
More is known about HIV than about any other virus. Thirty years ago, doctors were puzzled when Kaposi's sarcoma and Pneumocystis pneumonia were being diagnosed in young gay men. Since then, scientists and doctors, supported by AIDS activism, have discovered a virus called HIV and proven that it causes AIDS by destroying the immune system to the point that the body can no longer fight off life-threatening infections.
Scientists from all over the world isolated HIV, photographed it with an electron microscope, and determined the sequence of bases in the genome of various subtypes of the virus. There are very accurate tests for antibodies to HIV and for the virus itself, and there are antiretroviral drugs to treat this infection, which are becoming increasingly effective and have fewer side effects.
Science is a slow process, and much about HIV is not yet known, but the evidence is overwhelming that HIV exists, that it is transmitted through blood, semen and vaginal secretions, and that it causes AIDS.
Despite this , there are thousands of people who persistently reject all these facts. They believe that HIV is harmless, or that it does not exist at all. Some argue that HIV has other causes, including drugs, depression, dirty sex, stress, poor diet or conventional medicine. Others claim that HIV is simply an artificial combination of similar diseases. Those who reject the science of HIV/AIDS as such call themselves "AIDS dissidents", others refer to themselves as "HIV deniers" because for them personal denial has become an ideology.
Most people are surprised by the very existence of HIV denial. “I had no idea there were any AIDS deniers, and I still don’t understand how anyone could believe such a thing,” one blogger wrote after reading about the deaths of prominent AIDS dissident Christina Maggiore and her young daughter, both of whom died as a result of AIDS. What is most puzzling is the persistent belief in irrational ideas that no evidence can shake, despite the terrible deaths of followers from AIDS and the complete absence of a single alternative theory. How can people ignore not just scientific evidence, but their own deteriorating health? How could Maggior refuse to prevent HIV transmission to her own children? How could she allow the senseless death of her own child and herself? And how can her fans, initially frightened by what happened, go back to HIV denial?
HIV denial can be understood if we view the movement as a form of religious sect. AIDS dissidents perceive official medicine and science regarding HIV as an “orthodox faith”; the scientific field is given an almost religious context. At the same time, they perceive themselves as leaders of the opposition, seers and prophets.
Sociologists and social psychologists have identified several signs of destructive sects. Many of these characteristics are characteristic of AIDS dissidents. First of all, this is expressed in the fact that they support a black and white view of the world, the “us against them” position. The members of your group are the chosen ones, one of the few who know the secret truth, the last stronghold among numerous and powerful enemies. They believe that pharmaceutical companies, the government, researchers, doctors, the UN, HIV activists, charities, AIDS service organizations are all part of a secret and sinister conspiracy. Former Highway Patrol cop Clark Baker calls the conspiracy "the most important criminal conspiracy I could imagine," and it was all about killing perfectly healthy people with toxic drugs for financial gain.
Many HIV deniers become supporters of “alternative medicine” and “spiritual practices,” including mind-altering practices that are typical of religious sects. Noteworthy is the use of hypnosis by the AIDS dissident organization HEAL in New York. Members of the organization believe that people get sick and die simply because they were told they were HIV positive. HEAL leader Michael Ellner uses hypnosis to get people out of the deadly "AIDS zone" and into "coming to terms with a positive test."
Ellner is not the only one who believes that words kill but viruses do not. The theologians of the sect call this “mystical manipulation.” AIDS dissident Matt Irwin, in his book AIDS and the Voodoo Curse, proposes the following theory: “The severe, acute psychological stress associated with being diagnosed as HIV positive quickly transforms into the severe, chronic psychological stress of living with the prediction of a terrible disintegration that could begin at any minute. This causes suppression of the immune system with a selective decrease in CD4 T cells. ... These factors were studied in healthy people when they created the same immunosuppression and immune dysregulation that could later be called “AIDS.”
AIDS dissident Michael Geiger, another proponent of “dangerous” thoughts, even blamed another dissident for the death of Christina Maggiore, saying he did it because of his concern for her health. “Have we still not learned anything... how easy it is to implant projections of illness and death into ourselves, as well as into our friends, acquaintances, or even our own children, thereby making our fears come true?” Ironically, Celia Farber regularly “projects” exactly this: “I feared for Maggiore’s life, always. I feared that her struggle would kill her, just as I felt that it would kill me if I did not find enough beauty to turn off the hostility. This is an occult battle, and Christina is caught in its darkest shadows." Farber also accuses proponents of the “AIDS orthodoxy” of long-distance mental murder: “It’s voodoo, what they did to [South African health minister and AIDS dissident] Manto. It's heartbreaking. Sometimes I think that they killed Ijey [Maggior's little daughter] with their voodoo. What did Ijey die from? Can anyone explain this to me? Is this like something anyone has seen before?” (Ijay died of AIDS-associated Pneumocystis pneumonia).
Cults manipulate the feelings of believers, using shame and guilt to control group members. Because both AIDS and practices associated with the risk of HIV transmission are highly stigmatized, HIV-negative leaders of the AIDS dissident movement often speak disparagingly of people with HIV, even if they are also AIDS dissidents.
Peter Duesberg always argued that AIDS in gay men develops due to drug use and promiscuous sex, and he openly called gay men who claimed that they did not do anything like that liars.
Clark Baker claims that AIDS was invented because “a small group of depraved, drug-addicted, nitrite-snorting, gonorrhea- and syphilis-ridden sauna veterans fell ill.” One poster at a dissident conference called AIDS "premature aging" from "snorting poppers, using methamphetamine, drinking too much, smoking too much, poor diet, lack of sleep, unprotected sex and all sorts of pathogens from hundreds of sexual partners."
If HIV-positive dissidents fell ill, they were accused of not being sufficiently committed to the movement: “Given that the choice comes down to death from the deadly HIV products or a long healthy life based on the dissident belief that HIV products are nothing more than a baseless commodity peddled by drug dealers, choosing [sic] the dissident dream is a much better choice. The pseudo-dissident... will use dissident views as a means of survival... When they are struck by the most common disease, and they run to drink poisonous drugs and suffer from a variety of health problems, exactly in accordance with the predictions of dissident models, they jeopardize the message of the dissidents.
When AIDS dissidents die of AIDS, they are often posthumously branded as liars or secret drug addicts. When Rafael Lombardo died, Peter Duesberg wrote: “Looking back, I see that his letter was too good to be true. Now I'm afraid he was describing the man he wanted to be, the man his Italian family wanted him to be, rather than who he really was." (What Duesberg means is that Lombardo lied about never using drugs). Liam Sheff tried to smear the reputation of the deceased Mark Griffiths with the help of rather transparent hints: “I knew he was very convincing when I worked with him, impeccable. Almost. Sometimes, once or twice, he seemed a little under the weather. But he told me it was just alcohol. In fact, he admitted to drinking alcohol perhaps more than he should." Sheff argued that Griffiths died of alcohol, not AIDS.
Like people who leave religious sects, former AIDS dissidents are met with incredible hostility. Dr. Joseph Sonnabend was one of the first doctors to treat people with AIDS. At the beginning of the epidemic, he insisted that more evidence was needed that HIV caused AIDS. He was also very cautious about prescribing new, less-tested drugs, and he recognized that additional factors, such as drug use and frequent episodes of sexually transmitted infections, played important roles in the development and risk of disease.
AIDS dissidents often claimed that Sonnabend was on their side. When video clips of him were used in the AIDS dissident film House of Numbers to support the views of those who deny that HIV causes AIDS, it prompted a negative blog post on Poz.com denouncing Sonnabend. However, he responded to this post, denying the film's thesis. Sonnabend stated unequivocally that HIV is the cause of AIDS, and that antiretroviral therapy saves lives. He wrote: “It is difficult to fully convey the feelings of a doctor who finally had the opportunity to help his patients in the mid-1990s, when the disease had already killed hundreds of patients. By the time antiretroviral drugs became available, about 400 of my patients had died of AIDS, a terrible mortality rate. The effect of the drugs saved the lives of many at the last stage of the disease, those who until recently had no chance of survival. When these drugs are presented as exclusively toxic, it is a terrible injustice.”
Sonnabed was immediately accused of betraying the dissident sect. On one forum, someone “Ellis” wrote: “In my opinion, you are a vile fraudster, as soon as the smell of frying began, you backed out, now pointing fingers and calling names on those who have enough decency not to buy into dollars and popularity. Who cares if HIV causes AIDS, or ten thousand causes cause AIDS? ...Are you trying to discredit the film because you are ridiculously bad at acting in front of a camera? Because you seem like a drunken old man, which you must be, and which you don’t hide very well? You sold out to pseudoscientific corporations a long time ago, but are you really so pathetic as to take out your hatred on those who are still dissatisfied with the industrial formal diagnosis? Shame on you, shame, shame, shame. You've sold out and you're ridiculous."
Celia Farber similarly attacked Sonnabend on the Spectator website, accusing him of personal and medical betrayal: “I have countless hours of tape from the mercurial and unscrupulous Joe Sonnabend, dating back to 1988... all the way back to 2001, if not longer. And after all this he became a fanatic of traditional views. … For me, like everyone Joe has hurt, I forgive him because he seems so ashamed. I even invited him to my wedding. But he is a weak, dishonest person with no decency, he loves sensationalism, and he loves to hurt everyone around him.”
At the same time, Sonnabed’s only “sin” in the eyes of the cult was the recognition of scientific research, the need for which he once insisted, and which proved that HIV causes AIDS, and that antiretroviral therapy is an effective method of treatment.
Peter Duesberg always blamed the emergence of AIDS on gays who drank poppers and were promiscuous. He called those people who said that neither the first nor the second applied to them liars.
The peculiarity of sects is that cult members are isolated from the outside world and this helps control the uniformity of their thoughts, preventing criticism. Of course, AIDS dissidents were not isolated in ashrams somewhere in the wilderness, but such isolation took place in their online groups and small circle of friends. People were urged not to take HIV antibody tests, not to read mainstream information about AIDS, but only to dissident texts, and to “stay as far away from allopathic doctors as possible.”
Robert Lifton, a social psychologist and expert on cults, identified the “principle of doctrine over man” as a key characteristic of destructive cults. This doctrine “is invoked when cult members are confronted with a contradiction between their actual experience and what dogma says they should experience. The learned rule is... that a person is obliged to suppress his personal experience in order to preserve the truth of dogma. Any contradictions cause a feeling of guilt: doubts are perceived as a sign of one’s own inferiority or sinfulness.”
Many HIV-positive AIDS dissidents experience similar conflict. In reality, their immune system is destroyed, which contradicts their belief that HIV does not exist or is harmless. There is a long list of HIV-positive AIDS dissidents who have died as a result of AIDS (published on the website AIDStruth.org), and it contradicts the fact that not a single HIV-negative leader of the dissident movement died young, not to mention the fact that not a single HIV-negative dissident died from the numerous strange infections that turned out to be AIDS-defining diseases.
Some HIV-positive AIDS dissidents violate the ban on HIV treatment when they develop AIDS. They start taking antiretroviral drugs and feel better quickly. But rather than abandoning AIDS dissident views, many are trying to come up with an alternative explanation for the success of the drugs. For example, Noreen Martin insists that her AIDS is not viral in nature: “My own experience of AIDS was caused by long-term negative health problems. When I got really sick, I took my medications, ate healthy, took about 50 supplements a day, and stayed positive. That’s why in just a few months I was as good as new.” She stopped taking antiretroviral drugs for three years. “During this period,” she wrote, “my chronic fatigue gradually returned, my CD4 count dropped, and my viral load rose to 3 million. However, I didn't really trust these numbers; after studying everything carefully, I realized that they had nothing to do with health. It was other diseases that were causing these problems, and the antiretroviral drugs were strong enough to affect them. ... Last fall I again felt extremely tired, and for a year I was anemic and struggled with lymphedema for several months. I started taking antiretroviral drugs because I could barely get out of bed and couldn't function at all." Her health improved again.
Another AIDS dissident says: “I’ve seen many of my friends get better on antiretroviral drugs, but I always thought that these drugs were just so broad-based that they could kill almost any microorganism, and at the same time the “good” inside the body.”
Another thoughtful woman, trying to reconcile her illness with dogma, wrote: “I can only say that I do what I think helps at this particular moment. If this stops working, I'll make a new plan. And just because they are called antiretroviral, does not mean that they really are.”
The only way to survive and remain in the dissident camp is to pretend that antiretroviral drugs, designed and intended solely to block the multiplication stages of HIV in T-lymphocytes, are some kind of super-strong disinfectants.
Some AIDS dissidents living with HIV find themselves unable to ignore their own experiences enough to resist the cult's rhetoric. One tired man, diagnosed with HIV in 1996, wrote: “To be honest, I'm fed up with questions like this. Some of us experience strangely similar symptoms. Some well-known people have died exactly as traditional medicine predicted. When will dissidents start asking important questions, instead of repeating the words "AIDS ZONE" over and over again? I'm not in any AIDS zone, there's just something happening to me that I can't control. I have never been this close to starting Atripla. I don’t want to print this... but it’s true.”
The AIDS dissident movement itself has always been divided. Different dissident leaders explain the causes of AIDS in different ways, and their explanations are not compatible with each other. There are different schools of quack alternative healing within the movement. Even on the question of the existence of HIV, there is no consensus - some dissidents believe that HIV does not exist at all, others that this virus is real, but harmless. The only thing that unites people with such contradictory views is the ritual and monotonous repetition of long-outdated statements, coupled with a refusal to listen to scientific evidence. The most successful dissident propaganda avoids direct statements altogether. New supporters are recruited through hints and generalities, since precise and specific statements can cause aggression within the movement itself and can be easily refuted by scientific evidence.
And all the same, it is very difficult for believing dissidents to free themselves from the sect. Dissidents become dependent on AIDS dissent - it becomes part of their world view and part of their identity. AIDS dissidents get used to feeling like brave heroes and fighters for a just cause; very often they begin to engage in professional journalism to promote their views, or participate in the alternative medicine business. Their social circle begins to consist of those who reject the science of HIV and official medicine. So if they admit they are wrong, they have a lot to lose.
However, HIV treatments are getting better and better, and people with HIV are able to live long and healthy lives through treatment. As a result, the psychological need to deny the diagnosis becomes less and less, since it is no longer a terrible death sentence, but a chronic, treatable disease.
It is quite possible that very soon there will be no HIV-positive people left among the AIDS dissidents. The only dissidents will be HIV-negative people who know nothing about the communities affected by the epidemic, and no one will care about their sect.
Author: Gene Bergman, veteran HIV activist and human rights activist based in New York.