Comments on the project

Open data expert Ivan Belytin analyzed the draft government of the government to disclose information with heat supply organizations, heat -power organizations, regulation bodies http://www.fstrf.ru/about/activity/Projectsnorm/638

Ivan Belytin. Photo by Anton of Office

(Direct link - http://www.fstrf.ru/about/activity/projectsnorm/638/pp_red._18.07.11.doc ). You can leave your comments and suggestions as always in the comments on this article or on the blog of Ivan.

Comments Ivan Begin on the text

2. The disclosure of information in this document means ensuring access to information of an unlimited circle of persons, regardless of the purpose of receiving this information .

This definition should be remembered.

11. Regulated organizations, regulation bodies are required to keep records of written requests of consumers, as well as store copies of answers to such requests for 5 years.

No 5 years - only forever. In addition, now all regulators should have additional databases with personal data - appeals of citizens.

12. The list of information to be disclosed in accordance with this document is exhaustive .

But this is no longer at all. What is less impossible would be understandable, but if in some region the local leadership would oblige a greater level of disclosure, why do they not have the right to do this? By the way, tariff regulation in subjects is the prerogative of regional authorities.

II. Standards for disclosing information with heat supply organizations, heat -power organizations

There are no requirements for machine -readiness. No data standardization.

25. The provision of information is carried out in writing by sending to the consumer of the mail or issuing to the consumer personally at the location of the regulated organization.

That is, it is impossible to get information by e -mail and this is clearly spelled out in the decision.

28. The regulated organization (regulation authority) no later than 20 calendar days from the date of receipt of the request sends the information disclosed in accordance with this document to the consumer in accordance with the consumer chosen by the method of obtaining information.

20 days - this is not as bad as with other written appeals of citizens, but if it were possible to receive e -mail, then 20 days could be reduced to a maximum of 5.

IV. Standards for disclosing information by regulatory authorities

There are no requirements for machine -readiness. No data standardization.

On the page - http://www.fstrf.ru/about/activity/Projectsnorm there are contacts for sending independent examinations. Who wants to direct his?

More information about open lawmaking can be read in the manifesto of Ivan Begin.