As was shown in the first part of the book, comparison in history has existed since time immemorial, but only since the end of the 19th century. historians, influenced by the natural and social sciences, in which the comparative method was widely used, also began to talk about its use in their research. It is characteristic that at first the comparative method itself was considered uniform, common to all sciences, and debates were conducted mainly about how fruitful its application in history would be. If Sh.-V. Langlois, in an article in 1890, and later his colleagues G. Glotz and L. Davilier had high hopes for this method, then the same Langlois, in the textbook “Introduction to the Study of History” (1898), written jointly with S. Senobos, as well as E. Bernheim and a number of other German scientists expressed doubts about the advisability of its use in historical research.
Subsequently, however, the idea arose that historians need a special comparative method, developed specifically for the needs of their science. This idea was clearly expressed already in 1913 by the famous Russian scientist N.I. Kareev: bearing in mind the division of sciences into nomothetic and idiographic, introduced by the neo-Kantians, he wrote that “the comparative study of historical facts is a bridge thrown from the shore of history to the shore of sociology. It can serve both the tasks of historical (idiographic) knowledge and the goals of sociological (nomological) knowledge” [68, p. 193]. Kareev pointed out that in “general historical methodologies <...> the question of the comparative method for idiographic purposes remains undeveloped.” As we remember, Marc Bloch, in his later famous article “On the Comparative History of European Societies” (1928), readily quoted the linguist Antoine Meillet and the anthropologist
James Frazer, but he did not borrow from them or from other representatives of the social sciences the methods of comparison they developed, but instead, using the example of his own work, he tried to demonstrate to his fellow historians the heuristic capabilities of the comparative method and “some practical ways” of its use.
The development of the comparative historical method continued in the 1960s. In particular, Theodor Schieder, based on the five functions of comparison he described, identified the corresponding forms of the comparative method in history: paradigmatic, analogical, generalizing, individualizing and synthetic. However, due to the vagueness of the author’s terminology, it remains unclear whether we are talking about the forms of one single method or the coexistence of different methods: the title of the article uses the plural (“comparative methods in historical science”), and the text mainly talks about “method” in the singular, but in the final conclusions “methods” appear again, and two of them are directly mentioned: “individualizing” and “generalizing.”
The American historian William Sewell based his thoughts on the comparative method in history on the works of Marc Bloch - primarily his classic article of 1928. According to Sewell, with all the variety of useful functions of comparison noted by the French scientist, they all have a common logic - the logic of testing hypotheses. In one respect, the American researcher is ready to argue with his venerable predecessor: he does not agree with the preference that Blok gave to comparing neighboring and contemporary societies. According to Sewell, comparisons of social systems distant from each other in time and space can be no less fruitful: as an example, he points to the comparison of Germany and Japan within the framework of the study of industrialization. In addition, the scientist considered it necessary to indicate the limits of the capabilities of the comparative method (which Blok did not do in his time). Sewell described his most important limitation as follows: “The comparative method is a method, a set of rules that can be methodically and systematically applied in collecting and using data to test explanatory hypotheses. He does not provide us with testable explanations: that is the task of the historical imagination.”
Sewell's work also draws attention to the clarification of the different meanings of the term “comparative history”: the comparative method, which is the main content of his article, is only one of these meanings. "Comparative history" can also be understood as a comparative perspective, that is, the consideration of historical problems in a broader context that goes beyond the specific circumstances of place and time. The comparative perspective does not have the limitations of the comparative method, but for the same reason it cannot be reduced to a set of simple rules. However, most historians, Sewell emphasizes, understand comparative history not as a method or perspective, but as a kind of subject matter, that is, studies in which the comparison of two or more societies is systematically applied and the results are presented in comparative form. Nevertheless, the scholar recommends that the term should not be reduced to such limited use, emphasizing the value of the comparative method and comparative perspective for all historians. Marc Bloch's classic article continued to serve as a source of inspiration for comparative scholars, but over time, historians' confidence in the existence of a special comparative method began to disappear. The year 1980 was a turning point in this regard.
Alette and Boyd Hill in their article “Marc Bloch and Comparative History” (1980) showed that the famous French scientist in practice did not at all follow the linguistic model of comparison, which he borrowed, according to him, from Antoine Meillet and recommended to fellow historians [81, p. 832–834]. This, apparently, is indeed the case, and a similar ambivalent attitude is expressed by the greatest historian of the 20th century. the social and human sciences have already been discussed above (see Part I, Chapter 3). But American researchers did not stop at stating this fact: emphasizing the lack of “precision and consistency” in M. Blok’s statements regarding the methodology of comparative history, they noted that “flaws” (flaws) in his judgments about the value of the linguistic model, due to the master’s enormous influence on all subsequent historiography, were reproduced in the works of his students; This is how a methodological tradition has developed that needs critical revision [ibid., p. 837–838]. As examples of this tradition, the Hills cited Sylvia Trapp's editorial introduction to the first issue of Comparative Studies in Society and History (1958) and the article I just quoted by William Sewell on Marc Bloch and the Logic of Comparative History (1967): neither of these works, as critics rightly noted, contained a clear definition of the comparative method in history.