What is happening today in Ukraine has never been called anything. Can I suggest another option? A global political experiment is taking place in Ukraine. In order to answer the question: is it possible, with the help of the most cynical PR technologies, to overthrow the most stupid government? In Russia, this has not happened several times in a row over the past five years. But Ukraine is smaller, the mass consciousness there is more infantile, and in small territories the intensity of political life increases and passions are concentrated. And what did not work out in large and inertial Russia may well work out in Ukraine, which is relatively virgin in the sense of a new type of PR.
Personally, after my trip to Kyiv, other questions arise. Is it possible to bring some decent people into power as a result of a PR coup? Will anything change in the lives of the inhabitants of the tents on Khreshchatyk if the PR coup really succeeds? And couldn’t it happen that as a result of this confrontation “everyone against Kuchma”, the head of Ukraine will be not a yellow-black or green, but a pink or red president?
Just don’t make me out to be a supporter of Leonid Danilovich Kuchma. This is a typical post-communist leader of the nineties, a deeply Soviet man, a normal red director, forced by fate to play at democracy and independence, but organically cannot stand them.
If we briefly recall the main stages of the current Ukrainian Great Experiment, one will inevitably be amazed at the suddenness of popular unrest. Things have not been good at all in Ukraine in the last five years. But they endured. Patience ran out somehow suddenly, but at all the seams. The pretext was the disappearance of online journalist Georgy Gongadze, and subsequently the publication of the notorious “sofa recording”, which security officer Melnichenko allegedly made by putting a digital voice recorder under the president’s personal sofa. how Melnichenko placed the equipment under Kuchma, whether he asked to move or crawled up from below, remains a mystery. However, there is also a version that the entire residence of the President of Ukraine - the former building of the Central Committee - is bugged through and through. So on this very recording, swearing profusely, Kuchma expressed his dissatisfaction with Gongadze’s publications. The voice, as confirmed by the examination, indeed belonged to the president.
Things are tense with opposition leaders in Kyiv. Historically, former Deputy Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko, leader of the Fatherland party (Fatherland, appreciate the coincidence), herself an oligarch and the wife of an oligarch, is considered in Ukraine and beyond its borders to be the only man among local politicians. In alliance with the socialist Alexander Moroz (who published the recordings of Melnichenko, now living abroad), she headed the very “national salvation front”, which united more than a dozen small and large political parties. Neither Tymoshenko nor Moroz claimed the presidency as such: they had their own candidate, Prime Minister Viktor Yushchenko, who was very popular in Ukraine, and former head of the National Bank. They bet on him. Yushchenko remained silent for the time being.
But the current situation in Kyiv differs from a banal behind-the-scenes struggle in that the opposition managed, as they say, to raise the people (more precisely, the most marginal part of it, which has nothing to lose and which, because of this, is not very capable of thinking about its actions). Political strategists have already realized that revolutions cannot be made without popular indignation - and a coup needs real legitimacy in the form of popular support. Let me remind you, by the way, that in exactly the same way - and with the help of similar PR - a coup was already carried out in Russia: in February-October 1917, the criminally negligent Emperor Nicholas II was overthrown. The Bolsheviks had plenty of arguments and many of their saints; without an atoning sacrifice such a revolution was impossible.
And the most cynical “promotion” of Georgy Gongadze began.
The Kiev tent city, which now numbers 44 tents, is called “a territory free from Kuchma” and will not disperse until his resignation. At least that's what the inhabitants say. Among them, as well as among the miners, there are practically no residents of the capital. In any case, the mayor of Kyiv, Mr. Omelchenko, allegedly reported to the president: “I checked it myself, Leonid Danilovich, the people of Kiev are not!” The information, apparently, is again from the sofa.
I’m afraid that Russians have a rather wrong idea about this tent city and the scale of the Kyiv unrest in general. The spectacle turned out to be tragicomic. To prevent the tents from being demolished, several people's deputies hung their forms on them - “Property of a deputy of the Verkhovna Rada”: such property is, by definition, inviolable. Opposite the Porcelain-faience store, Kyiv University students laid out their homemade newspapers and hung posters; the lower part of everyone’s face is tied with a black scarf (they say so that the rector doesn’t find out, but I think it’s for fear; it really looks as if they are about to point a toy gun at you and ask in a scary, hoarse child’s voice: your wallet or your life? Are you for the bloody regime of Kuchma or against it?). Near the other tents, a continuous argument is in full swing, strongly reminiscent of “Hyde Park” in front of the editorial office of Yakovlev’s “Moscow News” of 1989: the same newspapers are laid out, the same poorly dressed middle-aged people are hoarsely yelling at each other, and even the argumentation is all the same - the whole set. The number of Kuchma’s supporters is in no way inferior to the number of his opponents who came to Kyiv from Galich, Chernigov, Poltava... They say that the president’s agents are really lurking around the tent city, that disguised security forces are walking in the crowd to prevent conflicts... But so far, thank God, things have not gone further than shouting.
On the blizzard night of February 19, when a five-hour snowfall with a cold wind fell on already spring Kyiv, no one left - they warmed themselves with vodka and sang. By the way, at many tents I saw ditties and Cossack toasts: “Hai Kashchiy zhue saltse, and we know, de egg!” Be gay! Get rid of Kuchma!”
Apparently, the president’s nerves are losing steam - instead of treating the popular unrest the same way Yeltsin treated it in 1998, he has taken active action. On February 14, Yulia Tymoshenko was arrested (Ukrainian journalists darkly joke that the former deputy prime minister was reunited on Valentine’s Day with her husband, who has been in the same prison for six months - also on charges of giving bribes to former Prime Minister Pavel Lazarenko). On the same day, Kuchma and the Speaker of the Rada Plyushch, together with Prime Minister Yushchenko, on whom the opposition pinned such hopes in the event of its victory, sign the notorious triple appeal to the people, where they directly call the opposition destabilizers, lawbreakers... The main trauma for the opposition, as you understand, was not the cheerful and confident tone of this statement (everyone can see that Kuchma was very nervous), but the fact that the prime minister signed it. Civilized, pro-Western, not seen in anything bad.
Immediately, versions arise one after another: Kuchma dared to arrest Tymoshenko only because Putin arrived and gave him such advice, completely in his own spirit. Kuchma will pay Putin for his support (and for stolen gas) with shares of Ukrainian enterprises, which Russia will now receive for pennies. Guard, Putin supports the killer of journalists! Yushchenko signed the triple appeal only because he was intimidated; he didn’t even know what he was signing; he signed at dinner with Ivych without reading... (The latest version, I’m not kidding, is even being discussed in the press; few people think that a prime minister who signs an address to the nation at dinner without reading it is even less fit to be president than Kuchma.)
...The NTV channel, known for the fact that back in ninety-eight, its correspondents personally led Rostov miners onto the rails from the very beginning, has been the most active in covering Kuchmagate - they thought the picture in which the same miners were sitting near the Rostovugol building was not impressive enough. I wrote about this then: they were taken out to pose, but they remained on the rails... Sometimes I honestly wonder (and I think I’m not alone): well, what is the reason for NTV to blame Kuchma? What did he do to disturb them? They can’t seriously believe that Gongadze was killed on his personal order? for Russia, a weakened and rushing president, who, like a sinner in a temple, at the first trouble runs under the wing of Russia, where it is beneficial! Compromised, hunted, Kuchma, whom the West disdains, is a gift from fate! But no. And it seems that I understand why NTV is vitally interested in the Kyiv opposition succeeding. Here the very same scenario is being worked out, which can later be applied here too - and what’s more, it’s being used with might and main...
The fact is that during the years of glasnost (our only achievement, it is believed), the country acquired several shrines, several sacred cows. You can't touch journalists! That’s right, it’s impossible; as a journalist, I completely agree with this. I am only against political strategists speculating on this. Because in the end it will be the press, which is thus thoroughly compromised, that will have to take the rap. And when Kuchma is accused of the murder of journalist Gongadze (and here Putin is accused of any search that happened in the editorial office of a provincial publication) - I see how people who are deeply disgusting to me are speculating on MY freedom. Gongadze - alive or dead - turned into a pretext, a cover, just as “our boys” from the Kursk submarine turned into it in their time.
Yes, Kuchma should have been replaced long ago with a more consistent, more democratic, more intelligent person. But here’s the horror - a politician brought to power in such a way as they are trying today in Ukraine will not bring any relief to anyone - for he is doomed to depend on his patrons, on the most cynical manipulators of the people’s consciousness. Can we believe that the new president of Ukraine can be better than Kuchma? Which - alas and alas - today there is just as no real alternative as its smarter northern counterpart?!
After all, an alternative cannot be cobbled together “from what was.” She comes with her ideology, program, charisma. With all my ardent compassion for the brave and beautiful woman Yulia Tymoshenko (throwing whom into prison was not only cruel, but also monstrously stupid), she cannot become the president of Ukraine - simply because there is dirt on her, like on any person from “this government”. Tymoshenko is the same Ukrainian Gusinsky, only braver and with convictions: she is still a woman! The very methods by which “Kuchmagate” was promoted in the press, and the struggle of “independent” publications, which can only exist in Ukraine “under a roof,” are all too clearly visible to the majority of the population. That is why in almost all the Kyiv houses where I have been and whose owners have been friends for many years, the “Ukraine without Kuchma” campaign is not taken seriously. Speculation on blood and poverty, which very rich people in Russia and Ukraine are so diligently engaged in, does not solve the problems of the former republics. And even if Kuchma really doesn’t sit at his post, does even more stupid things, flees in panic to Madagascar on Putin’s personal plane, or who knows what else he comes up with, the most terrible thing will be the delight of the crowd on Khreshchatyk. These people will firmly believe that freedom will now come, that it is for this that they starved and froze.
...On Khreshchatyk there is a young man selling bubbles - plastic tubes with a soap solution for blowing bubbles. He has a huge, thirty centimeters in diameter, round wire frame, he dips it into a bowl of foam - and the wind itself blows out multi-colored bubbles the size of a Cossack head. And they float over the tent city, and its inhabitants see them off with a smile... Just like passers-by who are rushing about their business. And - I hope, I hope, I hope! - they will continue to rush along them, they will not end up in the new Khodynka, or in a new shootout a la Moscow-93... Let them continue like this, and go to the shops, and look at the bubbles.
Until from their own midst, from a genuine and not an invented people, something more durable and less colorful than a soap bubble, even a very large one, comes to light.
Dmitry Bykov
Kyiv—Moscow