metaphor tries to repeat the structure of the ideal image, so the metaphor expresses the inexpressible, depicts the inexpressible!
This is already a very important difference from Freud. There is, Freud’s repression of the forbidden has not gone away, but we can say a general thing: our consciousness is not able to accommodate the unconscious, the infinite and much, much more, not because this something is being pushed out, but because it is not built according to the rules of grammar, semantics, syntactics, not according to the rules of accepted logic.
Let us ask ourselves more specifically, what and why cannot be expressed directly logically? Here we suddenly find ourselves in a collision that is no longer ethical or even psychological, but in a cognitive conflict, but this is an immense sphere.
Nevertheless, here, to continue the thought, we are obliged to formulate at least in a few words the most important principle of cognition, which, in my opinion, has not been realized by anyone, I will call it the “matrix principle of cognition.” What is it? Let me take my favorite example with light:
Let there be light! The Lord said, and since then white, pure God's light has been pouring onto the earth! But the sinful earth devilishly perverts everything. We do not see the light itself at all, only its reflection. At the same time, falling on vegetation, white light appears green to us, falling on the sea appears blue to us (“near the bluest sea”), falling on sand white light appears yellow... it is always cunning, playing hide and seek, changing its faces.
Now let’s imagine that vegetation is a kind of matrix limited in its reflection capabilities and, moreover, again crafty. She gives us only one component of God's pure light - green, and hides the rest, oh this eternal deception! But the sand and the sea do the same thing - diabolical!
Everything in the world interacts, that is, everything reflects each other, and let’s call the reflecting reality a matrix and immediately notice that all matrices are limited and cunning: this one reflects only green, hides red and yellow, that one vice versa, and so on ad infinitum. The human system is multi-matrix, multi-receptor: sound is reflected by the ears, but never by the eyes, light by the eyes, but not by the ears, etc.
But our logic can also be presented as a matrix, it can reflect a lot, but not everything - it is very important to realize these limitations.
It is important that:
1. logic cannot understand the quality of things, it can only name these qualities: blue, red, green, but these realities themselves are already outside logic, they belong to a different sensory visual matrix, sounds belong to the auditory matrix, etc.
2. Logic, in principle, cannot grasp the whole, because the whole is a whole synchronous world, and logic is diachronic, linear. And so logic loses a lot, but not because it represses, pushes away, but because it is not able to perceive, just as the ears cannot perceive light. This is no longer repression - omission, and this not repressed, but missed reality is also capable of turning into metaphors.
This needs to be traced in more detail, because the main thing here is that the extra-logical-sensory elements of the psyche are not only real, but also very strong (a horse carrying a rider)
and they are very active. As in chemistry, these sensory realities are connected and separated according to their nonlinear, material, sensory, intuitive, imaginative, qualitative - integral logic - all this is fundamentally opposite to the “ideal-linear” logic.
As always, music turns out to be a necessary example: it is not bodies that act here—field waves—“clouds,” as in an atom. And just as atoms uniting to form molecules, so sounds uniting create new wholes - consonances, motives... an integral, creative, holistic principle of interaction.
Music combines diachrony and synchrony because at the end of a melody we remember its beginning.
If I say: the plane landed at 8. Then there is no plane here - there is a name that turns it into a point, the landing is also precise - a point. And this implies a line of communication between cities, which have also turned into points. This is the main intention of ideal logic: to turn everything into points and lines, it gives precise connections between events, but the events themselves, the things-subjects, were left behind.
The logic of things, the logic of life is directly opposite to the usual point-linear logic. In life, it is not points that interact. Even elementary particles are depicted today as clouds. Things are not clouds, but the functional boundaries of a thing go far beyond its material limits, giving it cloudiness as well. I would even contrast ideal or verbal logic, point-linear, with cloudy, non-linear logic, because the more point-wise the elements, the more linear, the more schematic the logic. Why is this important? Yes, because you need to understand the contrast between the real logic of life and the “ideal” logic of points and lines. It turns out that our sensuality is not laid out on the matrix of logic, remains homeless, lives on its own.
And here is the main thing of the main thing: when I said that the plane landed at 8, I did not create anything, I noted the connection of events, but in real, material, sensory life there are no points, there are “subjects-things-clouds”, when they meet, as in chemistry they unite, integrate, create new and new wholes-organisms, this logic can be called integral-creative creative. And this is a completely different principle compared to ordinary, point-linear, non-creative-ascertaining logic - different matrices! So is it any wonder that our sensual, emotional life is always outside of logic, and this emotional life seeks its expression in the metaphor of art, dreams, while it always remains unclear to what extent the metaphor-alogism-dream is present and guides us in our waking life. After all, above us is myth, cult, religion, tradition, fashion, complexes that are types of collective sleep. Freud preferred to see this as a collective neurosis, but having discovered in the illogical metaphor not only and not so much repression, but
THE EXPRESSION OF THE UNPRESSABLE, I prefer to call it the collective waking dream. So Karl Marx is on my side, calling religion “the opium of the people.” He puts only a negative meaning into this, but to what black reality did we wake up in the sobering-up tank of socialism? No, religion is, first of all, a spiritually organizing institution, and there is no substitute for religion; the masses are unable to perceive a rational idea except by turning it into a religion: Confucianism, Marxism-Leninism... because religion has a strong suggestion, which is not found in a scientific text, and it also has a psychologically protective function.
Metaphor is also always illogical, but like music it tries to depict the indescribable, at least in a hint to repeat the structure of an emotional image.
And if in our daytime consciousness ordinary verbal logic dominates, then at night “the power has changed,” sensual, emotional, figurative—integral chemistry dominates. It invades the world of daytime logic, forming bizarre logical-illogical connections, surreal, psychedelic dreams. This can be compared to the bending of light near gravitating masses; our logic in a dream is distorted under the influence of gravitating sensory elements that we do not see in wakefulness.
Thus, we have replaced the repression with the principle of a nonlinear sensory integral logos, similar to the chemical one. Metaphor is an expression of the inexpressible, an image of the inexpressible. She is always not logical, but with a hint she tries to repeat and depict the structure of an invisible image, and thus how to depict it.
But it inevitably follows from this that all art is a continuous metaphor, because initially the condition was set to transfer our experiences to another matrix, be it canvas, stone, stage, word, which means that Pushkin also sins with metaphor... Emotional, figurative logos - it simply cannot be expressed by ordinary linear logic, hence this “mania of allegory” in dreams and in art, and we still need to thoroughly understand to what extent we sleep while awake!
And one more thing, again the “most” important thing. Our thinking is generalized, every word is a generalization: a house is all houses, a forest is all forests, that is, the word denotes not objects, but types of objects, etc. But what logical connection, tell me, can there be between the elevator and space? No! But Einstein, going up in the elevator, and feeling that his body was getting heavier, understood the deepest connection between speed and mass, and then he built the theory of relativity. This means that our sensuality and intuition are capable of capturing immeasurably deep similarities between things. Our brain is filled with logical schemes, and intuition captures deeper connections between phenomena and builds its own systems.
And it took the coming of Freud, who would try to explain sensory systems, calling them complexes, logically. This is another aspect of what we have designated as the inability of the logical matrix to reflect cardinal sensory realities: the inability of logic to comprehend quality, to grasp the whole, and now we have noted its insensitivity to the very deep connections of things. Let us note right away that in other cases logic and mathematics can rise to heights of intuition that are inaccessible, so let’s not quarrel too much with the sisters of knowledge. But in all cases of logical impotence, the sisters resolve the conflict with the help of metaphor, which takes the form of myth during the day, dreams at night, and poetry for all occasions!
Metaphor!