Polina Kolozaridi is a junior researcher at the Higher School of Economics and coordinator of the Club of Internet and Society Lovers . In an interview with Kirill Rozhentsov, she talked about different images of the Internet and explained why the network still has liberating potential.
This material was first published in English on Inrussia.com .
KR: You can often see that researchers and journalists writing about technological progress in general and the Internet in particular take a pessimistic and critical position. How appropriate are apocalyptic predictions? Does the Internet really negatively affect our communication abilities or social processes, for example?
PC: Indeed, there is this drama that fascinates me as a researcher: people are partial to technology, but I must say that this attitude is not new at all. A hundred years ago, intellectuals also argued that everything was irreversibly changing due to technological progress and that the only solution was to abandon it. And other thinkers defended the view that technology provides the opportunity for emancipation - this tradition also continues.
In general, there is no need to equate paranoid fear with a critical attitude, which, it seems to me, is precisely what our time lacks. When people start talking about the Internet, they often rehash common conspiracy theories - how corporations collect user data, how government control is increasing, how we are becoming hostage to social networks.
But this is a misunderstanding stemming from mistakes in the technology adaptation process. It happens that they do not work as intended by the inventors, are appropriated by the market and change our practices unpredictably. Critical thought must embrace this diversity, understand and explain its mechanisms. Only such activity can counter the hysteria and blind accusations against technology that are abundant in modern culture.
KR: You mentioned diversity. In a recent article, researcher Benjamin Peters, using the example of the Soviet cybernetic project, discusses the existence of many different versions of the Internet - possible and impossible, past and future, changing from culture to culture and from era to era. Can we talk about the existence of a specific Runet, different from other national versions of the global network?
PC: No matter how much people make fun of George Bush, he was far-sighted when he spoke about the “internet” in the plural. “Alternative Internet” is a very rich and relevant topic: there were de facto isolated networks, some of which survived and some of which did not. The same Soviet cybernetic project, for example. But there are also images of the Internet that exist simultaneously and may differ from community to community, from country to country. The most popular idea remains the global network as an ideal democratic space. Even people who don’t think about it and treat the Internet pragmatically, renting or renting a home through CIAN, feel something is wrong when a realtor appears. It is perceived as a threat to the direct and horizontal interaction that civilized democratic networks make possible.
As for the Runet, like all early computer networks, it was co-constructed by the creative intelligentsia as a platform for direct communication and free exchange of information. Later, it was designed based on the corporate interests of large companies or, for example, the needs of political activists. Now the state has begun to pay more and more attention to our network. It is important to note that these are not periods of linear development of the Runet, but overlapping and intersecting areas. Now at the Higher School of Economics we are conducting a large study of how the Russian state’s attitude towards the Internet has changed. It often seems that only relatively recently have authorities begun to restrict our rights, censor online media, and control online relationships in general. In reality this is not the case.
KR: As, for example, in the case of discussions on the adoption of the “Yarovaya package” by the State Duma?
PC: Yes, this is a very good example. Everyone was discussing the Yarovaya Package, but no one remembered, for example, the much earlier and unexpected change in President Medvedev’s rhetoric in the second half of his term. If at first he stated that the Internet could help in the fight against corruption, he soon began to talk about the dangers emanating from the World Wide Web. Then an even more interesting thing happened: they suddenly started telling us that technology itself is not dangerous. Only foreign influence poses a risk, but with Russian sovereign technologies everything is in order. It is very interesting to observe from a historical perspective how the language of the “ Information Security Doctrine of the Russian Federation ” - that is, the language of the military - gradually took over the public space.
And I think that's true in many countries. If you look at the preliminary program of President-elect Donald Trump, you can also see statements about the need to build up offensive cyber capabilities. And the attempt to create your own independent Internet, bypassing the United States, is by no means a unique Russian phenomenon; this is being done in Brazil and Germany, for example. The Internet is indeed becoming an important element of a new type of conflict, war, state aggression, which is often discussed in the news, but the point is not in the technology itself, but in social and power relations, which needs to be studied.
KR: There is also such a widespread prejudice that the Internet in Russia is used only in big cities, and in the provinces everyone watches TV - so there, relatively speaking, they vote for Putin. Or that the politically active elite uses Facebook, and schoolchildren exchange memes on VKontakte. Are there any statistics that can confirm such assumptions?
PC: Yes, I understand. This is a beautiful and catchy idea, but it has no basis in reality. Statistics collected by the Public Opinion Foundation show that more than half of the population living in small Russian villages uses the Internet. But these people do not use it for political debates, which, by the way, is another manifestation of the myth of a free democratic Internet, but listen to the radio there, for example.
And VKontakte offers the user unprecedented diversity. There you can not only exchange memes, but also listen to music and watch movies for free, for example. Or read thematic communities that are dedicated to everything in the world, from fashion to critical theory. Perhaps this is why VKontakte is so popular: almost a quarter of all Russian Internet users consider this social network to be the most important.
Whether there is a connection between political activity on the Internet and changes in social structure is unknown, but it is definitely impossible to talk about a strict cause-and-effect relationship. Technology in itself does not change anything. Information spreads very quickly on the Internet, it’s true, but it also disappears just as quickly. And there is no division between the elite and the masses, there are only different types of behavior that inevitably lead to new types of inequality: someone consumes more information, someone produces more of it. Perceiving the majority of Internet users as some kind of mass with whom something needs to be done is a dead-end path, which, however, is very popular among intellectuals.
It seems necessary to look at this diffusion more closely and from an unexpected point of view. According to anthropologist Daniel Miller , we live in a multimedia situation, where we use different services and different elements of the digital environment in different ways. It seems to us that Instagram is only needed to share photos of food and cats. But in situations where other means of communication are unavailable—for example, during earthquakes—people use it to make themselves known.
My colleagues and I are preparing a large anthropological study of how people in different regions of Russia use the Internet. It turns out that there are also many differences here, unnoticeable at first glance: in Yakutia, for example, WhatsApp has gained incredible popularity due to limited access to wired Internet and the proliferation of inexpensive smartphones. People of all ages use it to communicate with each other, receive news from government services and the media. And it is quite possible that our research will reveal other unique ways of using the Internet that we are not at all accustomed to and which, hopefully, will be able to tell us more than popular misconceptions.
KR: This inexhaustible variety reminds me of the utopian dreams and hacker manifestos of the 90s. Can we still perceive the Internet as a universal emancipatory mechanism?
PC: You know, I like this idea of emancipation, but I'm afraid that there is less and less room for it. The network utopia of the late 1990s promised us the opportunity to remain authors of ourselves in virtual space. But on the modern Internet, dominated by non-anonymous services like social networks, a user's reputation limits the opportunity for self-expression.
Now, in the words of David Nye, we live in a state of “nos-topia,” that is, a nostalgic utopia. The prophecies and dreams of the 90s regarding the Internet did not come true, but we continue to relate ourselves to this past, which still has powerful potential. Most likely, we will no longer be able to change the global trend of Internet development, but we will be able to create networks with a small number of participants - centers of resistance, where relationships will be built according to completely different principles.
KR: In a recent interview , Boris Groys argued that the emergence and development of the Internet marks the end of community, but, on the other hand, gives greater weight to artistic or theoretical statements that have a smaller circulation zone. It seems to me that this is connected precisely with this prospect of alternative “Internets” that can be created.
PC: Yes, indeed, this is the same idea expressed in the language of applied social knowledge. Media ecologist Neil Postman argued that technology always brings with it some kind of good to replace the previous one. The Internet has taken away our community, but at the same time it has given everyone the opportunity to live in their own fragment of reality.
In a sense, the Internet has become the absolutization of the ideas of the early 20th century sociologist Georg Simmel. He described how residents of large cities, discouraged by the endless stream of information that they cannot process, are given the opportunity not to be themselves, to escape their identity. Everyone feels this in one way or another when going down the metro in Moscow or any other metropolis. This is strikingly different from life in small settlements, where a person's identity is strictly determined by his origin, occupation, and so on. The Internet becomes a logical development of this urban structure. It just doesn’t free everyone and, like a big city, it causes a natural feeling of discomfort in many. It is not known for certain what will happen to this structure next, because history moves in a complex and nonlinear way.
But, returning to Postman’s ideas, I want to say that in any case we should not mystify technologies, perceive them as some kind of unconditional thing. By separating ourselves from them, we, in fact, abdicate responsibility for their future development - this is a very conservative position. We need to explore technologies and form new practices for their use, because the Internet is neither an enslaver nor a liberator. It contains many possibilities that can only manifest themselves in a meeting with us.