There are places in the historical center of Moscow where tour guides will tell you: “Stop. We can’t go any further!” We are talking about the famous memorial New Donskoy Cemetery: there are too many areas here where being simply dangerous to life...
There are places in the historical center of Moscow where tour guides will tell you: “Stop. We can’t go any further!” We are talking about the famous memorial New Donskoy Cemetery: there are too many areas here where it is simply life-threatening.
The walls of the columbariums, which have not been repaired for a long time, are propped up with boards.
And when soldiers’ graves are being cleaned up all over the country on Victory Day, in this strange place even the Heroes of the Soviet Union are not held in high esteem. Why? Are repairs really that expensive?
By the way, starting from 1927 (then a crematorium was built in Moscow), only cremated people were buried here. And they only need a niche in the wall with an area of less than half a meter, which is cheaper to maintain than a monument on a grave.
The fight against devastation here is simple: they lock the most dangerous premises with a key - and that’s all! For example, the 16th underground columbarium has become inaccessible in recent years.
Only once did we manage to get there. The employee sent to help came with a powerful flashlight, wearing a helmet and grumbled that he was being dragged to the underworld.
The underworld is a place for sinners. But is this true? Here are the ashes of hundreds of people who gave their lives for the Fatherland and selflessly served it.
At one time, “underworld” decoration was apparently considered luxurious. Now her remains hang from the damp ceiling, threatening to break the heads of visitors.
There are broken urns on the floor here and there; you have to walk around the scattered ashes. Many people were taken away from here by their relatives, but there are still a lot of ballot boxes. “Ownerless”, forgotten, abandoned?
A green fungus is crawling along the walls.
Both heating and electricity are turned off here. Although they failed and worked before. Due to dampness, the fungus is actively growing higher, on the upper ground floors, in the 7th and 8th columbariums, which are located just above the 16th.
By the way, guests often visit there. Well, no one knows that the foundation of the building has rotted and it can easily settle down, burying the dead for the second time, and with them the living...
– Or maybe this is a logical fate for the cemetery, because they all collapse over time. How big is its significance? – I asked Sergei Merzhanov, an architect, a member of the non-profit partnership “Society of Necropolisists”.
– It was created at the beginning of the twentieth century, that is, new by the standards of Moscow, where many necropolises opened in 1771, during the plague epidemic, and in theory it should be in better condition than the old ones. And calculate its meaning yourself: the country’s top officials, only a few of them, were buried in a coffin near the Kremlin.
Those who were less significant (according to the criteria of the authorities) were cremated, regardless of the wishes of their relatives, and placed in the Kremlin wall. Then it was Novodevichy’s turn, and after that it was Novoye Donskoye. It was called “a branch of Novodevichy”. Here is the elite of the Soviet era.
Double standards?
Who should keep order is a dead question (sorry for the joke). On all ritual sites, the Don Cemetery appears as a single whole. At the same time, these are two different graveyards.
The first was opened in 1591 on the territory of the Donskoy Monastery; princes, princes, and archbishops rest here. The ashes of one of the leaders of the White movement, Anton Ivanovich Denikin and his wife, were also transported here from the United States.
From Switzerland - the remains of Ivan Ilyin, a philosopher, writer, critic of communist power, who wrote in his works: “What did Hitler do? He stopped the process of Bolshevisation in Germany and thereby rendered the greatest service to all of Europe.”
Next to them is General Vladimir Kappel. Many people remember his name from the film “Chapaev,” where he launches a “psychic attack” against the Chapaevites. The general's ashes were found in a church in Harbin and transported to Moscow.
The Church has the right to rebury anyone it deems necessary near churches. The inhabitants of the “Soviet” graves and columbariums next to the old Donskoy cemetery, apparently, do not fit into the new trends; their ashes are not really needed. But the territory of the New Donskoy Cemetery at one time
Y. Luzhkov handed it over to the monastery, and the document specifically said: “... take into account that the Donskoy Monastery undertakes, at its own expense, to carry out all repair and restoration work on the necropolis monuments, buildings and structures.”
So far this is an unanswered question: Does Donskoye consist of two independent parts or is it one cemetery? If one, does he have the same budget? And if so, who determines spending priorities? Why is exhumation and a flight between the USA and Russia for some, while for others it’s not even enough to paint a sign?
The dead move out slowly
Scandals on Novy Donskoy have arisen periodically since the early 90s. At that time, they began to return to the Russian Orthodox Church all the property taken away by the Bolsheviks.
The list also included the Church of Seraphim of Sarov. Relatives were asked to take the urns with ashes, saying that now there would be a temple here.
A spontaneous transfer began, and then... the urns with the ashes of Hero of the Soviet Union S.A. Asyamov and Honored Pilot of the USSR M.A. Volkovoinov disappeared. The last one, by the way, had two Orders of the Red Banner (not dummies, real ones!).
Maybe what else is missing or who is missing, we don’t know. In general, then the transfer was postponed. We took it up again ten years later.
But then Alexander Shirvindt and Nikolai Karachentsov intervened, because their loved ones were buried in the former temple. The building was defended again. And yet exactly a year
ago, the Russian Orthodox Church again started talking about vacating the premises, then the “Necropolitan Society” raised a fuss in the media...
The necropolitanists received the most interesting answer from the Patriarchate from Vsevolod Chaplin, who was asked about the plans of the Russian Orthodox Church for the columbarium.
If you didn’t know that the document was genuine, you would never believe it. The archpriest writes that “the sacred space of the temple is difficult to combine with the idea of burial as a place of peace.” What then should we do with everyone who is buried in churches, since there are many of them?
Such a tradition exists. Or, perhaps, the hierarchs are waiting for everything to resolve itself - to collapse, crumble into complete dust, and then it will be possible to build a new temple on the soil they fertilized?
Temple-crematorium
In 1914, a new church of Saints Seraphim of Sarov and Anna Kashinskaya was consecrated at the New Donskoy Cemetery.
The Soviet government found a more pragmatic use for it: the temple was rebuilt into a crematorium (before that there had never been one in Moscow), and since 1927 its ovens began to regularly turn ordinary deceased fellow citizens into ashes.
In modern times, after Yu. Luzhkov transferred the cemetery to the monastery, the crematorium was rebuilt again... into a temple (pictured). Its architecture turned out to be, to put it mildly, strange, not much like Orthodox churches.
At the same time, a columbarium with the ashes of the deceased remained inside the building, which does not please the hierarchs at all... Cremation in the Orthodox tradition is not approved, and some priests even consider it a sin.
Who is buried in mass graves?
On Novy Donskoy, in “common graves” No. 1 and No. 2, the ashes of repressed party and government figures are buried - S. Kosior, P. Postyshev, V. Chubar, Yu. Pyatakov, A. Kosarev, military leaders - M. Tukhachevsky, V. Blucher, A. Egorov, I. Yakir, I. Uborevich, V. Gordov. The list is quite extensive.
Here, after execution and cremation, were the remains of V. Meyerhold, writer and journalist M. Koltsov and many other cultural figures disliked by the authorities. Monuments over graves appeared only recently.