Translated material
Anyuta has gone, but love will remain
The Minister of Education of Germany, devoid of degree for plagiarism in the dissertation, resigns
Photo: Reuters
02/09/2013, 17:15 | "Gazeta.ru"
http://www.gazeta.ru/politics/news/2013/02/09/n_2747201.shtml
L.N. Glebov. Photo: ITAR-TASS
"Job": two Vakovsky publications L.N. Glebova. Personal participation-0.35-0.4 printed sheets
Glebova, L.N. The possibilities of socio-professional design in the training of specialists for the social sphere [Text] / L.N. Glebova, T.T. Shelina. // News of St. Petersburg University of Economics and Finance. -2008.-No. 4:-S. 34-40. - 0.7 pl. (personal participation 0.35 pl.).
Glebova, L.N. Preparation of social teachers in modern higher education [Text] / L.N. Glebova, T.T. Shelina. // World of Education and Education in the world. -2008.-No. 4-S. 9-17. - 0.8 pl. (Personal participation 0.4 pp).
In the magazine itself, published at the Moscow Psychological and Social Institute, that is, where the defense of the doctoral dissertation of L.N. Glebova was held, the name of the "co-author" was not mentioned and all the "personal participation" is assigned to itself, the pages are incorrectly indicated: in the abstract, 9-17, instead of 29-38.
http://psyjournals.ru/mpsi_worldeducation/2008/n4/free/
Below is a comparative analysis of the dissertation of the doctoral dissertation of the former head of Rosobrnadzor and the current Senator L.N. Glebov with another doctoral dissertation of the Arzamas professor T.T. Shelina.
Such work would not be possible without a DOCT-Z blogger, using legal access to the text of the dissertation L.N. Glebova in the Russian State Library. Therefore, this study can be considered our common post ...
Several preliminary remarks that are useful for future experts who have to study L.N. Glebova/
There is a special variety of plagiarism, in which both the one who borrow the text and the one who uses it for further submission to the advice on protecting the dissertation are involved. In the further chain of protection - the chairman of the council and his scientific secretary, opponents, the leading organization are "understanding" people who pretend that they are really a scientific product. When the dissertation comes to the examination in the Higher Attestation Commission, there the same people “supervise” it - experts of the Higher Attestation Commission who took work to defend and acted opponents. Next - the applicant receives the desired degree, and the text is sent for storage to the "dissertation" RGB. Everything got away until this hall became computer ...
In addition, scientific slaves are also people, they understand that, ultimately, those who pulled them into the process of making false dissertations are responsible for the resulting text. Therefore, they do not carry out their work so carefully that there are no "seams of the finish" at all. A favorite technique is to take a text, you can even add something to your own in order to distract attention from straightforward repetitions. On "methodologies" and other formalized things in the dissertation, they relax and leave everything as it is, without rearranging anything in places, preferring the previously previously passed the text to some innovations. The doctors of pedagogical sciences are usually stereotypical “sources” - lists from the same names, later found only in the list of literature (and is it always?). The stages of work, the venue for "experiments", testing and, as a result, "scientific novelty and reliability" often coincide.
Further in the text, the compiler’s thought works stereotypically, it takes what is called “fish” on scientific Argo, and adds to the content of the finished dissertation everything that can be related to the topic of the compiled dissertation.
In a conclusion, which can also be read by members of the Council and other reviewers, pieces of new text appear again.
Two examples from the dissertation L.N. Glebova is one funny, rather worthy of the attention of satirists. And the other is completely sad ...
Us . 256 A piece of text bursts into the presentation, suitable for a guide to Arzamas, and not the text of a doctoral dissertation. "Currently, at the 21st industrial enterprise, special vehicles, utilities for utilities, technological equipment for light industry, automobiles and spare parts for cars, instrumentation and electronics, medical equipment, sewing and mineral watic, felt, reinforced concrete structures, confectionery, milky, meat products and a lot of bakery products and a lot are produced at the 21st industrial enterprise. Other ". So, is this, indeed, an island of Soviet well -being in the market Russian sea?
Particularly delightful passage about Arzamas is a city located "in the node of a number of auto -lifting roads." Tol Lee Arzamas is such an anomaly where this term is still in use, or L.N. Glebov, contrary to her statements in the dissertation, has not been to home for a long time. Indeed, already in the 1990s, the number of residents of the city exceeded the indicator it presented. The still not very understandable craving for the science of the portal administrators about Arzamas-Gorodok and the Open VKontakte group, who were not too lazy, signed up for the RGB reading room, found this passage in the dissertation of L.N. Glebova and also inserted it into their pages. With repetition of the word in the word about the "node of the road roads."
P .256 Modern Arzamas is one of the most interesting cities in the Nizhny Novgorod region. In terms of industrial development and population (108.1 thousand, people), it is noticeably distinguished among the cities of the region. Arzamas is located in the center of the right -bank part of the region, at a distance of 100 km from N. Novgorod. and 410 km from Moscow, at the intersection of railway highways, as well as in the node of a number of auto -luminous roads. All this makes the transport and geographical position of the city convenient, and in relation to the surrounding areas-from a kind of "capital" of the Nizhny Novgorod right-bank.
Cf.: Http://www.arzamas-city.ru/?mode=City2
The story of Arzamas
Arzamas is one of the most interesting cities in the Nizhny Novgorod region. In terms of industrial development and population (108.3 thousand people), it is noticeably distinguished among other cities of the region. Arzamas is located in the center of the right -bank part of the region, 110 km from Nizhny Novgorod, 410 km from Moscow, at the intersection of railway highways, as well as in the node of a number of highways. All this makes the transport and geographical position of the city convenient, and in relation to the surrounding areas-this is a kind of "capital" of the Nizhny Novgorod right-bank.
Cf.: Open group "In contact"
(((((+++ Arzamas +++))))))
I also like this quote:
Description:
Arzamas is one of the most interesting cities in the Nizhny Novgorod region. In terms of industrial development and population (108.3 thousand people), it is noticeably distinguished among other cities of the region. Arzamas is located in the center of the right -bank part of the region, 110 km from Nizhny Novgorod, 410 km from Moscow, at the intersection of railway highways, as well as in the node of a number of highways. All this makes the transport and geographical position of the city convenient, and in relation to the surrounding areas-this is a kind of "capital" of the Nizhny Novgorod right-bank.
And now it’s very serious, because they are not joking on this subject.
L.N. Glebov on s. 10-11 dissertations writes the following about his "personal participation" in conducting the study (partially, but verbatim coincides with the text of T.T. Schelina):
"The personal participation of the applicant consisted of: in the development of the main ideas and provisions of the study; in the leadership of the conduct of experimental work and in direct participation in it as an organizer and expert of fairs of socio-cultural projects in the Volga Federal District, teacher of pedagogical disciplines, projects coordinator and scientific and design activities of students, employees of the department of general and social pedagogy, employees Teachers and professional retraining and professional retraining in the projects: "Orphanage-good house!" With the support of the ARO program "Help in Russia" 2002; "Prison Reform in Russia" with the financial support of Penal Reform International (International Prison Reform) 2003-2004; "Return to the origins" with the support of the Charitable Fund of the Monk Seraphim of Sarovsky 2007; "Maintaining social ties of minor convicts" with the support of the department of the President of the Russian Federation 2007; "Team of professionals: protect children from trouble!" With the support of the Knowledge International Public Humanitarian Fund, within the framework of the order of the President of the Russian Federation of June 30, 2007 No. 367-RF 2008 "
We find the mentioned order of the President of the Russian Federation of June 30, 2007 N 367-RP, and this is: "About the provision of state support of non-profit non-governmental organizations participating in the development of civil society institutions in 2007."
http://bazazakonov.ru/doc/?id=693204
And please, in Appendix No. 1 "The list of non -profit non -governmental organizations that provide budget funds for the allocation of grants to other non -profit non -governmental organizations" in paragraph 2, the Knowledge Foundation is mentioned, which received 270,000 (thousands of rubles) rubles to support its projects. How many 270 million or 270 thousand are I do not know. Let anyone explain more competent in the distribution of assistance to the nuclear NPOs and state officials who carry out their "projects" through them.
The project "Team of professionals: protect children from trouble!", Which is mentioned in the dissertation L.N. Glebova is presented in Appendix No. 3 to the dissertation on p. 328-347. In fact, this is an application for money (interesting news for those scientists who have many such applications have accumulated in the archives, it can also be used when writing doctoral dissertations).
And why about his participation in the "Protection of children from trouble" to write in doctoral dissertations, Madame L.N. Glebova?
Unless, of course, this is your text ...
And now the promised "analysis of the products of activity", as determine their methods of work by T.T. Shelin and L.N. Glebov
