About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
09/25/2021
Author
Evgeny Konoplev
Source
syg.ma
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

The structure of Marxist apology

Ilya Repin, "Arrest of a Propagandist", 1892

The famous writer Jack London has an essay: “How I became a socialist?” In it, he describes how life itself hammered into him the principles of socialism, dispelling faith in the entrepreneurial and patriotic prejudices from which he had previously suffered. Realizing that it was extremely difficult for the “blond beast” - or in modern terms, the “Atlanta of free enterprise” - to survive without going bankrupt for six months, without damaging one’s health, or being arrested on false charges, Jack London realized that society should be structured differently - and in socialist literature he found the answer to what forces in an already existing society would bring about its qualitative transformation in the near future. The description of socialism “from the first person”, learned from life experience and accepted with all my heart, which runs through the American writer in his works, can leave a rare reader indifferent, an outside observer.

Vladimir Ilyich Lenin’s justification for socialism was structured differently. In his articles and books, he never tired of insisting that Marxism is an integral scientific theory and a natural product of the development of the social movement and scientific thought of his time. In the article “The Three Sources and Three Components of Marxism,” he characterizes this universal objectivity in the following words:

“The history of philosophy and the history of social science show with complete clarity that in Marxism there is nothing like “sectarianism” in the sense of some closed, ossified teaching that arose away from the high road of development of world civilization. On the contrary, the whole genius of Marx lies precisely in the fact that he gave answers to questions that the progressive thought of mankind had already posed. His teaching arose as a direct and immediate continuation of the teaching of the greatest representatives of philosophy, political economy and socialism.

Marx's teaching is omnipotent because it is true. It is complete and harmonious, giving people a complete worldview , irreconcilable with any superstition, with any reaction, with any defense of bourgeois oppression. It is the legitimate successor to the best that humanity created in the 19th century in the person of German philosophy, English political economy, French socialism."

Both methods of presentation form a stable structure: either you become a socialist from subjective, vital, experienced reasons - or you assimilate socialist ideas from scientific literature, reasoning objectively. This structure of objective and subjective presentation of socialist ideas in some way correlates with the synchronic division between right and left deviations in the socialist movement - for example, Karl Kautsky or the ideologists of the Fabian society, unshakably confident in the objectivity of the victory of communism, clearly downplayed the importance of the subjective acceptance of communist ideas and practical adherence to them; the course of world history will ultimately still lead to their triumph. On the contrary, supporters of left communism - such as the communism of workers' councils, the left wing of the Russian Socialist Revolutionaries and similar comrades, believed that without strong-willed, immediate practical action, world history would not lead to socialism, considering it unnecessary to study the objective conditions under which their actions would make sense or lead to results not opposite to those expected, as is usually the case with illiterate activists overwhelmed by the euphoria of direct action.

On the other hand, such a division clearly correlates with the diachronic division between orthodox and neo-Marxism. Thus, for a supporter of orthodox, political-economic Marxism - the period of which can be outlined from the moment the work of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels began in the mid-40s of the 19th century, and ending with the tragic death of Lev Davydovich Trotsky, killed on August 21, 1940 on the orders of the traitor to the October Revolution, the complete counter-revolutionary I.V. Stalin - it is essential to exclude both right and left deviations that deny the possibility of the masses to follow the proletariat, the proletariat to unite into a party, and the party to follow the objective, scientifically known laws of social development. On the contrary, for the supporter of neo-Marxism - the period of which can be outlined from the creation of the Frankfurt School to the present day - the inclusion in a single movement of all subjectivities generated by exclusion from capitalist society, oppressed and exploited by the existing system, which thereby prepares its own end, is essential.

Everyone can judge for themselves how successfully these structures are implemented on their average statistical media by talking with members of currently existing Marxist parties or activist associations. In my subjective experience, the problem of the former is that the books of Marx, Engels, Lenin, Trotsky (for some - Stalin, Mao Zedong or Che Guevara) are revered in them, but not read - for years - not to mention modern natural and social scientific literature, which, according to V.I. himself, should be deeply known and regularly studied. Lenin, every communist is obliged : “<…> you would make a huge mistake if you tried to draw the conclusion that you can become a communist without mastering what has been accumulated by human knowledge. It would be a mistake to think that it is enough to assimilate communist slogans, the conclusions of communist science, without mastering the sum of knowledge, the consequence of which is communism itself. An example of how communism emerged from the sum of human knowledge is Marxism. <...> You can become a communist only when you enrich your memory with the knowledge of all the riches that humanity has developed ."

Whereas the problem of the latter can be illustrated by the following anecdote that happened to me five or six years ago. One day, animal rights activists came to me to convince me that wearing fur products was bad and immoral. They did not come empty-handed, but with propaganda, including a calendar in which a photograph of two fluffy raccoons looking into the frame was combined with the inscription: “Look into the eyes of your fur coat!” One must think that among citizens who do not know zoology in general and the anatomy of the eye of mammals in particular, this propaganda was supposed to arouse compassion for the unfortunate and cute little animals, so similar to human babies, who are skinned in fur factories for the pleasure of rich slackers - or something like that.

Fortunately, even at school I studied biology quite well, and even took 38th place in the All-Russian Olympiad in this subject out of two million of my peers, puzzling the activists themselves with a counter question: why should I consider the presence of raccoons’ eyes (and this was precisely the fact presented on the calendar), consisting of a retina, cornea, pupil, lens and other functional parts, as a basis for compassion and certain socio-political actions caused by compassion, and not by reasoning with a cool head? Eyes, for example, exist not only in raccoons, foxes, arctic foxes and other fur-bearing animals - but also in rats, pigeons, fleas, mosquitoes and the like - should we, out of compassion for them, stop measures aimed at limiting their populations, which harm people and agriculture? And what about organisms that do not have eyes to look into, but which are also living beings - should we sympathize with them in the same way as the raccoons presented? Science knows of over sixty thousand species of parasitic worms alone—more than all mammals and birds combined. Finally, in nature there are a great many objects that are not living - on what basis should we have compassion for some and be indifferent to others? If it is permissible to fight for the liberation of raccoons out of sheer compassion for them, not based on any rational arguments, then why not fight for the liberation of, say, slippers , if someone has compassion and spiritual sympathy for them? And it is precisely this trend that we observe in modern posthumanism, about the philosophical foundations and alternatives of which I write in the articles “ Beyond the Threshold of Humanity ” and “ Theses on Critical Humanisms .”

The comrade activists were unable to give me an intelligible answer either at that time or during subsequent communication - since their cultural level, alas, was far from the one at which they can safely question their own beliefs, redefining them over and over again in accordance with the developing scientific picture of the world. The condition for raising the cultural level of one or another part of society is the development of material production, which requires increasingly qualified personnel to work and manage it - which is the ultimate goal of socialism, regardless of what its individual representatives think about it.

Let us assume, however, that our contemporary, who in one way or another has adopted the socialist or communist worldview - which today is again expectedly becoming a cultural norm, after some time would decide to reflect on the reasons why he did this, so as not to take a bad example either from members of the “communist” parties, where communism is the same name, or from activists who are ready to fight for the liberation of domestic plants from their imprisonment in flower pots. It is expected that its presentation, determined by the structure of the existing argumentation on this issue, would develop in one of the indicated directions. Either he would present his views subjectively, writing something along the lines of “Why did I become a Marxist?”, or he would emphasize the scientific objectivity of socialism, writing an article along the lines of “Why is Marx’s teaching correct?”

Is it possible today to insist on the truth of Marxism in particular and socialism in general beyond this binary structure, in a new way? One of the possible and even obvious solutions, which does not claim absolute novelty, but which shifts the relationship of already given opposites, is from mutual expression: subjective acceptance through objective evidence and vice versa. Such mutual expression is an application of the principle of mesoticism as the possibility of a true unity of opposites, formulated by Mikhail Lifshits within the framework of materialist dialectics as ontognoseology.

So, what is the advantage of Marxism over all other scientific, philosophical, ideological and political schools of thought? In this regard, there are three main issues that require clarification:

First , we should clarify the relationship of Marxism to critical thinking. Does Marxism presuppose doubt at all, does it have a methodology of doubt , and does it allow for ideas about the supernatural?

Secondly , it is necessary to determine the attitude of Marxism to individual sciences and to the scientific picture of the world as a whole.

Thirdly , it is necessary to establish the relationship of Marxism to practice in general and to the practice of political transformation of the world in particular.

In other words, essential for proving or refuting the truth and superiority of Marxism compared to all other possible ideas are its critical form, scientific content and practical conclusions.